Improving the Performance of the Bilevel Solution for the Continuous Network Design Problem

For a long time, many researchers have investigated the continuous network design problem (CNDP) to distribute equitably additional capacity between selected links in a road network, to overcome traffic congestion in urban roads. In addition, CNDP plays a critical role for local authorities in tackling traffic congestion with a limited budget. Due to the mutual interaction between road users and local authorities, CNDP is usually solved using the bilevel modeling technique. The upper level seeks to find the optimal capacity enhancements of selected links, while the lower level is used to solve the traffic assignment problem. In this study, we introduced the enhanced differential evolution algorithm based on multiple improvement strategies (EDEMIS) for solving CNDP. We applied EDEMIS first to a hypothetical network to show its ability in finding the global optimum solution, at least in a small network. Then, we used a 16-link network to reveal the capability of EDEMIS especially in the case of high demand. Finally, we used the Sioux Falls city network to evaluate the performance of EDEMIS according to other solution methods on a medium-sized road network. The results showed that EDEMIS produces better solutions than other considered algorithms, encouraging transportation planners to use it in large-scale road networks.</p

The Network Improvement Problem for Equilibrium Routing

In routing games, agents pick their routes through a network to minimize their own delay. A primary concern for the network designer in routing games is the average agent delay at equilibrium. A number of methods to control this average delay have received substantial attention, including network tolls, Stackelberg routing, and edge removal. A related approach with arguably greater practical relevance is that of making investments in improvements to the edges of the network, so that, for a given investment budget, the average delay at equilibrium in the improved network is minimized. This problem has received considerable attention in the literature on transportation research and a number of different algorithms have been studied. To our knowledge, none of this work gives guarantees on the output quality of any polynomial-time algorithm. We study a model for this problem introduced in transportation research literature, and present both hardness results and algorithms that obtain nearly optimal performance guarantees. - We first show that a simple algorithm obtains good approximation guarantees for the problem. Despite its simplicity, we show that for affine delays the approximation ratio of 4/3 obtained by the algorithm cannot be improved. - To obtain better results, we then consider restricted topologies. For graphs consisting of parallel paths with affine delay functions we give an optimal algorithm. However, for graphs that consist of a series of parallel links, we show the problem is weakly NP-hard. - Finally, we consider the problem in series-parallel graphs, and give an FPTAS for this case. Our work thus formalizes the intuition held by transportation researchers that the network improvement problem is hard, and presents topology-dependent algorithms that have provably tight approximation guarantees.Comment: 27 pages (including abstract), 3 figure

A Bilevel Approach to Frequency Optimization in Public Transportation Systems

We consider the problem of frequency optimization in transit systems, whose objective is to determine the time interval between subsequent buses for a set of public transportation lines. We extend an existing single level model by adding a constraint on bus capacities, while maintaining user choice on routes by means of an assignment sub-model. The resulting formulation is bilevel, and is transformed into a mixed integer linear programming formulation (MILP) that can be solved to optimality for small-sized problem instances, using standard MILP techniques. We study different variants of the same formulation to better understand the bilevel nature of the model and its application to real settings

A Machine Learning Approach to Solving Large Bilevel and Stochastic Programs: Application to Cycling Network Design

We present a novel machine learning-based approach to solving bilevel programs that involve a large number of independent followers, which as a special case include two-stage stochastic programming. We propose an optimization model that explicitly considers a sampled subset of followers and exploits a machine learning model to estimate the objective values of unsampled followers. Unlike existing approaches, we embed machine learning model training into the optimization problem, which allows us to employ general follower features that can not be represented using leader decisions. We prove bounds on the optimality gap of the generated leader decision as measured by the original objective function that considers the full follower set. We then develop follower sampling algorithms to tighten the bounds and a representation learning approach to learn follower features, which can be used as inputs to the embedded machine learning model. Using synthetic instances of a cycling network design problem, we compare the computational performance of our approach versus baseline methods. Our approach provides more accurate predictions for follower objective values, and more importantly, generates leader decisions of higher quality. Finally, we perform a real-world case study on cycling infrastructure planning, where we apply our approach to solve a network design problem with over one million followers. Our approach presents favorable performance compared to the current cycling network expansion practices

Traffic prediction and bilevel network design

Cette thèse porte sur la modélisation du trafic dans les réseaux routiers et comment celle-ci est intégrée dans des modèles d'optimisation. Ces deux sujets ont évolué de manière plutôt disjointe: le trafic est prédit par des modèles mathématiques de plus en plus complexes, mais ce progrès n'a pas été incorporé dans les modèles de design de réseau dans lesquels les usagers de la route jouent un rôle crucial. Le but de cet ouvrage est d'intégrer des modèles d'utilités aléatoires calibrés avec de vraies données dans certains modèles biniveaux d'optimisation et ce, par une décomposition de Benders efficace. Cette décomposition particulière s'avère être généralisable par rapport à une grande classe de problèmes communs dans la litérature et permet d'en résoudre des exemples de grande taille. Le premier article présente une méthodologie générale pour utiliser des données GPS d'une flotte de véhicules afin d'estimer les paramètres d'un modèle de demande dit recursive logit. Les traces GPS sont d'abord associées aux liens d'un réseau à l'aide d'un algorithme tenant compte de plusieurs facteurs. Les chemins formés par ces suites de liens et leurs caractéristiques sont utilisés afin d'estimer les paramètres d'un modèle de choix. Ces paramètres représentent la perception qu'ont les usagers de chacune de ces caractéristiques par rapport au choix de leur chemin. Les données utilisées dans cet article proviennent des véhicules appartenant à plusieurs compagnies de transport opérant principalement dans la région de Montréal. Le deuxième article aborde l'intégration d'un modèle de choix de chemin avec utilités aléatoires dans une nouvelle formulation biniveau pour le problème de capture de flot de trafic. Le modèle proposé permet de représenter différents comportements des usagers par rapport à leur choix de chemin en définissant les utilités d'arcs appropriées. Ces utilités sont stochastiques ce qui contribue d'autant plus à capturer un comportement réaliste des usagers. Le modèle biniveau est rendu linéaire à travers l'ajout d'un terme lagrangien basé sur la dualité forte et ceci mène à une décomposition de Benders particulièrement efficace. Les expériences numériques sont principalement menés sur un réseau représentant la ville de Winnipeg ce qui démontre la possibilité de résoudre des problèmes de taille relativement grande. Le troisième article démontre que l'approche du second article peut s'appliquer à une forme particulière de modèles biniveaux qui comprennent plusieurs problèmes différents. La décomposition est d'abord présentée dans un cadre général, puis dans un contexte où le second niveau du modèle biniveau est un problème de plus courts chemins. Afin d'établir que ce contexte inclut plusieurs applications, deux applications distinctes sont adaptées à la forme requise: le transport de matières dangeureuses et la capture de flot de trafic déterministe. Une troisième application, la conception et l'établissement de prix de réseau simultanés, est aussi présentée de manière similaire à l'Annexe B de cette thèse.The subject of this thesis is the modeling of traffic in road networks and its integration in optimization models. In the literature, these two topics have to a large extent evolved independently: traffic is predicted more accurately by increasingly complex mathematical models, but this progress has not been incorporated in network design models where road users play a crucial role. The goal of this work is to integrate random utility models calibrated with real data into bilevel optimization models through an efficient Benders decomposition. This particular decomposition generalizes to a wide class of problems commonly found in the literature and can be used to solved large-scale instances. The first article presents a general methodology to use GPS data gathered from a fleet of vehicles to estimate the parameters of a recursive logit demand model. The GPS traces are first matched to the arcs of a network through an algorithm taking into account various factors. The paths resulting from these sequences of arcs, along with their characteristics, are used to estimate parameters of a choice model. The parameters represent users' perception of each of these characteristics in regards to their path choice behaviour. The data used in this article comes from trucks used by a number of transportation companies operating mainly in the Montreal region. The second article addresses the integration of a random utility maximization model in a new bilevel formulation for the general flow capture problem. The proposed model allows for a representation of different user behaviors in regards to their path choice by defining appropriate arc utilities. These arc utilities are stochastic which further contributes in capturing real user behavior. This bilevel model is linearized through the inclusion of a Lagrangian term based on strong duality which paves the way for a particularly efficient Benders decomposition. The numerical experiments are mostly conducted on a network representing the city of Winnipeg which demonstrates the ability to solve problems of a relatively large size. The third article illustrates how the approach used in the second article can be generalized to a particular form of bilevel models which encompasses many different problems. The decomposition is first presented in a general setting and subsequently in a context where the lower level of the bilevel model is a shortest path problem. In order to demonstrate that this form is general, two distinct applications are adapted to fit the required form: hazmat transportation network design and general flow capture. A third application, joint network design and pricing, is also similarly explored in Appendix B of this thesis

Line planning with user-optimal route choice

We consider the problem of designing lines in a public transport system, where we include user-optimal route choice. The model we develop ensures that there is enough capacity present for every passenger to travel on a shortest route. We present two different integer programming formulations for this problem, and discuss exact solution approaches. To solve large-scale line planning instances, we also implemented a genetic solution algorithms. We test our algorithms in computational experiments using randomly generated instances along realistic data, as well as a realistic instance modeling the German long-distance network. We examine the advantages and disadvantages of using such user-optimal solutions, and show that our algorithms sufficiently scale with instance size to be used for practical purposes