1,142 research outputs found
Computationally Sound, Automated Proofs for Security Protocols
Since the 1980s, two approaches have been developed for analyzing security protocols. One of the approaches relies on a computational model that considers issues of complexity and probability. This approach captures a strong notion of security, guaranteed against all probabilistic polynomial-time attacks. The other approach relies on a symbolic model of protocol executions in which cryptographic primitives are treated as black boxes. Since the seminal work of Dolev and Yao, it has been realized that this latter approach enables significantly simpler and often automated proofs. However, the guarantees that it offers have been quite unclear. In this paper, we show that it is possible to obtain the best of both worlds: fully automated proofs and strong, clear security guarantees. Specifically, for the case of protocols that use signatures and asymmetric encryption, we establish that symbolic integrity and secrecy proofs are sound with respect to the computational model. The main new challenges concern secrecy properties for which we obtain the first soundness result for the case of active adversaries. Our proofs are carried out using Casrul, a fully automated tool
Computational Soundness for Dalvik Bytecode
Automatically analyzing information flow within Android applications that
rely on cryptographic operations with their computational security guarantees
imposes formidable challenges that existing approaches for understanding an
app's behavior struggle to meet. These approaches do not distinguish
cryptographic and non-cryptographic operations, and hence do not account for
cryptographic protections: f(m) is considered sensitive for a sensitive message
m irrespective of potential secrecy properties offered by a cryptographic
operation f. These approaches consequently provide a safe approximation of the
app's behavior, but they mistakenly classify a large fraction of apps as
potentially insecure and consequently yield overly pessimistic results.
In this paper, we show how cryptographic operations can be faithfully
included into existing approaches for automated app analysis. To this end, we
first show how cryptographic operations can be expressed as symbolic
abstractions within the comprehensive Dalvik bytecode language. These
abstractions are accessible to automated analysis, and they can be conveniently
added to existing app analysis tools using minor changes in their semantics.
Second, we show that our abstractions are faithful by providing the first
computational soundness result for Dalvik bytecode, i.e., the absence of
attacks against our symbolically abstracted program entails the absence of any
attacks against a suitable cryptographic program realization. We cast our
computational soundness result in the CoSP framework, which makes the result
modular and composable.Comment: Technical report for the ACM CCS 2016 conference pape
Actor-network procedures: Modeling multi-factor authentication, device pairing, social interactions
As computation spreads from computers to networks of computers, and migrates
into cyberspace, it ceases to be globally programmable, but it remains
programmable indirectly: network computations cannot be controlled, but they
can be steered by local constraints on network nodes. The tasks of
"programming" global behaviors through local constraints belong to the area of
security. The "program particles" that assure that a system of local
interactions leads towards some desired global goals are called security
protocols. As computation spreads beyond cyberspace, into physical and social
spaces, new security tasks and problems arise. As networks are extended by
physical sensors and controllers, including the humans, and interlaced with
social networks, the engineering concepts and techniques of computer security
blend with the social processes of security. These new connectors for
computational and social software require a new "discipline of programming" of
global behaviors through local constraints. Since the new discipline seems to
be emerging from a combination of established models of security protocols with
older methods of procedural programming, we use the name procedures for these
new connectors, that generalize protocols. In the present paper we propose
actor-networks as a formal model of computation in heterogenous networks of
computers, humans and their devices; and we introduce Procedure Derivation
Logic (PDL) as a framework for reasoning about security in actor-networks. On
the way, we survey the guiding ideas of Protocol Derivation Logic (also PDL)
that evolved through our work in security in last 10 years. Both formalisms are
geared towards graphic reasoning and tool support. We illustrate their workings
by analysing a popular form of two-factor authentication, and a multi-channel
device pairing procedure, devised for this occasion.Comment: 32 pages, 12 figures, 3 tables; journal submission; extended
references, added discussio
How to prove security of communication protocols? A discussion on the soundness of formal models w.r.t. computational ones.
Security protocols are short programs that aim at securing communication over a public network. Their design is known to be error-prone with flaws found years later. That is why they deserve a careful security analysis, with rigorous proofs. Two main lines of research have been (independently) developed to analyse the security of protocols. On the one hand, formal methods provide with symbolic models and often automatic proofs. On the other hand, cryptographic models propose a tighter modeling but proofs are more difficult to write and to check. An approach developed during the last decade consists in bridging the two approaches, showing that symbolic models are sound w.r.t. symbolic ones, yielding strong security guarantees using automatic tools. These results have been developed for several cryptographic primitives (e.g. symmetric and asymmetric encryption, signatures, hash) and security properties.
While proving soundness of symbolic models is a very promising approach, several technical details are often not satisfactory. Focusing on symmetric encryption, we describe the difficulties and limitations of the available results
- …