Implementation of a performance optimized database join operation on FPGA-GPU platforms using OpenCL

The growing trend toward heterogeneous platforms is crucial to meet time and power consumption constraints for high-performance computing applications. The OpenCL parallel programming language and framework enable programming CPU, GPU and recently FPGAs using the same source code. This eases software developers to implement applications on various devices supported by heterogeneous HPC platforms. This work presents two very different FPGA implementations of a database join operation, one using a direct O(n2) algorithm, and the other using a bitonic sort network to speed up the join operation. Comparison of performance and energy consumption for both FPGA and GPUs is provided which suggests a 40% performance/watt improvement by using an FPGA instead of a GPU

High Performance Computing via High Level Synthesis

As more and more powerful integrated circuits are appearing on the market, more and more applications, with very different requirements and workloads, are making use of the available computing power. This thesis is in particular devoted to High Performance Computing applications, where those trends are carried to the extreme. In this domain, the primary aspects to be taken into consideration are (1) performance (by definition) and (2) energy consumption (since operational costs dominate over procurement costs). These requirements can be satisfied more easily by deploying heterogeneous platforms, which include CPUs, GPUs and FPGAs to provide a broad range of performance and energy-per-operation choices. In particular, as we will see, FPGAs clearly dominate both CPUs and GPUs in terms of energy, and can provide comparable performance. An important aspect of this trend is of course design technology, because these applications were traditionally programmed in high-level languages, while FPGAs required low-level RTL design. The OpenCL (Open Computing Language) developed by the Khronos group enables developers to program CPU, GPU and recently FPGAs using functionally portable (but sadly not performance portable) source code which creates new possibilities and challenges both for research and industry. FPGAs have been always used for mid-size designs and ASIC prototyping thanks to their energy efficient and flexible hardware architecture, but their usage requires hardware design knowledge and laborious design cycles. Several approaches are developed and deployed to address this issue and shorten the gap between software and hardware in FPGA design flow, in order to enable FPGAs to capture a larger portion of the hardware acceleration market in data centers. Moreover, FPGAs usage in data centers is growing already, regardless of and in addition to their use as computational accelerators, because they can be used as high performance, low power and secure switches inside data-centers. High-Level Synthesis (HLS) is the methodology that enables designers to map their applications on FPGAs (and ASICs). It synthesizes parallel hardware from a model originally written C-based programming languages .e.g. C/C++, SystemC and OpenCL. Design space exploration of the variety of implementations that can be obtained from this C model is possible through wide range of optimization techniques and directives, e.g. to pipeline loops and partition memories into multiple banks, which guide RTL generation toward application dependent hardware and benefit designers from flexible parallel architecture of FPGAs. Model Based Design (MBD) is a high-level and visual process used to generate implementations that solve mathematical problems through a varied set of IP-blocks. MBD enables developers with different expertise, e.g. control theory, embedded software development, and hardware design to share a common design framework and contribute to a shared design using the same tool. Simulink, developed by MATLAB, is a model based design tool for simulation and development of complex dynamical systems. Moreover, Simulink embedded code generators can produce verified C/C++ and HDL code from the graphical model. This code can be used to program micro-controllers and FPGAs. This PhD thesis work presents a study using automatic code generator of Simulink to target Xilinx FPGAs using both HDL and C/C++ code to demonstrate capabilities and challenges of high-level synthesis process. To do so, firstly, digital signal processing unit of a real-time radar application is developed using Simulink blocks. Secondly, generated C based model was used for high level synthesis process and finally the implementation cost of HLS is compared to traditional HDL synthesis using Xilinx tool chain. Alternative to model based design approach, this work also presents an analysis on FPGA programming via high-level synthesis techniques for computationally intensive algorithms and demonstrates the importance of HLS by comparing performance-per-watt of GPUs(NVIDIA) and FPGAs(Xilinx) manufactured in the same node running standard OpenCL benchmarks. We conclude that generation of high quality RTL from OpenCL model requires stronger hardware background with respect to the MBD approach, however, the availability of a fast and broad design space exploration ability and portability of the OpenCL code, e.g. to CPUs and GPUs, motivates FPGA industry leaders to provide users with OpenCL software development environment which promises FPGA programming in CPU/GPU-like fashion. Our experiments, through extensive design space exploration(DSE), suggest that FPGAs have higher performance-per-watt with respect to two high-end GPUs manufactured in the same technology(28 nm). Moreover, FPGAs with more available resources and using a more modern process (20 nm) can outperform the tested GPUs while consuming much less power at the cost of more expensive devices

Exploring heterogeneous scheduling for edge computing with CPU and FPGA MPSoCs

This paper presents a framework targeted to low-cost and low-power heterogeneous MultiProcessors that exploits FPGAs and multicore CPUs, with the overarching goal of providing developers with a productive programming model and runtime support to fully use all the processing resources available. FPGA productivity is achieved using a high-level programming model based on OpenCL, the standard for cross-platform parallel heterogeneous programming. In this work, we focus on the parallel for pattern, and as part of the runtime support for this pattern, we leverage a new scheduler that strives to maximize the number of iterations per joule by dynamically and adaptively partitioning the iteration space between the multicore and the accelerator when working simultaneously. A total of 7 benchmarks are ported and optimized for a low-cost DE1 board. The results show that the heterogeneous solution can improve performance up to 2.9x and increases energy efficiency up to 2.7x compared tothe traditional approach of keeping all the CPU cores idle while the accelerator computes the workload. Our results also demonstrate two interesting insights: First, an adaptive scheduler able to find at runtime the right chunk size for each type of application and device configuration is an essential component for these kinds of heterogeneous platforms, and second, device configurations that provide higher throughput do not always achieve better energy eciency when only the running power (excluding the idle power component) is considered

From Parallel Programs to Customized Parallel Processors

The need for fast time to market of new embedded processor-based designs calls for a rapid design methodology of the included processors. The call for such a methodology is even more emphasized in the context of so called soft cores targeted to reconfigurable fabrics where per-design processor customization is commonplace. The C language has been commonly used as an input to hardware/software co-design flows. However, as C is a sequential language, its potential to generate parallel operations to utilize naturally parallel hardware constructs is far from optimal, leading to a customized processor design space with limited parallel resource scalability. In contrast, when utilizing a parallel programming language as an input, a wider processor design space can be explored to produce customized processors with varying degrees of utilized parallelism. This Thesis proposes a novel Multicore Application-Specific Instruction Set Processor (MCASIP) co-design methodology that exploits parallel programming languages as the application input format. In the methodology, the designer can explicitly capture the parallelism of the algorithm and exploit specialized instructions using a parallel programming language in contrast to being on the mercy of the compiler or the hardware to extract the parallelism from a sequential input. The Thesis proposes a multicore processor template based on the Transport Triggered Architecture, compiler techniques involved in static parallelization of computation kernels with barriers and a datapath integrated hardware accelerator for low overhead software synchronization implementation. These contributions enable scaling the customized processors both at the instruction and task levels to efficiently exploit the parallelism in the input program up to the implementation constraints such as the memory bandwidth or the chip area. The different contributions are validated with case studies, comparisons and design examples

Reconfigurable Computing Systems for Robotics using a Component-Oriented Approach

Robotic platforms are becoming more complex due to the wide range of modern applications, including multiple heterogeneous sensors and actuators. In order to comply with real-time and power-consumption constraints, these systems need to process a large amount of heterogeneous data from multiple sensors and take action (via actuators), which represents a problem as the resources of these systems have limitations in memory storage, bandwidth, and computational power. Field Programmable Gate Arrays (FPGAs) are programmable logic devices that offer high-speed parallel processing. FPGAs are particularly well-suited for applications that require real-time processing, high bandwidth, and low latency. One of the fundamental advantages of FPGAs is their flexibility in designing hardware tailored to specific needs, making them adaptable to a wide range of applications. They can be programmed to pre-process data close to sensors, which reduces the amount of data that needs to be transferred to other computing resources, improving overall system efficiency. Additionally, the reprogrammability of FPGAs enables them to be repurposed for different applications, providing a cost-effective solution that needs to adapt quickly to changing demands. FPGAs' performance per watt is close to that of Application-Specific Integrated Circuits (ASICs), with the added advantage of being reprogrammable. Despite all the advantages of FPGAs (e.g., energy efficiency, computing capabilities), the robotics community has not fully included them so far as part of their systems for several reasons. First, designing FPGA-based solutions requires hardware knowledge and longer development times as their programmability is more challenging than Central Processing Units (CPUs) or Graphics Processing Units (GPUs). Second, porting a robotics application (or parts of it) from software to an accelerator requires adequate interfaces between software and FPGAs. Third, the robotics workflow is already complex on its own, combining several fields such as mechanics, electronics, and software. There have been partial contributions in the state-of-the-art for FPGAs as part of robotics systems. However, a study of FPGAs as a whole for robotics systems is missing in the literature, which is the primary goal of this dissertation. Three main objectives have been established to accomplish this. (1) Define all components required for an FPGAs-based system for robotics applications as a whole. (2) Establish how all the defined components are related. (3) With the help of Model-Driven Engineering (MDE) techniques, generate these components, deploy them, and integrate them into existing solutions. The component-oriented approach proposed in this dissertation provides a proper solution for designing and implementing FPGA-based designs for robotics applications. The modular architecture, the tool 'FPGA Interfaces for Robotics Middlewares' (FIRM), and the toolchain 'FPGA Architectures for Robotics' (FAR) provide a set of tools and a comprehensive design process that enables the development of complex FPGA-based designs more straightforwardly and efficiently. The component-oriented approach contributed to the state-of-the-art in FPGA-based designs significantly for robotics applications and helps to promote their wider adoption and use by specialists with little FPGA knowledge

Optimal program variant generation for hybrid manycore systems

Field Programmable Gate Arrays promise to deliver superior energy efficiency in heterogeneous high performance computing, as compared to multicore CPUs and GPUs. The rate of adoption is however hampered by the relative difficulty of programming FPGAs. High-level synthesis tools such as Xilinx Vivado, Altera OpenCL or Intel's HLS address a large part of the programmability issue by synthesizing a Hardware Description Languages representation from a high-level specification of the application, given in programming languages such as OpenCL C, typically used to program CPUs and GPUs. Although HLS solutions make programming easier, they fail to also lighten the burden of optimization. Application developers must rely on expert knowledge to manually optimize their applications for each target device, meaning that traditional HLS solutions do not offer a solution to the issue of performance portability. This state of fact prompted the development of compiler frameworks such as TyTra that operate at an even higher level of abstraction that is amenable to the use of Design Space Exploration (DSE). With DSE the initial program specification can be seen as the starting location in a search-space of correct-by-construction program transformations. In TyTra the search-space is generated from the transitive-closure of term-level transformations derived from type-level transformations. Compiler frameworks such as TyTra theoretically solve the issue of performance portability by providing a way to automatically generate alternative correct program variants. They however suffer from the very practical issue that the generated space is often too large to fully explore. As a consequence, the globally optimal solution may be overlooked. In this work we provide a novel solution to issue performance portability by deriving an efficient yet effective DSE strategy for the TyTra compiler framework. We make use of categorical data types to derive categorical semantics for the formal languages that describe the terms, types, cost-performance estimates and their transformations. From these we define a category of interpretations for TyTra applications, from which we derive a DSE strategy that finds the globally optimal transformation sequence in polynomial time. This is achieved by reducing the size of the generated search space. We formally state and prove a theorem for this claim and then show that the polynomial run-time for our DSE strategy has practically negligible coefficients leading to sub-second exploration times for realistic applications

Performance engineering of data-intensive applications

Data-intensive programs deal with big chunks of data and often contain compute-intensive characteristics. Among various HPC application domains, big data analytics, machine learning and the more recent deep-learning models are well-known data-intensive applications. An efficient design of such applications demands extensive knowledge of the target hardware and software, particularly the memory/cache hierarchy and the data communication among threads/processes. Such a requirement makes code development an arduous task, as inappropriate data structures and algorithm design may result in superfluous runtime, let alone hardware incompatibilities while porting the code to other platforms. In this dissertation, we introduce a set of tools and methods for the performance engineering of parallel data-intensive programs. We start with performance profiling to gain insights on thread communications and relevant code optimizations. Then, by narrowing down our scope to deep-learning applications, we introduce our tools for enhancing the performance portability and scalability of convolutional neural networks (ConvNet) at inference and training phases. Our first contribution is a novel performance-profiling method to unveil potential communication bottlenecks caused by data-access patterns and thread interactions. Our findings show that the data shared between a pair of threads should be reused with a reasonably short intervals to preserve data locality, yet existing profilers neglect them and mainly report the communication volume. We propose new hardware-independent metrics to characterize thread communication and provide suggestions for applying appropriate optimizations on a specific code region. Our experiments show that applying relevant optimizations improves the performance in Rodinia benchmarks by up to 56%. For the next contribution, we developed a framework for automatic generation of efficient and performance-portable convolution kernels, including Winograd convolutions, for various GPU platforms. We employed a synergy of meta-programming, symbolic execution, and auto-tuning. The results demonstrate efficient kernels generated through an automated optimization pipeline with runtimes close to vendor deep-learning libraries, and the minimum required programming effort confirms the performance portability of our approach. Furthermore, our symbolic execution method exploits repetitive patterns in Winograd convolutions, enabling us to reduce the number of arithmetic operations by up to 62% without compromising the numerical stability. Lastly, we investigate possible methods to scale the performance of ConvNets in training and inference phases. Our specialized training platform equipped with a novel topology-aware network pruning algorithm enables rapid training, neural architecture search, and network compression. Thus, an AI model training can be easily scaled to a multitude of compute nodes, leading to faster model design with less operating costs. Furthermore, the network compression component scales a ConvNet model down by removing redundant layers, preparing the model for a more pertinent deployment. Altogether, this work demonstrates the necessity and shows the benefit of performance engineering and parallel programming methods in accelerating emerging data-intensive workloads. With the help of the proposed tools and techniques, we pinpoint data communication bottlenecks and achieve performance portability and scalability in data-intensive applications