High efficiency power amplifiers for modern mobile communications: The load-modulation approach

Modern mobile communication signals require power amplifiers able to maintain very high efficiency in a wide range of output power levels, which is a major issue for classical power amplifier architectures. Following the load-modulation approach, efficiency enhancement is achieved by dynamically changing the amplifier load impedance as a function of the input power. In this paper, a review of the widely-adopted Doherty power amplifier and of the other load-modulation efficiency enhancement techniques is presented. The main theoretical aspects behind each method are introduced, and the most relevant practical implementations available in recent literature are reported and discussed

A review of technologies and design techniques of millimeter-wave power amplifiers

his article reviews the state-of-the-art millimeter-wave (mm-wave) power amplifiers (PAs), focusing on broadband design techniques. An overview of the main solid-state technologies is provided, including Si, gallium arsenide (GaAs), GaN, and other III-V materials, and both field-effect and bipolar transistors. The most popular broadband design techniques are introduced, before critically comparing through the most relevant design examples found in the scientific literature. Given the wide breadth of applications that are foreseen to exploit the mm-wave spectrum, this contribution will represent a valuable guide for designers who need a single reference before adventuring in the challenging task of the mm-wave PA design

On the design of high-efficiency RF Doherty power amplifiers

Power amplifiers (PAs) are one of the most crucial elements in wireless standards becasue they are the most power hungry subsystems. These elements have to face an important issue, which is the power efficiency, a fact related with the output back-off (OBO). But the OBO depends on the kind of modulated signal, in proportion to the modulated signal peak-to-average power ratio (PAPR). The higuer is the data rate, the higer is the OBO, and consequently the lower is the efficiency. A low efficiency of PAs causes the waste of energy as heat. Furthermore, the trade-off between linearity and efficiency in PAs is another major issue. To cope with the undesired circumstances producing efficiency degradation, the Doherty power amplifier (DPA) is one of the useful techniques which provide high efficiency for high PAPR of modern communication signals. Nevertheless, the limited bandwidth (BW) of this kind of PAs (about 10% of fractional bandwidth) and its importance (in modern wireless systems such as LTE, WiMAX, Wi-Fi and satellite systems) have encouraged the researchers to improve this drawback in recent years. Some typical BW limiting factors effect on the performance of DPAs: i) quarter-wave length transformers, ii) phase compensation networks in/output matching circuits, iii) offset lines and device non-idealities; The quarter-wave length transformers performs as an inverter impedance in the load modulation technique of DPAs. The future objective in designing DPAs is to decrease the impact of these issues. In this context, this PhD-thesis is focused on improving fractional bandwidth of DPAs using the new methods that are related to impedance transformers instead of impedance inverters in the load modulation technique. This study is twofold. First, it is presented a novel DPA where a wideband GaN DPA in the 2.5 GHz band with an asymmetrical Wilkinson splitter. The impedance transformer of the proposed architecture is based on a matching network including a tapered line with multi-section transformer in the main stage. The BW of this DPA has ranged from 1.8 to 2.7 GHz. Plus, the obtained power efficiency (drain) is higher than 33% in the whole BW at both maximum and OBO power levels. Second, based on the benefits of the Klopfenstein taper, a promising DPA design is proposed where a Klopfenstein taper replaces the tapered line. In fact, this substitution results on reducing the reflection coefficient of the transformer. From a practical prototype realization of this novel Doherty-like PA in the 2.25 GHz band, this modification has demonstrated that the resulting DPA BW is increased in comparison to the conventional topology while keeping the efficiency figures. Moreover, this study also shows that the Klopfenstein taper based design allows an easy tuning of the group delay through the output reactance of the taper, resulting in a more straightforward adjustments than other recently published designs where the quarter-wave transformer is replaced by multi-section transmission lines (hybrid or similar). Experimental results have shown 43-54% of drain efficiency at 42 dBm output power, in the range of 1.7 to 2.75 GHz. Concretely, the results presented in this novel Doherty-like PA implies an specific load modulation technique that uses the mixed Klopfenstein tapered line together with a multi-section transformer in order to obtain high bandwidth with the usual efficiency in DPAs.Los amplificadores de potencia (PAs) son uno de los elementos más importantes para los transmisores inalámbricos desde el punto de vista del consumo energético. Un aspecto muy importante es su eficiencia energética, un concepto relacionado con el back-off de salida (OBO), que a su vez viene condicionadpo por el PAPR de la señal modulada a amplificar. Una baja eficiencia de los PA hace que la pérdida de energía se manifieste en forma de calor. De hecho, esta cuestión conduce al incremento de los costes y tamaño, esto último por los radiadores. Además, el compromiso entre la linealidad y la eficiencia en los PA es otro problema importante. Para hacer frente a las circunstancias que producen la degradación de la eficiencia, el amplificador de potencia tipo Doherty (DPA) es una de las técnicas más útiles que proporcionan una buena eficiencia incluso para los altos PAPR comunes en señales de comunicación modernos. Sin embargo, el limitado ancho de banda (BW) de este tipo de PA (alrededor del 10% del ancho de banda fraccional) y su importancia (en los sistemas inalámbricos modernos, tales como LTE, WiMAX, Wi-Fi y sistemas de satélites) han animado a los investigadores para mejorar este inconveniente en los últimos años. Algunos aspectos típicos que limitan el BW en los DPA son: i) transformadores de longitud de cuarto de onda, ii) redes de compensación de fase y circuitos de adaptación de salida, iii) compensación de las líneas y los dispositivos no ideales. Los transformadores de cuarto de onda actuan como un inversor de impedancia en la técnica de modulación de carga de la DPA "("load modulation"). Concretamente, el objetivo futuro de diseño de DPA es disminuir el impacto de estos problemas. En este contexto, esta tesis doctoral se centra en mejorar el ancho de banda fraccional de DPA utilizando los nuevos métodos que están relacionados con el uso de transformadores de impedancias en vez de inversores en el subcircuito de modulación de carga. Este estudio tiene dos niveles. En primer lugar, se presenta una novedosa estructura del DPA de banda ancha usándose dispositivos de GaN en la banda de 2,5 GHz con un divisor Wilkinson asimétrico. El transformador de impedancias de la arquitectura propuesta se basa en una red de adaptación, incluyendo una línea cónica con múltiples secciones del transformador en la etapa principal. El BW de este DPA ha sido de 1,8 a 2,7 GHz. Además, se obtiene una eficiencia de drenador de más del 33% en todo el BW, tanto a nivel de potencia máxima como a nivel del OBO. En segundo lugar, aprovechando los beneficios de un adaptador de Klopfenstein, se propone un nuevo diseño del DPA. Con la sustitución de la lina conica por el Klopfenstein se reduce el coeficiente de reflexión de transformador de impedancias. Sobre un prototipo práctico de esta nueva estructura del Doherty, en la banda de 2,25 GHz, se ha demostrado que el BW resultante se incrementa en comparación con la topología convencional mientras se mantienen las cifras de eficiencia. Por otra parte, en este estudio se demuestra que el diseño basado en el Klopfenstein permite una afinación fácil del retardo de grupo a través de la reactancia de salida del taper, lo que resulta en un ajuste más sencillo que otros diseños publicados recientemente en el que el transformador de cuarto de onda se sustituye por multi-líneas de transmisión de la sección (híbridos o similar). Los resultados experimentales han mostrado un 43-54% de eficiencia de drenador sobre 42 dBm de potencia de salida, en el intervalo de 1,7 a 2,75 GHz. Concretamente, los resultados presentados en esta nueva estructura tipo-Doherty implican una técnica de modulación de carga que utiliza una combinación de un Klopfenstein junto con un transformador de múltiples secciones con el fin de obtener un alto ancho de banda con la eficiencia habitual en DPAs.Els amplificadors de potència (PA) són un dels elements més importants per els sistemes ràdio ja que sone ls principals consumidors d'energía. Un aspecte molt important és l'eficiència de l'amplificador, aspecte relacionat amb el back-off de sortida (OBO) que a la seva vegada ve condicionat pel PAPR del senyal modulat. Una baixa eficiència dels PA fa que la pèrdua d'energia en manifesti en forma de calor. De fet, aquesta qüestió porta a l'increment dels costos i grandària, degut als dissipadors de calor. A més, el compromís entre la linealitat i l'eficiència en els PA es un altre problema important. Per fer front a les circumstàncies que porten a la degradació de l'eficiència, l'amplificador de potència Doherty (DPA) és una de les tècniques més útils i que proporcionen una bona eficiència per als alts PAPR comuns en senyals de comunicació moderns. No obstant això, l'ample de banda limitat (BW) d'aquest tipus de PA (al voltant del 10% de l'ample de banda fraccional) i la seva importància (en els sistemes moderns, com ara LTE, WiMAX, Wi-Fi i sistemes de satèl·lits) han animat els investigadors per millorar aquest inconvenient en els últims anys. Alguns aspectes tipicament limitadors del BW en els DPA son: i) transformadors de longitud d'quart d'ona, ii) xarxes de compensació de fase en circuits / adaptacions de sortida, iii) compensació de les línies i els dispositius no ideals. Els transformadors de quart d'ona s'utilitzen com a inversors d'impedàncies en la tècnica de modulació de càrrega del DPA ("load modulation"). Concretament, l'objectiu futur de disseny d'DPA és disminuir l'impacte d'aquests problemes. En aquest context, aquesta tesi doctoral es centra en millorar l'ample de banda fraccional dels DPA utilitzant nous mètodes que estan relacionats amb l'ús de transformadors d'impedàncies, en comptes d'inversors, en el subcircuit de modulació de càrrega. Aquest treball té dos nivells. En primer lloc, es presenta un DPA novedós que fa servir dispositus GaN DPA a la banda de 2,5 GHz amb un divisor Wilkinson asimètric. El transformador d'impedàncies de l'arquitectura proposada es basa en una xarxa d'adaptació, incloent una línia cònica amb múltiples seccions del transformador en l'etapa principal. El BW d'aquest DPA ha mostrat ser d'1,8 a a 2,7 GHz. A més, s'obté una eficiència de drenador de més del 33% en tot el BW, tant a nivell de potència màxima com de OBO. En segon lloc, sobre la base dels beneficis del adaptador de Klopfenstein, un proposa un nou disseny on un Klopfenstein substitueix la anterior línia cònica. Aquesta substitució repercuteix en la reducció del coeficient de reflexió de transformador d'impedàncies.Des d'una realització pràctica (prototipus) d'aquest nou amplificador tipus Doherty a la banda de 2,25 GHz, s'ha demostrat que el BW resultant s'incrementa en comparació amb la topologia convencional mentre es mantenen les xifres d'eficiència. D'altra banda, en aquest estudi es demostra que el disseny basat en el Klopfenstein permet una afinació fàcil del retard de grup a través de la reactància de sortida de la forma cònica, el que resulta en un ajust més senzill que altres dissenys publicats recentment en què el transformador de quart d'ona es substitueix per multi-línies de transmissió de la secció (híbrids o similar). Els resultats experimentals han mostrat un 43-54% d'eficiència de drenador en 42 dBm de potència de sortida, en l'interval de 1,7-2,75 GHz. Concretament, els resultats presentats en aquest nou amplificador tipus Doherty impliquen una tècnica de modulació de càrrega específic que utilitza una combinació del Klopfenstein juntament amb un transformador de múltiples seccions per tal d'obtenir un alt ample de banda amb la usual eficiència en DPAs.Postprint (published version

Efficient and Wideband Load Modulated Power Amplifiers for Wireless Communication

The increasing demand for mobile data traffic has resulted in new challenges and requirements for the development of the wireless communication infrastructure. With the transition to higher frequencies and multi-antenna systems, radio frequency (RF) hardware performance, especially the power amplifier (PA), becomes increasingly important. Enhancing PA energy efficiency and bandwidth is vital for maximizing channel capacity, reducing operational costs, and facilitating integration.In the first part of the thesis, the bandwidth limitations of the standard two-way Doherty PA are discussed. A comprehensive analysis is provided, and the frequency responses of different Doherty combiner networks are presented. Furthermore, a Doherty combiner network is proposed, notable for its inherent broadband frequency and its capacity to account for the influence of output parasitics and packaged components from the active devices. The introduced Doherty combiner network is experimentally verified by a wideband gallium nitride (GaN) Doherty PA operating over 1.6-2.7 GHz.In the second part of the thesis, an analytically based combiner synthesis approach for the three-stage Doherty PA is proposed and presented. A compact output combiner network, together with the input phase delays, is derived directly from transistor load-pull data and the PA design requirements. The technique opens up new design space for three-stage Doherty PAs with reconfigurable high-efficiency power back-off levels. The utility of the proposed technique is demonstrated by the implementation of a 30-W GaN three-stage Doherty PA prototype at 2.14 GHz. Measurements show that a drain efficiency of 68% and 55% is exhibited at 6- and 10-dB back-off power, respectively.In the third part, a new PA architecture named the circulator load modulated amplifier (CLMA), is proposed. This architecture utilizes active load modulation for achieving enhanced back-off efficiency. Two active devices are incorporated in this innovative architecture, and a non-reciprocal circulator-based combiner is leveraged. Following this, the sequential CLMA (SCLMA) is introduced, characterized by its ability to enhance back-off efficiency without the necessity of load modulation. GaN demonstrator circuits for both CLMA and SCLMA architectures, whether with dual-input or RF single-input, are designed and fabricated, with excellent performance being measured.\ua0The thesis contributes novel design techniques and architectures to enhance PA efficiency and bandwidth. These findings pave the way for energy-efficient and adaptable RF transmitters in future wireless communication systems

A survey on RF and microwave doherty power amplifier for mobile handset applications

This survey addresses the cutting-edge load modulation microwave and radio frequency power amplifiers for next-generation wireless communication standards. The basic operational principle of the Doherty amplifier and its defective behavior that has been originated by transistor characteristics will be presented. Moreover, advance design architectures for enhancing the Doherty power amplifier’s performance in terms of higher efficiency and wider bandwidth characteristics, as well as the compact design techniques of Doherty amplifier that meets the requirements of legacy 5G handset applications, will be discussed.Agencia Estatal de Investigación | Ref. TEC2017-88242-C3-2-RFundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia | Ref. UIDP/50008/201

Advanced High Efficiency Architectures for Next Generation Wireless Communications

L'abstract è presente nell'allegato / the abstract is in the attachmen

Recent Developments of Dual-Band Doherty Power Amplifiers for Upcoming Mobile Communications Systems

Power amplifiers in modern and future communications should be able to handle different modulation standards at different frequency bands, and in addition, to be compatible with the previous generations. This paper reviews the recent design techniques that have been used to operate dual-band amplifiers and in particular the Doherty amplifiers. Special attention is focused on the design methodologies used for power splitters, phase compensation networks, impedance inverter networks and impedance transformer networks of such power amplifier. The most important materials of the dual-band Doherty amplifier are highlighted and surveyed. The main problems and challenges covering dual-band design concepts are presented and discussed. In addition, improvement techniques to enhance such operations are also exploited. The study shows that the transistor parasitic has a great impact in the design of a dual-band amplifier, and reduction of the transforming ratio of the inverter simplifies the dual-band design. The offset line can be functionally replaced by a Π-network in dual-band design rather than T-network

Advanced High Efficiency and Broadband Power Amplifiers Based on GaN HEMT for Wireless Applications

In advanced wireless communication systems, a rapid increase in the mobile data traffic and broad information bandwidth requirement can lead to the use of complex spectrally efficient modulation schemes such as orthogonal frequency-division multiplexing (OFDM). Generally, complex non-constant envelope modulated signals have very high peak-to-average ratios (PAPR). Doherty Power Amplifier (DPA) is the most commonly used power amplifier (PA) architecture for meeting high efficiency requirement in advanced communication systems, in the presence of high PAPR signals. However, limited bandwidth of the conventional DPA is often identified as a bottleneck for widespread deployment in base-station application for multi-standard communication signals. The research in this thesis focuses on the development of new designs to overcome the bandwidth limitations of a conventional PA. In particular, the bandwidth limitation factors of a conventional DPA architecture are studied. Moreover, a novel design technique is proposed for DPA’s bandwidth extension. In the first PA design, limited bandwidth and linearity problems are addressed simultaneously. For this purpose, a new Class-AB PA with extended bandwidth and improved linearity is presented for LTE 5 W pico-cell base-station over a frequency range of 1.9–2.5 GHz. A two-tone load/source-pull and bias point optimization techniques are used to extract the sweet spots for optimum efficiency and linearity from the 6 W Cree GaN HEMT device for the whole frequency band. The realized prototype presented saturated PAE higher than 60%, a power gain of 13 dB and an average output power of 36.5 dBm over the desired bandwidth. The proposed PA is also characterized by QAM-256 and LTE input communication signals for linearity characterization. Measured ACPRs are lower than -40 dBc for an input power of 17 dBm. The documented results indicate that the proposed Class-AB architecture is suitable for pico-cell base-station application. In the second PA design, an inherent bandwidth limitation of Class-F power amplifier forced by the improper load harmonics terminations at multiple harmonics is investigated and analyzed. It is demonstrated that the impedance tuning of the second and third harmonics at the drain terminal of a transistor is crucial to achieve a broadband performance. The effect of harmonics terminations on power amplifier’s bandwidth up to fourth harmonics is investigated. The implemented broadband Class-F PA achieved maximum saturated drain efficiency 60-77%, and 10 W output power throughout (1.1-2.1 GHz) band. The simulated and measured results verify that the presented Class-F PA is suitable for a high-efficiency system application in wireless communications over a wide range of frequencies. In the third PA design, a single- and dual-input DPA for LTE application in the 3.5 GHz frequency band are presented and compared. The main goal of this study is to improve the performance of gallium–nitride (GaN) Doherty transmitters over a wide bandwidth in the 3.5 GHz frequency band. For this purpose, the linearity-efficiency trade-off for the two proposed architectures is discussed in detail. Simulated results demonstrate that the single- and dual-input DPA exhibited a peak drain efficiency (DE) of 72.4% and 77%, respectively. Both the circuits showed saturated output power more than 42.9 dBm throughout the designed band. Saturated efficiency, gain and bandwidth of dual-input DPA are higher than that of the single-input DPA. On the other side, dual-input DPA linearity is worse as compared to the single-input DPA. In the last PA design, a novel design methodology for ultra-wide band DPA is presented. The bandwidth limitation factors of the conventional Doherty amplifier are discussed on the ground of broadband matching with impedance variation. To extend the DPA bandwidth, three different methods are used such as post-matching, low impedance transformation ratio and the optimization of offset line for wide bandwidth in the proposed design. The proposed Doherty power amplifier was designed and realized based on two 10 W GaN HEMT devices from Cree Inc. The measured results exhibited 42-57% of efficiency at the 6-dB back-off and saturated output power ranges from 41.5 to 43.1 dBm in the frequency range of 1.15 to 2.35 GHz (68.5% fractional bandwidth). Moreover, less than -25 dBc ACPRs are measured at 42 dBm peak output power throughout the designed band. In a nutshell, all power amplifiers presented in this thesis are suitable for wideband operation and their performances are satisfying the required operational standard. Therefore, this thesis has a significant contribution in the domain of high efficiency and broadband power amplifiers

Ultra-Compact mm-Wave Monolithic IC Doherty Power Amplifier for Mobile Handsets

YesThis work develops a novel dynamic load modulation Power Amplifier (PA) circuity that can provide an optimum compromise between linearity and efficiency while covering multiple cellular frequency bands. Exploiting monolithic microwave integrated circuits (MMIC) technology, a fully integrated 1W Doherty PA architecture is proposed based on 0.1 µm AlGaAs/InGaAs Depletion- Mode (D-Mode) technology provided by the WIN Semiconductors foundry. The proposed wideband DPA incorporates the harmonic tuning Class-J mode of operation, which aims to engineer the voltage waveform via second harmonic capacitive load termination. Moreover, the applied post-matching technique not only reduces the impedance transformation ratio of the conventional DPA, but also restores its proper load modulation. The simulation results indicate that the monolithic drive load modulation PA at 4 V operation voltage delivers 44% PAE at the maximum output power of 30 dBm at the 1 dB compression point, and 34% power-added efficiency (PAE) at 6 dB power back-off (PBO). A power gain flatness of around 14 ± 0.5 dB was achieved over the frequency band of 23 GHz to 27 GHz. The compact MMIC load modulation technique developed for the 5G mobile handset occupies the die area of 3.2.This research was funded by the European Regional Development Fund (FEDER), through COMPETE 2020, POR ALGARVE 2020, Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia (FCT) under i-Five Project (POCI-01-0145-FEDER-030500). This work is also part of the POSITION-II project funded by the ECSEL joint Undertaking under grant number Ecsel-345 7831132-Postitio-II-2017-IA. This work is supported by FCT/MCTES through national funds and when applicable co-funded EU funds under the project UIDB/50008/2020-UIDP/50008/2020. The authors would like to thank the WIN Semiconductors foundry for providing the MMIC GaAs pHEMT PDKs and technical support. This work is supported by the Project TEC2017-88242-C3-2-R- Spanish Ministerio de Ciencia, Innovación e Universidades and EU-FEDER funding