Loop pipelining with resource and timing constraints

Developing efficient programs for many of the current parallel computers is not easy due to the architectural complexity of those machines. The wide variety of machine organizations often makes it more difficult to port an existing program than to reprogram it completely. Therefore, powerful translators are necessary to generate effective code and free the programmer from concerns about the specific characteristics of the target machine. This work focuses on techniques to be used by an important class of translators, whose objective is to transform sequential programs into equivalent more parallel programs. The transformations are performed at instruction level in order to exploit low level parallelism and increase memory locality.Most of the current applications are programmed in languages which do not allow us to express parallelism between high-level sentences (as Pascal, C or Fortran). Furthermore, a lot of applications written ten or more years ago are still used today, and it is not feasible to rewrite such applications for many reasons (not only technical reasons, but also economic ones). Translators enable programmers to write the application in a familiar sequential programming language, without concerning their selves with the architecture of the target machine. Current compilers for parallel architectures not only translate a program written on a high-level language to the appropriate machine language, but also perform some transformations in the final code in order to execute the program in a more parallel way. The transformations improve the performance in the execution of the program by making use of the knowledge that the compiler has about the machine architecture. The semantics of the program remain intact after any transformation.Experiments show that limiting parallelization to basic blocks not included in loops limits maximum speedup. This is because loops often comprise a large portion of the parallelism available to be exploited in a program. For this reason, a lot of effort has been devoted in the recent years to parallelize loop execution. Several parallel computer architectures and compilation techniques have been proposed to exploit such a parallelism at different granularities. Multiprocessors exploit coarse grained parallelism by distributing entire loop iterations to different processors. Systems oriented to the high-level synthesis (HLS) of VLSI circuits, superscalar processors and very long instruction word (VLIW) processors exploit fine-grained parallelism at instruction level. This work addresses fine-grained parallelization of loops addressed to the HLS of VLSI circuits. Two algorithms are proposed for resource constraints and for timing constraints. An algorithm to reduce the number of registers required to execute a loop in a given architecture is also proposed

Emulation of the dataflow computing paradigm using field programmable gate arrays (FPGAs)

Building a perfect dataflow computer has been an endeavor of many computer engineers. Ideally, it is a perfect parallel machine with zero overheads, but implementing one has been anything but perfect. While the sequential nature of control flow machines makes them relatively easy to implement, dataflow machines have to address a number of issues that are easily solved in the realm of control flow paradigm. Past implementations of dataflow computers have addressed these issues, such as conditional and reentrant program structures, along with the flow of data, at the processor level, i.e. each processor in the design would handle these issues. The design presented in this thesis solves these issues at the memory level (by using intelligent-memory), separating the processor from dataflow tasks. Specifically, a two-level memory design, along with a pool of processors was prototyped on a group of Altera FPGAs. The first level of memory is an intelligent-memory called Dataflow Memory (DFM), carrying out dataflow tasks. The second level of memory called the Instruction Queue (IQ) is a buffer that queues instructions ready for execution, sent by the DFM. The second level memory has a multiple bank architecture that allows multiple processors from the processor pool to simultaneously execute instructions retrieved from the banks. After executing an instruction, each processor sends the result back to the dataflow memory, where they fire new instructions and send them to the IQ. This thesis shows that implementing dataflow computers at the intelligent-memory level is a viable alternative to implementing them at the processor level

An automated OpenCL FPGA compilation framework targeting a configurable, VLIW chip multiprocessor

Modern system-on-chips augment their baseline CPU with coprocessors and accelerators to increase overall computational capacity and power efficiency, and thus have evolved into heterogeneous systems. Several languages have been developed to enable this paradigm shift, including CUDA and OpenCL. This thesis discusses a unified compilation environment to enable heterogeneous system design through the use of OpenCL and a customised VLIW chip multiprocessor (CMP) architecture, known as the LE1. An LLVM compilation framework was researched and a prototype developed to enable the execution of OpenCL applications on the LE1 CPU. The framework fully automates the compilation flow and supports work-item coalescing to better utilise the CPU cores and alleviate the effects of thread divergence. This thesis discusses in detail both the software stack and target hardware architecture and evaluates the scalability of the proposed framework on a highly precise cycle-accurate simulator. This is achieved through the execution of 12 benchmarks across 240 different machine configurations, as well as further results utilising an incomplete development branch of the compiler. It is shown that the problems generally scale well with the LE1 architecture, up to eight cores, when the memory system becomes a serious bottleneck. Results demonstrate superlinear performance on certain benchmarks (x9 for the bitonic sort benchmark with 8 dual-issue cores) with further improvements from compiler optimisations (x14 for bitonic with the same configuration

Design and Simulation of High Performance Parallel Architectures Using the ISAC Language

Most of modern embedded systems for multimediaand network applications are based on parallel data streamprocessing. The data processing can be done using very longinstruction word processors (VLIW), or using more than onehigh performance application-specific instruction set processor(ASIPs), or even by their combination on single chip.Design and testing of these complex systems is time-consumingand iterative process. Architecture description languages (ADLs)are one of the most effective solutions for single processor design.However, support for description of parallel architectures andmulti-processor systems is very low or completely missing innowadays ADLs. This article presents utilization of newextensions for existing architecture description language ISAC.These extensions are used for easy and fast prototyping andtesting of parallel based systems and processors

On Extracting Course-Grained Function Parallelism from C Programs

To efficiently utilize the emerging heterogeneous multi-core architecture, it is essential to exploit the inherent coarse-grained parallelism in applications. In addition to data parallelism, applications like telecommunication, multimedia, and gaming can also benefit from the exploitation of coarse-grained function parallelism. To exploit coarse-grained function parallelism, the common wisdom is to rely on programmers to explicitly express the coarse-grained data-flow between coarse-grained functions using data-flow or streaming languages. This research is set to explore another approach to exploiting coarse-grained function parallelism, that is to rely on compiler to extract coarse-grained data-flow from imperative programs. We believe imperative languages and the von Neumann programming model will still be the dominating programming languages programming model in the future. This dissertation discusses the design and implementation of a memory data-flow analysis system which extracts coarse-grained data-flow from C programs. The memory data-flow analysis system partitions a C program into a hierarchy of program regions. It then traverses the program region hierarchy from bottom up, summarizing the exposed memory access patterns for each program region, meanwhile deriving a conservative producer-consumer relations between program regions. An ensuing top-down traversal of the program region hierarchy will refine the producer-consumer relations by pruning spurious relations. We built an in-lining based prototype of the memory data-flow analysis system on top of the IMPACT compiler infrastructure. We applied the prototype to analyze the memory data-flow of several MediaBench programs. The experiment results showed that while the prototype performed reasonably well for the tested programs, the in-lining based implementation may not efficient for larger programs. Also, there is still room in improving the effectiveness of the memory data-flow analysis system. We did root cause analysis for the inaccuracy in the memory data-flow analysis results, which provided us insights on how to improve the memory data-flow analysis system in the future

Automatic Design of Efficient Application-centric Architectures.

As the market for embedded devices continues to grow, the demand for high performance, low cost, and low power computation grows as well. Many embedded applications perform computationally intensive tasks such as processing streaming video or audio, wireless communication, or speech recognition and must be implemented within tight power budgets. Typically, general purpose processors are not able to meet these performance and power requirements. Custom hardware in the form of loop accelerators are often used to execute the compute-intensive portions of these applications because they can achieve significantly higher levels of performance and power efficiency. Automated hardware synthesis from high level specifications is a key technology used in designing these accelerators, because the resulting hardware is correct by construction, easing verification and greatly decreasing time-to-market in the quickly evolving embedded domain. In this dissertation, a compiler-directed approach is used to design a loop accelerator from a C specification and a throughput requirement. The compiler analyzes the loop and generates a virtual architecture containing sufficient resources to sustain the required throughput. Next, a software pipelining scheduler maps the operations in the loop to the virtual architecture. Finally, the accelerator datapath is derived from the resulting schedule. In this dissertation, synthesis of different types of loop accelerators is investigated. First, the system for synthesizing single loop accelerators is detailed. In particular, a scheduler is presented that is aware of the effects of its decisions on the resulting hardware, and attempts to minimize hardware cost. Second, synthesis of multifunction loop accelerators, or accelerators capable of executing multiple loops, is presented. Such accelerators exploit coarse-grained hardware sharing across loops in order to reduce overall cost. Finally, synthesis of post-programmable accelerators is presented, allowing changes to be made to the software after an accelerator has been created. The tradeoffs between the flexibility, cost, and energy efficiency of these different types of accelerators are investigated. Automatically synthesized loop accelerators are capable of achieving order-of-magnitude gains in performance, area efficiency, and power efficiency over processors, and programmable accelerators allow software changes while maintaining highly efficient levels of computation.Ph.D.Computer Science & EngineeringUniversity of Michigan, Horace H. Rackham School of Graduate Studieshttp://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/61644/1/fank_1.pd

Exploiting Fine-Grain Concurrency Analytical Insights in Superscalar Processor Design

This dissertation develops analytical models to provide insight into various design issues associated with superscalar-type processors, i.e., the processors capable of executing multiple instructions per cycle. A survey of the existing machines and literature has been completed with a proposed classification of various approaches for exploiting fine-grain concurrency. Optimization of a single pipeline is discussed based on an analytical model. The model-predicted performance curves are found to be in close proximity to published results using simulation techniques. A model is also developed for comparing different branch strategies for single-pipeline processors in terms of their effectiveness in reducing branch delay. The additional instruction fetch traffic generated by certain branch strategies is also studied and is shown to be a useful criterion for choosing between equally well performing strategies. Next, processors with multiple pipelines are modelled to study the tradeoffs associated with deeper pipelines versus multiple pipelines. The model developed can reveal the cause of performance bottleneck: insufficient resources to exploit discovered parallelism, insufficient instruction stream parallelism, or insufficient scope of concurrency detection. The cost associated with speculative (i.e., beyond basic block) execution is examined via probability distributions that characterize the inherent parallelism in the instruction stream. The throughput prediction of the analytic model is shown, using a variety of benchmarks, to be close to the measured static throughput of the compiler output, under resource and scope constraints. Further experiments provide misprediction delay estimates for these benchmarks under scope constraints, assuming beyond-basic-block, out-of-order execution and run-time scheduling. These results were derived using traces generated by the Multiflow TRACE SCHEDULING™(*) compacting C and FORTRAN 77 compilers. A simplified extension to the model to include multiprocessors is also proposed. The extended model is used to analyze combined systems, such as superpipelined multiprocessors and superscalar multiprocessors, both with shared memory. It is shown that the number of pipelines (or processors) at which the maximum throughput is obtained is increasingly sensitive to the ratio of memory access time to network access delay, as memory access time increases. Further, as a function of inter-iteration dependency distance, optimum throughput is shown to vary nonlinearly, whereas the corresponding Optimum number of processors varies linearly. The predictions from the analytical model agree with published results based on simulations. (*)TRACE SCHEDULING is a trademark of Multiflow Computer, Inc

Task assignment in parallel processor systems

A generic object-oriented simulation platform is developed in order to conduct experiments on the performance of assignment schemes. The simulation platform, called Genesis, is generic in the sense that it can model the key parameters that describe a parallel system: the architecture, the program, the assignment scheme and the message routing strategy. Genesis uses as its basis a sound architectural representation scheme developed in the thesis. The thesis reports results from a number of experiments assessing the performance of assignment schemes using Genesis. The comparison results indicate that the new assignment scheme proposed in this thesis is a promising alternative to the work-greedy assignment schemes. The proposed scheme has a time-complexity less than those of the work-greedy schemes and achieves an average performance better than, or comparable to, those of the work-greedy schemes. To generate an assignment, some parameters describing the program model will be required. In many cases, accurate estimation of these parameters is hard. It is thought that inaccuracies in the estimation would lead to poor assignments. The thesis investigates this speculation and presents experimental evidence that shows such inaccuracies do not greatly affect the quality of the assignments

A hardware-software codesign framework for cellular computing

Until recently, the ever-increasing demand of computing power has been met on one hand by increasing the operating frequency of processors and on the other hand by designing architectures capable of exploiting parallelism at the instruction level through hardware mechanisms such as super-scalar execution. However, both these approaches seem to have reached a plateau, mainly due to issues related to design complexity and cost-effectiveness. To face the stabilization of performance of single-threaded processors, the current trend in processor design seems to favor a switch to coarser-grain parallelization, typically at the thread level. In other words, high computational power is achieved not only by a single, very fast and very complex processor, but through the parallel operation of several processors, each executing a different thread. Extrapolating this trend to take into account the vast amount of on-chip hardware resources that will be available in the next few decades (either through further shrinkage of silicon fabrication processes or by the introduction of molecular-scale devices), together with the predicted features of such devices (e.g., the impossibility of global synchronization or higher failure rates), it seems reasonable to foretell that current design techniques will not be able to cope with the requirements of next-generation electronic devices and that novel design tools and programming methods will have to be devised. A tempting source of inspiration to solve the problems implied by a massively parallel organization and inherently error-prone substrates is biology. In fact, living beings possess characteristics, such as robustness to damage and self-organization, which were shown in previous research as interesting to be implemented in hardware. For instance, it was possible to realize relatively simple systems, such as a self-repairing watch. Overall, these bio-inspired approaches seem very promising but their interest for a wider audience is problematic because their heavily hardware-oriented designs lack some of the flexibility achievable with a general purpose processor. In the context of this thesis, we will introduce a processor-grade processing element at the heart of a bio-inspired hardware system. This processor, based on a single-instruction, features some key properties that allow it to maintain the versatility required by the implementation of bio-inspired mechanisms and to realize general computation. We will also demonstrate that the flexibility of such a processor enables it to be evolved so it can be tailored to different types of applications. In the second half of this thesis, we will analyze how the implementation of a large number of these processors can be used on a hardware platform to explore various bio-inspired mechanisms. Based on an extensible platform of many FPGAs, configured as a networked structure of processors, the hardware part of this computing framework is backed by an open library of software components that provides primitives for efficient inter-processor communication and distributed computation. We will show that this dual software–hardware approach allows a very quick exploration of different ways to solve computational problems using bio-inspired techniques. In addition, we also show that the flexibility of our approach allows it to exploit replication as a solution to issues that concern standard embedded applications

Customizing the Computation Capabilities of Microprocessors.

Designers of microprocessor-based systems must constantly improve performance and increase computational efficiency in their designs to create value. To this end, it is increasingly common to see computation accelerators in general-purpose processor designs. Computation accelerators collapse portions of an application's dataflow graph, reducing the critical path of computations, easing the burden on processor resources, and reducing energy consumption in systems. There are many problems associated with adding accelerators to microprocessors, though. Design of accelerators, architectural integration, and software support all present major challenges. This dissertation tackles these challenges in the context of accelerators targeting acyclic and cyclic patterns of computation. First, a technique to identify critical computation subgraphs within an application set is presented. This technique is hardware-cognizant and effectively generates a set of instruction set extensions given a domain of target applications. Next, several general-purpose accelerator structures are quantitatively designed using critical subgraph analysis for a broad application set. The next challenge is architectural integration of accelerators. Traditionally, software invokes accelerators by statically encoding new instructions into the application binary. This is incredibly costly, though, requiring many portions of hardware and software to be redesigned. This dissertation develops strategies to utilize accelerators, without changing the instruction set. In the proposed approach, the microarchitecture translates applications at run-time, replacing computation subgraphs with microcode to utilize accelerators. We explore the tradeoffs in performing difficult aspects of the translation at compile-time, while retaining run-time replacement. This culminates in a simple microarchitectural interface that supports a plug-and-play model for integrating accelerators into a pre-designed microprocessor. Software support is the last challenge in dealing with computation accelerators. The primary issue is difficulty in generating high-quality code utilizing accelerators. Hand-written assembly code is standard in industry, and if compiler support does exist, simple greedy algorithms are common. In this work, we investigate more thorough techniques for compiling for computation accelerators. Where greedy heuristics only explore one possible solution, the techniques in this dissertation explore the entire design space, when possible. Intelligent pruning methods ensure that compilation is both tractable and scalable.Ph.D.Computer Science & EngineeringUniversity of Michigan, Horace H. Rackham School of Graduate Studieshttp://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/57633/2/ntclark_1.pd