Seven years of INEX interactive retrieval experiments – lessons and challenges

This paper summarizes a major effort in interactive search investigation, the INEX i-track, a collective effort run over a seven-year period. We present the experimental conditions, report some of the findings of the participating groups, and examine the challenges posed by this kind of collective experimental effort

Recherche d'information dans les documents XML : prise en compte des liens pour la sélection d'éléments pertinents

156 p. : ill. ; 30 cmNotre travail se situe dans le contexte de la recherche d'information (RI), plus particulièrement la recherche d'information dans des documents semi structurés de type XML. L'exploitation efficace des documents XML disponibles doit prendre en compte la dimension structurelle. Cette dimension a conduit à l'émergence de nouveaux défis dans le domaine de la RI. Contrairement aux approches classiques de RI qui mettent l'accent sur la recherche des contenus non structurés, la RI XML combine à la fois des informations textuelles et structurelles pour effectuer différentes tâches de recherche. Plusieurs approches exploitant les types d'évidence ont été proposées et sont principalement basées sur les modèles classiques de RI, adaptées à des documents XML. La structure XML a été utilisée pour fournir un accès ciblé aux documents, en retournant des composants de document (par exemple, sections, paragraphes, etc.), au lieu de retourner tout un document en réponse une requête de l'utilisateur. En RI traditionnelle, la mesure de similarité est généralement basée sur l'information textuelle. Elle permetle classement des documents en fonction de leur degré de pertinence en utilisant des mesures comme:" similitude terme " ou " probabilité terme ". Cependant, d'autres sources d'évidence peuvent être considérées pour rechercher des informations pertinentes dans les documents. Par exemple, les liens hypertextes ont été largement exploités dans le cadre de la RI sur le Web.Malgré leur popularité dans le contexte du Web, peud'approchesexploitant cette source d'évidence ont été proposées dans le contexte de la RI XML. Le but de notre travail est de proposer des approches pour l'utilisation de liens comme une source d'évidencedans le cadre de la recherche d'information XML. Cette thèse vise à apporter des réponses aux questions de recherche suivantes : 1. Peut-on considérer les liens comme une source d'évidence dans le contexte de la RIXML? 2. Est-ce que l'utilisation de certains algorithmes d'analyse de liensdans le contexte de la RI XML améliore la qualité des résultats, en particulier dans le cas de la collection Wikipedia? 3. Quels types de liens peuvent être utilisés pour améliorer le mieux la pertinence des résultats de recherche? 4. Comment calculer le score lien des différents éléments retournés comme résultats de recherche? Doit-on considérer lesliens de type "document-document" ou plus précisément les liens de type "élément-élément"? Quel est le poids des liens de navigation par rapport aux liens hiérarchiques? 5. Quel est l'impact d'utilisation de liens dans le contexte global ou local? 6. Comment intégrer le score lien dans le calcul du score final des éléments XML retournés? 7. Quel est l'impact de la qualité des premiers résultats sur le comportement des formules proposées? Pour répondre à ces questions, nous avons mené une étude statistique, sur les résultats de recherche retournés par le système de recherche d'information"DALIAN", qui a clairement montré que les liens représentent un signe de pertinence des éléments dans le contexte de la RI XML, et cecien utilisant la collection de test fournie par INEX. Aussi, nous avons implémenté trois algorithmes d'analyse des liens (Pagerank, HITS et SALSA) qui nous ont permis de réaliser une étude comparative montrant que les approches "query-dependent" sont les meilleures par rapport aux approches "global context" . Nous avons proposé durant cette thèse trois formules de calcul du score lien: Le premièreest appelée "Topical Pagerank"; la seconde est la formule : "distance-based"; et la troisième est :"weighted links based". Nous avons proposé aussi trois formules de combinaison, à savoir, la formule linéaire, la formule Dempster-Shafer et la formule fuzzy-based. Enfin, nous avons mené une série d'expérimentations. Toutes ces expérimentations ont montré que: les approches proposées ont permis d'améliorer la pertinence des résultats pour les différentes configurations testées; les approches "query-dependent" sont les meilleurescomparées aux approches global context; les approches exploitant les liens de type "élément-élément"ont obtenu de bons résultats; les formules de combinaison qui se basent sur le principe de l'incertitude pour le calcul des scores finaux des éléments XML permettent de réaliser de bonnes performance

Evaluation of effective XML information retrieval

XML is being adopted as a common storage format in scientific data repositories, digital libraries, and on the World Wide Web. Accordingly, there is a need for content-oriented XML retrieval systems that can efficiently and effectively store, search and retrieve information from XML document collections. Unlike traditional information retrieval systems where whole documents are usually indexed and retrieved as information units, XML retrieval systems typically index and retrieve document components of varying granularity. To evaluate the effectiveness of such systems, test collections where relevance assessments are provided according to an XML-specific definition of relevance are necessary. Such test collections have been built during four rounds of the INitiative for the Evaluation of XML Retrieval (INEX). There are many different approaches to XML retrieval; most approaches either extend full-text information retrieval systems to handle XML retrieval, or use database technologies that incorporate existing XML standards to handle both XML presentation and retrieval. We present a hybrid approach to XML retrieval that combines text information retrieval features with XML-specific features found in a native XML database. Results from our experiments on the INEX 2003 and 2004 test collections demonstrate the usefulness of applying our hybrid approach to different XML retrieval tasks. A realistic definition of relevance is necessary for meaningful comparison of alternative XML retrieval approaches. The three relevance definitions used by INEX since 2002 comprise two relevance dimensions, each based on topical relevance. We perform an extensive analysis of the two INEX 2004 and 2005 relevance definitions, and show that assessors and users find them difficult to understand. We propose a new definition of relevance for XML retrieval, and demonstrate that a relevance scale based on this definition is useful for XML retrieval experiments. Finding the appropriate approach to evaluate XML retrieval effectiveness is the subject of ongoing debate within the XML information retrieval research community. We present an overview of the evaluation methodologies implemented in the current INEX metrics, which reveals that the metrics follow different assumptions and measure different XML retrieval behaviours. We propose a new evaluation metric for XML retrieval and conduct an extensive analysis of the retrieval performance of simulated runs to show what is measured. We compare the evaluation behaviour obtained with the new metric to the behaviours obtained with two of the official INEX 2005 metrics, and demonstrate that the new metric can be used to reliably evaluate XML retrieval effectiveness. To analyse the effectiveness of XML retrieval in different application scenarios, we use evaluation measures in our new metric to investigate the behaviour of XML retrieval approaches under the following two scenarios: the ad-hoc retrieval scenario, exploring the activities carried out as part of the INEX 2005 Ad-hoc track; and the multimedia retrieval scenario, exploring the activities carried out as part of the INEX 2005 Multimedia track. For both application scenarios we show that, although different values for retrieval parameters are needed to achieve the optimal performance, the desired textual or multimedia information can be effectively located using a combination of XML retrieval approaches

Interactive Information Retrieval with Structured Documents

In recent years there has been a growing realisation in the IR community that the interaction of searchers with information is an indispensable component of the IR process. As a result, issues relating to interactive IR have been extensively investigated in the last decade. This research has been performed in the context of unstructured documents or in the context of the loosely-defined structure encountered in web pages. XML documents, on the other hand, define a different context, by offering the possibility of navigating within the structure of a single document, or of following links to other documents. Relatively little work has been carried out to study user interaction with IR systems that make use of the additional features offered by XML documents. As part of the INEX initiative for the evaluation of XML retrieval, the INEX interactive track has focused on interactive XML retrieval since 2004. Here user friendly exposition to various features of XML documents is provided and some new features are designed and implemented to enable searchers to have access to their desired information in an efficient manner. In this study interaction entails three levels: query formulation, inspecting result list, and examining the detail. For query formulation, suggesting related terms is a conventional method to assist searchers. Here we investigate the related terms derived from two different co-occurrence units: elements and documents. In addition, contextual aspect is added to facilitate the searchers for appropriate selection of terms. Results showed the usefulness of suggesting related terms and some what acceptance of the contextual related tool. For inspecting the result list, classic document retrieval systems such as web search engines retrieve whole documents, and leave it to the searchers to collect their required information from possibly a lengthy text. In contrast, element retrieval aims at a focused view of information by pointing to the optimal access points of the document. A number of strategies have been investigated for presenting result lists. For examining the detail of a document, traditionally the complete document is presented to a searcher and here again the searcher has to put in effort to reach its required information. We investigated the use of additional support such as a table of contents along with document detail. In addition, we also investigated graphical representations of documents depicting its structure and granularity of retrieved elements along with their estimated relevance. Here the table of contents was found to be a very useful features for examining details. In order to conduct the analysis of searcher's interaction, a visualisation technique based on Tree Map was developed. It depicts the search interaction with element retrieval system. A number of browsing strategies has been identified with the help of this tool. The value of element retrieval for searchers and comparison between two focused approaches such as element and passage retrieval system was also evaluated. The study suggests that searchers find elements useful for their tasks and they locate a lot of the relevant information in specific elements rather than full documents. Sections, in particular, appear to be helpful. In order to provide user-specific support, the system needs feedback from searchers, who in turn, are very reluctant to give this information explicitly. Therefore, we investigated to what extent the different features can be used as relevance predictors. Of the five features regarded, primarily the reading time is a useful relevance predictor. Overall, relevance predictors for structured documents seem to be much weaker than for the case of atomic documents

Treatment of Semantic Heterogeneity in Information Retrieval

"Nowadays, users of information services are faced with highly decentralised, heterogeneous document sources with different content analysis. Semantic heterogeneity occurs e.g. when resources using different systems for content description are searched using a single query system. This report describes several approaches of handling semantic heterogeneity used in projects of the German Social Science Information Centre." (author's abstract