Comparison of multi-layer bus interconnection and a network on chip solution

Abstract. This thesis explains the basic subjects that are required to take in consideration when designing a network on chip solutions in the semiconductor world. For example, general topologies such as mesh, torus, octagon and fat tree are explained. In addition, discussion related to network interfaces, switches, arbitration, flow control, routing, error avoidance and error handling are provided. Furthermore, there is discussion related to design flow, a computer aided designing tools and a few comprehensive researches. However, several networks are designed for the minimum latency, although there are also versions which trade performance for decreased bus widths. These designed networks are compared with a corresponding multi-layer bus interconnection and both synthesis and register transfer level simulations are run. For example, results from throughput, latency, logic area and power consumptions are gathered and compared. It was discovered that overall throughput was well balanced with the network on chip solutions, although its maximum throughput was limited by protocol conversions. For example, the multi-layer bus interconnection was capable of providing a few times smaller latencies and higher throughputs when only a single interface was injected at the time. However, with parallel traffic and high-performance requirements a network on chip solution provided better results, even though the difference decreased when performance requirements were lower. Furthermore, it was discovered that the network on chip solutions required approximately 3–4 times higher total cell area than the multi-layer bus interconnection and that resources were mainly located at network interfaces and switches. In addition, power consumption was approximately 2–3 times higher and was mostly caused by dynamic consumption.Monitasoisen väyläarkkitehtuurin ja tietokoneverkkomaisen ratkaisun vertailua. Tiivistelmä. Tutkielmassa käsitellään tärkeimpiä aihealueita, jotka tulee huomioida suunniteltaessa tietokoneverkkomaisia väyläratkaisuja puolijohdemaailmassa. Esimerkiksi yleiset rakenteet, kuten verkko-, torus-, kahdeksankulmio- ja puutopologiat käsitellään lyhyesti. Lisäksi alustetaan verkon liitäntäkohdat, kytkimet, vuorottelu, vuon hallinta, reititys, virheiden välttely ja -käsittely. Lopuksi kerrotaan suunnitteluvuon oleellisimmat välivaiheet ja niihin soveltuvia kaupallisia työkaluja, sekä käsitellään lyhyesti muutaman aiemman julkaisun tuloksia. Tutkielmassa käytetään suunnittelutyökalua muutaman tietokoneverkkomaisen ratkaisun toteutukseen ja tavoitteena on saavuttaa pienin mahdollinen latenssi. Toisaalta myös hieman suuremman latenssin versioita suunnitellaan, mutta pienemmillä väylänleveyksillä. Lisäksi suunniteltuja tietokoneverkkomaisia ratkaisuja vertaillaan perinteisempään monitasoiseen väyläarkkitehtuuriin. Esimerkiksi synteesi- ja simulaatiotuloksia, kuten logiikan vaatimaa pinta-alaa, tehonkulutusta, latenssia ja suorituskykyä, vertaillaan keskenään. Tutkielmassa selvisi, että suunnittelutyökalulla toteutetut tietokoneverkkomaiset ratkaisut mahdollistivat tasaisemman suorituskyvyn, joskin niiden suurin saavutettu suorituskyky ja pienin latenssi määräytyivät protokollan käännöksen aiheuttamasta viiveestä. Tutkielmassa havaittiin, että perinteisemmillä menetelmillä saavutettiin noin kaksi kertaa suurempi suorituskyky ja pienempi latenssi, kun verkossa ei ollut muuta liikennettä. Rinnakkaisen liikenteen lisääntyessä tietokoneverkkomainen ratkaisu tarjosi keskimäärin paremman suorituskyvyn, kun sille asetetut tehokkuusvaateet olivat suuret, mutta suorituskykyvaatimuksien laskiessa erot kapenivat. Lisäksi huomattiin, että tietokoneverkkomaisten ratkaisujen käyttämä pinta-ala oli noin 3–4 kertaa suurempi kuin monitasoisella väyläarkkitehtuurilla ja että resurssit sijaitsivat enimmäkseen verkon liittymäkohdissa ja kytkimissä. Lisäksi tehonkulutuksen huomattiin olevan noin 2–3 kertaa suurempi, joskin sen havaittiin koostuvan pääosin dynaamisesta kulutuksesta

Design and implementation of the Quarc network on-chip

Networks-on-Chip (NoC) have emerged as alternative to buses to provide a packet-switched communication medium for modular development of large Systems-on-Chip. However, to successfully replace its predecessor, the NoC has to be able to efficiently exchange all types of traffic including collective communications. The latter is especially important for e.g. cache updates in multicore systems. The Quarc NoC architecture has been introduced as a Networks-on-Chip which is highly efficient in exchanging all types of traffic including broadcast and multicast. In this paper we present the hardware implementation of the switch architecture and the network adapter (transceiver) of the Quarc NoC. Moreover, the paper presents an analysis and comparison of the cost and performance between the Quarc and the Spidergon NoCs implemented in Verilog targeting the Xilinx Virtex FPGA family. We demonstrate a dramatic improvement in performance over the Spidergon especially for broadcast traffic, at no additional hardware cost

A DRAM/SRAM memory scheme for fast packet buffers

We address the design of high-speed packet buffers for Internet routers. We use a general DRAM/SRAM architecture for which previous proposals can be seen as particular cases. For this architecture, large SRAMs are needed to sustain high line rates and a large number of interfaces. A novel algorithm for DRAM bank allocation is presented that reduces the SRAM size requirements of previously proposed schemes by almost an order of magnitude, without having memory fragmentation problems. A technological evaluation shows that our design can support thousands of queues for line rates up to 160 Gbps.Peer ReviewedPostprint (published version

MOTIM – An Industrial Application Using NOCs

High-speed networks used to interconnect computers advance at an extraordinary pace, driven by the evolution of several contributing technologies. Due to the ever-increasing complexity of designing parts and equipments for these networks, design complexity management makes scalability and reusability more important issues than performance, in most cases. This paper describes MOTIM, a scalable and reusable architecture enabling the implementation of Ethernet switches with low latency and high throughput. The architecture is built around a network-on-chip-based switch fabric, which guarantees scalability. The architecture has been validated by functional simulation and prototyped in FPGAs. The experimental results show that even under severe traffic conditions the architecture achieves packet transmission with low latencies. Categories and Subject Descriptor

Quarc: a high-efficiency network on-chip architecture

The novel Quarc NoC architecture, inspired by the Spidergon scheme is introduced as a NoC architecture that is highly efficient in performing collective communication operations including broadcast and multicast. The efficiency of the Quarc architecture is achieved through balancing the traffic which is the result of the modifications applied to the topology and the routing elements of the Spidergon NoC. This paper provides an ASIC implementation of both architectures using UMCpsilas 0.13 mum CMOS technology and demonstrates an analysis and comparison of the cost and performance between the Quarc and the Spidergon NoCs