Degree-degree correlations in random graphs with heavy-tailed degrees

Mixing patterns in large self-organizing networks, such as the Internet, the World Wide Web, social and biological networks are often characterized by degree-degree {dependencies} between neighbouring nodes. One of the problems with the commonly used Pearson's correlation coefficient (termed as the assortativity coefficient) is that {in disassortative networks its magnitude decreases} with the network size. This makes it impossible to compare mixing patterns, for example, in two web crawls of different size. We start with a simple model of two heavy-tailed highly correlated random variable $X$ and $Y$, and show that the sample correlation coefficient converges in distribution either to a proper random variable on $[-1,1]$, or to zero, and if $X,Y\ge 0$ then the limit is non-negative. We next show that it is non-negative in the large graph limit when the degree distribution has an infinite third moment. We consider the alternative degree-degree dependency measure, based on the Spearman's rho, and prove that it converges to an appropriate limit under very general conditions. We verify that these conditions hold in common network models, such as configuration model and Preferential Attachment model. We conclude that rank correlations provide a suitable and informative method for uncovering network mixing patterns

Convergence of rank based degree-degree correlations in random directed networks

We introduce, and analyze, three measures for degree-degree dependencies, also called degree assortativity, in directed random graphs, based on Spearman's rho and Kendall's tau. We proof statistical consistency of these measures in general random graphs and show that the directed configuration model can serve as a null model for our degree-degree dependency measures. Based on these results we argue that the measures we introduce should be preferred over Pearson's correlation coefficients, when studying degree-degree dependencies, since the latter has several issues in the case of large networks with scale-free degree distributions

Phase transitions for scaling of structural correlations in directed networks

Analysis of degree-degree dependencies in complex networks, and their impact on processes on networks requires null models, i.e. models that generate uncorrelated scale-free networks. Most models to date however show structural negative dependencies, caused by finite size effects. We analyze the behavior of these structural negative degree-degree dependencies, using rank based correlation measures, in the directed Erased Configuration Model. We obtain expressions for the scaling as a function of the exponents of the distributions. Moreover, we show that this scaling undergoes a phase transition, where one region exhibits scaling related to the natural cut-off of the network while another region has scaling similar to the structural cut-off for uncorrelated networks. By establishing the speed of convergence of these structural dependencies we are able to asses statistical significance of degree-degree dependencies on finite complex networks when compared to networks generated by the directed Erased Configuration Model

Average nearest neighbor degrees in scale-free networks

The average nearest neighbor degree (ANND) of a node of degree $k$ is widely used to measure dependencies between degrees of neighbor nodes in a network. We formally analyze ANND in undirected random graphs when the graph size tends to infinity. The limiting behavior of ANND depends on the variance of the degree distribution. When the variance is finite, the ANND has a deterministic limit. When the variance is infinite, the ANND scales with the size of the graph, and we prove a corresponding central limit theorem in the configuration model (CM, a network with random connections). As ANND proved uninformative in the infinite variance scenario, we propose an alternative measure, the average nearest neighbor rank (ANNR). We prove that ANNR converges to a deterministic function whenever the degree distribution has finite mean. We then consider the erased configuration model (ECM), where self-loops and multiple edges are removed, and investigate the well-known `structural negative correlations', or `finite-size effects', that arise in simple graphs, such as ECM, because large nodes can only have a limited number of large neighbors. Interestingly, we prove that for any fixed $k$, ANNR in ECM converges to the same limit as in CM. However, numerical experiments show that finite-size effects occur when $k$ scales with $n$

Provable and practical approximations for the degree distribution using sublinear graph samples

The degree distribution is one of the most fundamental properties used in the analysis of massive graphs. There is a large literature on graph sampling, where the goal is to estimate properties (especially the degree distribution) of a large graph through a small, random sample. The degree distribution estimation poses a significant challenge, due to its heavy-tailed nature and the large variance in degrees. We design a new algorithm, SADDLES, for this problem, using recent mathematical techniques from the field of sublinear algorithms. The SADDLES algorithm gives provably accurate outputs for all values of the degree distribution. For the analysis, we define two fatness measures of the degree distribution, called the $h$-index and the $z$-index. We prove that SADDLES is sublinear in the graph size when these indices are large. A corollary of this result is a provably sublinear algorithm for any degree distribution bounded below by a power law. We deploy our new algorithm on a variety of real datasets and demonstrate its excellent empirical behavior. In all instances, we get extremely accurate approximations for all values in the degree distribution by observing at most $1\%$ of the vertices. This is a major improvement over the state-of-the-art sampling algorithms, which typically sample more than $10\%$ of the vertices to give comparable results. We also observe that the $h$ and $z$-indices of real graphs are large, validating our theoretical analysis.Comment: Longer version of the WWW 2018 submissio