Unsupervised Graph-based Rank Aggregation for Improved Retrieval

This paper presents a robust and comprehensive graph-based rank aggregation approach, used to combine results of isolated ranker models in retrieval tasks. The method follows an unsupervised scheme, which is independent of how the isolated ranks are formulated. Our approach is able to combine arbitrary models, defined in terms of different ranking criteria, such as those based on textual, image or hybrid content representations. We reformulate the ad-hoc retrieval problem as a document retrieval based on fusion graphs, which we propose as a new unified representation model capable of merging multiple ranks and expressing inter-relationships of retrieval results automatically. By doing so, we claim that the retrieval system can benefit from learning the manifold structure of datasets, thus leading to more effective results. Another contribution is that our graph-based aggregation formulation, unlike existing approaches, allows for encapsulating contextual information encoded from multiple ranks, which can be directly used for ranking, without further computations and post-processing steps over the graphs. Based on the graphs, a novel similarity retrieval score is formulated using an efficient computation of minimum common subgraphs. Finally, another benefit over existing approaches is the absence of hyperparameters. A comprehensive experimental evaluation was conducted considering diverse well-known public datasets, composed of textual, image, and multimodal documents. Performed experiments demonstrate that our method reaches top performance, yielding better effectiveness scores than state-of-the-art baseline methods and promoting large gains over the rankers being fused, thus demonstrating the successful capability of the proposal in representing queries based on a unified graph-based model of rank fusions

Heuristic ensembles of filters for accurate and reliable feature selection

Feature selection has become increasingly important in data mining in recent years. However, the accuracy and stability of feature selection methods vary considerably when used individually, and yet no rule exists to indicate which one should be used for a particular dataset. Thus, an ensemble method that combines the outputs of several individual feature selection methods appears to be a promising approach to address the issue and hence is investigated in this research. This research aims to develop an effective ensemble that can improve the accuracy and stability of the feature selection. We proposed a novel heuristic ensemble of filters (HEF). It combines two types of filters: subset filters and ranking filters with a heuristic consensus algorithm in order to utilise the strength of each type. The ensemble is tested on ten benchmark datasets and its performance is evaluated by two stability measures and three classifiers. The experimental results demonstrate that HEF improves the stability and accuracy of the selected features and in most cases outperforms the other ensemble algorithms, individual filters and the full feature set. The research on the HEF algorithm is extended in several dimensions; including more filter members, three novel schemes of mean rank aggregation with partial lists, and three novel schemes for a weighted heuristic ensemble of filters. However, the experimental results demonstrate that adding weight to filters in HEF does not achieve the expected improvement in accuracy, but increases time and space complexity, and clearly decreases stability. Therefore, the core ensemble algorithm (HEF) is demonstrated to be not just simpler but also more reliable and consistent than the later more complicated and weighted ensembles. In addition, we investigated how to use data in feature selection, using ALL or PART of it. Systematic experiments with thirty five synthetic and benchmark real-world datasets were carried out

Analysis of a Voting Method for Ranking Network Centrality Measures on a Node-aligned Multiplex Network

Identifying relevant actors using information gleaned from multiple networks is a key goal within the context of human aspects of military operations. The application of a voting theory methodology for determining nodes of critical importance—in ranked order of importance—for a node-aligned multiplex network is demonstrated. Both statistical and qualitative analyses on the differences of ranking outcomes under this methodology is provided. As a corollary, a multilayer network reduction algorithm is investigated within the context of the proposed ranking methodology. The application of the methodology detailed in this thesis will allow meaningful rankings of relevant actors to be produced on a multiplex network

Novel Extensions of Label Propagation for Biomarker Discovery in Genomic Data

One primary goal of analyzing genomic data is the identification of biomarkers which may be causative of, correlated with, or otherwise biologically relevant to disease phenotypes. In this work, I implement and extend a multivariate feature ranking algorithm called label propagation (LP) for biomarker discovery in genome-wide single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) data. This graph-based algorithm utilizes an iterative propagation method to efficiently compute the strength of association between a SNP and a phenotype. I developed three extensions to the LP algorithm, with the goal of tailoring it to genomic data. The first extension is a modification to the LP score which yields a variable-level score for each SNP, rather than a score for each SNP genotype. The second extension incorporates prior biological knowledge that is encoded as a prior value for each SNP. The third extension enables the combination of rankings produced by LP and another feature ranking algorithm. The LP algorithm, its extensions, and two control algorithms (chi squared and sparse logistic regression) were applied to 11 genomic datasets, including a synthetic dataset, a semi-synthetic dataset, and nine genome-wide association study (GWAS) datasets covering eight diseases. The quality of each feature ranking algorithm was evaluated by using a subset of top-ranked SNPs to construct a classifier, whose predictive power was evaluated in terms of the area under the Receiver Operating Characteristic curve. Top-ranked SNPs were also evaluated for prior evidence of being associated with disease using evidence from the literature. The LP algorithm was found to be effective at identifying predictive and biologically meaningful SNPs. The single-score extension performed significantly better than the original algorithm on the GWAS datasets. The prior knowledge extension did not improve on the feature ranking results, and in some cases it reduced the predictive power of top-ranked variants. The ranking combination method was effective for some pairs of algorithms, but not for others. Overall, this work’s main results are the formulation and evaluation of several algorithmic extensions of LP for use in the analysis of genomic data, as well as the identification of several disease-associated SNPs

Statistical Methods for Aggregation of Indirect Information

How to properly aggregate indirect information is more and more important. In this dissertation, we will present two aspects of the issue: indirect comparison of treatment effects and aggregation of ordered-based rank data.Statistic

Towards an Architecture for Efficient Distributed Search of Multimodal Information

The creation of very large-scale multimedia search engines, with more than one billion images and videos, is a pressing need of digital societies where data is generated by multiple connected devices. Distributing search indexes in cloud environments is the inevitable solution to deal with the increasing scale of image and video collections. The distribution of such indexes in this setting raises multiple challenges such as the even partitioning of data space, load balancing across index nodes and the fusion of the results computed over multiple nodes. The main question behind this thesis is how to reduce and distribute the multimedia retrieval computational complexity? This thesis studies the extension of sparse hash inverted indexing to distributed settings. The main goal is to ensure that indexes are uniformly distributed across computing nodes while keeping similar documents on the same nodes. Load balancing is performed at both node and index level, to guarantee that the retrieval process is not delayed by nodes that have to inspect larger subsets of the index. Multimodal search requires the combination of the search results from individual modalities and document features. This thesis studies rank fusion techniques focused on reducing complexity by automatically selecting only the features that improve retrieval effectiveness. The achievements of this thesis span both distributed indexing and rank fusion research. Experiments across multiple datasets show that sparse hashes can be used to distribute documents and queries across index entries in a balanced and redundant manner across nodes. Rank fusion results show that is possible to reduce retrieval complexity and improve efficiency by searching only a subset of the feature indexes

Agregação de ranks baseada em grafos

Orientador: Ricardo da Silva TorresTese (doutorado) - Universidade Estadual de Campinas, Instituto de ComputaçãoResumo: Neste trabalho, apresentamos uma abordagem robusta de agregação de listas baseada em grafos, capaz de combinar resultados de modelos de recuperação isolados. O método segue um esquema não supervisionado, que é independente de como as listas isoladas são geradas. Nossa abordagem é capaz de incorporar modelos heterogêneos, de diferentes critérios de recuperação, tal como baseados em conteúdo textual, de imagem ou híbridos. Reformulamos o problema de recuperação ad-hoc como uma recuperação baseada em fusion graphs, que propomos como um novo modelo de representação unificada capaz de mesclar várias listas e expressar automaticamente inter-relações de resultados de recuperação. Assim, mostramos que o sistema de recuperação se beneficia do aprendizado da estrutura intrínseca das coleções, levando a melhores resultados de busca. Nossa formulação de agregação baseada em grafos, diferentemente das abordagens existentes, permite encapsular informação contextual oriunda de múltiplas listas, que podem ser usadas diretamente para ranqueamento. Experimentos realizados demonstram que o método apresenta alto desempenho, produzindo melhores eficácias que métodos recentes da literatura e promovendo ganhos expressivos sobre os métodos de recuperação fundidos. Outra contribuição é a extensão da proposta de grafo de fusão visando consulta eficiente. Trabalhos anteriores são promissores quanto à eficácia, mas geralmente ignoram questões de eficiência. Propomos uma função inovadora de agregação de consulta, não supervisionada, intrinsecamente multimodal almejando recuperação eficiente e eficaz. Introduzimos os conceitos de projeção e indexação de modelos de representação de agregação de consulta com base em grafos, e a sua aplicação em tarefas de busca. Formulações de projeção são propostas para representações de consulta baseadas em grafos. Introduzimos os fusion vectors, uma representação de fusão tardia de objetos com base em listas, a partir da qual é definido um modelo de recuperação baseado intrinsecamente em agregação. A seguir, apresentamos uma abordagem para consulta rápida baseada nos vetores de fusão, promovendo agregação de consultas eficiente. O método apresentou alta eficácia quanto ao estado da arte, além de trazer uma perspectiva de eficiência pouco abordada. Ganhos consistentes de eficiência são alcançadas em relação aos trabalhos recentes. Também propomos modelos de representação baseados em consulta para problemas gerais de predição. Os conceitos de grafos de fusão e vetores de fusão são estendidos para cenários de predição, nos quais podem ser usados para construir um modelo de estimador para determinar se um objeto de avaliação (ainda que multimodal) se refere a uma classe ou não. Experimentos em tarefas de classificação multimodal, tal como detecção de inundação, mostraram que a solução é altamente eficaz para diferentes cenários de predição que envolvam dados textuais, visuais e multimodais, produzindo resultados melhores que vários métodos recentes. Por fim, investigamos a adoção de abordagens de aprendizagem para ajudar a otimizar a criação de modelos de representação baseados em consultas, a fim de maximizar seus aspectos de capacidade discriminativa e eficiência em tarefas de predição e de buscaAbstract: In this work, we introduce a robust graph-based rank aggregation approach, capable of combining results of isolated ranker models in retrieval tasks. The method follows an unsupervised scheme, which is independent of how the isolated ranks are formulated. Our approach is able to incorporate heterogeneous models, defined in terms of different ranking criteria, such as those based on textual, image, or hybrid content representations. We reformulate the ad-hoc retrieval problem as a graph-based retrieval based on {\em fusion graphs}, which we propose as a new unified representation model capable of merging multiple ranks and expressing inter-relationships of retrieval results automatically. By doing so, we show that the retrieval system can benefit from learning the manifold structure of datasets, thus leading to more effective results. Our graph-based aggregation formulation, unlike existing approaches, allows for encapsulating contextual information encoded from multiple ranks, which can be directly used for ranking. Performed experiments demonstrate that our method reaches top performance, yielding better effectiveness scores than state-of-the-art baseline methods and promoting large gains over the rankers being fused. Another contribution refers to the extension of the fusion graph solution for efficient rank aggregation. Although previous works are promising with respect to effectiveness, they usually overlook efficiency aspects. We propose an innovative rank aggregation function that it is unsupervised, intrinsically multimodal, and targeted for fast retrieval and top effectiveness performance. We introduce the concepts of embedding and indexing graph-based rank-aggregation representation models, and their application for search tasks. Embedding formulations are also proposed for graph-based rank representations. We introduce the concept of {\em fusion vectors}, a late-fusion representation of objects based on ranks, from which an intrinsically rank-aggregation retrieval model is defined. Next, we present an approach for fast retrieval based on fusion vectors, thus promoting an efficient rank aggregation system. Our method presents top effectiveness performance among state-of-the-art related work, while promoting an efficiency perspective not yet covered. Consistent speedups are achieved against the recent baselines in all datasets considered. Derived from the fusion graphs and fusion vectors, we propose rank-based representation models for general prediction problems. The concepts of fusion graphs and fusion vectors are extended to prediction scenarios, where they can be used to build an estimator model to determine whether an input (even multimodal) object refers to a class or not. Performed experiments in the context of multimodal classification tasks, such as flood detection, show that the proposed solution is highly effective for different detection scenarios involving textual, visual, and multimodal features, yielding better detection results than several state-of-the-art methods. Finally, we investigate the adoption of learning approaches to help optimize the creation of rank-based representation models, in order to maximize their discriminative power and efficiency aspects in prediction and search tasksDoutoradoCiência da ComputaçãoDoutor em Ciência da Computaçã

CHORUS Deliverable 2.1: State of the Art on Multimedia Search Engines

Based on the information provided by European projects and national initiatives related to multimedia search as well as domains experts that participated in the CHORUS Think-thanks and workshops, this document reports on the state of the art related to multimedia content search from, a technical, and socio-economic perspective. The technical perspective includes an up to date view on content based indexing and retrieval technologies, multimedia search in the context of mobile devices and peer-to-peer networks, and an overview of current evaluation and benchmark inititiatives to measure the performance of multimedia search engines. From a socio-economic perspective we inventorize the impact and legal consequences of these technical advances and point out future directions of research

Temporal multimodal video and lifelog retrieval

The past decades have seen exponential growth of both consumption and production of data, with multimedia such as images and videos contributing significantly to said growth. The widespread proliferation of smartphones has provided everyday users with the ability to consume and produce such content easily. As the complexity and diversity of multimedia data has grown, so has the need for more complex retrieval models which address the information needs of users. Finding relevant multimedia content is central in many scenarios, from internet search engines and medical retrieval to querying one's personal multimedia archive, also called lifelog. Traditional retrieval models have often focused on queries targeting small units of retrieval, yet users usually remember temporal context and expect results to include this. However, there is little research into enabling these information needs in interactive multimedia retrieval. In this thesis, we aim to close this research gap by making several contributions to multimedia retrieval with a focus on two scenarios, namely video and lifelog retrieval. We provide a retrieval model for complex information needs with temporal components, including a data model for multimedia retrieval, a query model for complex information needs, and a modular and adaptable query execution model which includes novel algorithms for result fusion. The concepts and models are implemented in vitrivr, an open-source multimodal multimedia retrieval system, which covers all aspects from extraction to query formulation and browsing. vitrivr has proven its usefulness in evaluation campaigns and is now used in two large-scale interdisciplinary research projects. We show the feasibility and effectiveness of our contributions in two ways: firstly, through results from user-centric evaluations which pit different user-system combinations against one another. Secondly, we perform a system-centric evaluation by creating a new dataset for temporal information needs in video and lifelog retrieval with which we quantitatively evaluate our models. The results show significant benefits for systems that enable users to specify more complex information needs with temporal components. Participation in interactive retrieval evaluation campaigns over multiple years provides insight into possible future developments and challenges of such campaigns