The Structure of First-Order Causality

Game semantics describe the interactive behavior of proofs by interpreting formulas as games on which proofs induce strategies. Such a semantics is introduced here for capturing dependencies induced by quantifications in first-order propositional logic. One of the main difficulties that has to be faced during the elaboration of this kind of semantics is to characterize definable strategies, that is strategies which actually behave like a proof. This is usually done by restricting the model to strategies satisfying subtle combinatorial conditions, whose preservation under composition is often difficult to show. Here, we present an original methodology to achieve this task, which requires to combine advanced tools from game semantics, rewriting theory and categorical algebra. We introduce a diagrammatic presentation of the monoidal category of definable strategies of our model, by the means of generators and relations: those strategies can be generated from a finite set of atomic strategies and the equality between strategies admits a finite axiomatization, this equational structure corresponding to a polarized variation of the notion of bialgebra. This work thus bridges algebra and denotational semantics in order to reveal the structure of dependencies induced by first-order quantifiers, and lays the foundations for a mechanized analysis of causality in programming languages

Angelic Processes

In the formal modelling of systems, demonic and angelic nondeterminism play fundamental roles as abstraction mechanisms. The angelic nature of a choice pertains to the property of avoiding failure whenever possible. As a concept, angelic choice first appeared in automata theory and Turing machines, where it can be implemented via backtracking. It has traditionally been studied in the refinement calculus, and has proved to be useful in a variety of applications and refinement techniques. Recently it has been studied within relational, multirelational and higher-order models. It has been employed for modelling user interactions, game-like scenarios, theorem proving tactics, constraint satisfaction problems and control systems. When the formal modelling of state-rich reactive systems is considered, it only seems natural that both types of nondeterministic choice should be considered. However, despite several treatments of angelic nondeterminism in the context of process algebras, namely Communicating Sequential Processes, the counterpart to the angelic choice of the refinement calculus has been elusive. In this thesis, we develop a semantics in the relational setting of Hoare and He's Unifying Theories of Programming that enables the characterisation of angelic nondeterminism in CSP. Since CSP processes are given semantics in the UTP via designs, that is, pre and postcondition pairs, we first introduce a theory of angelic designs, and an isomorphic multirelational model, that is suitable for characterising processes. We then develop a theory of reactive angelic designs by enforcing the healthiness conditions of CSP. Finally, by introducing a notion of divergence that can undo the history of events, we obtain a model where angelic choice avoids divergence. This lays the foundation for a process algebra with both nondeterministic constructs, where existing and novel abstract modelling approaches can be considered. The UTP basis of our work makes it applicable in the wider context of reactive systems

Towards a quantitative alloy

Dissertação de mestrado integrado em Engenharia InformáticaWhen one comes across a new problem that needs to be solved, by abstracting from its associated details in a simple and concise way through the use of formal methods, one is able to better understand the matter at hand. Alloy (Jackson, 2012), a declarative specification language based on relational logic, is an example of an effective modelling tool, allowing high-level specification of potentially very complex systems. However, along with the irrelevant information, measurable data of the system is often lost in the abstraction as well, making it not as adequate for certain situations. The Alloy Analyzer represents the relations under analysis by Boolean matrices. By extending this type of structure to: • numeric matrices, over N0 , one is able to work with multirelations, i.e. relations whose arcs are weighted; each tuple is thus associated with a natural number, which allows reasoning in a similar fashion as in optimization problems and integer programming techniques; • left-Stochastic matrices, one is able to model faulty behaviour and other forms of quantitative information about software systems in a probabilistic way; in particular, this introduces the notion of a probabilistic contract in software design. Such an increase in Alloy’s capabilities strengthens its position in the area of formal methods for software design, in particular towards becoming a quantitative formal method. This dissertation explores the motivation and importance behind quantitative analysis by studying and establishing theoretical foundations through categorial approaches to accomplish such reasoning in Alloy. This starts by reviewing the required tools to support such groundwork and proceeds to the design and implementation of such a quantitative Alloy extension. This project aims to promote the evolution of quantitative formal methods by successfully achieving quantitative abstractions in Alloy, extending its support to these concepts and implementing them in the Alloy Analyzer.Quando se depara com um novo problema que precisa de ser resolvido, ao abstrair dos seus detalhes associados de forma simples e concisa recorrendo a métodos formais, é possível compreender melhor o assunto em questão. Alloy (Jackson, 2012), uma linguagem de especificação declarativa baseada em lógica relacional, é um exemplo de uma ferramenta de modelação eficaz, possibilitando especificações de alto-nível de sistemas potencialmente bastante complexos. Contudo, em conjunto com a informação irrelevante, os dados mensuráveis são muitas vezes também perdidos na abstração, tornando-a não tão adequada para certas situações. O Alloy Analyzer representa as relações sujeitas a análise através de matrizes Booleanas. Ao estender este tipo de estrutura para: • matrizes numéricas, em N0 , é possível lidar com multirelações, i.e., relações cujos arcos são pesados; cada tuplo é consequentemente associado a um número natural, o que proporciona uma linha de raciocínio semelhante à de técnicas de problemas de otimização e de programação inteira; • matrizes estocásticas, permitindo a modelação de comportamento defeituoso e de outros tipos de informação quantitativa de sistemas de software probabilisticamente; em particular, é introduzida a noção de contrato probabilístico em design de software. Tal aumento às capacidades do Alloy, fortalece a sua posição na área de métodos formais para design de software, em particular, a caminho de se tornar um método formal quantitativo. Esta dissertação explora a motivação e a importância subjacente à análise quantitativa, a partir do estudo e consolidação dos fundamentos teóricos através de abordagens categóricas de forma a conseguir suportar esse tipo de raciocínio em Alloy. Inicialmente, as ferramentas imprescindíveis para assegurar tal base são analisadas, passando de seguida ao planeamento e posterior implementação de tal extensão quantitativa do Alloy. Este projecto pretende promover a evolução dos métodos formais quantitativos através da concretização de abstracção quantitativa em Alloy, estendendo a sua base para suportar estes conceitos e assim implementá los no Alloy Analyzer