Comments on "what the back of the object looks like: 3D reconstruction from line drawings without hidden lines"

I comment on a paper describing a method for deducing the hidden topology of an object portrayed in a 2D natural line drawing. The principal problem with this paper is that it cannot be considered an advance on (or even an equal of) the state of the art as the approach it describes makes the same limiting assumptions as approaches proposed 10 years ago. There are also important omissions in the review of related wor

3D Reconstruction of Indoor Corridor Models Using Single Imagery and Video Sequences

In recent years, 3D indoor modeling has gained more attention due to its role in decision-making process of maintaining the status and managing the security of building indoor spaces. In this thesis, the problem of continuous indoor corridor space modeling has been tackled through two approaches. The first approach develops a modeling method based on middle-level perceptual organization. The second approach develops a visual Simultaneous Localisation and Mapping (SLAM) system with model-based loop closure. In the first approach, the image space was searched for a corridor layout that can be converted into a geometrically accurate 3D model. Manhattan rule assumption was adopted, and indoor corridor layout hypotheses were generated through a random rule-based intersection of image physical line segments and virtual rays of orthogonal vanishing points. Volumetric reasoning, correspondences to physical edges, orientation map and geometric context of an image are all considered for scoring layout hypotheses. This approach provides physically plausible solutions while facing objects or occlusions in a corridor scene. In the second approach, Layout SLAM is introduced. Layout SLAM performs camera localization while maps layout corners and normal point features in 3D space. Here, a new feature matching cost function was proposed considering both local and global context information. In addition, a rotation compensation variable makes Layout SLAM robust against cameras orientation errors accumulations. Moreover, layout model matching of keyframes insures accurate loop closures that prevent miss-association of newly visited landmarks to previously visited scene parts. The comparison of generated single image-based 3D models to ground truth models showed that average ratio differences in widths, heights and lengths were 1.8%, 3.7% and 19.2% respectively. Moreover, Layout SLAM performed with the maximum absolute trajectory error of 2.4m in position and 8.2 degree in orientation for approximately 318m path on RAWSEEDS data set. Loop closing was strongly performed for Layout SLAM and provided 3D indoor corridor layouts with less than 1.05m displacement errors in length and less than 20cm in width and height for approximately 315m path on York University data set. The proposed methods can successfully generate 3D indoor corridor models compared to their major counterpart

Automatic Reconstruction of Parametric, Volumetric Building Models from 3D Point Clouds

Planning, construction, modification, and analysis of buildings requires means of representing a building's physical structure and related semantics in a meaningful way. With the rise of novel technologies and increasing requirements in the architecture, engineering and construction (AEC) domain, two general concepts for representing buildings have gained particular attention in recent years. First, the concept of Building Information Modeling (BIM) is increasingly used as a modern means for representing and managing a building's as-planned state digitally, including not only a geometric model but also various additional semantic properties. Second, point cloud measurements are now widely used for capturing a building's as-built condition by means of laser scanning techniques. A particular challenge and topic of current research are methods for combining the strengths of both point cloud measurements and Building Information Modeling concepts to quickly obtain accurate building models from measured data. In this thesis, we present our recent approaches to tackle the intermeshed challenges of automated indoor point cloud interpretation using targeted segmentation methods, and the automatic reconstruction of high-level, parametric and volumetric building models as the basis for further usage in BIM scenarios. In contrast to most reconstruction methods available at the time, we fundamentally base our approaches on BIM principles and standards, and overcome critical limitations of previous approaches in order to reconstruct globally plausible, volumetric, and parametric models.Automatische Rekonstruktion von parametrischen, volumetrischen Gebäudemodellen aus 3D Punktwolken Für die Planung, Konstruktion, Modifikation und Analyse von Gebäuden werden Möglichkeiten zur sinnvollen Repräsentation der physischen Gebäudestruktur sowie dazugehöriger Semantik benötigt. Mit dem Aufkommen neuer Technologien und steigenden Anforderungen im Bereich von Architecture, Engineering and Construction (AEC) haben zwei Konzepte für die Repräsentation von Gebäuden in den letzten Jahren besondere Aufmerksamkeit erlangt. Erstens wird das Konzept des Building Information Modeling (BIM) zunehmend als ein modernes Mittel zur digitalen Abbildung und Verwaltung "As-Planned"-Zustands von Gebäuden verwendet, welches nicht nur ein geometrisches Modell sondern auch verschiedene zusätzliche semantische Eigenschaften beinhaltet. Zweitens werden Punktwolkenmessungen inzwischen häufig zur Aufnahme des "As-Built"-Zustands mittels Laser-Scan-Techniken eingesetzt. Eine besondere Herausforderung und Thema aktueller Forschung ist die Entwicklung von Methoden zur Vereinigung der Stärken von Punktwolken und Konzepten des Building Information Modeling um schnell akkurate Gebäudemodelle aus den gemessenen Daten zu erzeugen. In dieser Dissertation präsentieren wir unsere aktuellen Ansätze um die miteinander verwobenen Herausforderungen anzugehen, Punktwolken mithilfe geeigneter Segmentierungsmethoden automatisiert zu interpretieren, sowie hochwertige, parametrische und volumetrische Gebäudemodelle als Basis für die Verwendung im BIM-Umfeld zu rekonstruieren. Im Gegensatz zu den meisten derzeit verfügbaren Rekonstruktionsverfahren basieren unsere Ansätze grundlegend auf Prinzipien und Standards aus dem BIM-Umfeld und überwinden kritische Einschränkungen bisheriger Ansätze um vollständig plausible, volumetrische und parametrische Modelle zu erzeugen.</p

View generated database

This document represents the final report for the View Generated Database (VGD) project, NAS7-1066. It documents the work done on the project up to the point at which all project work was terminated due to lack of project funds. The VGD was to provide the capability to accurately represent any real-world object or scene as a computer model. Such models include both an accurate spatial/geometric representation of surfaces of the object or scene, as well as any surface detail present on the object. Applications of such models are numerous, including acquisition and maintenance of work models for tele-autonomous systems, generation of accurate 3-D geometric/photometric models for various 3-D vision systems, and graphical models for realistic rendering of 3-D scenes via computer graphics