Wireless Technologies for IoT in Smart Cities

[EN] As cities continue to grow, numerous initiatives for Smart Cities are being conducted. The concept of Smart City encompasses several concepts being governance, economy, management, infrastructure, technology and people. This means that a Smart City can have different communication needs. Wireless technologies such as WiFi, ZigBee, Bluetooth, WiMax, 4G or LTE (Long Term Evolution) have presented themselves as solutions to the communication needs of Smart City initiatives. However, as most of them employ unlicensed bands, interference and coexistence problems are increasing. In this paper, the wireless technologies available nowadays for IoT (Internet of Things) in Smart Cities are presented. Our contribution is a review of wireless technologies, their comparison and the problems that difficult coexistence among them. In order to do so, the characteristics and adequacy of wireless technologies to each domain are considered. The problems derived of over-crowded unlicensed spectrum and coexistence difficulties among each technology are discussed as well. Finally, power consumption concerns are addressed.García-García, L.; Jimenez, JM.; Abdullah, MTA.; Lloret, J. (2018). Wireless Technologies for IoT in Smart Cities. Network Protocols and Algorithms. 10(1):23-64. doi:10.5296/npa.v10i1.12798S236410

Practical Extensions to the Evaluation and Analysis of Wireless Coexistence in Unlicensed Bands

Sharing spectrum resources in unlicensed bands has proven cost effective and beneficial for providing ubiquitous access to wireless functionality for a broad range of applications. Chipsets designed to implement communication standards in the Industrial, Scientific and Medical (ISM) band have become increasingly inexpensive and widely available, making wireless-enabled medical and non-medical devices attractive to an increased number of users. Consequently, wireless coexistence becomes a concern. In response, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has issued a guidance document to assist medical device manufacturers ensure reasonable safety and effectiveness. Coexistence-testing methods are now being reported in literature, and novel solutions are under consideration for inclusion in the American National Standards Institute (ANSI) C63.27 Standard for Evaluation of Wireless Coexistence. This dissertation addresses practical issues for evaluating and reporting wireless coexistence. During testing, an under-test-system (UTS) is evaluated in the presence of an interfering system (IS). Accordingly, an innovative method is suggested for estimating channel utilization of multiple, concurrent wireless transmitters sharing an unlicensed band in the context of radiated open environment coexistence testing (ROECT). Passively received power measurements were collected, and then a Gaussian mixture model (GMM) was used to build a classifier for labeling observed power samples relative to their source. Overall accuracy was verified at 98.86%. Case studies are presented utilizing IEEE 802.11n as an IS with UTS based on either IEEE 802.11n or ZigBee. Results demonstrated the mutual effect of spectrum sharing on both IS and UTS in terms of per-second channel utilization and frame collision. The process of approximating the probability of a device to coexist in its intended environment is discussed, and a generalized framework for modeling the environment is presented. An 84-day spectrum survey of the 2.4 GHz to 2.48 GHz ISM band in a hospital environment serves as proof of concept. A custom platform was used to monitor power flux spectral density and record received power in both an intensive care unit (ICU) and a post-surgery recovery room (RR). Observations indicated that significant correlation in activity patterns corresponded mainly to IEEE 802.11 channels 1, 6, and 11. Consequently, channel utilization of three non-overlapping channels of 20 MHz bandwidth---relative to IEEE 802.11 channels 1, 6, and 11---were calculated and fitted to a generalized extreme value (GEV) distribution. Low channel utilization ( 50%), was observed in the surveyed environment. Reported findings can be complementary to wireless coexistence testing. Quantifying the probability of UTS coexistence in a given environment is central to the evaluation of coexistence, as evidenced in the draft of the C63.27 standard. Notably, a method for this calculation is not currently provided in the standard. To fill this void, the work presented herein proposes the use of logistic regression (LR) to estimate coexistence probability. ROECT was utilized to test a scenario with an 802.11n IS and ZigBee UTS medical device. Findings demonstrate that fitted LR model achieves 92.72% overall accuracy of classification on a testing dataset that included the outcome of a wide variety of coexistence testing scenarios. Results were incorporated with those reported in [1] using Monte Carlo simulation to estimate UTS probability of coexistence in a hospital environment

Towards Efficient and Enhanced Wireless Coexistence in the Unlicensed Spectrum

The 3rd Generation Partnership Project (3GPP) is developing the fifth generation (5G) of wireless broadband technology and has identified the unlicensed spectrum as a principal item on the plan of action. Listen-Before-Talk (LBT) has been recognized as the starting development point for the channel access scheme of future 5G New Radio-Unlicensed (NR-U) networks. Recent technical reports suggest that all sub-7 GHz unlicensed spectrum is targeted for 5G NR-U operation, including the 2.4 GHz Industrial, Scientific, and Medical (ISM) band. Literature is inundated with research on Wi-Fi and LBT-based long-term evolution License-Assisted Access (LTE-LAA) wireless coexistence analysis. While a treasure trove of radio spectrum has been approved for license-exempt use in the 6 GHz band, industry and standard organizations must make sure it is well utilized by enhancing their coexistence schemes. A proper assessment of the homogeneous LBT deployment is imperative under the new use cases and regulatory circumstances. The work presented herein aimed to fill the gap and underline the importance of improving channel access mechanisms in next-generation wireless systems. The research in this dissertation first analyzed the LBT channel access scheme and analytically evaluated its performance in terms of a metrics set, such as effective channel utilization, collision probability, mean access delay, and temporal fairness among coexisting nodes. Outcomes of the developed analytical model revealed inefficiencies in various cases. For example, high priority classes generally hinder overall effective channel utilization, exhibit a high collision rate, and incur long latencies compared to lower priorities; and low priority classes sustain longer delays in class-heterogeneous scenarios. The developed framework was then utilized to investigate wireless coexistence in a 5G-enabled intensive care unit, employing remote patient monitoring over 5G NR-U. A modified LBT scheme is then proposed in this work to enhance overall channel efficiency in homogeneous LBT deployments by reducing the collision probability among coexisting stations based on the analytical investigation of the LBT mechanism. It is expected that low-power, narrowband frequency hoppers will be allowed to operate in the 6 GHz spectrum based on recent European Communications Committee (ECC) mandates, which raises speculation around coexistence with incumbent radio access technologies (RATs). To address the potential operation of cellular LBT in the 2.4 GHz and frequency hopping systems in the 5- and 6-GHz bands, the coexistence of Bluetooth Low Energy (BLE) 5 and LBT was investigated empirically in an anechoic chamber. The mutual impact was explored by means of throughput, packet error rate, and interframe delays. Empirical evaluation results demonstrated how BLE throughput dropped as the intended-to-unintended signal ratio decreased and the way in which LBT classes exhibited a diminishing effect as the class priority descended. Long Range BLE physical layer (PHY) was found to sustain longer gap times (i.e., delay) than the other two PHYs; however, the LR PHY showed less susceptibility to interference. Results also demonstrated that low data rate BLE PHYs hindered LBT throughput performance since they correspond to longer airtime durations

Performance measurements of Bluetooth 5 technique under interference

Abstract. This thesis focuses on experimental performance of the Bluetooth 5 technology and compares results with the previous version. Bluetooth technology, institute of electrical and electronics engineers (IEEE) Std. 802.15.4, and other techniques share the same unlicensed 2.4 GHz industrial, scientific, and medical (ISM) spectrum. Various technologies are operating in the same frequency band, and if the channel utilized by these technologies overlap, end in cross-technology interference (CTI). Measurements have been performed in indoor scenario and ZigBee nodes were used as an interference. Performance output of the Bluetooth 5 is compared to a previous release Bluetooth low energy (BLE) 4 which is currently one of the popular technologies in commercial wireless devices and expected to be even more widespread in the future. This new Bluetooth technology has featured increased data rate, low power consumption, longer range, higher broadcasting capacity, and improved coexistence with other wireless technologies operating in the same frequency band. The main goal of this work was to evaluate the experimental communication range and throughput of the BLE 5 coded version under interference. Nordic Semiconductor nRF52840 chipset has been used for measurements and result shows the practical communication range and throughput of BLE 5 coded version under interference. In this work, with error correction coding, one-third BLE link gain was achieved when considering packet error rate (PER) less than 10%. In addition, ZigBee interference was found to be very harmful for the Bluetooth communication when operating in the same frequency band

Wireless industrial monitoring and control networks: the journey so far and the road ahead

While traditional wired communication technologies have played a crucial role in industrial monitoring and control networks over the past few decades, they are increasingly proving to be inadequate to meet the highly dynamic and stringent demands of today’s industrial applications, primarily due to the very rigid nature of wired infrastructures. Wireless technology, however, through its increased pervasiveness, has the potential to revolutionize the industry, not only by mitigating the problems faced by wired solutions, but also by introducing a completely new class of applications. While present day wireless technologies made some preliminary inroads in the monitoring domain, they still have severe limitations especially when real-time, reliable distributed control operations are concerned. This article provides the reader with an overview of existing wireless technologies commonly used in the monitoring and control industry. It highlights the pros and cons of each technology and assesses the degree to which each technology is able to meet the stringent demands of industrial monitoring and control networks. Additionally, it summarizes mechanisms proposed by academia, especially serving critical applications by addressing the real-time and reliability requirements of industrial process automation. The article also describes certain key research problems from the physical layer communication for sensor networks and the wireless networking perspective that have yet to be addressed to allow the successful use of wireless technologies in industrial monitoring and control networks

A critical analysis of research potential, challenges and future directives in industrial wireless sensor networks

In recent years, Industrial Wireless Sensor Networks (IWSNs) have emerged as an important research theme with applications spanning a wide range of industries including automation, monitoring, process control, feedback systems and automotive. Wide scope of IWSNs applications ranging from small production units, large oil and gas industries to nuclear fission control, enables a fast-paced research in this field. Though IWSNs offer advantages of low cost, flexibility, scalability, self-healing, easy deployment and reformation, yet they pose certain limitations on available potential and introduce challenges on multiple fronts due to their susceptibility to highly complex and uncertain industrial environments. In this paper a detailed discussion on design objectives, challenges and solutions, for IWSNs, are presented. A careful evaluation of industrial systems, deadlines and possible hazards in industrial atmosphere are discussed. The paper also presents a thorough review of the existing standards and industrial protocols and gives a critical evaluation of potential of these standards and protocols along with a detailed discussion on available hardware platforms, specific industrial energy harvesting techniques and their capabilities. The paper lists main service providers for IWSNs solutions and gives insight of future trends and research gaps in the field of IWSNs

IEEE 802.11-Enabled Wake-Up Radio: use cases and applications

IEEE 802.11 is one of the most commonly used radio access technologies, being present in almost all handheld devices with networking capabilities. However, its energy-hungry communication modes are a challenge for the increased battery lifetime of such devices and are an obstacle for its use in battery-constrained devices such as the ones defined by many Internet of Things applications. Wake-up Radio (WuR) systems have appeared as a solution for increasing the energy efficiency of communication technologies by employing a secondary low-power radio interface, which is always in the active state and switches the primary transceiver (used for main data communication) from the energy-saving to the active operation mode. The high market penetration of IEEE 802.11 technology, together with the benefits that WuR systems can bring to this widespread technology, motivates this article’s focus on IEEE 802.11-basedWuR solutions. More specifically, we elaborate on the feasibility of such IEEE 802.11-based WuR solutions, and introduce the latest standardization efforts in this IEEE 802.11-based WuR domain, IEEE 802.11ba, which is a forthcoming IEEE 802.11 amendment, discussing its main features and potential use cases. As a use case consisting of green Wi-Fi application, we provide a proof-of-concept smart plug system implemented by a WuR that is activated remotely using IEEE 802.11 devices, evaluate its monetary and energy savings, and compare it with commercially available smart plug solutions. Finally, we discuss novel applications beyond the wake-up functionality that IEEE 802.11-enabled WuR devices can offer using a secondary radio, as well as applications that have not yet been considered by IEEE 802.11ba. As a result, we argue that the IEEE 802.11-based WuR solution will support a wide range of devices and deployments, for both low-rate and low-power communications, as well as high-rate transmissions.Postprint (author's final draft

Contributions to IEEE 802.11-based long range communications

The most essential part of the Internet of Things (IoT) infrastructure is the wireless communication system that acts as a bridge for the delivery of data and control messages between the connected things and the Internet. Since the conception of the IoT, a large number of promising applications and technologies have been developed, which will change different aspects in our daily life. However, the existing wireless technologies lack the ability to support a huge amount of data exchange from many battery-driven devices, spread over a wide area. In order to support the IoT paradigm, IEEE 802.11ah is an Internet of Things enabling technology, where the efficient management of thousands of devices is a key function. This is one of the most promising and appealing standards, which aims to bridge the gap between traditional mobile networks and the demands of the IoT. To this aim, IEEE 802.11ah provides the Restricted Access Window (RAW) mechanism, which reduces contention by enabling transmissions for small groups of stations. Optimal grouping of RAW stations requires an evaluation of many possible configurations. In this thesis, we first discuss the main PHY and MAC layer amendments proposed for IEEE 802.11ah. Furthermore, we investigate the operability of IEEE 802.11ah as a backhaul link to connect devices over possibly long distances. Additionally, we compare the aforementioned standard with previous notable IEEE 802.11 amendments (i.e. IEEE 802.11n and IEEE 802.11ac) in terms of throughput (with and without frame aggregation) by utilizing the most robust modulation schemes. The results show an improved performance of IEEE 802.11ah (in terms of power received at long range while experiencing different packet error rates) as compared to previous IEEE 802.11 standards. Additionally, we expose the capabilities of future IEEE 802.11ah in supporting different IoT applications. In addition, we provide a brief overview of the technology contenders that are competing to cover the IoT communications framework. Numerical results are presented showing how the future IEEE 802.11ah specification offers the features required by IoT communications, thus putting forward IEEE 802.11ah as a technology to cater the needs of the Internet of Things paradigm. Finally, we propose an analytical model (named e-model) that provides an evaluation of the RAW onfiguration performance, allowing a fast adaptation of RAW grouping policies, in accordance to varying channel conditions. We base the e-model in known saturation models, which we adapted to include the IEEE 802.11ah’s PHY and MAC layer modifications and to support different bit rate and packet sizes. As a proof of concept, we use the proposed model to compare the performance of different grouping strategies,showing that the e-model is a useful analysis tool in RAW-enabled scenarios. We validate the model with existing IEEE 802.11ah implementation for ns-3.La clave del concepto Internet de las cosas (IoT) es que utiliza un sistema de comunicación inalámbrica, el cual actúa como puente para la entrega de datos y mensajes de control entre las "cosas" conectadas y el Internet. Desde la concepción del IoT, se han desarrollado gran cantidad de aplicaciones y tecnologías prometedoras que cambiarán distintos aspectos de nuestra vida diaria.Sin embargo, las tecnologías de redes computacionales inalámbricas existentes carecen de la capacidad de soportar las características del IoT, como las grandes cantidades de envío y recepción de datos desde múltiples dispositivos distribuidos en un área amplia, donde los dispositivos IoT funcionan con baterías. Para respaldar el paradigma del IoT, IEEE 802.11ah, la cual es una tecnología habilitadora del Internet de las cosas, para el cual la gestión eficiente de miles de dispositivos es una función clave. IEEE 802.11ah es uno de los estándares más prometedores y atractivos, desde su concepción orientada para IoT, su objetivo principal es cerrar la brecha entre las redes móviles tradicionales y la demandada por el IoT. Con este objetivo en mente, IEEE 802.11ah incluye entre sus características especificas el mecanismo de ventana de acceso restringido (RAW, por sus siglas en ingles), el cual define un nuevo período de acceso al canal libre de contención, reduciendo la misma al permitir transmisiones para pequeños grupos de estaciones. Nótese que para obtener una agrupación óptima de estaciones RAW, se requiere una evaluación de las distintas configuraciones posibles. En esta tesis, primero discutimos las principales mejoras de las capas PHY y MAC propuestas para IEEE 802.11ah. Además, investigamos la operatividad de IEEE 802.11ah como enlace de backhaul para conectar dispositivos a distancias largas. También, comparamos el estándar antes mencionado con las notables especificaciones IEEE 802.11 anteriores (es decir, IEEE 802.11n y IEEE 802.11ac), en términos de rendimiento (incluyendo y excluyendo la agregación de tramas de datos) y utilizando los esquemas de modulación más robustos. Los resultados muestran mejores resultados en cuanto al rendimiento de IEEE 802.11ah (en términos de potencia recibida a largo alcance, mientras se experimentan diferentes tasas de error de paquetes de datos) en comparación con los estándares IEEE 802.11 anteriores.Además, exponemos las capacidades de IEEE 802.11ah para admitir diferentes aplicaciones de IoT. A su vez, proporcionamos una descripción general de los competidores tecnológicos, los cuales contienden para cubrir el marco de comunicaciones IoT. También se presentan resultados numéricos que muestran cómo la especificación IEEE 802.11ah ofrece las características requeridas por las comunicaciones IoT, presentando así a IEEE 802.11ah como una tecnología que puede satisfacer las necesidades del paradigma de Internet de las cosas.Finalmente, proponemos un modelo analítico (denominado e-model) que proporciona una evaluación del rendimiento utilizando la característica RAW con múltiples configuraciones, el cual permite una rápida adaptación de las políticas de agrupación RAW, de acuerdo con las diferentes condiciones del canal de comunicación. Basamos el e-model en modelos de saturación conocidos, que adaptamos para incluir las modificaciones de la capa MAC y PHY de IEEE 802.11ah y para poder admitir diferentes velocidades de transmisión de datos y tamaños de paquetes. Como prueba de concepto, utilizamos el modelo propuesto para comparar el desempeño de diferentes estrategias de agrupación, mostrando que el e-model es una herramienta de análisis útil en escenarios habilitados para RAW. Cabe mencionar que también validamos el modelo con la implementación IEEE 802.11ah existente para ns-3

Wireless Sensor Technology Selection for I4.0 Manufacturing Systems

The term smart manufacturing has surfaced as an industrial revolution in Germany known as Industry 4.0 (I4.0); this revolution aims to help the manufacturers adapt to turbulent market trends. Its main scope is implementing machine communication, both vertically and horizontally across the manufacturing hierarchy through Internet of things (IoT), technologies and servitization concepts. The main objective of this research is to help manufacturers manage the high levels of variety and the extreme turbulence of market trends through developing a selection tool that utilizes Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) techniques to recommend a suitable industrial wireless sensor network (IWSN) technology that fits their manufacturing requirements.In this thesis, IWSN technologies and their properties were identified, analyzed and compared to identify their potential suitability for different industrial manufacturing system application areas. The study included the identification and analysis of different industrial system types, their application areas, scenarios and respective communication requirements. The developed tool’s sensitivity is also tested to recommend different IWSN technology options with changing influential factors. Also, a prioritizing protocol is introduced in the case where more than one IWSN technology options are recommended by the AHP tool.A real industrial case study with the collaboration of SPM Automation Inc. is presented, where the industrial systems’ class, communication traffic types, and communication requirements were analyzed to recommend a suitable IWSN technology that fits their requirements and assists their shift towards I4.0 through utilizing AHP techniques. The results of this research will serve as a step forward, in the transformation process of manufacturing towards a more digitalized and better connected cyber-physical systems; thus, enhancing manufacturing attributes such as flexibility, reconfigurability, scalability and easing the shift towards implementing I4.0

Spectrum-efficient Architecture for Cognitive Wireless Sensor Networks

Projecte realitzat en col.laboració amb el centre Université Libre de BruxellesHoy en día existe la creencia de que en unos pocos años las actuales Redes Inalámbricas de Sensores estarán presentes en muchas aplicaciones. Mientras estas sigan actuando en la banda sin licencia de ISM 2,4GHz, tendrán que coexistir con otras exitosas tecnologías como Wi-Fi o Bluetooth. En consecuencia, resulta obvio asegurar que la banda en cuestión estará superpoblada en un futuro próximo. Sin embargo y gracias a las nuevas técnicas de Radio Cognitiva, que permitirán la aplicación de un eficiente Acceso al Espectro Dinámico, se conseguirá una distribución racional, dentro del espectro disponible en ese momento y lugar, de las comunicaciones inalámbricas que se estén llevando a cabo. Esta actuación permitirá acceder a frecuencias menos pobladas para poder transmitir con menos interferencias e incluso con menos pérdidas de propagación. A lo largo de este trabajo se va a presentar una arquitectura eficiente, espectralmente hablando, para Redes Inalámbricas de Sensores y Cognitivas. Este esquema desarrolla un protocolo de recolección de datos, para una red con topología de árbol, totalmente escalable y con finalidades genéricas. A través de las pruebas realizadas, podemos afirmar que nuestro esquema, sin alterar el ciclo normal de recolección de datos, puede detectar la presencia de otras Redes Inalámbricas de Sensores y, consecuentemente, migrar la red a nueva frecuencia mientras que todas estas operaciones están ocultas al usuario final. También es eficiente a nivel de energía, ya que no se realizan comprobaciones redundantes de la presencia de otras redes. De esta manera, nuestra propuesta asegura un mejor comportamiento en caso de la existencia de una Red Inalámbrica de Sensores externa, sin realizar operaciones complicadas ni añadiendo más tráfico a la red