Performance evaluation of HEVC RCL applications mapped onto NoC-based embedded platforms

Today, several applications running into embedded systems have to fulfill soft or hard timing constraints. Video applications, like the modern High Efficiency Video Coding (HEVC), e.g., most often have soft real-time constraints. However, in specific scenarios, such as in robotic surgeries, the coupling of satellites and so on, harder timing constraints arise, becoming a huge challenge. Although the implementation of such applications in Networks-on-Chip (NoCs) being an alternative to reduce their algorithmic complexity and meet real-time constraints, a performance evaluation of the mapped NoC and the schedulability analysis for a given application are mandatory. In this work we make a performance evaluation of HEVC Residual Coding Loop (RCL) mapped onto a NoC-based embedded platform, considering the encoding of a single 1920x1080 pixels frame. A set of analysis exploring the combination of different NoC sizes and task mapping strategies were performed, showing for the typical and upper-bound workload cases scenarios when the application is schedulable and meets the real-time constraints

Approximate and timing-speculative hardware design for high-performance and energy-efficient video processing

Since the end of transistor scaling in 2-D appeared on the horizon, innovative circuit design paradigms have been on the rise to go beyond the well-established and ultraconservative exact computing. Many compute-intensive applications – such as video processing – exhibit an intrinsic error resilience and do not necessarily require perfect accuracy in their numerical operations. Approximate computing (AxC) is emerging as a design alternative to improve the performance and energy-efficiency requirements for many applications by trading its intrinsic error tolerance with algorithm and circuit efficiency. Exact computing also imposes a worst-case timing to the conventional design of hardware accelerators to ensure reliability, leading to an efficiency loss. Conversely, the timing-speculative (TS) hardware design paradigm allows increasing the frequency or decreasing the voltage beyond the limits determined by static timing analysis (STA), thereby narrowing pessimistic safety margins that conventional design methods implement to prevent hardware timing errors. Timing errors should be evaluated by an accurate gate-level simulation, but a significant gap remains: How these timing errors propagate from the underlying hardware all the way up to the entire algorithm behavior, where they just may degrade the performance and quality of service of the application at stake? This thesis tackles this issue by developing and demonstrating a cross-layer framework capable of performing investigations of both AxC (i.e., from approximate arithmetic operators, approximate synthesis, gate-level pruning) and TS hardware design (i.e., from voltage over-scaling, frequency over-clocking, temperature rising, and device aging). The cross-layer framework can simulate both timing errors and logic errors at the gate-level by crossing them dynamically, linking the hardware result with the algorithm-level, and vice versa during the evolution of the application’s runtime. Existing frameworks perform investigations of AxC and TS techniques at circuit-level (i.e., at the output of the accelerator) agnostic to the ultimate impact at the application level (i.e., where the impact is truly manifested), leading to less optimization. Unlike state of the art, the framework proposed offers a holistic approach to assessing the tradeoff of AxC and TS techniques at the application-level. This framework maximizes energy efficiency and performance by identifying the maximum approximation levels at the application level to fulfill the required good enough quality. This thesis evaluates the framework with an 8-way SAD (Sum of Absolute Differences) hardware accelerator operating into an HEVC encoder as a case study. Application-level results showed that the SAD based on the approximate adders achieve savings of up to 45% of energy/operation with an increase of only 1.9% in BD-BR. On the other hand, VOS (Voltage Over-Scaling) applied to the SAD generates savings of up to 16.5% in energy/operation with around 6% of increase in BD-BR. The framework also reveals that the boost of about 6.96% (at 50°) to 17.41% (at 75° with 10- Y aging) in the maximum clock frequency achieved with TS hardware design is totally lost by the processing overhead from 8.06% to 46.96% when choosing an unreliable algorithm to the blocking match algorithm (BMA). We also show that the overhead can be avoided by adopting a reliable BMA. This thesis also shows approximate DTT (Discrete Tchebichef Transform) hardware proposals by exploring a transform matrix approximation, truncation and pruning. The results show that the approximate DTT hardware proposal increases the maximum frequency up to 64%, minimizes the circuit area in up to 43.6%, and saves up to 65.4% in power dissipation. The DTT proposal mapped for FPGA shows an increase of up to 58.9% on the maximum frequency and savings of about 28.7% and 32.2% on slices and dynamic power, respectively compared with stat

High Performance Multiview Video Coding

Following the standardization of the latest video coding standard High Efficiency Video Coding in 2013, in 2014, multiview extension of HEVC (MV-HEVC) was published and brought significantly better compression performance of around 50% for multiview and 3D videos compared to multiple independent single-view HEVC coding. However, the extremely high computational complexity of MV-HEVC demands significant optimization of the encoder. To tackle this problem, this work investigates the possibilities of using modern parallel computing platforms and tools such as single-instruction-multiple-data (SIMD) instructions, multi-core CPU, massively parallel GPU, and computer cluster to significantly enhance the MVC encoder performance. The aforementioned computing tools have very different computing characteristics and misuse of the tools may result in poor performance improvement and sometimes even reduction. To achieve the best possible encoding performance from modern computing tools, different levels of parallelism inside a typical MVC encoder are identified and analyzed. Novel optimization techniques at various levels of abstraction are proposed, non-aggregation massively parallel motion estimation (ME) and disparity estimation (DE) in prediction unit (PU), fractional and bi-directional ME/DE acceleration through SIMD, quantization parameter (QP)-based early termination for coding tree unit (CTU), optimized resource-scheduled wave-front parallel processing for CTU, and workload balanced, cluster-based multiple-view parallel are proposed. The result shows proposed parallel optimization techniques, with insignificant loss to coding efficiency, significantly improves the execution time performance. This , in turn, proves modern parallel computing platforms, with appropriate platform-specific algorithm design, are valuable tools for improving the performance of computationally intensive applications

Towards Computational Efficiency of Next Generation Multimedia Systems

To address throughput demands of complex applications (like Multimedia), a next-generation system designer needs to co-design and co-optimize the hardware and software layers. Hardware/software knobs must be tuned in synergy to increase the throughput efficiency. This thesis provides such algorithmic and architectural solutions, while considering the new technology challenges (power-cap and memory aging). The goal is to maximize the throughput efficiency, under timing- and hardware-constraints

Algorithms for compression of high dynamic range images and video

The recent advances in sensor and display technologies have brought upon the High Dynamic Range (HDR) imaging capability. The modern multiple exposure HDR sensors can achieve the dynamic range of 100-120 dB and LED and OLED display devices have contrast ratios of 10^5:1 to 10^6:1. Despite the above advances in technology the image/video compression algorithms and associated hardware are yet based on Standard Dynamic Range (SDR) technology, i.e. they operate within an effective dynamic range of up to 70 dB for 8 bit gamma corrected images. Further the existing infrastructure for content distribution is also designed for SDR, which creates interoperability problems with true HDR capture and display equipment. The current solutions for the above problem include tone mapping the HDR content to fit SDR. However this approach leads to image quality associated problems, when strong dynamic range compression is applied. Even though some HDR-only solutions have been proposed in literature, they are not interoperable with current SDR infrastructure and are thus typically used in closed systems. Given the above observations a research gap was identified in the need for efficient algorithms for the compression of still images and video, which are capable of storing full dynamic range and colour gamut of HDR images and at the same time backward compatible with existing SDR infrastructure. To improve the usability of SDR content it is vital that any such algorithms should accommodate different tone mapping operators, including those that are spatially non-uniform. In the course of the research presented in this thesis a novel two layer CODEC architecture is introduced for both HDR image and video coding. Further a universal and computationally efficient approximation of the tone mapping operator is developed and presented. It is shown that the use of perceptually uniform colourspaces for internal representation of pixel data enables improved compression efficiency of the algorithms. Further proposed novel approaches to the compression of metadata for the tone mapping operator is shown to improve compression performance for low bitrate video content. Multiple compression algorithms are designed, implemented and compared and quality-complexity trade-offs are identified. Finally practical aspects of implementing the developed algorithms are explored by automating the design space exploration flow and integrating the high level systems design framework with domain specific tools for synthesis and simulation of multiprocessor systems. The directions for further work are also presented

Gestión de recursos energéticamente eficiente para aplicaciones paralelas basadas en tareas en entornos multi-aplicación

Tesis de la Universidad Complutense de Madrid, Facultad de Informática, leída el 28/01/2021The end of Dennard scaling, as well as the arrival of the post-Moore era, has meant a big change in the way performance and energy efficiency are achieved by modern processors. From a constant increase of the clock frequency as the main method to increase performance at the beginning of the 2000s, the increase in the number of cores inside processors running at relatively conservative frequencies has stabilised as the current trend to increase both performance and energy efficiency. The increase of the heterogeneity in the systems, both inside the processors comprising different types of cores (e.g., big LITTLE architectures) or adding specific compute units (like multimedia extensions), as well as in the platform by the addition of other specific compute units (like GPUs), offering different performance and energy-efficiency trade-offs. Together with the increase in the number of cores, the processor evolution has been accompanied by the addition of different techologies that allow processors to adapt dynamically to the changes in the environment and running aplications. Among others, techiniques like dynamic voltage and frequiency scaling, power capping or cache partitioning are widely used nowadays to increase the performance and/or energy-efficiency...El fin del escalado de Dennard, así como la llegada de la era post-Moore ha supuesto una gran revolución en la forma de obtener el rendimiento y eficiencia energética en los procesadores modernos. Desde un incremento constante en la frecuencia relativamente moderadas se ha impuesto como la tendencia actual para incrementar tanto el rendimiento como la eficiencia energética. El aumento del número de núcleos dentro del procesado ha venido acompañado en los últimos años por el aumento de la heterogeneidad en la plataforma, tanto dentro del procesador incorporando distintos tipos de núcleos en el mismo procesador (e.g., la arquitectura big.LITTLE) como añadiendo unidades de cómputo específicas (e.g., extensiones multimedia), como la incorporación de otros elementos de computo específicos, ofreciendo diferentes grados de rendimiento y eficiencia energética. La evolución de los procesadores no solo ha venido dictada por el aumento del número de núcleos, sino que ha venido acompañada por la incorporación de diferentes técnicas permitiendo la adaptación de las arquitecturas de forma dinámica al entorno así como a las aplicaciones en ejecución. Entre otras, técnicas como el escalado de frecuencia, la limitación de consumo o el particionado de la memoria caché son ampliamente utilizadas en la actualidad como métodos para incrementar el consumo y/o la eficiencia energética...Fac. de InformáticaTRUEunpu

Delivery of 360° videos in edge caching assisted wireless cellular networks

In recent years, 360° videos have become increasingly popular on commercial social platforms, and are a vital part of emerging Virtual Reality (VR) applications. However, the delivery of 360° videos requires significant bandwidth resources, which makes streaming of such data on mobile networks challenging. The bandwidth required for delivering 360° videos can be reduced by exploiting the fact that users are interested in viewing only a part of the video scene, the requested viewport. As different users may request different viewports, some parts of the 360° scenes may be more popular than others. 360° video delivery on mobile networks can be facilitated by caching popular content at edge servers, and delivering it from there to the users. However, existing edge caching schemes do not take full potential of the unequal popularity of different parts of a video, which renders them inefficient for caching 360° videos. Inspired by the above, in this thesis, we investigate how advanced 360° video coding tools, i.e., encoding into multiple quality layers and tiles, can be utilized to build more efficient wireless edge caching schemes for 360° videos. The above encoding allows the caching of only the parts of the 360° videos that are popular in high quality. To understand how edge caching schemes can benefit from 360° video coding, we compare the caching of 360° videos encoded into multiple quality layers and tiles with layer-agnostic and tile-agnostic schemes. To cope with the fact that the content popularity distribution may be unknown, we use machine learning techniques, for both Video on Demand (VoD), and live streaming scenarios. From our findings, it is clear that by taking into account the aforementioned 360° video characteristics leads to an increased performance in terms of the quality of the video delivered to the users, and the usage of the backhaul links

Feasibility Study of High-Level Synthesis : Implementation of a Real-Time HEVC Intra Encoder on FPGA

High-Level Synthesis (HLS) on automatisoitu suunnitteluprosessi, joka pyrkii parantamaan tuottavuutta perinteisiin suunnittelumenetelmiin verrattuna, nostamalla suunnittelun abstraktiota rekisterisiirtotasolta (RTL) käyttäytymistasolle. Erilaisia kaupallisia HLS-työkaluja on ollut markkinoilla aina 1990-luvulta lähtien, mutta vasta äskettäin ne ovat alkaneet saada hyväksyntää teollisuudessa sekä akateemisessa maailmassa. Hidas käyttöönottoaste on johtunut pääasiassa huonommasta tulosten laadusta (QoR) kuin mitä on ollut mahdollista tavanomaisilla laitteistokuvauskielillä (HDL). Uusimmat HLS-työkalusukupolvet ovat kuitenkin kaventaneet QoR-aukkoa huomattavasti. Tämä väitöskirja tutkii HLS:n soveltuvuutta videokoodekkien kehittämiseen. Se esittelee useita HLS-toteutuksia High Efficiency Video Coding (HEVC) -koodaukselle, joka on keskeinen mahdollistava tekniikka lukuisille nykyaikaisille mediasovelluksille. HEVC kaksinkertaistaa koodaustehokkuuden edeltäjäänsä Advanced Video Coding (AVC) -standardiin verrattuna, saavuttaen silti saman subjektiivisen visuaalisen laadun. Tämä tyypillisesti saavutetaan huomattavalla laskennallisella lisäkustannuksella. Siksi reaaliaikainen HEVC vaatii automatisoituja suunnittelumenetelmiä, joita voidaan käyttää rautatoteutus- (HW ) ja varmennustyön minimoimiseen. Tässä väitöskirjassa ehdotetaan HLS:n käyttöä koko enkooderin suunnitteluprosessissa. Dataintensiivisistä koodaustyökaluista, kuten intra-ennustus ja diskreetit muunnokset, myös enemmän kontrollia vaativiin kokonaisuuksiin, kuten entropiakoodaukseen. Avoimen lähdekoodin Kvazaar HEVC -enkooderin C-lähdekoodia hyödynnetään tässä työssä referenssinä HLS-suunnittelulle sekä toteutuksen varmentamisessa. Suorituskykytulokset saadaan ja raportoidaan ohjelmoitavalla porttimatriisilla (FPGA). Tämän väitöskirjan tärkein tuotos on HEVC intra enkooderin prototyyppi. Prototyyppi koostuu Nokia AirFrame Cloud Server palvelimesta, varustettuna kahdella 2.4 GHz:n 14-ytiminen Intel Xeon prosessorilla, sekä kahdesta Intel Arria 10 GX FPGA kiihdytinkortista, jotka voidaan kytkeä serveriin käyttäen joko peripheral component interconnect express (PCIe) liitäntää tai 40 gigabitin Ethernettiä. Prototyyppijärjestelmä saavuttaa reaaliaikaisen 4K enkoodausnopeuden, jopa 120 kuvaa sekunnissa. Lisäksi järjestelmän suorituskykyä on helppo skaalata paremmaksi lisäämällä järjestelmään käytännössä minkä tahansa määrän verkkoon kytkettäviä FPGA-kortteja. Monimutkaisen HEVC:n tehokas mallinnus ja sen monipuolisten ominaisuuksien mukauttaminen reaaliaikaiselle HW HEVC enkooderille ei ole triviaali tehtävä, koska HW-toteutukset ovat perinteisesti erittäin aikaa vieviä. Tämä väitöskirja osoittaa, että HLS:n avulla pystytään nopeuttamaan kehitysaikaa, tarjoamaan ennen näkemätöntä suunnittelun skaalautuvuutta, ja silti osoittamaan kilpailukykyisiä QoR-arvoja ja absoluuttista suorituskykyä verrattuna olemassa oleviin toteutuksiin.High-Level Synthesis (HLS) is an automated design process that seeks to improve productivity over traditional design methods by increasing design abstraction from register transfer level (RTL) to behavioural level. Various commercial HLS tools have been available on the market since the 1990s, but only recently they have started to gain adoption across industry and academia. The slow adoption rate has mainly stemmed from lower quality of results (QoR) than obtained with conventional hardware description languages (HDLs). However, the latest HLS tool generations have substantially narrowed the QoR gap. This thesis studies the feasibility of HLS in video codec development. It introduces several HLS implementations for High Efficiency Video Coding (HEVC) , that is the key enabling technology for numerous modern media applications. HEVC doubles the coding efficiency over its predecessor Advanced Video Coding (AVC) standard for the same subjective visual quality, but typically at the cost of considerably higher computational complexity. Therefore, real-time HEVC calls for automated design methodologies that can be used to minimize the HW implementation and verification effort. This thesis proposes to use HLS throughout the whole encoder design process. From data-intensive coding tools, like intra prediction and discrete transforms, to more control-oriented tools, such as entropy coding. The C source code of the open-source Kvazaar HEVC encoder serves as a design entry point for the HLS flow, and it is also utilized in design verification. The performance results are gathered with and reported for field programmable gate array (FPGA) . The main contribution of this thesis is an HEVC intra encoder prototype that is built on a Nokia AirFrame Cloud Server equipped with 2.4 GHz dual 14-core Intel Xeon processors and two Intel Arria 10 GX FPGA Development Kits, that can be connected to the server via peripheral component interconnect express (PCIe) generation 3 or 40 Gigabit Ethernet. The proof-of-concept system achieves real-time. 4K coding speed up to 120 fps, which can be further scaled up by adding practically any number of network-connected FPGA cards. Overcoming the complexity of HEVC and customizing its rich features for a real-time HEVC encoder implementation on hardware is not a trivial task, as hardware development has traditionally turned out to be very time-consuming. This thesis shows that HLS is able to boost the development time, provide previously unseen design scalability, and still result in competitive performance and QoR over state-of-the-art hardware implementations

Design Space Exploration of Accelerators for Warehouse Scale Computing

With Moore’s law grinding to a halt, accelerators are one of the ways that new silicon can improve performance, and they are already a key component in modern datacenters. Accelerators are integrated circuits that implement parts of an application with the objective of higher energy efficiency compared to execution on a standard general purpose CPU. Many accelerators can target any particular workload, generally with a wide range of performance, and costs such as area or power. Exploring these design choices, called Design Space Exploration (DSE), is a crucial step in trying to find the most efficient accelerator design, the one that produces the largest reduction of the total cost of ownership. This work aims to improve this design space exploration phase for accelerators and to avoid pitfalls in the process. This dissertation supports the thesis that early design choices – including the level of specialization – are critical for accelerator development and therefore require benchmarks reflective of production workloads. We present three studies that support this thesis. First, we show how to benchmark datacenter applications by creating a benchmark for large video sharing infrastructures. Then, we present two studies focused on accelerators for analytical query processing. The first is an analysis on the impact of Network on Chip specialization while the second analyses the impact of the level of specialization. The first part of this dissertation introduces vbench: a video transcoding benchmark tailored to the growing video-as-a-service market. Video transcoding is not accurately represented in current computer architecture benchmarks such as SPEC or PARSEC. Despite posing a big computational burden for cloud video providers, such as YouTube and Facebook, it is not included in cloud benchmarks such as CloudSuite. Using vbench, we found that the microarchitectural profile of video transcoding is highly dependent on the input video, that SIMD extensions provide limited benefits, and that commercial hardware transcoders impose tradeoffs that are not ideal for cloud video providers. Our benchmark should spur architectural innovations for this critical workload. This work shows how to benchmark a real world warehouse scale application and the possible pitfalls in case of a mischaracterization. When considering accelerators for the different, but no less important, application of analytical query processing, design space exploration plays a critical role. We analyzed the Q100, a class of accelerators for this application domain, using TPC-H as the reference benchmark. We found that the hardware computational blocks have to be tailored to the requirements of the application, but also the Network on Chip (NoC) can be specialized. We developed an algorithm capable of producing more effective Q100 designs by tailoring the NoC to the communication requirements of the system. Our algorithm is capable of producing designs that are Pareto optimal compared to standard NoC topologies. This shows how NoC specialization is highly effective for accelerators and it should be an integral part of design space exploration for large accelerators’ designs. The third part of this dissertation analyzes the impact of the level of specialization, e.g. using an ASIC or Coarse Grain Reconfigurable Architecture (CGRA) implementation, on an accelerator performance. We developed a CGRA architecture capable of executing SQL query plans. We compare this architecture against Q100, an ASIC that targets the same class of workloads. Despite being less specialized, this programmable architecture shows comparable performance to the Q100 given an area and power budget. Resource usage explains this counterintuitive result, since a well programmed, homogeneous array of resources is able to more effectively harness silicon for the workload at hand. This suggests that a balanced accelerator research portfolio must include alternative programmable architectures – and their software stacks