A Fast Causal Profiler for Task Parallel Programs

This paper proposes TASKPROF, a profiler that identifies parallelism bottlenecks in task parallel programs. It leverages the structure of a task parallel execution to perform fine-grained attribution of work to various parts of the program. TASKPROF's use of hardware performance counters to perform fine-grained measurements minimizes perturbation. TASKPROF's profile execution runs in parallel using multi-cores. TASKPROF's causal profile enables users to estimate improvements in parallelism when a region of code is optimized even when concrete optimizations are not yet known. We have used TASKPROF to isolate parallelism bottlenecks in twenty three applications that use the Intel Threading Building Blocks library. We have designed parallelization techniques in five applications to in- crease parallelism by an order of magnitude using TASKPROF. Our user study indicates that developers are able to isolate performance bottlenecks with ease using TASKPROF.Comment: 11 page

Improving the effective use of multithreaded architectures : implications on compilation, thread assignment, and timing analysis

This thesis presents cross-domain approaches that improve the effective use of multithreaded architectures. The contributions of the thesis can be classified in three groups. First, we propose several methods for thread assignment of network applications running in multithreaded network servers. Second, we analyze the problem of graph partitioning that is a part of the compilation process of multithreaded streaming applications. Finally, we present a method that improves the measurement-based timing analysis of multithreaded architectures used in time-critical environments. The following sections summarize each of the contributions. (1) Thread assignment on multithreaded processors: State-of-the-art multithreaded processors have different level of resource sharing (e.g. between thread running on the same core and globally shared resources). Thus, the way that threads of a given workload are assigned to processors' hardware contexts determines which resources the threads share, which, in turn, may significantly affect the system performance. In this thesis, we demonstrate the importance of thread assignment for network applications running in multithreaded servers. We also present TSBSched and BlackBox scheduler, methods for thread assignment of multithreaded network applications running on processors with several levels of resource sharing. Finally, we propose a statistical approach to the thread assignment problem. In particular, we show that running a sample of several hundred or several thousand random thread assignments is sufficient to capture at least one out of 1% of the best-performing assignments with a very high probability. We also describe the method that estimates the optimal system performance for given workload. We successfull y applied TSBSched, BlackBox scheduler, and the presented statistical approach to a case study of thread assignment of multithreaded network applications running on the UltraSPARC T2 processor. (2) Kernel partitioning of streaming applications: An important step in compiling a stream program to multiple processors is kernel partitioning. Finding an optimal kernel partition is, however, an intractable problem. We propose a statistical approach to the kernel partitioning problem. We describe a method that statistically estimates the performance of the optimal kernel partition. We demonstrate that the sampling method is an important part of the analysis, and that not all methods that generate random samples provide good results. We also show that random sampling on its own can be used to find a good kernel partition, and that it could be an alternative to heuristics-based approaches. The presented statistical method is applied successfully to the benchmarks included in the StreamIt 2.1.1 suite. (3) Multithreaded processors in time-critical environments: Despite the benefits that multithreaded commercial-of-the-shelf (MT COTS) processors may offer in embedded real-time systems, the time-critical market has not yet embraced a shift toward these architectures. The main challenge with MT COTS architectures is the difficulty when predicting the execution time of concurrently-running (co-running) time-critical tasks. Providing a timing analysis for real industrial applications running on MT COTS processors becomes extremely difficult because the execution time of a task, and hence its worst-case execution time (WCET) depends on the interference with co-running tasks in shared processor resources. We show that the measurement-based timing analysis used for single-threaded processors cannot be directly extended for MT COTS architectures. Also, we propose a methodology that quantifies the slowdown that a task may experience because of collision with co-running tasks in shared resources of MT COTS processor. The methodology is applied to a case study in which different time-critical applications were executed on several MT COTS multithreaded processors

Coz: Finding Code that Counts with Causal Profiling

Improving performance is a central concern for software developers. To locate optimization opportunities, developers rely on software profilers. However, these profilers only report where programs spent their time: optimizing that code may have no impact on performance. Past profilers thus both waste developer time and make it difficult for them to uncover significant optimization opportunities. This paper introduces causal profiling. Unlike past profiling approaches, causal profiling indicates exactly where programmers should focus their optimization efforts, and quantifies their potential impact. Causal profiling works by running performance experiments during program execution. Each experiment calculates the impact of any potential optimization by virtually speeding up code: inserting pauses that slow down all other code running concurrently. The key insight is that this slowdown has the same relative effect as running that line faster, thus "virtually" speeding it up. We present Coz, a causal profiler, which we evaluate on a range of highly-tuned applications: Memcached, SQLite, and the PARSEC benchmark suite. Coz identifies previously unknown optimization opportunities that are both significant and targeted. Guided by Coz, we improve the performance of Memcached by 9%, SQLite by 25%, and accelerate six PARSEC applications by as much as 68%; in most cases, these optimizations involve modifying under 10 lines of code.Comment: Published at SOSP 2015 (Best Paper Award

Quantifying the benefits of SPECint distant parallelism in simultaneous multithreading architectures

We exploit the existence of distant parallelism that future compilers could detect and characterise its performance under simultaneous multithreading architectures. By distant parallelism we mean parallelism that cannot be captured by the processor instruction window and that can produce threads suitable for parallel execution in a multithreaded processor. We show that distant parallelism can make feasible wider issue processors by providing more instructions from the distant threads, thus better exploiting the resources from the processor in the case of speeding up single integer applications. We also investigate the necessity of out-of-order processors in the presence of multiple threads of the same program. It is important to notice at this point that the benefits described are totally orthogonal to any other architectural techniques targeting a single thread.Peer ReviewedPostprint (published version

An Initial Evaluation of the Tera Multithreaded Architecture and Programming System Using the C3I Parallel Benchmark Suite

The Tera Multithreaded Architecture (MTA) is a radical new architecture intended to revolutionize high-performance computing in both the scientific and commercial marketplaces. Each processor supports 128 threads in hardware. Extremely fast thread switching is used to mask latency in a uniform-access memory system without caching. It is claimed that these hardware characteristics allow compilers to easily transform sequential programs into efficient multithreaded programs for the Tera MTA. In this paper, we attempt to provide an objective initial evaluation of the performance of the Tera multithreaded architecture and programming system for general-purpose applications. The basis of our investigation is two programs from the C3I Parallel Benchmark Suite (C3IPBS). Both these programs have previously been shown to have the potential for large-scale parallelization. We compare the performance of these programs on (i) a fast uniprocessor, (ii) two conventional shared-memory multiprocessors, and (iii) the first installed Tera MTA (at the San Diego Supercomputer Center). On these platforms, we compare the effectiveness of both automatic and manual parallelization