Design and Implementation of MPICH2 over InfiniBand with RDMA Support

For several years, MPI has been the de facto standard for writing parallel applications. One of the most popular MPI implementations is MPICH. Its successor, MPICH2, features a completely new design that provides more performance and flexibility. To ensure portability, it has a hierarchical structure based on which porting can be done at different levels. In this paper, we present our experiences designing and implementing MPICH2 over InfiniBand. Because of its high performance and open standard, InfiniBand is gaining popularity in the area of high-performance computing. Our study focuses on optimizing the performance of MPI-1 functions in MPICH2. One of our objectives is to exploit Remote Direct Memory Access (RDMA) in Infiniband to achieve high performance. We have based our design on the RDMA Channel interface provided by MPICH2, which encapsulates architecture-dependent communication functionalities into a very small set of functions. Starting with a basic design, we apply different optimizations and also propose a zero-copy-based design. We characterize the impact of our optimizations and designs using microbenchmarks. We have also performed an application-level evaluation using the NAS Parallel Benchmarks. Our optimized MPICH2 implementation achieves 7.6 $\mu$s latency and 857 MB/s bandwidth, which are close to the raw performance of the underlying InfiniBand layer. Our study shows that the RDMA Channel interface in MPICH2 provides a simple, yet powerful, abstraction that enables implementations with high performance by exploiting RDMA operations in InfiniBand. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first high-performance design and implementation of MPICH2 on InfiniBand using RDMA support.Comment: 12 pages, 17 figure

Design and Evaluation of Low-Latency Communication Middleware on High Performance Computing Systems

[Resumen]El interés en Java para computación paralela está motivado por sus interesantes características, tales como su soporte multithread, portabilidad, facilidad de aprendizaje,alta productividad y el aumento significativo en su rendimiento omputacional. No obstante, las aplicaciones paralelas en Java carecen generalmente de mecanismos de comunicación eficientes, los cuales utilizan a menudo protocolos basados en sockets incapaces de obtener el máximo provecho de las redes de baja latencia, obstaculizando la adopción de Java en computación de altas prestaciones (High Per- formance Computing, HPC). Esta Tesis Doctoral presenta el diseño, implementación y evaluación de soluciones de comunicación en Java que superan esta limitación. En consecuencia, se desarrollaron múltiples dispositivos de comunicación a bajo nivel para paso de mensajes en Java (Message-Passing in Java, MPJ) que aprovechan al máximo el hardware de red subyacente mediante operaciones de acceso directo a memoria remota que proporcionan comunicaciones de baja latencia. También se incluye una biblioteca de paso de mensajes en Java totalmente funcional, FastMPJ, en la cual se integraron los dispositivos de comunicación. La evaluación experimental ha mostrado que las primitivas de comunicación de FastMPJ son competitivas en comparación con bibliotecas nativas, aumentando significativamente la escalabilidad de aplicaciones MPJ. Por otro lado, esta Tesis analiza el potencial de la computación en la nube (cloud computing) para HPC, donde el modelo de distribución de infraestructura como servicio (Infrastructure as a Service, IaaS) emerge como una alternativa viable a los sistemas HPC tradicionales. La evaluación del rendimiento de recursos cloud específicos para HPC del proveedor líder, Amazon EC2, ha puesto de manifiesto el impacto significativo que la virtualización impone en la red, impidiendo mover las aplicaciones intensivas en comunicaciones a la nube. La clave reside en un soporte de virtualización apropiado, como el acceso directo al hardware de red, junto con las directrices para la optimización del rendimiento sugeridas en esta Tesis.[Resumo]O interese en Java para computación paralela está motivado polas súas interesantes características, tales como o seu apoio multithread, portabilidade, facilidade de aprendizaxe, alta produtividade e o aumento signi cativo no seu rendemento computacional. No entanto, as aplicacións paralelas en Java carecen xeralmente de mecanismos de comunicación e cientes, os cales adoitan usar protocolos baseados en sockets que son incapaces de obter o máximo proveito das redes de baixa latencia, obstaculizando a adopción de Java na computación de altas prestacións (High Performance Computing, HPC). Esta Tese de Doutoramento presenta o deseño, implementaci ón e avaliación de solucións de comunicación en Java que superan esta limitación. En consecuencia, desenvolvéronse múltiples dispositivos de comunicación a baixo nivel para paso de mensaxes en Java (Message-Passing in Java, MPJ) que aproveitan ao máaximo o hardware de rede subxacente mediante operacións de acceso directo a memoria remota que proporcionan comunicacións de baixa latencia. Tamén se inclúe unha biblioteca de paso de mensaxes en Java totalmente funcional, FastMPJ, na cal foron integrados os dispositivos de comunicación. A avaliación experimental amosou que as primitivas de comunicación de FastMPJ son competitivas en comparación con bibliotecas nativas, aumentando signi cativamente a escalabilidade de aplicacións MPJ. Por outra banda, esta Tese analiza o potencial da computación na nube (cloud computing) para HPC, onde o modelo de distribución de infraestrutura como servizo (Infrastructure as a Service, IaaS) xorde como unha alternativa viable aos sistemas HPC tradicionais. A ampla avaliación do rendemento de recursos cloud específi cos para HPC do proveedor líder, Amazon EC2, puxo de manifesto o impacto signi ficativo que a virtualización impón na rede, impedindo mover as aplicacións intensivas en comunicacións á nube. A clave atópase no soporte de virtualización apropiado, como o acceso directo ao hardware de rede, xunto coas directrices para a optimización do rendemento suxeridas nesta Tese.[Abstract]The use of Java for parallel computing is becoming more promising owing to its appealing features, particularly its multithreading support, portability, easy-tolearn properties, high programming productivity and the noticeable improvement in its computational performance. However, parallel Java applications generally su er from inefficient communication middleware, most of which use socket-based protocols that are unable to take full advantage of high-speed networks, hindering the adoption of Java in the High Performance Computing (HPC) area. This PhD Thesis presents the design, development and evaluation of scalable Java communication solutions that overcome these constraints. Hence, we have implemented several lowlevel message-passing devices that fully exploit the underlying network hardware while taking advantage of Remote Direct Memory Access (RDMA) operations to provide low-latency communications. Moreover, we have developed a productionquality Java message-passing middleware, FastMPJ, in which the devices have been integrated seamlessly, thus allowing the productive development of Message-Passing in Java (MPJ) applications. The performance evaluation has shown that FastMPJ communication primitives are competitive with native message-passing libraries, improving signi cantly the scalability of MPJ applications. Furthermore, this Thesis has analyzed the potential of cloud computing towards spreading the outreach of HPC, where Infrastructure as a Service (IaaS) o erings have emerged as a feasible alternative to traditional HPC systems. Several cloud resources from the leading IaaS provider, Amazon EC2, which speci cally target HPC workloads, have been thoroughly assessed. The experimental results have shown the signi cant impact that virtualized environments still have on network performance, which hampers porting communication-intensive codes to the cloud. The key is the availability of the proper virtualization support, such as the direct access to the network hardware, along with the guidelines for performance optimization suggested in this Thesis

One-Sided Communication for High Performance Computing Applications

Thesis (Ph.D.) - Indiana University, Computer Sciences, 2009Parallel programming presents a number of critical challenges to application developers. Traditionally, message passing, in which a process explicitly sends data and another explicitly receives the data, has been used to program parallel applications. With the recent growth in multi-core processors, the level of parallelism necessary for next generation machines is cause for concern in the message passing community. The one-sided programming paradigm, in which only one of the two processes involved in communication actively participates in message transfer, has seen increased interest as a potential replacement for message passing. One-sided communication does not carry the heavy per-message overhead associated with modern message passing libraries. The paradigm offers lower synchronization costs and advanced data manipulation techniques such as remote atomic arithmetic and synchronization operations. These combine to present an appealing interface for applications with random communication patterns, which traditionally present message passing implementations with difficulties. This thesis presents a taxonomy of both the one-sided paradigm and of applications which are ideal for the one-sided interface. Three case studies, based on real-world applications, are used to motivate both taxonomies and verify the applicability of the MPI one-sided communication and Cray SHMEM one-sided interfaces to real-world problems. While our results show a number of short-comings with existing implementations, they also suggest that a number of applications could benefit from the one-sided paradigm. Finally, an implementation of the MPI one-sided interface within Open MPI is presented, which provides a number of unique performance features necessary for efficient use of the one-sided programming paradigm

Kernel-assisted and Topology-aware MPI Collective Communication among Multicore or Many-core Clusters

Multicore or many-core clusters have become the most prominent form of High Performance Computing (HPC) systems. Hardware complexity and hierarchies not only exist in the inter-node layer, i.e., hierarchical networks, but also exist in internals of multicore compute nodes, e.g., Non Uniform Memory Accesses (NUMA), network-style interconnect, and memory and shared cache hierarchies. Message Passing Interface (MPI), the most widely adopted in the HPC communities, suffers from decreased performance and portability due to increased hardware complexity of multiple levels. We identified three critical issues specific to collective communication: The first problem arises from the gap between logical collective topologies and underlying hardware topologies; Second, current MPI communications lack efficient shared memory message delivering approaches; Last, on distributed memory machines, like multicore clusters, a single approach cannot encompass the extreme variations not only in the bandwidth and latency capabilities, but also in features such as the aptitude to operate multiple concurrent copies simultaneously. To bridge the gap between logical collective topologies and hardware topologies, we developed a distance-aware framework to integrate the knowledge of hardware distance into collective algorithms in order to dynamically reshape the communication patterns to suit the hardware capabilities. Based on process distance information, we used graph partitioning techniques to organize the MPI processes in a multi-level hierarchy, mapping on the hardware characteristics. Meanwhile, we took advantage of the kernel-assisted one-sided single-copy approach (KNEM) as the default shared memory delivering method. Via kernel-assisted memory copy, the collective algorithms offload copy tasks onto non-leader/not-root processes to evenly distribute copy workloads among available cores. Finally, on distributed memory machines, we developed a technique to compose multi-layered collective algorithms together to express a multi-level algorithm with tight interoperability between the levels. This tight collaboration results in more overlaps between inter- and intra-node communication. Experimental results have confirmed that, by leveraging several technologies together, such as kernel-assisted memory copy, the distance-aware framework, and collective algorithm composition, not only do MPI collectives reach the potential maximum performance on a wide variation of platforms, but they also deliver a level of performance immune to modifications of the underlying process-core binding

Low‐latency Java communication devices on RDMA‐enabled networks

This is the peer reviewed version of the following article: Expósito, R. R., Taboada, G. L., Ramos, S., Touriño, J., & Doallo, R. (2015). Low‐latency Java communication devices on RDMA‐enabled networks. Concurrency and Computation: Practice and Experience, 27(17), 4852-4879., which has been published in final form at https://doi.org/10.1002/cpe.3473. This article may be used for non-commercial purposes in accordance with Wiley Terms and Conditions for Use of Self-Archived Versions.[Abstract] Providing high‐performance inter‐node communication is a key capability for running high performance computing applications efficiently on parallel architectures. In fact, current systems deployments are aggregating a significant number of cores interconnected via advanced networking hardware with Remote Direct Memory Access (RDMA) mechanisms, that enable zero‐copy and kernel‐bypass features. The use of Java for parallel programming is becoming more promising thanks to some useful characteristics of this language, particularly its built‐in multithreading support, portability, easy‐to‐learn properties, and high productivity, along with the continuous increase in the performance of the Java virtual machine. However, current parallel Java applications generally suffer from inefficient communication middleware, mainly based on protocols with high communication overhead that do not take full advantage of RDMA‐enabled networks. This paper presents efficient low‐level Java communication devices that overcome these constraints by fully exploiting the underlying RDMA hardware, providing low‐latency and high‐bandwidth communications for parallel Java applications. The performance evaluation conducted on representative RDMA networks and parallel systems has shown significant point‐to‐point performance increases compared with previous Java communication middleware, allowing to obtain up to 40% improvement in application‐level performance on 4096 cores of a Cray XE6 supercomputer.Ministerio de Economía y Competitividad; TIN2013-42148-PXunta de Galicia; GRC2013/055Ministerio de Educación y Ciencia; AP2010-434

High performance checksum computation for fault-tolerant MPI over InfiniBand

International audienceWith the increase of the number of nodes in clusters, the probability of failures and unusual events increases. In this paper, we present checksum mechanisms to detect data corruption. We study the impact of checksums on network communication performance and we propose a mechanism to amortize their cost on InfiniBand. We have implemented our mechanisms in the NEWMADELEINE communication library. Our evaluation shows that our mechanisms to ensure message integrity do not impact noticeably the application performance, which is an improvement over the state of the art MPI implementations

On the conditions for efficient interoperability with threads: An experience with PGAS languages using Cray communication domains

Today's high performance systems are typically built from shared memory nodes connected by a high speed network. That architecture, combined with the trend towards less memory per core, encourages programmers to use a mixture of message passing and multithreaded programming. Unfortunately, the advantages of using threads for in-node programming are hindered by their inability to efficiently communicate between nodes. In this work, we identify some of the performance problems that arise in such hybrid programming environments and characterize conditions needed to achieve high communication performance for multiple threads: addressability of targets, separability of communication paths, and full direct reachability to targets. Using the GASNet communication layer on the Cray XC30 as our experimental platform, we show how to satisfy these conditions. We also discuss how satisfying these conditions is influenced by the communication abstraction, implementation constraints, and the interconnect messaging capabilities. To evaluate these ideas, we compare the communication performance of a thread-based node runtime to a process-based runtime. Without our GASNet extensions, thread communication is significantly slower than processes - up to 21x slower. Once the implementation is modified to address each of our conditions, the two runtimes have comparable communication performance. This allows programmers to more easily mix models like OpenMP, CILK, or pthreads with a GASNet-based model like UPC, with the associated performance, convenience and interoperability advantages that come from using threads within a node. © 2014 ACM

Performance Analysis Of Pde Based Parallel Algorithms On Different Computer Architectures

Tez (Yüksek Lisans) -- İstanbul Teknik Üniversitesi, Bilişim Enstitüsü, 2009Thesis (M.Sc.) -- İstanbul Technical University, Institute of Informatics, 2009Son yıllarda dağıtık algoritmaların farklı platformlarda kullanılabilmesi platform ve uygulama bağımsız performans analizi uygulamaları ihtiyacını arttırmıştır. Farklı donanımları ve haberleşme metodlarını destekleyen uygulamalar kullanıcılara donanım ve yazılımdan bağımsız ortak bir zemin hazırladıkları için kolaylık sağlamaktadır. Kısmi fark denklemleri hesaplamalı bilim ve mühendisliğin bir çok alanında kullanılmaktadır (ısı, dalga yayılımı gibi). Bu denklemlerin sayısal çözümü yinelemeli yöntemler kullanılarak yapılmaktadır. Problemin boyutu ve hata değerine göre çözüme ulaşmak için gereken yineleme sayısı ve buna bağlı olarak süresi değişmektedir. Kısmi fark denklemelerinin tek işlemcili bilgisayarlardaki çözümü uzun sürdüğü ve yüksek boyutlarda hafızaları yetersiz kaldığı için paralelleştirilerek birden fazla bilgisayarın işlemcisi ve hafızası kullanılarak çözülmektedir. Tezimde eliptik kısmi fark denklemlerini Gauss-Seidel ve Successive Over-Relaxation (SOR) metodlarını kullanarak çözen paralel algoritmalar kullanılmıştır. Performans analizi ve eniyilemesi kabaca üç adımdan oluşmaktadır; ölçüm, sonuçların analizi, darboğazların tespit edilip yazılımda iyileştirme yapılması. Ölçüm aşamasında programın koşarken ürettiği performans bilgisi toplanır, toplanan bu veriler görselleştirme araçları ile anlaşılır hale getirilerek yorumlanır. Yorumlama aşamasında tespit edilen dar boğazlar belirlenir ve giderilme yöntemleri araştırılır. Gerekli iyileştirmeler yapılarak program yeniden analiz edilir. Bu aşamaların her birinde farklı uygulamalar kullanılabilir fakat tez çalışmamda uygulamaları tek çatı altında toplayan TAU kullanılmıştır. TAU (Tuning and Analysis Utilities) farklı donanımları ve işletim sistemlerini destekleyerek farklı paralelleştirme metodlarını analiz edebilmektedir. Açık kaynak kodlu olan TAU diğer açık kaynak kodlu uygulamalar ile uyumlu olup birçok seviyede bütünleşme sağlanmıştır. Bu tez çalışmasında, iki farklı platformda aynı uygulamanın performans analizi yapılarak platform farkının getirdiği farklılıklar incelenmektedir. Performans analizinde bir algoritmanın eniyilemesini yapmak için genel bir kural olmadığından her algoritma her platformda incelenerek gerekli değişiklikler yapılmalıdır. Bu bağlamda kullandığım PDE algoritmasının her iki sistemdeki analizi sonucu elde edilen bilgiler yorumlanmıştır.In last two decades, use of parallel algorithms on different architectures increased the need of architecture and application independent performance analysis tools. Tools that support different communication methods and hardware prepare a common ground regardless of equipments provided. Partial differential equations (PDE) are used in several applications (such as propagation of heat, wave) in computational science and engineering. These equations can be solved using iterative numerical methods. Problem size and error tolerance effects iteration count and computation time to solve equation. PDE computations take long time using single processor computers with sequential algorithms, and if data size gets bigger single processors memory may be insufficient. Thus, PDE?s are solved using parallel algorithms on multiple processors. In this thesis, elliptic partial differential equation is solved using Gauss-Seidel and Successive Over-Relaxation (SOR) methods parallel algorithms. Performance analysis and optimization basically has three steps; evaluation, analysis of gathered information, defining and optimizing bottlenecks. In evaluation, performance information is gathered while program runs, then observations are made on gathered information by using visualization tools. Bottlenecks are defined and optimization techniques are researched. Necessary improvements are made to analyze the program again. Different applications in each of these stages can be used but in this thesis TAU is used, which collects these applications under one roof. TAU (Tuning and Analysis Utilities) supports many hardware, operating systems and parallelization methods. TAU is an open source application and collaborates with other open source applications at different levels. In this thesis, differences based on performance analysis of an algorithm in different two architectures are investigated. In performance analysis and optimization there is no golden rule to speed up algorithm. Each algorithm must be analyzed on that specific architecture. In this context, the performance analysis of a PDE algorithm on two architectures has been interpreted.Yüksek LisansM.Sc