Access network selection schemes for multiple calls in next generation wireless networks

There is an increasing demand for internet services by mobile subscribers over the wireless access networks, with limited radio resources and capacity constraints. A viable solution to this capacity crunch is the deployment of heterogeneous networks. However, in this wireless environment, the choice of the most appropriate Radio Access Technology (RAT) that can Tsustain or meet the quality of service (QoS) requirements of users' applications require careful planning and cost efficient radio resource management methods. Previous research works on access network selection have focused on selecting a suitable RAT for a user's single call request. With the present request for multiple calls over wireless access networks, where each call has different QoS requirements and the available networks exhibit dynamic channel conditions, the choice of a suitable RAT capable of providing the "Always Best Connected" (ABC) experience for the user becomes a challenge. In this thesis, the problem of selecting the suitable RAT that is capable of meeting the QoS requirements for multiple call requests by mobile users in access networks is investigated. In addressing this problem, we proposed the use of Complex PRoprtional ASsesment (COPRAS) and Consensus-based Multi-Attribute Group Decision Making (MAGDM) techniques as novel and viable RAT selection methods for a grouped-multiple call. The performance of the proposed COPRAS multi-attribute decision making approach to RAT selection for a grouped-call has been evaluated through simulations in different network scenarios. The results show that the COPRAS method, which is simple and flexible, is more efficient in the selection of appropriate RAT for group multiple calls. The COPRAS method reduces handoff frequency and is computationally inexpensive when compared with other methods such as the Technique for Order Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution (TOPSIS), Simple Additive Weighting (SAW) and Multiplicative Exponent Weighting (MEW). The application of the proposed consensus-based algorithm in the selection of a suitable RAT for group-multiple calls, comprising of voice, video-streaming, and file-downloading has been intensively investigated. This algorithm aggregates the QoS requirement of the individual application into a collective QoS for the group calls. This new and novel approach to RAT selection for a grouped-call measures and compares the consensus degree of the collective solution and individual solution against a predefined threshold value. Using the methods of coincidence among preferences and coincidence among solutions with a predefined consensus threshold of 0.9, we evaluated the performance of the consensus-based RAT selection scheme through simulations under different network scenarios. The obtained results show that both methods of coincidences have the capability to select the most suitable RAT for a group of multiple calls. However, the method of coincidence among solutions achieves better results in terms of accuracy, it is less complex and the number of iteration before achieving the predefined consensus threshold is reduced. A utility-based RAT selection method for parallel traffic-streaming in an overlapped heterogeneous wireless network has also been developed. The RAT selection method was modeled with constraints on terminal battery power, service cost and network congestion to select a specified number of RATs that optimizes the terminal interface utility. The results obtained show an optimum RAT selection strategy that maximizes the terminal utility and selects the best RAT combinations for user's parallel-streaming for voice, video and file-download

Will SDN be part of 5G?

For many, this is no longer a valid question and the case is considered settled with SDN/NFV (Software Defined Networking/Network Function Virtualization) providing the inevitable innovation enablers solving many outstanding management issues regarding 5G. However, given the monumental task of softwarization of radio access network (RAN) while 5G is just around the corner and some companies have started unveiling their 5G equipment already, the concern is very realistic that we may only see some point solutions involving SDN technology instead of a fully SDN-enabled RAN. This survey paper identifies all important obstacles in the way and looks at the state of the art of the relevant solutions. This survey is different from the previous surveys on SDN-based RAN as it focuses on the salient problems and discusses solutions proposed within and outside SDN literature. Our main focus is on fronthaul, backward compatibility, supposedly disruptive nature of SDN deployment, business cases and monetization of SDN related upgrades, latency of general purpose processors (GPP), and additional security vulnerabilities, softwarization brings along to the RAN. We have also provided a summary of the architectural developments in SDN-based RAN landscape as not all work can be covered under the focused issues. This paper provides a comprehensive survey on the state of the art of SDN-based RAN and clearly points out the gaps in the technology.Comment: 33 pages, 10 figure

Enhanced mobility management mechanisms for 5G networks

Many mechanisms that served the legacy networks till now, are being identified as being grossly sub-optimal for 5G networks. The reason being, the increased complexity of the 5G networks compared previous legacy systems. One such class of mechanisms, important for any wireless standard, is the Mobility Management (MM) mechanisms. MM mechanismsensure the seamless connectivity and continuity of service for a user when it moves away from the geographic location where it initially got attached to the network. In this thesis, we firstly present a detailed state of the art on MM mechanisms. Based on the 5G requirements as well as the initial discussions on Beyond 5G networks, we provision a gap analysis for the current technologies/solutions to satisfy the presented requirements. We also define the persistent challenges that exist concerning MM mechanisms for 5G and beyond networks. Based on these challenges, we define the potential solutions and a novel framework for the 5G and beyond MM mechanisms. This framework specifies a set of MM mechanisms at the access, core and the extreme edge network (users/devices) level, that will help to satisfy the requirements for the 5G and beyond MM mechanisms. Following this, we present an on demand MM service concept. Such an on-demand feature provisions the necessary reliability, scalability and flexibility to the MM mechanisms. It's objective is to ensure that appropriate resources and mobility contexts are defined for users who will have heterogeneous mobility profiles, versatile QoS requirements in a multi-RAT network. Next, in this thesis we tackle the problem of core network signaling that occurs during MM in 5G/4G networks. A novel handover signaling mechanism has been developed, which eliminates unnecessary handshakes during the handover preparation phase, while allowing the transition to future softwarized network architectures. We also provide a handover failure aware handover preparation phase signaling process. We then utilize operator data and a realistic network deployment to perform a comparative analysis of the proposed strategy and the 3GPP handover signaling strategy on a network wide deployment scenario. We show the benefits of our strategy in terms of latency of handover process, and the transmission and processing cost incurred. Lastly, a novel user association and resource allocation methodology, namely AURA-5G, has been proposed. AURA-5G addresses scenarios wherein applications with heterogeneous requirements, i.e., enhanced Mobile Broadband (eMBB) and massive Machine Type Communications (mMTC), are present simultaneously. Consequently, a joint optimization process for performing the user association and resource allocation while being cognizant of heterogeneous application requirements, has been performed. We capture the peculiarities of this important mobility management process through the various constraints, such as backhaul requirements, dual connectivity options, available access resources, minimum rate requirements, etc., that we have imposed on a Mixed Integer Linear Program (MILP). The objective function of this established MILP problem is to maximize the total network throughput of the eMBB users, while satisfying the minimum requirements of the mMTC and eMBB users defined in a given scenario. Through numerical evaluations we show that our approach outperforms the baseline user association scenario significantly. Moreover, we have presented a system fairness analysis, as well as a novel fidelity and computational complexity analysis for the same, which express the utility of our methodology given the myriad network scenarios.Muchos mecanismos que sirvieron en las redes actuales, se están identificando como extremadamente subóptimos para las redes 5G. Esto es debido a la mayor complejidad de las redes 5G. Un tipo de mecanismo importante para cualquier estándar inalámbrico, consiste en el mecanismo de gestión de la movilidad (MM). Los mecanismos MM aseguran la conectividad sin interrupciones y la continuidad del servicio para un usuario cuando éste se aleja de la ubicación geográfica donde inicialmente se conectó a la red. En esta tesis, presentamos, en primer lugar, un estado del arte detallado de los mecanismos MM. Bas ándonos en los requisitos de 5G, así como en las discusiones iniciales sobre las redes Beyond 5G, proporcionamos un análisis de las tecnologías/soluciones actuales para satisfacer los requisitos presentados. También definimos los desafíos persistentes que existen con respecto a los mecanismos MM para redes 5G y Beyond 5G. En base a estos desafíos, definimos las posibles soluciones y un marco novedoso para los mecanismos 5G y Beyond 5G de MM. Este marco especifica un conjunto de mecanismos MM a nivel de red acceso, red del núcleo y extremo de la red (usuarios/dispositivos), que ayudarán a satisfacer los requisitos para los mecanismos MM 5G y posteriores. A continuación, presentamos el concepto de servicio bajo demanda MM. Tal característica proporciona la confiabilidad, escalabilidad y flexibilidad necesarias para los mecanismos MM. Su objetivo es garantizar que se definan los recursos y contextos de movilidad adecuados para los usuarios que tendrán perfiles de movilidad heterogéneos, y requisitos de QoS versátiles en una red multi-RAT. Más adelante, abordamos el problema de la señalización de la red troncal que ocurre durante la gestión de la movilidad en redes 5G/4G. Se ha desarrollado un nuevo mecanismo de señalización de handover, que elimina los intercambios de mensajes innecesarios durante la fase de preparación del handover, al tiempo que permite la transición a futuras arquitecturas de red softwarizada. Utilizamos los datos de operadores y consideramos un despliegue de red realista para realizar un análisis comparativo de la estrategia propuesta y la estrategia de señalización de 3GPP. Mostramos los beneficios de nuestra estrategia en términos de latencia del proceso de handover y los costes de transmisión y procesado. Por último, se ha propuesto una nueva asociación de usuarios y una metodología de asignación de recursos, i.e, AURA-5G. AURA-5G aborda escenarios en los que las aplicaciones con requisitos heterogéneos, i.e., enhanced Mobile Broadband (eMBB) y massive Machine Type Communications (mMTC), están presentes simultáneamente. En consecuencia, se ha llevado a cabo un proceso de optimización conjunta para realizar la asociación de usuarios y la asignación de recursos mientras se tienen en cuenta los requisitos de aplicaciónes heterogéneas. Capturamos las peculiaridades de este importante proceso de gestión de la movilidad a través de las diversas restricciones impuestas, como son los requisitos de backhaul, las opciones de conectividad dual, los recursos de la red de acceso disponibles, los requisitos de velocidad mínima, etc., que hemos introducido en un Mixed Integer Linear Program (MILP). La función objetivo de este problema MILP es maximizar el rendimiento total de la red de los usuarios de eMBB, y a la vez satisfacer los requisitos mínimos de los usuarios de mMTC y eMBB definidos en un escenario dado. A través de evaluaciones numéricas, mostramos que nuestro enfoque supera significativamente el escenario de asociación de usuarios de referencia. Además, hemos presentado un análisis de la justicia del sistema, así como un novedoso análisis de fidelidad y complejidad computacional para el mismo, que expresa la utilidad de nuestra metodología

Enhanced mobility management mechanisms for 5G networks

Many mechanisms that served the legacy networks till now, are being identified as being grossly sub-optimal for 5G networks. The reason being, the increased complexity of the 5G networks compared previous legacy systems. One such class of mechanisms, important for any wireless standard, is the Mobility Management (MM) mechanisms. MM mechanismsensure the seamless connectivity and continuity of service for a user when it moves away from the geographic location where it initially got attached to the network. In this thesis, we firstly present a detailed state of the art on MM mechanisms. Based on the 5G requirements as well as the initial discussions on Beyond 5G networks, we provision a gap analysis for the current technologies/solutions to satisfy the presented requirements. We also define the persistent challenges that exist concerning MM mechanisms for 5G and beyond networks. Based on these challenges, we define the potential solutions and a novel framework for the 5G and beyond MM mechanisms. This framework specifies a set of MM mechanisms at the access, core and the extreme edge network (users/devices) level, that will help to satisfy the requirements for the 5G and beyond MM mechanisms. Following this, we present an on demand MM service concept. Such an on-demand feature provisions the necessary reliability, scalability and flexibility to the MM mechanisms. It's objective is to ensure that appropriate resources and mobility contexts are defined for users who will have heterogeneous mobility profiles, versatile QoS requirements in a multi-RAT network. Next, in this thesis we tackle the problem of core network signaling that occurs during MM in 5G/4G networks. A novel handover signaling mechanism has been developed, which eliminates unnecessary handshakes during the handover preparation phase, while allowing the transition to future softwarized network architectures. We also provide a handover failure aware handover preparation phase signaling process. We then utilize operator data and a realistic network deployment to perform a comparative analysis of the proposed strategy and the 3GPP handover signaling strategy on a network wide deployment scenario. We show the benefits of our strategy in terms of latency of handover process, and the transmission and processing cost incurred. Lastly, a novel user association and resource allocation methodology, namely AURA-5G, has been proposed. AURA-5G addresses scenarios wherein applications with heterogeneous requirements, i.e., enhanced Mobile Broadband (eMBB) and massive Machine Type Communications (mMTC), are present simultaneously. Consequently, a joint optimization process for performing the user association and resource allocation while being cognizant of heterogeneous application requirements, has been performed. We capture the peculiarities of this important mobility management process through the various constraints, such as backhaul requirements, dual connectivity options, available access resources, minimum rate requirements, etc., that we have imposed on a Mixed Integer Linear Program (MILP). The objective function of this established MILP problem is to maximize the total network throughput of the eMBB users, while satisfying the minimum requirements of the mMTC and eMBB users defined in a given scenario. Through numerical evaluations we show that our approach outperforms the baseline user association scenario significantly. Moreover, we have presented a system fairness analysis, as well as a novel fidelity and computational complexity analysis for the same, which express the utility of our methodology given the myriad network scenarios.Muchos mecanismos que sirvieron en las redes actuales, se están identificando como extremadamente subóptimos para las redes 5G. Esto es debido a la mayor complejidad de las redes 5G. Un tipo de mecanismo importante para cualquier estándar inalámbrico, consiste en el mecanismo de gestión de la movilidad (MM). Los mecanismos MM aseguran la conectividad sin interrupciones y la continuidad del servicio para un usuario cuando éste se aleja de la ubicación geográfica donde inicialmente se conectó a la red. En esta tesis, presentamos, en primer lugar, un estado del arte detallado de los mecanismos MM. Bas ándonos en los requisitos de 5G, así como en las discusiones iniciales sobre las redes Beyond 5G, proporcionamos un análisis de las tecnologías/soluciones actuales para satisfacer los requisitos presentados. También definimos los desafíos persistentes que existen con respecto a los mecanismos MM para redes 5G y Beyond 5G. En base a estos desafíos, definimos las posibles soluciones y un marco novedoso para los mecanismos 5G y Beyond 5G de MM. Este marco especifica un conjunto de mecanismos MM a nivel de red acceso, red del núcleo y extremo de la red (usuarios/dispositivos), que ayudarán a satisfacer los requisitos para los mecanismos MM 5G y posteriores. A continuación, presentamos el concepto de servicio bajo demanda MM. Tal característica proporciona la confiabilidad, escalabilidad y flexibilidad necesarias para los mecanismos MM. Su objetivo es garantizar que se definan los recursos y contextos de movilidad adecuados para los usuarios que tendrán perfiles de movilidad heterogéneos, y requisitos de QoS versátiles en una red multi-RAT. Más adelante, abordamos el problema de la señalización de la red troncal que ocurre durante la gestión de la movilidad en redes 5G/4G. Se ha desarrollado un nuevo mecanismo de señalización de handover, que elimina los intercambios de mensajes innecesarios durante la fase de preparación del handover, al tiempo que permite la transición a futuras arquitecturas de red softwarizada. Utilizamos los datos de operadores y consideramos un despliegue de red realista para realizar un análisis comparativo de la estrategia propuesta y la estrategia de señalización de 3GPP. Mostramos los beneficios de nuestra estrategia en términos de latencia del proceso de handover y los costes de transmisión y procesado. Por último, se ha propuesto una nueva asociación de usuarios y una metodología de asignación de recursos, i.e, AURA-5G. AURA-5G aborda escenarios en los que las aplicaciones con requisitos heterogéneos, i.e., enhanced Mobile Broadband (eMBB) y massive Machine Type Communications (mMTC), están presentes simultáneamente. En consecuencia, se ha llevado a cabo un proceso de optimización conjunta para realizar la asociación de usuarios y la asignación de recursos mientras se tienen en cuenta los requisitos de aplicaciónes heterogéneas. Capturamos las peculiaridades de este importante proceso de gestión de la movilidad a través de las diversas restricciones impuestas, como son los requisitos de backhaul, las opciones de conectividad dual, los recursos de la red de acceso disponibles, los requisitos de velocidad mínima, etc., que hemos introducido en un Mixed Integer Linear Program (MILP). La función objetivo de este problema MILP es maximizar el rendimiento total de la red de los usuarios de eMBB, y a la vez satisfacer los requisitos mínimos de los usuarios de mMTC y eMBB definidos en un escenario dado. A través de evaluaciones numéricas, mostramos que nuestro enfoque supera significativamente el escenario de asociación de usuarios de referencia. Además, hemos presentado un análisis de la justicia del sistema, así como un novedoso análisis de fidelidad y complejidad computacional para el mismo, que expresa la utilidad de nuestra metodología.Postprint (published version

Assessing the WiFi offloading benefit on both service performance and EMF exposure in urban areas

In this paper we assess the benefit of WiFi offloading over dense urban scenarios in terms of both Quality of Service (QoS) and Electromagnetic Field (EMF) exposure. This study relies on results obtained with two complementary simulation platforms: a two-tier dynamic system-level simulator and a 3D coverage-based simulator. Outputs are usual service coverage key performance indicators, handover probability statistics, as well as common and innovative metrics for EMF exposure characterization that jointly take into account the contributions from the base-station and the User-Equipment (UE) transmissions. The main outcome is that, for elastic services, the best QoS and minimum global EMF exposure are jointly achieved with maximum WiFi offloading.This paper reports work undertaken in the context of the FP7 project LEXNET (GA nº 318273). Ramón Agüero also acknowledges the Spanish Government for the project “Connectivity as a Service: Access for the Internet of the Future”, COSAIF (TEC2012-38574-C02-02)

An Innovative RAN Architecture for Emerging Heterogeneous Networks: The Road to the 5G Era

The global demand for mobile-broadband data services has experienced phenomenal growth over the last few years, driven by the rapid proliferation of smart devices such as smartphones and tablets. This growth is expected to continue unabated as mobile data traffic is predicted to grow anywhere from 20 to 50 times over the next 5 years. Exacerbating the problem is that such unprecedented surge in smartphones usage, which is characterized by frequent short on/off connections and mobility, generates heavy signaling traffic load in the network signaling storms . This consumes a disproportion amount of network resources, compromising network throughput and efficiency, and in extreme cases can cause the Third-Generation (3G) or 4G (long-term evolution (LTE) and LTE-Advanced (LTE-A)) cellular networks to crash. As the conventional approaches of improving the spectral efficiency and/or allocation additional spectrum are fast approaching their theoretical limits, there is a growing consensus that current 3G and 4G (LTE/LTE-A) cellular radio access technologies (RATs) won\u27t be able to meet the anticipated growth in mobile traffic demand. To address these challenges, the wireless industry and standardization bodies have initiated a roadmap for transition from 4G to 5G cellular technology with a key objective to increase capacity by 1000Ã? by 2020 . Even though the technology hasn\u27t been invented yet, the hype around 5G networks has begun to bubble. The emerging consensus is that 5G is not a single technology, but rather a synergistic collection of interworking technical innovations and solutions that collectively address the challenge of traffic growth. The core emerging ingredients that are widely considered the key enabling technologies to realize the envisioned 5G era, listed in the order of importance, are: 1) Heterogeneous networks (HetNets); 2) flexible backhauling; 3) efficient traffic offload techniques; and 4) Self Organizing Networks (SONs). The anticipated solutions delivered by efficient interworking/ integration of these enabling technologies are not simply about throwing more resources and /or spectrum at the challenge. The envisioned solution, however, requires radically different cellular RAN and mobile core architectures that efficiently and cost-effectively deploy and manage radio resources as well as offload mobile traffic from the overloaded core network. The main objective of this thesis is to address the key techno-economics challenges facing the transition from current Fourth-Generation (4G) cellular technology to the 5G era in the context of proposing a novel high-risk revolutionary direction to the design and implementation of the envisioned 5G cellular networks. The ultimate goal is to explore the potential and viability of cost-effectively implementing the 1000x capacity challenge while continuing to provide adequate mobile broadband experience to users. Specifically, this work proposes and devises a novel PON-based HetNet mobile backhaul RAN architecture that: 1) holistically addresses the key techno-economics hurdles facing the implementation of the envisioned 5G cellular technology, specifically, the backhauling and signaling challenges; and 2) enables, for the first time to the best of our knowledge, the support of efficient ground-breaking mobile data and signaling offload techniques, which significantly enhance the performance of both the HetNet-based RAN and LTE-A\u27s core network (Evolved Packet Core (EPC) per 3GPP standard), ensure that core network equipment is used more productively, and moderate the evolving 5G\u27s signaling growth and optimize its impact. To address the backhauling challenge, we propose a cost-effective fiber-based small cell backhaul infrastructure, which leverages existing fibered and powered facilities associated with a PON-based fiber-to-the-Node/Home (FTTN/FTTH)) residential access network. Due to the sharing of existing valuable fiber assets, the proposed PON-based backhaul architecture, in which the small cells are collocated with existing FTTN remote terminals (optical network units (ONUs)), is much more economical than conventional point-to-point (PTP) fiber backhaul designs. A fully distributed ring-based EPON architecture is utilized here as the fiber-based HetNet backhaul. The techno-economics merits of utilizing the proposed PON-based FTTx access HetNet RAN architecture versus that of traditional 4G LTE-A\u27s RAN will be thoroughly examined and quantified. Specifically, we quantify the techno-economics merits of the proposed PON-based HetNet backhaul by comparing its performance versus that of a conventional fiber-based PTP backhaul architecture as a benchmark. It is shown that the purposely selected ring-based PON architecture along with the supporting distributed control plane enable the proposed PON-based FTTx RAN architecture to support several key salient networking features that collectively significantly enhance the overall performance of both the HetNet-based RAN and 4G LTE-A\u27s core (EPC) compared to that of the typical fiber-based PTP backhaul architecture in terms of handoff capability, signaling overhead, overall network throughput and latency, and QoS support. It will also been shown that the proposed HetNet-based RAN architecture is not only capable of providing the typical macro-cell offloading gain (RAN gain) but also can provide ground-breaking EPC offloading gain. The simulation results indicate that the overall capacity of the proposed HetNet scales with the number of deployed small cells, thanks to LTE-A\u27s advanced interference management techniques. For example, if there are 10 deployed outdoor small cells for every macrocell in the network, then the overall capacity will be approximately 10-11x capacity gain over a macro-only network. To reach the 1000x capacity goal, numerous small cells including 3G, 4G, and WiFi (femtos, picos, metros, relays, remote radio heads, distributed antenna systems) need to be deployed indoors and outdoors, at all possible venues (residences and enterprises)

Proportional and Preemption-enabled Traffic Offloading for IP Flow Mobility:Algorithms and Performance Evaluation

IP Flow Mobility (IFOM) enables a user equipment to offload data traffic at the IP flow level. Although the procedure of IFOM-based flow offloading has been specified by 3GPP, how many IP flows should be offloaded and when offloading should be performed are not defined. Consequently, IP flows may be routed to a target access network which has a strong signal strength but with backhaul congestion or insufficient access capability. In this paper, we propose two algorithms, referred to as proportional offloading (PO), and proportional and preemption-enabled offloading (PPO), respectively, for IP flow offloading in hybrid cellular and wireless local area networks. The PO algorithm decides an optimal proportion of IP flows which could be offloaded by considering available resources at the target access network. In the PPO algorithm, both service continuity and network utilization are taken into consideration. Furthermore, a detailed analytical model is developed in order to evaluate the behavior of the proposed algorithms. The analytical model is validated through extensive simulations. The results show that by dynamically adjusting the percentage of traffic flows to be offloaded, PO can reduce blocking probability and increase resource utilization. PPO further improves the performance at the cost of slightly higher offloading overhead