31,514 research outputs found
Academy Recommendations on the Proposed Yucca Mountain Waste Repository: Overview and Criticisms
Offers alternative criticism of the NAS report
Probabilistic analysis of cost-effectiveness models: choosing between treatment strategies for gastroesophageal reflux disease
When choosing between mutually exclusive treatment options, it is common to construct a cost-effectiveness frontier on the cost-effectiveness plane that represents efficient points from among the treatment choices. Treatment options internal to the frontier are considered inefficient and are excluded either by strict dominance or by appealing to the principle of extended dominance. However, when uncertainty is considered, options excluded under the baseline analysis may form part of the cost-effectiveness frontier. By adopting a Bayesian approach, where distributions for model parameters are specified, uncertainty in the decision concerning which treatment option should be implemented is addressed directly. The approach is illustrated using an example from a recently published cost-effectiveness analysis of different possible treatment strategies for gastroesophageal reflux disease.It is argued that probabilistic analyses should be encouraged because they have potential to quantify the strength of evidence in favor of particular treatment choices
Calculating the Expected Value of Sample Information in Practice: Considerations from Three Case Studies
Investing efficiently in future research to improve policy decisions is an
important goal. Expected Value of Sample Information (EVSI) can be used to
select the specific design and sample size of a proposed study by assessing the
benefit of a range of different studies. Estimating EVSI with the standard
nested Monte Carlo algorithm has a notoriously high computational burden,
especially when using a complex decision model or when optimizing over study
sample sizes and designs. Therefore, a number of more efficient EVSI
approximation methods have been developed. However, these approximation methods
have not been compared and therefore their relative advantages and
disadvantages are not clear. A consortium of EVSI researchers, including the
developers of several approximation methods, compared four EVSI methods using
three previously published health economic models. The examples were chosen to
represent a range of real-world contexts, including situations with multiple
study outcomes, missing data, and data from an observational rather than a
randomized study. The computational speed and accuracy of each method were
compared, and the relative advantages and implementation challenges of the
methods were highlighted. In each example, the approximation methods took
minutes or hours to achieve reasonably accurate EVSI estimates, whereas the
traditional Monte Carlo method took weeks. Specific methods are particularly
suited to problems where we wish to compare multiple proposed sample sizes,
when the proposed sample size is large, or when the health economic model is
computationally expensive. All the evaluated methods gave estimates similar to
those given by traditional Monte Carlo, suggesting that EVSI can now be
efficiently computed with confidence in realistic examples.Comment: 11 pages, 3 figure
Demand Forecasting: Evidence-based Methods
We looked at evidence from comparative empirical studies to identify methods that can be useful for predicting demand in various situations and to warn against methods that should not be used. In general, use structured methods and avoid intuition, unstructured meetings, focus groups, and data mining. In situations where there are sufficient data, use quantitative methods including extrapolation, quantitative analogies, rule-based forecasting, and causal methods. Otherwise, use methods that structure judgement including surveys of intentions and expectations, judgmental bootstrapping, structured analogies, and simulated interaction. Managers' domain knowledge should be incorporated into statistical forecasts. Methods for combining forecasts, including Delphi and prediction markets, improve accuracy. We provide guidelines for the effective use of forecasts, including such procedures as scenarios. Few organizations use many of the methods described in this paper. Thus, there are opportunities to improve efficiency by adopting these forecasting practices.Accuracy, expertise, forecasting, judgement, marketing.
A methodology for the selection of new technologies in the aviation industry
The purpose of this report is to present a technology selection methodology to
quantify both tangible and intangible benefits of certain technology
alternatives within a fuzzy environment. Specifically, it describes an
application of the theory of fuzzy sets to hierarchical structural analysis and
economic evaluations for utilisation in the industry. The report proposes a
complete methodology to accurately select new technologies. A computer based
prototype model has been developed to handle the more complex fuzzy
calculations. Decision-makers are only required to express their opinions on
comparative importance of various factors in linguistic terms rather than exact
numerical values. These linguistic variable scales, such as ‘very high’, ‘high’,
‘medium’, ‘low’ and ‘very low’, are then converted into fuzzy numbers, since it
becomes more meaningful to quantify a subjective measurement into a range rather
than in an exact value. By aggregating the hierarchy, the preferential weight of
each alternative technology is found, which is called fuzzy appropriate index.
The fuzzy appropriate indices of different technologies are then ranked and
preferential ranking orders of technologies are found. From the economic
evaluation perspective, a fuzzy cash flow analysis is employed. This deals
quantitatively with imprecision or uncertainties, as the cash flows are modelled
as triangular fuzzy numbers which represent ‘the most likely possible value’,
‘the most pessimistic value’ and ‘the most optimistic value’. By using this
methodology, the ambiguities involved in the assessment data can be effectively
represented and processed to assure a more convincing and effective decision-
making process when selecting new technologies in which to invest. The prototype
model was validated with a case study within the aviation industry that ensured
it was properly configured to meet the
- …