Internet Congestion Control: Modeling and Stability Analysis

The proliferation and universal adoption of the Internet has made it become the key information transport platform of our time. Congestion occurs when resource demands exceed the capacity, which results in poor performance in the form of low network utilization and high packet loss rate. The goal of congestion control mechanisms is to use the network resources as efficiently as possible. The research work in this thesis is centered on finding ways to address these types of problems and provide guidelines for predicting and controlling network performance, through the use of suitable mathematical tools and control analysis. The first congestion collapse in the Internet was observed in 1980's. To solve the problem, Van Jacobson proposed the Transmission Control Protocol (TCP) congestion control algorithm based on the Additive Increase and Multiplicative Decrease (AIMD) mechanism in 1988. To be effective, a congestion control mechanism must be paired with a congestion detection scheme. To detect and distribute network congestion indicators fairly to all on-going flows, Active Queue Management (AQM), e.g., the Random Early Detection (RED) queue management scheme has been developed to be deployed in the intermediate nodes. The currently dominant AIMD congestion control, coupled with the RED queue in the core network, has been acknowledged as one of the key factors to the overwhelming success of the Internet. In this thesis, the AIMD/RED system, based on the fluid-flow model, is systematically studied. In particular, we concentrate on the system modeling, stability analysis and bounds estimates. We first focus on the stability and fairness analysis of the AIMD/RED system with a single bottleneck. Then, we derive the theoretical estimates for the upper and lower bounds of homogeneous and heterogeneous AIMD/RED systems with feedback delays and further discuss the system performance when it is not asymptotically stable. Last, we develop a general model for a class of multiple-bottleneck networks and discuss the stability properties of such a system. Theoretical and simulation results presented in this thesis provide insights for in-depth understanding of AIME/RED system and help predict and control the system performance for the Internet with higher data rate links multiplexed with heterogeneous flows

Queues with Congestion-dependent Feedback

This dissertation expands the theory of feedback queueing systems and applies a number of these models to a performance analysis of the Transmission Control Protocol, a flow control protocol commonly used in the Internet

Trade-offs in rate control with communication delay

We adopt the optimization framework for rate allocation problem proposed by Kelly and characterize the stability condition with an arbitrary communication delay in the case of single resource. We demonstrate the existence of a fundamental trade-off between users price elasticity of demand and the responsiveness of resource through a choice of price function as well as between system stability and resource utilization. We investigate the effects of non-responsive traffic on system stability and show that the presence of non-responsive traffic enhances the stability of system. We also investigate the system behavior after the system loses its stability

Network flow optimization and distributed control algorithms

This thesis concerns the problem of designing distributed algorithms for achieving efficient and fair bandwidth allocations in a resource constrained network. This problem is fundamental to the design of transmission protocols for communication networks, since the fluid models of popular protocols such as TCP and Proportional Fair Controller can be viewed as distributed algorithms which solve the network flow optimization problems corresponding to some fairness criteria. Because of the convexity of the optimization problem as well as its decoupling structure, there exist classical dual algorithm and primal/dual algorithm which are both distributed. However, the main difficulty is the possible instability of the dynamics of these algorithms caused by transmission delays. We use customized Lyapunov-Krasovskii functionals to obtain the stability conditions for these algorithms in networks with heterogeneous time-varying delays. There are two main features of our results. The first is that these stability conditions can be enforced by a small amount of information exchange among relevant users and links. The second is that these stability conditions only depend on the upper bound of delays, not on the rate of delay variations. We further our discussion on scalable algorithms with minimum information to maintain stability. We present a design methodology for such algorithms and prove the global stability of our scalable controllers by the use of Zames-Falb multipliers. Next we extend this method to design the first scalable and globally stable algorithm for the joint multipath routing and flow optimization problem. We achieve this by adding additional delays to different paths for all users. Lastly we discuss the joint single path routing and flow optimization problem, which is a NP hard problem. We show bounded price of anarchy for combined flow and routing game for simple networks and show for many-user networks, simple Nash algorithm leads to approximate optimum of the problem

Traffic and resource management in content-centric networks (design and evaluation)

Dans les dernières années, l utilisation d Internet a sensiblement changé en passant d un modèle de communication centré sur les machines á un centré sur les contenus. La plus part de services utilisés par les clients d Internet aujourd hui sont déjà centré sur les contenus même et pas sur leurs emplacement. Dans ce contexte, beaucoup de projets de recherche proposent un changement de l architecture de l Internet, en mettent des contenu identifié par leur nom au centre du réseau. Ce group de proposition est identifiés sous le nom de Information Centric Networking (ICN). Cette thèse se focalise sur la proposition Content-Centric Network (CCN). Dans une premier temps, nous analysons les performance du modèle de communication CCN en se concentrent sur le partage de la bande passante et de la mémoire et en proposant des formules pour la caractérisation du temps de transfert. Deuxièmement, nous proposons un protocole de contrôle de congestion et des mécanismes de forwarding pour CCN. En particulier on présent un premier mécanisme de contrôle de congestion, Interest Control Protocol (ICP), qui utilise une fenêtre contrôlé avec le mécanisme Additive Increase Multiplicative Decrease au récepteur. En complément avec ça, nous présentons un mécanisme distribué (hop-by-hop) pour obtenir une détection/réaction à la congestion plus rapide. Nous proposons aussi une modification d'ICP en implémentant le mécanisme Remote Adaptive Active Queue Management pour exploiter efficacement le multi-chemin. En fin, nous présentons un mécanisme de forwarding distribué qui base ses décisions sur des mesure de qualité d interface par chaque préfixe disponible dans les tableaux de routage.The advent of the World Wide Web has radically changed Internet usage from host-to-host to service access and data retrieval. The majority of services used by Internet s clients are content-centric (e.g. web). However, the original Internet revolves around host-to-host communication for which it was conceived. Even if Internet has been able to address the challenges offered by new applications, there is an evident mismatch between the architecture and its current usage. Many projects in national research agencies propose to redesign the Internet architecture around named data. Such research efforts are identified under the name of Information Centric Networking. This thesis focuses on the Content-Centric Networking (CCN) proposition. We first analyze the CCN communication model with particular focus on the bandwidth and storage sharing performance, We compute closed formulas for data delivery time, that we use in the second part of the thesis as guideline for network protocol design. Second, we propose some CCN congestion control and forwarding mechanisms. We present a first window based receiver driven flow control protocol, Interest Control Protocol (ICP). We also introduce a hop-by-hop congestion control mechanism to obtain early congestion detection and reaction. We then extend the original ICP congestion control protocol implementing a Remote Adaptive Active Queue Management mechanism in order to efficiently exploit heterogeneous (joint/disjoint) network paths. Finally, we introduce a distributed forwarding mechanism that bases its decisions on per prefix and per interface quality measurement without impacting the system scalability.PARIS-Télécom ParisTech (751132302) / SudocSudocFranceF

DYNAMICS OF RANDOM EARLY DETECTION GATEWAY UNDER A LARGE NUMBER OF TCP FLOWS

While active queue management (AQM) mechanisms such as Random Early Detection (RED) are widely deployed in the Internet, they are rarely utilized or otherwise poorly configured. The problem stems from a lack of a tractable analytical framework which captures the interaction between the TCP congestion-control and AQM mechanisms. Traditional TCP traffic modeling has focused on "micro-scale" modeling of TCP, i.e., detailed modeling of a single TCP flow. While micro-scale models of TCP are suitable for understanding the precise behavior of an individual flow, they are not well suited to the situation where a large number of TCP flows interact with each other as is the case in realistic networks. In this dissertation, an innovative approach to TCP traffic modeling is proposed by considering the regime where the number of TCP flows competing for the bandwidth in the bottleneck RED gateway is large. In the limit, the queue size and the aggregate TCP traffic can be approximated by simple recursions which are independent of the number of flows. The limiting model is therefore scalable as it does not suffer from the state space explosion. The steady-state queue length and window distribution can be evaluated from well-known TCP models. We also extend the analysis to a more realistic model which incorporates session-level dynamics and heterogeneous round-trip delays. Typically, ad-hoc assumptions are required to make the analysis for models with session-level dynamics tractable under a certain regime. In contrast, our limiting model derived here is compatible with other previously proposed models in their respective regime without having to rely on ad-hoc assumptions. The contributions from these additional layers of dynamics to the asymptotic queue are now crisply revealed through the limit theorems. Under mild assumptions, we show that the steady-state queue size depends on the file size and round-trip delay only through their mean values. We obtain more accurate description of the queue dynamics by means of a Central Limit analysis which identifies an interesting relationship between the queue fluctuations and the random packet marking mechanism in AQM. The analysis also reveals the dependency of the magnitude of the queue fluctuations on the variability of the file size and round-trip delay. Simulation results supporting conclusions drawn from the limit theorems are also presented

On a Multiprocessor Computer Farm for Online Physics Data Processing

The topic of this thesis is the design-phase performance evaluation of a large multiprocessor (MP) computer farm intended for the on-line data processing of the Compact Muon Solenoid (CMS) experiment. CMS is a high energy Physics experiment, planned to operate at CERN (Geneva, Switzerland) during the year 2005. The CMS computer farm is consisting of 1,000 MP computer systems and a 1,000 X 1,000 communications switch. The followed approach to the farm performance evaluation is through simulation studies and evaluation of small prototype systems building blocks of the farm. For the purposes of the simulation studies, we have developed a discrete-event, event-driven simulator that is capable to describe the high-level architecture of the farm and give estimates of the farm's performance. The simulator is designed in a modular way to facilitate the development of various modules that model the behavior of the farm building blocks in the desired level of detail. With the aid of this simulator, we make a particular study on the scheduling of the nodes of the farm, showing that a preemptive scheduling can increase farm's throughput. We have developed a prototype setup of a farm node an event filter unit. The setup consists of a high performance MP system (the farm node) connected to a second computer system (used to emulate the data sources) through an ATM network. The performance issues of interfacing a network interface controller (NIC) to the application running in the farm node, are explored. It is shown with the aid of this setup, that the switch-to-farm interface (SFI) a device used to put together the incoming data fragments into a single entity can be entirely avoided by emulating its function in software. We show that in order to meet the required event assembly performance in the filter node inputs, the development effort has to concentrate on the NIC hardware, software and its interface to the application, rather than building a custom designed device specialized to perform the task of event assembly. Finally, the farm scaling issues are investigated. Our aim is to obtain an "operational region" inside the farm configuration space, when the various networking speeds are taken into account. Analytically obtained results that have been confirmed with the above mentioned simulator, are discussed. We present also results showing the influence 8 of the inherent to the farm parameters (like the algorithm rejection factor) on the requirements for the farm building blocks (sustained I/O bandwidth) of the inherent to the farm parameters (like the algorithm rejection factor) on the requirements for the farm building blocks (sustained I/O bandwidth)