Discordant voting processes on finite graphs

We consider an asynchronous voting process on graphs which we call discordant voting, and which can be described as follows. Initially each vertex holds one of two opinions, red or blue say. Neighbouring vertices with different opinions interact pairwise. After an interaction both vertices have the same colour. The quantity of interest is T, the time to reach consensus, i.e. the number of interactions needed for all vertices have the same colour. An edge whose endpoint colours differ (i.e. one vertex is coloured red and the other one blue) is said to be discordant. A vertex is discordant if its is incident with a discordant edge. In discordant voting, all interactions are based on discordant edges. Because the voting process is asynchronous there are several ways to update the colours of the interacting vertices. Push: Pick a random discordant vertex and push its colour to a random discordant neighbour. Pull: Pick a random discordant vertex and pull the colour of a random discordant neighbour. Oblivious: Pick a random endpoint of a random discordant edge and push the colour to the other end point. We show that ET, the expected time to reach consensus, depends strongly on the underlying graph and the update rule. For connected graphs on n vertices, and an initial half red, half blue colouring the following hold. For oblivious voting, ET = n2/4 independent of the underlying graph. For the complete graph Kn, the push protocol has ET = =(n log n), whereas the pull protocol has ET = =(2n). For the cycle Cn all three protocols have ET = =(n2). For the star graph however, the pull protocol has ET = O(n2), whereas the push protocol is slower with ET = =(n2 log n). The wide variation in ET for the pull protocol is to be contrasted with the well known model of synchronous pull voting, for which ET = O(n) on many classes of expanders

Discordant Voting Processes on Finite Graphs

We consider an asynchronous voting process on graphs called discordant voting, which can be described as follows. Initially each vertex holds one of two opinions, red or blue. Neighboring vertices with different opinions interact pairwise along an edge. After an interaction both vertices have the same color. The quantity of interest is the time to reach consensus, i.e., the number of steps needed for all vertices have the same color. We show that for a given initial coloring of the vertices, the expected time to reach consensus depends strongly on the underlying graph and the update rule (i.e., push, pull, oblivious)

Reality Inspired Voter Models: A Mini-Review

This mini-review presents extensions of the voter model that incorporate various plausible features of real decision-making processes by individuals. Although these generalizations are not calibrated by empirical data, the resulting dynamics are suggestive of realistic collective social behaviors.Comment: 13 pages, 16 figures. Version 2 contains various proofreading improvements. V3: fixed one trivial typ

Discordant voting protocols for cyclically linked agents

Voting protocols, such as the push and the pull protocol, are designed to model the behavior of people during an election, but they have other applications. These processes have been studied in many areas, including but not limited to social models of interaction, distributed computing in peer-to-peer networks, and to describe how viruses or rumors spread in a community. In this paper we study the runtime of discordant linear protocols on the cycle graph, and the probability for each consensus to win in the end

Nonlinear opinion models and other networked systems

Networks play a critical role in many physical, biological, and social systems. In this thesis, we investigate tools to model and analyze networked systems. We first examine some of the ways in which we can model social dynamics that take place on networks. We then study two recently developed data-analysis methods that employ a network framework and explore new ways in which they can be used to find meaningful signals in large data sets. In the first half of the thesis, we study opinion dynamics on networks. We begin by examining a class of opinion models, known as coevolving voter models (CVM), that couple the mechanisms of opinion formation and changing social connections. We then propose a version of CVMs that incorporates nonlinearity. In our models, we assume that individuals strive to achieve harmony and avoid disagreement, both by changing their social connections to reflect their opinions and by changing their opinions to reflect their social connections. By taking a minimalist approach to modeling social dynamics, we hope to gain a deeper understanding of how these two mechanisms can give rise to social phenomena such as the ``majority illusion''. Comparing several versions of CVMs, we find that seemingly small changes in update rules can lead to strikingly different behaviors. A particularly interesting feature of our nonlinear CVMs is that, under certain conditions, the opinion state that is held initially by a minority of the nodes can effectively spread to almost every node in a network if the minority nodes view themselves as the majority. We then discuss an ongoing project that involves another class of opinion models called bounded-confidence models. Specifically, we examine extensions of bounded-confidence models on hypergraphs and discuss some preliminary findings. In the second half of the thesis, we study problems in data analysis. We begin by considering topological structures as a tool to study integrated circuit (IC) devices. In particular, we examine a problem in the design and manufacturing of IC devices using topological data analysis (TDA), which is based on network structures called simplicial complexes. Failures in IC devices generally occur near the tolerance limits of photolithography systems, such as at the minimum separation distance between adjacent electronic components. However, for complex arrangements of electronic components, simply ensuring minimal separation is insufficient to guarantee that one can manufacture an IC design accurately and reliably. We apply tools from TDA to compare data from IC designs. Without inputting domain knowledge, we are able to infer several results about the IC design-manufacturing process. Finally, we discuss an ongoing project in the analysis of network data. Specifically, we explore applications of a recently developed algorithm called network dictionary learning (NDL) and discuss problems of network reconstruction and denoising using NDL on both synthetic and real-world networks