245 research outputs found
A Joint Matrix Factorization Analysis of Multilingual Representations
We present an analysis tool based on joint matrix factorization for comparing
latent representations of multilingual and monolingual models. An alternative
to probing, this tool allows us to analyze multiple sets of representations in
a joint manner. Using this tool, we study to what extent and how
morphosyntactic features are reflected in the representations learned by
multilingual pre-trained models. We conduct a large-scale empirical study of
over 33 languages and 17 morphosyntactic categories. Our findings demonstrate
variations in the encoding of morphosyntactic information across upper and
lower layers, with category-specific differences influenced by language
properties. Hierarchical clustering of the factorization outputs yields a tree
structure that is related to phylogenetic trees manually crafted by linguists.
Moreover, we find the factorization outputs exhibit strong associations with
performance observed across different cross-lingual tasks. We release our code
to facilitate future research.Comment: Accepted to Findings of EMNLP 202
Understanding Word Embedding Stability Across Languages and Applications
Despite the recent popularity of word embedding methods, there is only a small body of work exploring the limitations of these representations. In this thesis, we consider several aspects of embedding spaces, including their stability. First, we propose a definition of stability, and show that common English word embeddings are surprisingly unstable. We explore how properties of data, words, and algorithms relate to instability. We extend this work to approximately 100 world languages, considering how linguistic typology relates to stability. Additionally, we consider contextualized output embedding spaces. Using paraphrases, we explore properties and assumptions of BERT, a popular embedding algorithm.
Second, we consider how stability and other word embedding properties affect tasks where embeddings are commonly used. We consider both word embeddings used as features in downstream applications and corpus-centered applications, where embeddings are used to study characteristics of language and individual writers. In addition to stability, we also consider other word embedding properties, specifically batching and curriculum learning, and how methodological choices made for these properties affect downstream tasks.
Finally, we consider how knowledge of stability affects how we use word embeddings. Throughout this thesis, we discuss strategies to mitigate instability and provide analyses highlighting the strengths and weaknesses of word embeddings in different scenarios and languages. We show areas where more work is needed to improve embeddings, and we show where embeddings are already a strong tool.PHDComputer Science & EngineeringUniversity of Michigan, Horace H. Rackham School of Graduate Studieshttp://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/162917/1/lburdick_1.pd
General methods for fine-grained morphological and syntactic disambiguation
We present methods for improved handling of morphologically
rich languages (MRLS) where we define
MRLS as languages that
are morphologically more complex than English. Standard
algorithms for language modeling, tagging and parsing have
problems with the productive nature of such
languages. Consider for example the possible forms of a
typical English verb like work that generally has four
four different
forms: work, works, working
and worked. Its Spanish counterpart trabajar
has 6 different forms in present
tense: trabajo, trabajas, trabaja, trabajamos, trabajáis
and trabajan and more than 50 different forms when
including the different tenses, moods (indicative,
subjunctive and imperative) and participles. Such a high
number of forms leads to sparsity issues: In a recent
Wikipedia dump of more than 400 million tokens we find that
20 of these forms occur only twice or less and that 10 forms
do not occur at all. This means that even if we only need
unlabeled data to estimate a model and even when looking at
a relatively common and frequent verb, we do not have enough
data to make reasonable estimates for some of its
forms. However, if we decompose an unseen form such
as trabajaréis `you will work', we find that it
is trabajar in future tense and second person
plural. This allows us to make the predictions that are
needed to decide on the grammaticality (language modeling)
or syntax (tagging and parsing) of a sentence.
In the first part of this thesis, we develop
a morphological language model. A language model
estimates the grammaticality and coherence of a
sentence. Most language models used today are word-based
n-gram models, which means that they estimate the
transitional probability of a word following a history, the
sequence of the (n - 1) preceding words. The probabilities
are estimated from the frequencies of the history and the
history followed by the target word in a huge text
corpus. If either of the sequences is unseen, the length of
the history has to be reduced. This leads to a less accurate
estimate as less context is taken into account.
Our morphological language model estimates an additional
probability from the morphological classes of the
words. These classes are built automatically by extracting
morphological features from the word forms. To this end, we
use unsupervised segmentation algorithms to find the
suffixes of word forms. Such an algorithm might for example
segment trabajaréis into trabaja
and réis and we can then estimate the properties
of trabajaréis from other word forms with the same or
similar morphological properties. The data-driven nature of
the segmentation algorithms allows them to not only find
inflectional suffixes (such as -réis), but also more
derivational phenomena such as the head nouns of compounds
or even endings such as -tec, which identify
technology oriented companies such
as Vortec, Memotec and Portec and would
not be regarded as a morphological suffix by traditional
linguistics. Additionally, we extract shape features such as
if a form contains digits or capital characters. This is
important because many rare or unseen forms are proper
names or numbers and often do not have meaningful
suffixes. Our class-based morphological model is then
interpolated with a word-based model to combine the
generalization capabilities of the first and the high
accuracy in case of sufficient data of the second.
We evaluate our model across 21 European languages and find
improvements between 3% and 11% in perplexity, a standard
language modeling evaluation measure. Improvements are
highest for languages with more productive and complex
morphology such as Finnish and Estonian, but also visible
for languages with a relatively simple morphology such as
English and Dutch. We conclude that a morphological
component yields consistent improvements for all the tested
languages and argue that it should be part of every language
model.
Dependency trees represent the syntactic structure of a
sentence by attaching each word to its syntactic head, the
word it is directly modifying. Dependency parsing
is usually tackled using heavily lexicalized (word-based)
models and a thorough morphological preprocessing is
important for optimal performance, especially for MRLS. We
investigate if the lack of morphological features can be
compensated by features induced using hidden Markov
models with latent annotations (HMM-LAs)
and find this to be the case for German. HMM-LAs were
proposed as a method to increase part-of-speech tagging
accuracy. The model splits the observed part-of-speech tags
(such as verb and noun) into subtags. An expectation
maximization algorithm is then used to fit the subtags to
different roles. A verb tag for example might be split into
an auxiliary verb and a full verb subtag. Such a split is
usually beneficial because these two verb classes have
different contexts. That is, a full verb might follow an
auxiliary verb, but usually not another full verb.
For German and English, we find that our model leads to
consistent improvements over a parser
not using subtag features. Looking at the labeled attachment
score (LAS), the number of words correctly attached to their head,
we observe an improvement from 90.34 to 90.75 for English
and from 87.92 to 88.24 for German. For German, we
additionally find that our model achieves almost the same
performance (88.24) as a model using tags annotated by a
supervised morphological tagger (LAS of 88.35). We also find
that the German latent tags correlate with
morphology. Articles for example are split by their
grammatical case.
We also investigate the part-of-speech tagging accuracies of
models using the traditional treebank tagset and models
using induced tagsets of the same size and find that the
latter outperform the former, but are in turn outperformed
by a discriminative tagger.
Furthermore, we present a method for fast and
accurate morphological tagging. While
part-of-speech tagging annotates tokens in context with
their respective word categories, morphological tagging
produces a complete annotation containing all the relevant
inflectional features such as case, gender and tense. A
complete reading is represented as a single tag. As a
reading might consist of several morphological features the
resulting tagset usually contains hundreds or even thousands
of tags. This is an issue for many decoding algorithms such
as Viterbi which have runtimes depending quadratically on
the number of tags. In the case of morphological tagging,
the problem can be avoided by using a morphological
analyzer. A morphological analyzer is a manually created
finite-state transducer that produces the possible
morphological readings of a word form. This analyzer can be
used to prune the tagging lattice and to allow for the
application of standard sequence labeling algorithms. The
downside of this approach is that such an analyzer is not
available for every language or might not have the coverage
required for the task. Additionally, the output tags of some
analyzers are not compatible with the annotations of the
treebanks, which might require some manual mapping of the
different annotations or even to reduce the complexity of
the annotation.
To avoid this problem we propose to use the posterior
probabilities of a conditional random field (CRF)
lattice to prune the space of possible
taggings. At the zero-order level the posterior
probabilities of a token can be calculated independently
from the other tokens of a sentence. The necessary
computations can thus be performed in linear time. The
features available to the model at this time are similar to
the features used by a morphological analyzer (essentially
the word form and features based on it), but also include
the immediate lexical context. As the ambiguity of word
types varies substantially, we just fix the average number of
readings after pruning by dynamically estimating a
probability threshold. Once we obtain the pruned lattice, we
can add tag transitions and convert it into a first-order
lattice. The quadratic forward-backward computations are now
executed on the remaining plausible readings and thus
efficient. We can now continue pruning and extending the
lattice order at a relatively low additional runtime cost
(depending on the pruning thresholds). The training of the
model can be implemented efficiently by applying stochastic
gradient descent (SGD). The CRF gradient can be calculated
from a lattice of any order as long as the correct reading
is still in the lattice. During training, we thus run the
lattice pruning until we either reach the maximal order or
until the correct reading is pruned. If the reading is
pruned we perform the gradient update with the highest order
lattice still containing the reading. This approach is
similar to early updating in the structured perceptron
literature and forces the model to learn how to keep the
correct readings in the lower order lattices. In practice,
we observe a high number of lower updates during the first
training epoch and almost exclusively higher order updates
during later epochs.
We evaluate our CRF tagger on six languages with different
morphological properties. We find that for languages with a
high word form ambiguity such as German, the pruning results
in a moderate drop in tagging accuracy while for languages
with less ambiguity such as Spanish and Hungarian the loss
due to pruning is negligible. However, our pruning strategy
allows us to train higher order models (order > 1), which give
substantial improvements for all languages and also
outperform unpruned first-order models. That is, the model
might lose some of the correct readings during pruning, but
is also able to solve more of the harder cases that require
more context. We also find our model to substantially and
significantly outperform a number of frequently used taggers
such as Morfette and SVMTool.
Based on our morphological tagger we develop a simple method
to increase the performance of a state-of-the-art
constituency parser. A constituency tree
describes the syntactic properties of a sentence by
assigning spans of text to a hierarchical bracket
structure. developed a
language-independent approach for the automatic annotation
of accurate and compact grammars. Their implementation --
known as the Berkeley parser -- gives state-of-the-art results
for many languages such as English and German. For some MRLS
such as Basque and Korean, however, the parser gives
unsatisfactory results because of its simple unknown word
model. This model maps unknown words to a small number of
signatures (similar to our morphological classes). These
signatures do not seem expressive enough for many of the
subtle distinctions made during parsing. We propose to
replace rare words by the morphological reading generated by
our tagger instead. The motivation is twofold. First, our
tagger has access to a number of lexical and sublexical
features not available during parsing. Second, we expect
the morphological readings to contain most of the
information required to make the correct parsing decision
even though we know that things such as the correct
attachment of prepositional phrases might require some
notion of lexical semantics.
In experiments on the SPMRL 2013 dataset
of nine MRLS we find our method to give improvements for all
languages except French for which we observe a minor drop in
the Parseval score of 0.06. For Hebrew, Hungarian and
Basque we find substantial absolute improvements of 5.65,
11.87 and 15.16, respectively.
We also performed an extensive evaluation on the utility of
word representations for morphological tagging. Our goal was
to reduce the drop in performance that is caused when a
model trained on a specific domain is applied to some other
domain. This problem is usually addressed by domain adaption
(DA). DA adapts a model towards a specific domain using a
small amount of labeled or a huge amount of unlabeled data
from that domain. However, this procedure requires us to
train a model for every target domain. Instead we are trying
to build a robust system that is trained on domain-specific
labeled and domain-independent or general unlabeled data. We
believe word representations to be key in the development of
such models because they allow us to leverage unlabeled
data efficiently. We compare data-driven representations to
manually created morphological analyzers. We understand
data-driven representations as models that cluster word
forms or map them to a vectorial representation. Examples
heavily used in the literature include Brown clusters,
Singular Value Decompositions of count
vectors and neural-network-based
embeddings. We create a test suite of
six languages consisting of in-domain and out-of-domain test
sets. To this end we converted annotations for Spanish and
Czech and annotated the German part of the Smultron
treebank with a morphological layer. In
our experiments on these data sets we find Brown clusters to
outperform the other data-driven representations. Regarding
the comparison with morphological analyzers, we find Brown
clusters to give slightly better performance in
part-of-speech tagging, but to be substantially outperformed
in morphological tagging
Modeling Language Variation and Universals: A Survey on Typological Linguistics for Natural Language Processing
Linguistic typology aims to capture structural and semantic variation across
the world's languages. A large-scale typology could provide excellent guidance
for multilingual Natural Language Processing (NLP), particularly for languages
that suffer from the lack of human labeled resources. We present an extensive
literature survey on the use of typological information in the development of
NLP techniques. Our survey demonstrates that to date, the use of information in
existing typological databases has resulted in consistent but modest
improvements in system performance. We show that this is due to both intrinsic
limitations of databases (in terms of coverage and feature granularity) and
under-employment of the typological features included in them. We advocate for
a new approach that adapts the broad and discrete nature of typological
categories to the contextual and continuous nature of machine learning
algorithms used in contemporary NLP. In particular, we suggest that such
approach could be facilitated by recent developments in data-driven induction
of typological knowledge
On conditional random fields: applications, feature selection, parameter estimation and hierarchical modelling
There has been a growing interest in stochastic modelling and learning with complex data, whose elements are structured and interdependent. One of the most successful methods to model data dependencies is graphical models, which is a combination of graph theory and probability theory. This thesis focuses on a special type of graphical models known as Conditional Random Fields (CRFs) (Lafferty et al., 2001), in which the output state spaces, when conditioned on some observational input data, are represented by undirected graphical models. The contributions of thesis involve both (a) broadening the current applicability of CRFs in the real world and (b) deepening the understanding of theoretical aspects of CRFs. On the application side, we empirically investigate the applications of CRFs in two real world settings. The first application is on a novel domain of Vietnamese accent restoration, in which we need to restore accents of an accent-less Vietnamese sentence. Experiments on half a million sentences of news articles show that the CRF-based approach is highly accurate. In the second application, we develop a new CRF-based movie recommendation system called Preference Network (PN). The PN jointly integrates various sources of domain knowledge into a large and densely connected Markov network. We obtained competitive results against well-established methods in the recommendation field.On the theory side, the thesis addresses three important theoretical issues of CRFs: feature selection, parameter estimation and modelling recursive sequential data. These issues are all addressed under a general setting of partial supervision in that training labels are not fully available. For feature selection, we introduce a novel learning algorithm called AdaBoost.CRF that incrementally selects features out of a large feature pool as learning proceeds. AdaBoost.CRF is an extension of the standard boosting methodology to structured and partially observed data. We demonstrate that the AdaBoost.CRF is able to eliminate irrelevant features and as a result, returns a very compact feature set without significant loss of accuracy. Parameter estimation of CRFs is generally intractable in arbitrary network structures. This thesis contributes to this area by proposing a learning method called AdaBoost.MRF (which stands for AdaBoosted Markov Random Forests). As learning proceeds AdaBoost.MRF incrementally builds a tree ensemble (a forest) that cover the original network by selecting the best spanning tree at a time. As a result, we can approximately learn many rich classes of CRFs in linear time. The third theoretical work is on modelling recursive, sequential data in that each level of resolution is a Markov sequence, where each state in the sequence is also a Markov sequence at the finer grain. One of the key contributions of this thesis is Hierarchical Conditional Random Fields (HCRF), which is an extension to the currently popular sequential CRF and the recent semi-Markov CRF (Sarawagi and Cohen, 2004). Unlike previous CRF work, the HCRF does not assume any fixed graphical structures.Rather, it treats structure as an uncertain aspect and it can estimate the structure automatically from the data. The HCRF is motivated by Hierarchical Hidden Markov Model (HHMM) (Fine et al., 1998). Importantly, the thesis shows that the HHMM is a special case of HCRF with slight modification, and the semi-Markov CRF is essentially a flat version of the HCRF. Central to our contribution in HCRF is a polynomial-time algorithm based on the Asymmetric Inside Outside (AIO) family developed in (Bui et al., 2004) for learning and inference. Another important contribution is to extend the AIO family to address learning with missing data and inference under partially observed labels. We also derive methods to deal with practical concerns associated with the AIO family, including numerical overflow and cubic-time complexity. Finally, we demonstrate good performance of HCRF against rivals on two applications: indoor video surveillance and noun-phrase chunking
Adaptation and Augmentation: Towards Better Rescoring Strategies for Automatic Speech Recognition and Spoken Term Detection
Selecting the best prediction from a set of candidates is an essential problem for many spoken language processing tasks, including automatic speech recognition (ASR) and spoken keyword spotting (KWS). Generally, the selection is determined by a confidence score assigned to each candidate. Calibrating these confidence scores (i.e., rescoring them) could make better selections and improve the system performance. This dissertation focuses on using tailored language models to rescore ASR hypotheses as well as keyword search results for ASR-based KWS.
This dissertation introduces three kinds of rescoring techniques: (1) Freezing most model parameters while fine-tuning the output layer in order to adapt neural network language models (NNLMs) from the written domain to the spoken domain. Experiments on a large-scale Italian corpus show a 30.2% relative reduction in perplexity at the word-cluster level and a 2.3% relative reduction in WER in a state-of-the-art Italian ASR system. (2) Incorporating source application information associated with speech queries. By exploring a range of adaptation model architectures, we achieve a 21.3% relative reduction in perplexity compared to a fine-tuned baseline. Initial experiments using a state-of-the-art Italian ASR system show a 3.0% relative reduction in WER on top of an unadapted 5-gram LM. In addition, human evaluations show significant improvements by using the source application information. (3) Marrying machine learning algorithms (classification and ranking) with a variety of signals to rescore keyword search results in the context of KWS for low-resource languages. These systems, built for the IARPA BABEL Program, enhance search performance in terms of maximum term-weighted value (MTWV) across six different low-resource languages: Vietnamese, Tagalog, Pashto, Turkish, Zulu and Tamil
- …