Developments in multivariate post quantum cryptography.

Ever since Shor\u27s algorithm was introduced in 1994, cryptographers have been working to develop cryptosystems that can resist known quantum computer attacks. This push for quantum attack resistant schemes is known as post quantum cryptography. Specifically, my contributions to post quantum cryptography has been to the family of schemes known as Multivariate Public Key Cryptography (MPKC), which is a very attractive candidate for digital signature standardization in the post quantum collective for a wide variety of applications. In this document I will be providing all necessary background to fully understand MPKC and post quantum cryptography as a whole. Then, I will walk through the contributions I provided in my publications relating to differential security proofs for HFEv and HFEv−, key recovery attack for all parameters of HFEm, and my newly proposed multivariate encryption scheme, HFERP

A study of big field multivariate cryptography.

As the world grapples with the possibility of widespread quantum computing, the cryptosystems of the day need to be up to date. Multivariate Public Key Cryptography is a leading option for security in a post quantum society. One goal of this work is to classify the security of multivariate schemes, especially C*variants. We begin by introducing Multivariate Public Key Cryptography and will then discuss different multivariate schemes and the main types of attacks that have been proven effective against multivariate schemes. Once we have developed an appropriate background, we analyze security of different schemes against particular attacks. Specifically, we will analyze differential security of HFEv- and PFLASH schemes. We then introduce a variant of C* that may be used as an encryption scheme, not just as a signature scheme. Finally, we will analyze the security and efficiency of a (n,d,s,a,p,t) scheme in general. This allows for individuals to generally discuss security and performance of any C* variant

On the Complexity of the Hybrid Approach on HFEv-

The HFEv- signature scheme is one of the most promising candidates for post-quantum digital signatures. Most notably here is the short signature size of the scheme. It has long been known that direct attacks against HFEv- systems work more efficiently than against random systems. The reason for this was found by Jintai Ding et al., who proved an upper bound on the degree of regularity of these systems. However, not much is known about the efficiency of the hybrid approach against the HFEv- scheme. In order to find suitable parameter sets for HFEv- for higher levels of security, this topic has to be studied in more detail. In this article we consider this question by performing a large number of computer experiments. As our experiments show, guessing variables does not help to speed up direct attacks against HFEv- systems. Therefore, in the parameter selection of these schemes, we do not have to consider the hybrid approach. Furthermore, we develop in this article a simple formula to estimate the degree of regularity of a determined HFEv- system. Together with our results on the behavior of the hybrid approach, this formula gives us an easy way to estimate the complexity of direct attacks against HFEv- systems

MI-T-HFE, a New Multivariate Signature Scheme

In this paper, we propose a new multivariate signature scheme named MI-T-HFE as a competitor of QUARTZ. The core map of MI-T-HFE is of an HFEv type but more importantly has a specially designed trapdoor. This special trapdoor makes MI-T-HFE have several attractive advantages over QUARTZ. First of all, the core map and the public map of MI-T-HFE are both surjective. This surjectivity property is important for signature schemes because any message should always have valid signatures; otherwise it may be troublesome to exclude those messages without valid signatures. However this property is missing for a few major signature schemes, including QUARTZ. A practical parameter set is proposed for MI-T-HFE with the same length of message and same level of security as QUARTZ, but it has smaller public key size, and is more efficient than (the underlying HFEv- of) QUARTZ with the only cost that its signature length is twice that of QUARTZ

Improved Cryptanalysis of HFEv- via Projection

The HFEv- signature scheme is one of the most studied multivariate schemes and one of the major candidates for the upcoming standardization of post-quantum digital signature schemes. In this paper, we propose three new attack strategies against HFEv-, each of them using the idea of projection. Especially our third attack is very effective and is, for some parameter sets, the most efficient known attack against HFEv-. Furthermore, our attack requires much less memory than direct and rank attacks. By our work, we therefore give new insights in the security of the HFEv- signature scheme and restrictions for the parameter choice of a possible future standardized HFEv- instance

The Shortest Signatures Ever

Multivariate Cryptography is one of the main candidates for creating post quantum public key cryptosystems. Especially in the area of digital signatures, there exist many practical and secure multivariate schemes. In this paper we present a general technique to reduce the signature size of multivariate schemes. Our technique enables us to reduce the signature size of nearly all multivariate signature schemes by 10 to 15 % without slowing down the scheme significantly. We can prove that the security of the underlying scheme is not weakened by this modification. Furthermore, the technique enables a further reduction of the signature size when accepting a slightly more costly verification process. This trade off between signature size and complexity of the verification process can not be observed for any other class of digital signature schemes. By applying our technique to the Gui signature scheme, we obtain the shortest signatures of all existing digital signature schemes

Improved Key Recovery of the HFEv- Signature Scheme

The HFEv- signature scheme is a twenty year old multivariate public key signature scheme. It uses the Minus and the Vinegar modifier on the original HFE scheme. An instance of the HFEv- signature scheme called GeMSS is one of the alternative candidates for signature schemes in the third round of the NIST Post Quantum Crypto (PQC) Standardization Project. In this paper, we propose a new key recovery attack on the HFEv- signature scheme. We show that the Minus modification does not enhance the security of cryptosystems of the HFE family, while the Vinegar modification increases the complexity of our attack only by a polynomial factor. By doing so, we show that the proposed parameters of the GeMSS scheme are not as secure as claimed. Our attack shows that it is very difficult to build a secure and efficient signature scheme on the basis of HFEv-

Extracting Linearization Equations from Noisy Sources

This note was originally written under the name ``On the Security of HMFEv\u27\u27 and was submitted to PQCrypto 2018. The author was informed by the referees of his oversight of an eprint work of the same name by Hashimoto, see eprint article /2017/689/, that completely breaks HMFEv, rendering the result on HMFEv obsolete. Still, the author feels that the technique used here is interesting and that, at least in principal, this method could contribute to future cryptanalysis. Thus, with a change of title indicating the direction in which this work is leading, we present the original work with all of its oversights intact and with minimal correction (only references fixed). At PQCRYPTO 2017, a new multivariate digital signature based on Multi-HFE and utilizing the vinegar modifier was proposed. The vinegar modifier increases the Q-rank of the central map, preventing a direct application of the MinRank attack that defeated Multi-HFE. The authors were, therefore, confident enough to choose aggressive parameters for the Multi-HFE component of the central map (with vinegar variables fixed). Their analysis indicated that the security of the scheme depends on the sum of the number of variables $k$ over the extension field and the number $v$ of vinegar variables with the individual values being unimportant as long as they are not ``too small.\u27\u27 We analyze the consequences of this choice of parameters and derive some new attacks showing that the parameter $v$ must be chosen with care

Implementing 128-bit Secure MPKC Signatures

Multivariate Public Key Cryptosystems (MPKCs) are often touted as future-proofing against Quantum Computers. In 2009, it was shown that hardware advances do not favor just ``traditional\u27\u27 alternatives such as ECC and RSA, but also makes MPKCs faster and keeps them competitive at 80-bit security when properly implemented. These techniques became outdated due to emergence of new instruction sets and higher requirements on security. In this paper, we review how MPKC signatures changes from 2009 including new parameters (from a newer security level at 128-bit), crypto-safe implementations, and the impact of new AVX2and AESNI instructions. We also present new techniques on evaluating multivariate polynomials, multiplications of large finite fields by additive Fast Fourier Transforms, and constant time linear solvers