Playing with Conway’s problem

AbstractThe centralizer of a language is the maximal language commuting with it. The question, raised by Conway in [J.H. Conway, Regular Algebra and Finite Machines, Chapman Hall, 1971], whether the centralizer of a rational language is always rational, recently received a lot of attention. In Kunc [M. Kunc, The power of commuting with finite sets of words, in: Proc. of STACS 2005, in: LNCS, vol. 3404, Springer, 2005, pp. 569–580], a strong negative answer to this problem was given by showing that even complete co-recursively enumerable centralizers exist for finite languages. Using a combinatorial game approach, we give here an incremental construction of rational languages embedding any recursive computation in their centralizers

Relationships Between Bounded Languages, Counter Machines, Finite-Index Grammars, Ambiguity, and Commutative Equivalence

It is shown that for every language family that is a trio containing only semilinear languages, all bounded languages in it can be accepted by one-way deterministic reversal-bounded multicounter machines (DCM). This implies that for every semilinear trio (where these properties are effective), it is possible to decide containment, equivalence, and disjointness concerning its bounded languages. A condition is also provided for when the bounded languages in a semilinear trio coincide exactly with those accepted by DCM machines, and it is used to show that many grammar systems of finite index — such as finite-index matrix grammars (Mfin) and finite-index ET0L (ET0Lfin) — have identical bounded languages as DCM. Then connections between ambiguity, counting regularity, and commutative regularity are made, as many machines and grammars that are unambiguous can only generate/accept counting regular or com- mutatively regular languages. Thus, such a system that can generate/accept a non-counting regular or non-commutatively regular language implies the existence of inherently ambiguous languages over that system. In addition, it is shown that every language generated by an unambiguous Mfin has a rational char- acteristic series in commutative variables, and is counting regular. This result plus the connections are used to demonstrate that the grammar systems Mfin and ET0Lfin can generate inherently ambiguous languages (over their grammars), as do several machine models. It is also shown that all bounded languages generated by these two grammar systems (those in any semilinear trio) can be generated unambiguously within the systems. Finally, conditions on Mfin and ET0Lfin languages implying commutative regularity are obtained. In particular, it is shown that every finite-index ED0L language is commutatively regular

Automates à contraintes semilinéaires = Automata with a semilinear constraint

Cette thèse présente une étude dans divers domaines de l'informatique théorique de modèles de calculs combinant automates finis et contraintes arithmétiques. Nous nous intéressons aux questions de décidabilité, d'expressivité et de clôture, tout en ouvrant l'étude à la complexité, la logique, l'algèbre et aux applications. Cette étude est présentée au travers de quatre articles de recherche. Le premier article, Affine Parikh Automata, poursuit l'étude de Klaedtke et Ruess des automates de Parikh et en définit des généralisations et restrictions. L'automate de Parikh est un point de départ de cette thèse; nous montrons que ce modèle de calcul est équivalent à l'automate contraint que nous définissons comme un automate qui n'accepte un mot que si le nombre de fois que chaque transition est empruntée répond à une contrainte arithmétique. Ce modèle est naturellement étendu à l'automate de Parikh affine qui effectue une opération affine sur un ensemble de registres lors du franchissement d'une transition. Nous étudions aussi l'automate de Parikh sur lettres: un automate qui n'accepte un mot que si le nombre de fois que chaque lettre y apparaît répond à une contrainte arithmétique. Le deuxième article, Bounded Parikh Automata, étudie les langages bornés des automates de Parikh. Un langage est borné s'il existe des mots w_1, w_2, ..., w_k tels que chaque mot du langage peut s'écrire w_1...w_1w_2...w_2...w_k...w_k. Ces langages sont importants dans des domaines applicatifs et présentent usuellement de bonnes propriétés théoriques. Nous montrons que dans le contexte des langages bornés, le déterminisme n'influence pas l'expressivité des automates de Parikh. Le troisième article, Unambiguous Constrained Automata, introduit les automates contraints non ambigus, c'est-à-dire pour lesquels il n'existe qu'un chemin acceptant par mot reconnu par l'automate. Nous montrons qu'il s'agit d'un modèle combinant une meilleure expressivité et de meilleures propriétés de clôture que l'automate contraint déterministe. Le problème de déterminer si le langage d'un automate contraint non ambigu est régulier est montré décidable. Le quatrième article, Algebra and Complexity Meet Contrained Automata, présente une étude des représentations algébriques qu'admettent les automates contraints et les automates de Parikh affines. Nous déduisons de ces caractérisations des résultats d'expressivité et de complexité. Nous montrons aussi que certaines hypothèses classiques en complexité computationelle sont reliées à des résultats de séparation et de non clôture dans les automates de Parikh affines. La thèse est conclue par une ouverture à un possible approfondissement, au travers d'un certain nombre de problèmes ouverts.This thesis presents a study from the theoretical computer science perspective of computing models combining finite automata and arithmetic constraints. We focus on decidability questions, expressiveness, and closure properties, while opening the study to complexity, logic, algebra, and applications. This thesis is presented through four research articles. The first article, Affine Parikh Automata, continues the study of Klaedtke and Ruess on Parikh automata and defines generalizations and restrictions of this model. The Parikh automaton is one of the starting points of this thesis. We show that this model of computation is equivalent to the constrained automaton that we define as an automaton which accepts a word only if the number of times each transition is taken satisfies a given arithmetic constraint. This model is naturally extended to affine Parikh automata, in which an affine transformation is applied to a set of registers on taking a transition. We also study the Parikh automaton on letters, that is, an automaton which accepts a word only if the number of times each letter appears in the word verifies an arithmetic constraint. The second article, Bounded Parikh Automata, focuses on the bounded languages of Parikh automata. A language is bounded if there are words w_1, w_2, ..., w_k such that every word in the language can be written as w_1...w_1w_2...w_2 ... w_k...w_k. These languages are important in applications and usually display good theoretical properties. We show that, over the bounded languages, determinism does not influence the expressiveness of Parikh automata. The third article, Unambiguous Constrained Automata, introduces the concept of unambiguity in constrained automata. An automaton is unambiguous if there is only one accepting path per word of its language. We show that the unambiguous constrained automaton is an appealing model of computation which combines a better expressiveness and better closure properties than the deterministic constrained automaton. We show that it is decidable whether the language of an unambiguous constrained automaton is regular. The fourth article, Algebra and Complexity Meet Constrained Automata, presents a study of algebraic representations of constrained automata and affine Parikh automata. We deduce expressiveness and complexity results from these characterizations. We also study how classical computational complexity hypotheses help in showing separations and nonclosure properties in affine Parikh automata. The thesis is concluded by a presentation of possible future avenues of research, through several open problems

Foundations of Software Science and Computation Structures

This open access book constitutes the proceedings of the 22nd International Conference on Foundations of Software Science and Computational Structures, FOSSACS 2019, which took place in Prague, Czech Republic, in April 2019, held as part of the European Joint Conference on Theory and Practice of Software, ETAPS 2019. The 29 papers presented in this volume were carefully reviewed and selected from 85 submissions. They deal with foundational research with a clear significance for software science