Automated generation of geometrically-precise and semantically-informed virtual geographic environnements populated with spatially-reasoning agents

La Géo-Simulation Multi-Agent (GSMA) est un paradigme de modélisation et de simulation de phénomènes dynamiques dans une variété de domaines d'applications tels que le domaine du transport, le domaine des télécommunications, le domaine environnemental, etc. La GSMA est utilisée pour étudier et analyser des phénomènes qui mettent en jeu un grand nombre d'acteurs simulés (implémentés par des agents) qui évoluent et interagissent avec une représentation explicite de l'espace qu'on appelle Environnement Géographique Virtuel (EGV). Afin de pouvoir interagir avec son environnement géographique qui peut être dynamique, complexe et étendu (à grande échelle), un agent doit d'abord disposer d'une représentation détaillée de ce dernier. Les EGV classiques se limitent généralement à une représentation géométrique du monde réel laissant de côté les informations topologiques et sémantiques qui le caractérisent. Ceci a pour conséquence d'une part de produire des simulations multi-agents non plausibles, et, d'autre part, de réduire les capacités de raisonnement spatial des agents situés. La planification de chemin est un exemple typique de raisonnement spatial dont un agent pourrait avoir besoin dans une GSMA. Les approches classiques de planification de chemin se limitent à calculer un chemin qui lie deux positions situées dans l'espace et qui soit sans obstacle. Ces approches ne prennent pas en compte les caractéristiques de l'environnement (topologiques et sémantiques), ni celles des agents (types et capacités). Les agents situés ne possèdent donc pas de moyens leur permettant d'acquérir les connaissances nécessaires sur l'environnement virtuel pour pouvoir prendre une décision spatiale informée. Pour répondre à ces limites, nous proposons une nouvelle approche pour générer automatiquement des Environnements Géographiques Virtuels Informés (EGVI) en utilisant les données fournies par les Systèmes d'Information Géographique (SIG) enrichies par des informations sémantiques pour produire des GSMA précises et plus réalistes. De plus, nous présentons un algorithme de planification hiérarchique de chemin qui tire avantage de la description enrichie et optimisée de l'EGVI pour fournir aux agents un chemin qui tient compte à la fois des caractéristiques de leur environnement virtuel et de leurs types et capacités. Finalement, nous proposons une approche pour la gestion des connaissances sur l'environnement virtuel qui vise à supporter la prise de décision informée et le raisonnement spatial des agents situés

A Conceptual Model of Exploration Wayfinding: An Integrated Theoretical Framework and Computational Methodology

This thesis is an attempt to integrate contending cognitive approaches to modeling wayfinding behavior. The primary goal is to create a plausible model for exploration tasks within indoor environments. This conceptual model can be extended for practical applications in the design, planning, and Social sciences. Using empirical evidence a cognitive schema is designed that accounts for perceptual and behavioral preferences in pedestrian navigation. Using this created schema, as a guiding framework, the use of network analysis and space syntax act as a computational methods to simulate human exploration wayfinding in unfamiliar indoor environments. The conceptual model provided is then implemented in two ways. First of which is by updating an existing agent-based modeling software directly. The second means of deploying the model is using a spatial interaction model that distributed visual attraction and movement permeability across a graph-representation of building floor plans

Automated Pattern Detection and Generalization of Building Groups

This dissertation focuses on the topic of building group generalization by considering the detection of building patterns. Generalization is an important research field in cartography, which is part of map production and the basis for the derivation of multiple representation. As one of the most important features on map, buildings occupy large amount of map space and normally have complex shape and spatial distribution, which leads to that the generalization of buildings has long been an important and challenging task. For social, architectural and geographical reasons, the buildings were built with some special rules which forms different building patterns. Building patterns are crucial structures which should be carefully considered during graphical representation and generalization. Although people can effortlessly perceive these patterns, however, building patterns are not explicitly described in building datasets. Therefore, to better support the subsequent generalization process, it is important to automatically recognize building patterns. The objective of this dissertation is to develop effective methods to detect building patterns from building groups. Based on the identified patterns, some generalization methods are proposed to fulfill the task of building generalization. The main contribution of the dissertation is described as the following five aspects: (1) The terminology and concept of building pattern has been clearly explained; a detailed and relative complete typology of building patterns has been proposed by summarizing the previous researches as well as extending by the author; (2) A stroke-mesh based method has been developed to group buildings and detect different patterns from the building groups; (3) Through the analogy between line simplification and linear building group typification, a stroke simplification based typification method has been developed aiming at solving the generalization of building groups with linear patterns; (4) A mesh-based typification method has been developed for the generalization of the building groups with grid patterns; (5) A method of extracting hierarchical skeleton structures from discrete buildings have been proposed. The extracted hierarchical skeleton structures are regarded as the representations of the global shape of the entire region, which is used to control the generalization process. With the above methods, the building patterns are detected from the building groups and the generalization of building groups are executed based on the patterns. In addition, the thesis has also discussed the drawbacks of the methods and gave the potential solutions.:Abstract I Kurzfassung III Contents V List of Figures IX List of Tables XIII List of Abbreviations XIV Chapter 1 Introduction 1 1.1 Background and motivation 1 1.1.1 Cartographic generalization 1 1.1.2 Urban building and building patterns 1 1.1.3 Building generalization 3 1.1.4 Hierarchical property in geographical objects 3 1.2 Research objectives 4 1.3 Study area 5 1.4 Thesis structure 6 Chapter 2 State of the Art 8 2.1 Operators for building generalization 8 2.1.1 Selection 9 2.1.2 Aggregation 9 2.1.3 Simplification 10 2.1.4 Displacement 10 2.2 Researches of building grouping and pattern detection 11 2.2.1 Building grouping 11 2.2.2 Pattern detection 12 2.2.3 Problem analysis . 14 2.3 Researches of building typification 14 2.3.1 Global typification 15 2.3.2 Local typification 15 2.3.3 Comparison analysis 16 2.3.4 Problem analysis 17 2.4 Summary 17 Chapter 3 Using stroke and mesh to recognize building group patterns 18 3.1 Abstract 19 3.2 Introduction 19 3.3 Literature review 20 3.4 Building pattern typology and study area 22 3.4.1 Building pattern typology 22 3.4.2 Study area 24 3.5 Methodology 25 3.5.1 Generating and refining proximity graph 25 3.5.2 Generating stroke and mesh 29 3.5.3 Building pattern recognition 31 3.6 Experiments 33 3.6.1 Data derivation and test framework 33 3.6.2 Pattern recognition results 35 3.6.3 Evaluation 39 3.7 Discussion 40 3.7.1 Adaptation of parameters 40 3.7.2 Ambiguity of building patterns 44 3.7.3 Advantage and Limitation 45 3.8 Conclusion 46 Chapter 4 A typification method for linear building groups based on stroke simplification 47 4.1 Abstract 48 4.2 Introduction 48 4.3 Detection of linear building groups 50 4.3.1 Stroke-based detection method 50 4.3.2 Distinguishing collinear and curvilinear patterns 53 4.4 Typification method 55 4.4.1 Analogy of building typification and line simplification 55 4.4.2 Stroke generation 56 4.4.3 Stroke simplification 57 4.5 Representation of newly typified buildings 60 4.6 Experiment 63 4.6.1 Linear building group detection 63 4.6.2 Typification results 65 4.7 Discussion 66 4.7.1 Comparison of reallocating remained nodes 66 4.7.2 Comparison with classic line simplification method 67 4.7.3 Advantage 69 4.7.4 Further improvement 71 4.8 Conclusion 71 Chapter 5 A mesh-based typification method for building groups with grid patterns 73 5.1 Abstract 74 5.2 Introduction 74 5.3 Related work 75 5.4 Methodology of mesh-based typification 78 5.4.1 Grid pattern classification 78 5.4.2 Mesh generation 79 5.4.3 Triangular mesh elimination 80 5.4.4 Number and positioning of typified buildings 82 5.4.5 Representation of typified buildings 83 5.4.6 Resizing Newly Typified Buildings 85 5.5 Experiments 86 5.5.1 Data derivation 86 5.5.2 Typification results and evaluation 87 5.5.3 Comparison with official map 91 5.6 Discussion 92 5.6.1 Advantages 92 5.6.2 Further improvements 93 5.7 Conclusion 94 Chapter 6 Hierarchical extraction of skeleton structures from discrete buildings 95 6.1 Abstract 96 6.2 Introduction 96 6.3 Related work 97 6.4 Study area 99 6.5 Hierarchical extraction of skeleton structures 100 6.5.1 Proximity Graph Network (PGN) of buildings 100 6.5.2 Centrality analysis of proximity graph network 103 6.5.3 Hierarchical skeleton structures of buildings 108 6.6 Generalization application 111 6.7 Experiment and discussion 114 6.7.1 Data statement 114 6.7.2 Experimental results 115 6.7.3 Discussion 118 6.8 Conclusions 120 Chapter 7 Discussion 121 7.1 Revisiting the research problems 121 7.2 Evaluation of the presented methodology 123 7.2.1 Strengths 123 7.2.2 Limitations 125 Chapter 8 Conclusions 127 8.1 Main contributions 127 8.2 Outlook 128 8.3 Final thoughts 131 Bibliography 132 Acknowledgements 142 Publications 14

LEARNING TO RIG CHARACTERS

With the emergence of 3D virtual worlds, 3D social media, and massive online games, the need for diverse, high-quality, animation-ready characters and avatars is greater than ever. To animate characters, artists hand-craft articulation structures, such as animation skeletons and part deformers, which require significant amount of manual and laborious interaction with 2D/3D modeling interfaces. This thesis presents deep learning methods that are able to significantly automate the process of character rigging. First, the thesis introduces RigNet, a method capable of predicting an animation skeleton for an input static 3D shape in the form of a polygon mesh. The predicted skeletons match the animator expectations in joint placement and topology. RigNet also estimates surface skin weights which determine how the mesh is animated given the different skeletal poses. In contrast to prior work that fits pre-defined skeletal templates with hand-tuned objectives, RigNet is able to automatically rig diverse characters, such as humanoids, quadrupeds, toys, birds, with varying articulation structure and geometry. RigNet is based on a deep neural architecture that directly operates on the mesh representation. The architecture is trained on a diverse dataset of rigged models that we mined online and curated. The dataset includes 2.7K polygon meshes, along with their associated skeletons and corresponding skin weights. Second, the thesis introduces Morig, a method that automatically rigs character meshes driven by single-view point cloud streams capturing the motion of performing characters. Compared to RigNet, MoRig\u27s rigging is \emph{motion-aware}: its neural network encodes motion cues from the point clouds into compact feature representations that are informative about the articulated parts of the performing character. These motion-aware features guide the inference of an appropriate skeletal rig for the input mesh. Furthermore, Morig is able to animate the rig according to the captured point cloud motion. Morig can handle diverse characters with different morphologies (e.g., humanoids, quadrupeds, toy characters). It also accounts for occluded regions in the point clouds and mismatches in the part proportions between the input mesh and captured character. Third, the thesis introduces APES, a method that takes as input 2D raster images depicting a small set of poses of a character shown in a sprite sheet, and identifies articulated parts useful for rigging the character. APES uses a combination of neural network inference and integer linear programming to identify a compact set of articulated body parts, e.g. head, torso and limbs, that best reconstruct the input poses. Compared to Morig and RigNet that require a large collection of training models with associated skeletons and skinning weights, APES\u27 neural architecture relies on less effortful supervision from (i) pixel correspondences readily available in existing large cartoon image datasets (e.g., Creative Flow), (ii) a relatively small dataset of 57 cartoon characters segmented into moving parts. Finally, the thesis discusses future research directions related to combining neural rigging with 3D and 4D reconstruction of characters from point cloud data and 2D video as well as automating the process of motion synthesis for 3D characters

Example-Based Urban Modeling

The manual modeling of virtual cities or suburban regions is an extremely time-consuming task, which expects expert knowledge of different fields. Existing modeling tool-sets have a steep learning curve and may need special education skills to work with them productively. Existing automatic methods rely on rule sets and grammars to generate urban structures; however, their expressiveness is limited by the rule-sets. Expert skills are necessary to typeset rule sets successfully and, in many cases, new rule-sets need to be defined for every new building style or street network style. To enable non-expert users, the possibility to construct urban structures for individual experiments, this work proposes a portfolio of novel example-based synthesis algorithms and applications for the controlled generation of virtual urban environments. The notion example-based denotes here that new virtual urban environments are created by computer programs that re-use existing digitized real-world data serving as templates. The data, i.e., street networks, topography, layouts of building footprints, or even 3D building models, necessary to realize the envisioned task is already publicly available via online services. To enable the reuse of existing urban datasets, novel algorithms need to be developed by encapsulating expert knowledge and thus allow the controlled generation of virtual urban structures from sparse user input. The focus of this work is the automatic generation of three fundamental structures that are common in urban environments: road networks, city block, and individual buildings. In order to achieve this goal, the thesis proposes a portfolio of algorithms that are briefly summarized next. In a theoretical chapter, we propose a general optimization technique that allows formulating example-based synthesis as a general resource-constrained k-shortest path (RCKSP) problem. From an abstract problem specification and a database of exemplars carrying resource attributes, we construct an intermediate graph and employ a path-search optimization technique. This allows determining either the best or the k-best solutions. The resulting algorithm has a reduced complexity for the single constraint case when compared to other graph search-based techniques. For the generation of road networks, two different techniques are proposed. The first algorithm synthesizes a novel road network from user input, i.e., a desired arterial street skeleton, topography map, and a collection of hierarchical fragments extracted from real-world road networks. The algorithm recursively constructs a novel road network reusing these fragments. Candidate fragments are inserted into the current state of the road network, while shape differences will be compensated by warping. The second algorithm synthesizes road networks using generative adversarial networks (GANs), a recently introduced deep learning technique. A pre- and postprocessing pipeline allows using GANs for the generation of road networks. An in-depth evaluation shows that GANs faithfully learn the road structure present in the example network and that graph measures such as area, aspect ratio, and compactness, are maintained within the virtual road networks. To fill empty city blocks in road networks we propose two novel techniques. The first algorithm re-uses real-world city blocks and synthesizes building footprint layouts into empty city blocks by retrieving viable candidate blocks from a database. We evaluate the algorithm and synthesize a multitude of city block layouts reusing real-world building footprint arrangements from European and US-cities. In addition, we increase the realism of the synthesized layouts by performing example-based placement of 3D building models. This technique is evaluated by placing buildings onto challenging footprint layouts using different example building databases. The second algorithm computes a city block layout, resembling the style of a real-world city block. The original footprint layout is deformed to construct a textit{guidance map}, i.e., the original layout is transferred to a target city block using warping. This guidance map and the original footprints are used by an optimization technique that computes a novel footprint layout along the city block edges. We perform a detailed evaluation and show that using the guidance map allows transferring of the original layout, locally as well as globally, even when the source and target shapes drastically differ. To synthesize individual buildings, we use the general optimization technique described first and formulate the building generation process as a resource-constrained optimization problem. From an input database of annotated building parts, an abstract description of the building shape, and the specification of resource constraints such as length, area, or a number of architectural elements, a novel building is synthesized. We evaluate the technique by synthesizing a multitude of challenging buildings fulfilling several global and local resource constraints. Finally, we show how this technique can even be used to synthesize buildings having the shape of city blocks and might also be used to fill empty city blocks in virtual street networks. All algorithms presented in this work were developed to work with a small amount of user input. In most cases, simple sketches and the definition of constraints are enough to produce plausible results. Manual work is necessary to set up the building part databases and to download example data from mapping services available on the Internet

Analysis and Modular Approach for Text Extraction from Scientific Figures on Limited Data

Scientific figures are widely used as compact, comprehensible representations of important information. The re-usability of these figures is however limited, as one can rarely search directly for them, since they are mostly indexing by their surrounding text (e. g., publication or website) which often does not contain the full-message of the figure. In this thesis, the focus is on making the content of scientific figures accessible by extracting the text from these figures. A modular pipeline for unsupervised text extraction from scientific figures, based on a thorough analysis of the literature, was built to address the problem. This modular pipeline was used to build several unsupervised approaches, to evaluate different methods from the literature and new methods and method combinations. Some supervised approaches were built as well for comparison. One challenge, while evaluating the approaches, was the lack of annotated data, which especially needed to be considered when building the supervised approach. Three existing datasets were used for evaluation as well as two datasets of 241 scientific figures which were manually created and annotated. Additionally, two existing datasets for text extraction from other types of images were used for pretraining the supervised approach. Several experiments showed the superiority of the unsupervised pipeline over common Optical Character Recognition engines and identified the best unsupervised approach. This unsupervised approach was compared with the best supervised approach, which, despite of the limited amount of training data available, clearly outperformed the unsupervised approach.Infografiken sind ein viel verwendetes Medium zur kompakten Darstellung von Kernaussagen. Die Nachnutzbarkeit dieser Abbildungen ist jedoch häufig limitiert, da sie schlecht auffindbar sind, da sie meist über die umschließenden Medien, wie beispielsweise Publikationen oder Webseiten, und nicht über ihren Inhalt indexiert sind. Der Fokus dieser Arbeit liegt auf der Extraktion der textuellen Inhalte aus Infografiken, um deren Inhalt zu erschließen. Ausgehend von einer umfangreichen Analyse verwandter Arbeiten, wurde ein generalisierender, modularer Ansatz für die unüberwachte Textextraktion aus wissenschaftlichen Abbildungen entwickelt. Mit diesem modularen Ansatz wurden mehrere unüberwachte Ansätze und daneben auch noch einige überwachte Ansätze umgesetzt, um diverse Methoden aus der Literatur sowie neue und bisher noch nicht genutzte Methoden zu vergleichen. Eine Herausforderung bei der Evaluation war die geringe Menge an annotierten Abbildungen, was insbesondere beim überwachten Ansatz Methoden berücksichtigt werden musste. Für die Evaluation wurden drei existierende Datensätze verwendet und zudem wurden zusätzlich zwei Datensätze mit insgesamt 241 Infografiken erstellt und mit den nötigen Informationen annotiert, sodass insgesamt 5 Datensätze für die Evaluation verwendet werden konnten. Für das Pre-Training des überwachten Ansatzes wurden zudem zwei Datensätze aus verwandten Textextraktionsbereichen verwendet. In verschiedenen Experimenten wird gezeigt, dass der unüberwachte Ansatz besser funktioniert als klassische Texterkennungsverfahren und es wird aus den verschiedenen unüberwachten Ansätzen der beste ermittelt. Dieser unüberwachte Ansatz wird mit dem überwachten Ansatz verglichen, der trotz begrenzter Trainingsdaten die besten Ergebnisse liefert

Automatic Retrieval of Skeletal Structures of Trees from Terrestrial Laser Scanner Data

Research on forest ecosystems receives high attention, especially nowadays with regard to sustainable management of renewable resources and the climate change. In particular, accurate information on the 3D structure of a tree is important for forest science and bioclimatology, but also in the scope of commercial applications. Conventional methods to measure geometric plant features are labor- and time-intensive. For detailed analysis, trees have to be cut down, which is often undesirable. Here, Terrestrial Laser Scanning (TLS) provides a particularly attractive tool because of its contactless measurement technique. The object geometry is reproduced as a 3D point cloud. The objective of this thesis is the automatic retrieval of the spatial structure of trees from TLS data. We focus on forest scenes with comparably high stand density and with many occlusions resulting from it. The varying level of detail of TLS data poses a big challenge. We present two fully automatic methods to obtain skeletal structures from scanned trees that have complementary properties. First, we explain a method that retrieves the entire tree skeleton from 3D data of co-registered scans. The branching structure is obtained from a voxel space representation by searching paths from branch tips to the trunk. The trunk is determined in advance from the 3D points. The skeleton of a tree is generated as a 3D line graph. Besides 3D coordinates and range, a scan provides 2D indices from the intensity image for each measurement. This is exploited in the second method that processes individual scans. Furthermore, we introduce a novel concept to manage TLS data that facilitated the researchwork. Initially, the range image is segmented into connected components. We describe a procedure to retrieve the boundary of a component that is capable of tracing inner depth discontinuities. A 2D skeleton is generated from the boundary information and used to decompose the component into sub components. A Principal Curve is computed from the 3D point set that is associated with a sub component. The skeletal structure of a connected component is summarized as a set of polylines. Objective evaluation of the results remains an open problem because the task itself is ill-defined: There exists no clear definition of what the true skeleton should be w.r.t. a given point set. Consequently, we are not able to assess the correctness of the methods quantitatively, but have to rely on visual assessment of results and provide a thorough discussion of the particularities of both methods. We present experiment results of both methods. The first method efficiently retrieves full skeletons of trees, which approximate the branching structure. The level of detail is mainly governed by the voxel space and therefore, smaller branches are reproduced inadequately. The second method retrieves partial skeletons of a tree with high reproduction accuracy. The method is sensitive to noise in the boundary, but the results are very promising. There are plenty of possibilities to enhance the method’s robustness. The combination of the strengths of both presented methods needs to be investigated further and may lead to a robust way to obtain complete tree skeletons from TLS data automatically.Die Erforschung des ÖkosystemsWald spielt gerade heutzutage im Hinblick auf den nachhaltigen Umgang mit nachwachsenden Rohstoffen und den Klimawandel eine große Rolle. Insbesondere die exakte Beschreibung der dreidimensionalen Struktur eines Baumes ist wichtig für die Forstwissenschaften und Bioklimatologie, aber auch im Rahmen kommerzieller Anwendungen. Die konventionellen Methoden um geometrische Pflanzenmerkmale zu messen sind arbeitsintensiv und zeitaufwändig. Für eine genaue Analyse müssen Bäume gefällt werden, was oft unerwünscht ist. Hierbei bietet sich das Terrestrische Laserscanning (TLS) als besonders attraktives Werkzeug aufgrund seines kontaktlosen Messprinzips an. Die Objektgeometrie wird als 3D-Punktwolke wiedergegeben. Basierend darauf ist das Ziel der Arbeit die automatische Bestimmung der räumlichen Baumstruktur aus TLS-Daten. Der Fokus liegt dabei auf Waldszenen mit vergleichsweise hoher Bestandesdichte und mit zahlreichen daraus resultierenden Verdeckungen. Die Auswertung dieser TLS-Daten, die einen unterschiedlichen Grad an Detailreichtum aufweisen, stellt eine große Herausforderung dar. Zwei vollautomatische Methoden zur Generierung von Skelettstrukturen von gescannten Bäumen, welche komplementäre Eigenschaften besitzen, werden vorgestellt. Bei der ersten Methode wird das Gesamtskelett eines Baumes aus 3D-Daten von registrierten Scans bestimmt. Die Aststruktur wird von einer Voxelraum-Repräsentation abgeleitet indem Pfade von Astspitzen zum Stamm gesucht werden. Der Stamm wird im Voraus aus den 3D-Punkten rekonstruiert. Das Baumskelett wird als 3D-Liniengraph erzeugt. Für jeden gemessenen Punkt stellt ein Scan neben 3D-Koordinaten und Distanzwerten auch 2D-Indizes zur Verfügung, die sich aus dem Intensitätsbild ergeben. Bei der zweiten Methode, die auf Einzelscans arbeitet, wird dies ausgenutzt. Außerdem wird ein neuartiges Konzept zum Management von TLS-Daten beschrieben, welches die Forschungsarbeit erleichtert hat. Zunächst wird das Tiefenbild in Komponenten aufgeteilt. Es wird eine Prozedur zur Bestimmung von Komponentenkonturen vorgestellt, die in der Lage ist innere Tiefendiskontinuitäten zu verfolgen. Von der Konturinformation wird ein 2D-Skelett generiert, welches benutzt wird um die Komponente in Teilkomponenten zu zerlegen. Von der 3D-Punktmenge, die mit einer Teilkomponente assoziiert ist, wird eine Principal Curve berechnet. Die Skelettstruktur einer Komponente im Tiefenbild wird als Menge von Polylinien zusammengefasst. Die objektive Evaluation der Resultate stellt weiterhin ein ungelöstes Problem dar, weil die Aufgabe selbst nicht klar erfassbar ist: Es existiert keine eindeutige Definition davon was das wahre Skelett in Bezug auf eine gegebene Punktmenge sein sollte. Die Korrektheit der Methoden kann daher nicht quantitativ beschrieben werden. Aus diesem Grund, können die Ergebnisse nur visuell beurteiltwerden. Weiterhinwerden die Charakteristiken beider Methoden eingehend diskutiert. Es werden Experimentresultate beider Methoden vorgestellt. Die erste Methode bestimmt effizient das Skelett eines Baumes, welches die Aststruktur approximiert. Der Detaillierungsgrad wird hauptsächlich durch den Voxelraum bestimmt, weshalb kleinere Äste nicht angemessen reproduziert werden. Die zweite Methode rekonstruiert Teilskelette eines Baums mit hoher Detailtreue. Die Methode reagiert sensibel auf Rauschen in der Kontur, dennoch sind die Ergebnisse vielversprechend. Es gibt eine Vielzahl von Möglichkeiten die Robustheit der Methode zu verbessern. Die Kombination der Stärken von beiden präsentierten Methoden sollte weiter untersucht werden und kann zu einem robusteren Ansatz führen um vollständige Baumskelette automatisch aus TLS-Daten zu generieren