Memory Subsystem Optimization Techniques for Modern High-Performance General-Purpose Processors

abstract: General-purpose processors propel the advances and innovations that are the subject of humanity’s many endeavors. Catering to this demand, chip-multiprocessors (CMPs) and general-purpose graphics processing units (GPGPUs) have seen many high-performance innovations in their architectures. With these advances, the memory subsystem has become the performance- and energy-limiting aspect of CMPs and GPGPUs alike. This dissertation identifies and mitigates the key performance and energy-efficiency bottlenecks in the memory subsystem of general-purpose processors via novel, practical, microarchitecture and system-architecture solutions. Addressing the important Last Level Cache (LLC) management problem in CMPs, I observe that LLC management decisions made in isolation, as in prior proposals, often lead to sub-optimal system performance. I demonstrate that in order to maximize system performance, it is essential to manage the LLCs while being cognizant of its interaction with the system main memory. I propose ReMAP, which reduces the net memory access cost by evicting cache lines that either have no reuse, or have low memory access cost. ReMAP improves the performance of the CMP system by as much as 13%, and by an average of 6.5%. Rather than the LLC, the L1 data cache has a pronounced impact on GPGPU performance by acting as the bandwidth filter for the rest of the memory subsystem. Prior work has shown that the severely constrained data cache capacity in GPGPUs leads to sub-optimal performance. In this thesis, I propose two novel techniques that address the GPGPU data cache capacity problem. I propose ID-Cache that performs effective cache bypassing and cache line size selection to improve cache capacity utilization. Next, I propose LATTE-CC that considers the GPU’s latency tolerance feature and adaptively compresses the data stored in the data cache, thereby increasing its effective capacity. ID-Cache and LATTE-CC are shown to achieve 71% and 19.2% speedup, respectively, over a wide variety of GPGPU applications. Complementing the aforementioned microarchitecture techniques, I identify the need for system architecture innovations to sustain performance scalability of GPG- PUs in the face of slowing Moore’s Law. I propose a novel GPU architecture called the Multi-Chip-Module GPU (MCM-GPU) that integrates multiple GPU modules to form a single logical GPU. With intelligent memory subsystem optimizations tailored for MCM-GPUs, it can achieve within 7% of the performance of a similar but hypothetical monolithic die GPU. Taking a step further, I present an in-depth study of the energy-efficiency characteristics of future MCM-GPUs. I demonstrate that the inherent non-uniform memory access side-effects form the key energy-efficiency bottleneck in the future. In summary, this thesis offers key insights into the performance and energy-efficiency bottlenecks in CMPs and GPGPUs, which can guide future architects towards developing high-performance and energy-efficient general-purpose processors.Dissertation/ThesisDoctoral Dissertation Computer Science 201

An FPGA implementation of an investigative many-core processor, Fynbos : in support of a Fortran autoparallelising software pipeline

Includes bibliographical references.In light of the power, memory, ILP, and utilisation walls facing the computing industry, this work examines the hypothetical many-core approach to finding greater compute performance and efficiency. In order to achieve greater efficiency in an environment in which Moore’s law continues but TDP has been capped, a means of deriving performance from dark and dim silicon is needed. The many-core hypothesis is one approach to exploiting these available transistors efficiently. As understood in this work, it involves trading in hardware control complexity for hundreds to thousands of parallel simple processing elements, and operating at a clock speed sufficiently low as to allow the efficiency gains of near threshold voltage operation. Performance is there- fore dependant on exploiting a new degree of fine-grained parallelism such as is currently only found in GPGPUs, but in a manner that is not as restrictive in application domain range. While removing the complex control hardware of traditional CPUs provides space for more arithmetic hardware, a basic level of control is still required. For a number of reasons this work chooses to replace this control largely with static scheduling. This pushes the burden of control primarily to the software and specifically the compiler, rather not to the programmer or to an application specific means of control simplification. An existing legacy tool chain capable of autoparallelising sequential Fortran code to the degree of parallelism necessary for many-core exists. This work implements a many-core architecture to match it. Prototyping the design on an FPGA, it is possible to examine the real world performance of the compiler-architecture system to a greater degree than simulation only would allow. Comparing theoretical peak performance and real performance in a case study application, the system is found to be more efficient than any other reviewed, but to also significantly under perform relative to current competing architectures. This failing is apportioned to taking the need for simple hardware too far, and an inability to implement static scheduling mitigating tactics due to lack of support for such in the compiler

AN ARCHITECTURE EVALUATION AND IMPLEMENTATION OF A SOFT GPGPU FOR FPGAs

Embedded and mobile systems must be able to execute a variety of different types of code, often with minimal available hardware. Many embedded systems now come with a simple processor and an FPGA, but not more energy-hungry components, such as a GPGPU. In this dissertation we present FlexGrip, a soft architecture which allows for the execution of GPGPU code on an FPGA without the need to recompile the design. The architecture is optimized for FPGA implementation to effectively support the conditional and thread-based execution characteristics of GPGPU execution without FPGA design recompilation. This architecture supports direct CUDA compilation to a binary which is executable on the FPGA-based GPGPU. Our architecture is customizable, thus providing the FPGA designer with a selection of GPGPU cores which display performance versus area tradeoffs. This dissertation describes the FlexGrip architecture in detail and showcases the benefits by evaluating the design for a collection of five standard CUDA benchmarks which are compiled using standard GPGPU compilation tools. Speedups of 23x, on average, versus a MicroBlaze microprocessor are achieved for designs which take advantage of the conditional execution capabilities offered by FlexGrip. We also show FlexGrip can achieve an 80% average reduction of dynamic energy versus the MicroBlaze microprocessor. The dissertation furthers discussion by exploring application-customized versions of the soft GPGPU, thus exploiting the overlay architecture. We expand the architecture to multiple processors per GPGPU and optimizing away features which are not needed by certain classes of applications. These optimizations, which include the effective use of block RAMs and DSP blocks, are critical to the performance of FlexGrip. By implementing a 2 GPGPU design, we show speedups of 44x on average versus a MicroBlaze microprocessor. Application-customized versions of the soft GPGPU can be used to further reduce dynamic energy consumption by an average of 14%. To complete this thesis, we augmented a GPGPU cycle accurate simulator to emulate FlexGrip and evaluate different levels of cache design spaces. We show performance increases for select benchmarks, however, we also show that 64% and 45% of benchmarks exhibited performance decreases when L1D cache was enabled for the 1 SMP and 2 SMP configurations, and only one benchmark showed performance improvement when the L2 cache was enabled

Heterogeneous Photonic Network-on-Chip with Dynamic Bandwidth Allocation

Advancements in the field of chip fabrication has facilitated in integrating more number of transistors in a given area which has lead to an era of multi-core processors. Future multi-core chips or chip multiprocessors (CMPs) will have hundreds of heterogeneous components including processing engines, custom logic, GPU units, programmable fabrics and distributed memory. Such multi-core chips are expected to run varied multiple parallel workloads simultaneously. Hence, different communicating cores will require different bandwidths leading to the necessity of a heterogeneous Network-on-Chip (NoC) architecture. Simply over-provisioning for performance will invariably result in loss of power efficiency. On the other hand, recent research has shown that photonic interconnects are capable of achieving high-bandwidth and energy-efficient on-chip data transfer. In this paper we propose a dynamic heterogeneous photonic NoC (d-HetPNOC) architecture with dynamic bandwidth allocation to achieve better performance and energy-efficiency compared to a homogeneous photonic NoC architecture with the same aggregate data bandwidth

Improving the Performance and Energy Efficiency of GPGPU Computing through Adaptive Cache and Memory Management Techniques

Department of Computer Science and EngineeringAs the performance and energy efficiency requirement of GPGPUs have risen, memory management techniques of GPGPUs have improved to meet the requirements by employing hardware caches and utilizing heterogeneous memory. These techniques can improve GPGPUs by providing lower latency and higher bandwidth of the memory. However, these methods do not always guarantee improved performance and energy efficiency due to the small cache size and heterogeneity of the memory nodes. While prior works have proposed various techniques to address this issue, relatively little work has been done to investigate holistic support for memory management techniques. In this dissertation, we analyze performance pathologies and propose various techniques to improve memory management techniques. First, we investigate the effectiveness of advanced cache indexing (ACI) for high-performance and energy-efficient GPGPU computing. Specifically, we discuss the designs of various static and adaptive cache indexing schemes and present implementation for GPGPUs. We then quantify and analyze the effectiveness of the ACI schemes based on a cycle-accurate GPGPU simulator. Our quantitative evaluation shows that ACI schemes achieve significant performance and energy-efficiency gains over baseline conventional indexing scheme. We also analyze the performance sensitivity of ACI to key architectural parameters (i.e., capacity, associativity, and ICN bandwidth) and the cache indexing latency. We also demonstrate that ACI continues to achieve high performance in various settings. Second, we propose IACM, integrated adaptive cache management for high-performance and energy-efficient GPGPU computing. Based on the performance pathology analysis of GPGPUs, we integrate state-of-the-art adaptive cache management techniques (i.e., cache indexing, bypassing, and warp limiting) in a unified architectural framework to eliminate performance pathologies. Our quantitative evaluation demonstrates that IACM significantly improves the performance and energy efficiency of various GPGPU workloads over the baseline architecture (i.e., 98.1% and 61.9% on average, respectively) and achieves considerably higher performance than the state-of-the-art technique (i.e., 361.4% at maximum and 7.7% on average). Furthermore, IACM delivers significant performance and energy efficiency gains over the baseline GPGPU architecture even when enhanced with advanced architectural technologies (e.g., higher capacity, associativity). Third, we propose bandwidth- and latency-aware page placement (BLPP) for GPGPUs with heterogeneous memory. BLPP analyzes the characteristics of a application and determines the optimal page allocation ratio between the GPU and CPU memory. Based on the optimal page allocation ratio, BLPP dynamically allocate pages across the heterogeneous memory nodes. Our experimental results show that BLPP considerably outperforms the baseline and state-of-the-art technique (i.e., 13.4% and 16.7%) and performs similar to the static-best version (i.e., 1.2% difference), which requires extensive offline profiling.clos

Power Modeling and Optimization for GPGPUs

Modern graphics processing units (GPUs) supports tens of thousands of parallel threads and delivers remarkably high computing throughput. General-Purpose computing on GPUs (GPGPUs) is becoming the attractive platform for general-purpose applications that request high computational performance such as scientific computing, financial applications, medical data processing, and so on. However, GPGPUs is facing severe power challenge due to the increasing number of cores placed on a single chip with decreasing feature size. In order to explore the power optimization techniques in GPGPUs, I first build a power model for GPGPUs, which is able to estimate both dynamic and leakage power of major microarchitecture structures in GPGPUs. I then target on the power-hungry structures (e.g. register file) to explore the energy-efficient GPGPUs. In order to hide the long latency operations, GPGPUs employs the fine-grained multi-threading among numerous active threads, leading to the sizeable register files with massive power consumption. The conventional method to reduce dynamic power consumption is the supply voltage scaling. And the inter-bank tunneling FETs (TFETs) is the promising candidate compared to CMOS for low voltage operations regarding to both leakage and performance. However, always executing at the low voltage will result in significant performance degradation. In this study, I propose the hybrid CMOS-TFET based register file and allocate TFET-based registers to threads whose execution progress can be delayed to some degree to avoid the memory contentions with other threads to reduce both dynamic and leakage power, and the CMOS-based registers are still used for threads requiring normal execution speed. My experimental results show that the proposed technique achieves 30% energy (including both dynamic and leakage) reduction in register files with negligible performance degradation compared to the baseline case equipped with naive power optimization technique

High Performance On-Chip Interconnects Design for Future Many-Core Architectures

Switch-based Network-on-Chip (NoC) is a widely accepted inter-core communication infrastructure for Chip Multiprocessors (CMPs). With the continued advance of CMOS technology, the number of cores on a single chip keeps increasing at a rapid pace. It is highly expected that many-core architectures with more than hundreds of processor cores will be commercialized in the near future. In such a large scale CMP system, NoC overheads are more dominant than computation power in determining overall system performance. Also, for modern computational workloads requiring abundant thread level parallelism (TLP), NoC design for highly-parallel, many-core accelerators such as General Purpose Graphics Processing Units (GPGPUs) is of primary importance in harnessing the potential of massive thread- and data-level parallelism. In these contexts, it is critical that NoC provides both low latency and high bandwidth within limited on-chip power and area budgets. In this dissertation, we explore various design issues inherent in future many-core architectures, CMPs and GPGPUs, to achieve both high performance and power efficiency. First, we deal with issues in using a promising next generation memory technology, Spin-Transfer Torque Magnetic RAM (STT-MRAM), for NoC input buffers in CMPs. Using a high density and low leakage memory offers more buffer capacities with the same die footprint, thus helping increase network throughput in NoC routers. However, its long latency and high power consumption in write operations still need to be addressed. Thus, we propose a hybrid design of input buffers using both SRAM and STT-MRAM to hide the long write latency efficiently. Considering that simple data migration in the hybrid buffer consumes more dynamic power compared to SRAM, we provide a lazy migration scheme that reduces the dynamic power consumption of the hybrid buffer. Second, we propose the first NoC router design that uses only STT-MRAM, providing much larger buffer space with less power consumption, while preserving data integrity. To hide the multicycle writes, we employ a multibank STT-MRAM buffer, a virtual channel with multiple banks where every incoming flit is seamlessly pipelined to each bank alternately. Our STT-MRAM design has aggressively reduced the retention time, resulting in a significant reduction in the latency and power overheads of write operations. To ensure data integrity against inadvertent bit flips from the thermal fluctuation during the given retention time, we propose a cost-efficient dynamic buffer refresh scheme combined with Error Correcting Codes (ECC) to detect and correct data corruption. Third, we present schemes for bandwidth-efficient on-chip interconnects in GPGPUs. GPGPUs place a heavy demand on the on-chip interconnect between the many cores and a few memory controllers (MCs). Thus, traffic is highly asymmetric, impacting on-chip resource utilization and system performance. Here, we analyze the communication demands of typical GPGPU applications, and propose efficient NoC designs to meet those demands

Improving GPGPU NoC Performance with Memory Controller Placement Awareness

General-purpose Graphics Processing Units (GPGPUs) have become a critical component in high-performance computing (HPC) systems in executing modern computational workloads. The high thread level parallelism (TLP) and programmable shader cores allow thousands of threads to execute in Parallel. The fast-scaling of GPGPUs have increased the demand for performance optimizations on Network-On-Chip (NoC) designs. Previous works have exploited NoC designs in the Chip Multiprocessor (CMP) environments but not much in GPGPU systems. Unlike CMPs, traffic is highly asymmetric in GPGPUs because of the many cores but very few memory controllers (MCs). The asymmetric traffic impacts the resource utilization and performance of NoCs. This work aims at analyzing the maximum channel load associated with different MC placements and VC partitioning in interconnection networks of GPGPUs. We also utilize the recently introduced concept of VC monopolization and propose new ways to reduce link contention and improve performance. Evaluation results from cycle-accurate simulation and representative workloads show that the proposed scheme increases application performance (IPC) by 14%, on average, and reduces interconnection network packet latency by 21%

CD-Xbar : a converge-diverge crossbar network for high-performance GPUs

Modern GPUs feature an increasing number of streaming multiprocessors (SMs) to boost system throughput. How to construct an efficient and scalable network-on-chip (NoC) for future high-performance GPUs is particularly critical. Although a mesh network is a widely used NoC topology in manycore CPUs for scalability and simplicity reasons, it is ill-suited to GPUs because of the many-to-few-to-many traffic pattern observed in GPU-compute workloads. Although a crossbar NoC is a natural fit, it does not scale to large SM counts while operating at high frequency. In this paper, we propose the converge-diverge crossbar (CD-Xbar) network with round-robin routing and topology-aware concurrent thread array (CTA) scheduling. CD-Xbar consists of two types of crossbars, a local crossbar and a global crossbar. A local crossbar converges input ports from the SMs into so-called converged ports; the global crossbar diverges these converged ports to the last-level cache (LLC) slices and memory controllers. CD-Xbar provides routing path diversity through the converged ports. Round-robin routing and topology-aware CTA scheduling balance network traffic among the converged ports within a local crossbar and across crossbars, respectively. Compared to a mesh with the same bisection bandwidth, CD-Xbar reduces NoC active silicon area and power consumption by 52.5 and 48.5 percent, respectively, while at the same time improving performance by 13.9 percent on average. CD-Xbar performs within 2.9 percent of an idealized fully-connected crossbar. We further demonstrate CD-Xbar's scalability, flexibility and improved performance perWatt (by 17.1 percent) over state-of-the-art GPU NoCs which are highly customized and non-scalable

Limits on Fundamental Limits to Computation

An indispensable part of our lives, computing has also become essential to industries and governments. Steady improvements in computer hardware have been supported by periodic doubling of transistor densities in integrated circuits over the last fifty years. Such Moore scaling now requires increasingly heroic efforts, stimulating research in alternative hardware and stirring controversy. To help evaluate emerging technologies and enrich our understanding of integrated-circuit scaling, we review fundamental limits to computation: in manufacturing, energy, physical space, design and verification effort, and algorithms. To outline what is achievable in principle and in practice, we recall how some limits were circumvented, compare loose and tight limits. We also point out that engineering difficulties encountered by emerging technologies may indicate yet-unknown limits.Comment: 15 pages, 4 figures, 1 tabl