63,789 research outputs found

    Cake cutting really is not a piece of cake

    Full text link

    A Cryptographic Moving-Knife Cake-Cutting Protocol

    Full text link
    This paper proposes a cake-cutting protocol using cryptography when the cake is a heterogeneous good that is represented by an interval on a real line. Although the Dubins-Spanier moving-knife protocol with one knife achieves simple fairness, all players must execute the protocol synchronously. Thus, the protocol cannot be executed on asynchronous networks such as the Internet. We show that the moving-knife protocol can be executed asynchronously by a discrete protocol using a secure auction protocol. The number of cuts is n-1 where n is the number of players, which is the minimum.Comment: In Proceedings IWIGP 2012, arXiv:1202.422

    Communication Complexity of Cake Cutting

    Full text link
    We study classic cake-cutting problems, but in discrete models rather than using infinite-precision real values, specifically, focusing on their communication complexity. Using general discrete simulations of classical infinite-precision protocols (Robertson-Webb and moving-knife), we roughly partition the various fair-allocation problems into 3 classes: "easy" (constant number of rounds of logarithmic many bits), "medium" (poly-logarithmic total communication), and "hard". Our main technical result concerns two of the "medium" problems (perfect allocation for 2 players and equitable allocation for any number of players) which we prove are not in the "easy" class. Our main open problem is to separate the "hard" from the "medium" classes.Comment: Added efficient communication protocol for the monotone crossing proble

    On the Complexity of Chore Division

    Full text link
    We study the proportional chore division problem where a protocol wants to divide an undesirable object, called chore, among nn different players. The goal is to find an allocation such that the cost of the chore assigned to each player be at most 1/n1/n of the total cost. This problem is the dual variant of the cake cutting problem in which we want to allocate a desirable object. Edmonds and Pruhs showed that any protocol for the proportional cake cutting must use at least Ω(nlogn)\Omega(n \log n) queries in the worst case, however, finding a lower bound for the proportional chore division remained an interesting open problem. We show that chore division and cake cutting problems are closely related to each other and provide an Ω(nlogn)\Omega(n \log n) lower bound for chore division

    A Discrete and Bounded Envy-free Cake Cutting Protocol for Four Agents

    Full text link
    We consider the well-studied cake cutting problem in which the goal is to identify a fair allocation based on a minimal number of queries from the agents. The problem has attracted considerable attention within various branches of computer science, mathematics, and economics. Although, the elegant Selfridge-Conway envy-free protocol for three agents has been known since 1960, it has been a major open problem for the last fifty years to obtain a bounded envy-free protocol for more than three agents. We propose a discrete and bounded envy-free protocol for four agents

    How to solve the cake-cutting problem in sublinear time

    Get PDF
    In this paper, we show algorithms for solving the cake-cutting problem in sublinear-time. More specifically, we preassign (simple) fair portions to o(n) players in o(n)-time, and minimize the damage to the rest of the players. All currently known algorithms require Omega(n)-time, even when assigning a portion to just one player, and it is nontrivial to revise these algorithms to run in o(n)o(n)-time since many of the remaining players, who have not been asked any queries, may not be satisfied with the remaining cake. To challenge this problem, we begin by providing a framework for solving the cake-cutting problem in sublinear-time. Generally speaking, solving a problem in sublinear-time requires the use of approximations. However, in our framework, we introduce the concept of "eps n-victims," which means that eps n players (victims) may not get fair portions, where 0< eps =< 1 is an arbitrary constant. In our framework, an algorithm consists of the following two parts: In the first (Preassigning) part, it distributes fair portions to r < n players in o(n)-time. In the second (Completion) part, it distributes fair portions to the remaining n-r players except for the eps n victims in poly}(n)-time. There are two variations on the r players in the first part. Specifically, whether they can or cannot be designated. We will then present algorithms in this framework. In particular, an O(r/eps)-time algorithm for r =< eps n/127 undesignated players with eps n-victims, and an O~(r^2/eps)-time algorithm for r =< eps e^{{sqrt{ln{n}}}/{7}} designated players and eps =< 1/e with eps n-victims are presented.Comment: 15 pages, no figur
    corecore