Safety and EEG data quality of concurrent high-density EEG and high-speed fMRI at 3 Tesla

Concurrent EEG and fMRI is increasingly used to characterize the spatial-temporal dynamics of brain activity. However, most studies to date have been limited to conventional echo-planar imaging (EPI). There is considerable interest in integrating recently developed high-speed fMRI methods with high-density EEG to increase temporal resolution and sensitivity for task-based and resting state fMRI, and for detecting interictal spikes in epilepsy. In the present study using concurrent high-density EEG and recently developed high-speed fMRI methods, we investigate safety of radiofrequency (RF) related heating, the effect of EEG on cortical signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) in fMRI, and assess EEG data quality.The study compared EPI, multi-echo EPI, multi-band EPI and multi-slab echo-volumar imaging pulse sequences, using clinical 3 Tesla MR scanners from two different vendors that were equipped with 64- and 256-channel MR-compatible EEG systems, respectively, and receive only array head coils. Data were collected in 11 healthy controls (3 males, age range 18-70 years) and 13 patients with epilepsy (8 males, age range 21-67 years). Three of the healthy controls were scanned with the 256-channel EEG system, the other subjects were scanned with the 64-channel EEG system. Scalp surface temperature, SNR in occipital cortex and head movement were measured with and without the EEG cap. The degree of artifacts and the ability to identify background activity was assessed by visual analysis by a trained expert in the 64 channel EEG data (7 healthy controls, 13 patients).RF induced heating at the surface of the EEG electrodes during a 30-minute scan period with stable temperature prior to scanning did not exceed 1.0° C with either EEG system and any of the pulse sequences used in this study. There was no significant decrease in cortical SNR due to the presence of the EEG cap (p > 0.05). No significant differences in the visually analyzed EEG data quality were found between EEG recorded during high-speed fMRI and during conventional EPI (p = 0.78). Residual ballistocardiographic artifacts resulted in 58% of EEG data being rated as poor quality.This study demonstrates that high-density EEG can be safely implemented in conjunction with high-speed fMRI and that high-speed fMRI does not adversely affect EEG data quality. However, the deterioration of the EEG quality due to residual ballistocardiographic artifacts remains a significant constraint for routine clinical applications of concurrent EEG-fMRI

Exploring the relative efficacy of motion artefact correction techniques for EEG data acquired during simultaneous fMRI

Simultaneous EEG-fMRI allows multi-parametric characterisation of brain function, in principle enabling a more complete understanding of brain responses; unfortunately the hostile MRI environment severely reduces EEG data quality. Simply eliminating data segments containing gross motion artefacts [MAs] (generated by movement of the EEG system and head in the MRI scanner’s static magnetic field) was previously believed sufficient. However recently the importance of removal of all MAs has been highlighted and new methods developed.A systematic comparison of the ability to remove MAs and retain underlying neuronal activity using different methods of MA detection and post-processing algorithms is needed to guide the neuroscience community. Using a head phantom, we recorded MAs while simultaneously monitoring the motion using three different approaches: Reference Layer Artefact Subtraction (RLAS), Moire Phase Tracker (MPT) markers, and Wire Loop Motion Sensors (WLMS). These EEG recordings were combined with EEG responses to simple visual tasks acquired on a subject outside the MRI environment. MAs were then corrected using the motion information collected with each of the methods combined with different analysis pipelines.All tested methods retained the neuronal signal. However, often the MA was not removed sufficiently to allow accurate detection of the underlying neuronal signal. We show that the MA is best corrected using the RLAS combined with post-processing using a multi-channel, recursive least squares (M-RLS) algorithm. This method needs to be developed further to enable practical utility; thus, WLMS combined with M-RLS currently provides the best compromise between EEG data quality and practicalities of motion detection

Spurious correlations in simultaneous EEG-fMRI driven by in-scanner movement

Simultaneous EEG-fMRI provides an increasingly attractive research tool to investigate cognitive processes with high temporal and spatial resolution. However, artifacts in EEG data introduced by the MR-scanner still remain a major obstacle. This study employing commonly used artifact correction steps shows that head motion, one overlooked major source of artifacts in EEG-fMRI data, can cause plausible EEG effects and EEG-BOLD correlations. Specifically, low frequency EEG

Simultaneous EEG-fMRI : novel methods for EEG artefacts reduction at source

This thesis describes the development and application of novel techniques to reduce the EEG artefacts at source during the simultaneous acquisition of EEG and fMRI data. The work described in this thesis was carried out by the author in the Sir Peter Mansfield Magnetic Resonance Centre, School of Physics & Astronomy at the University of Nottingham, between October 2010 and January 2013. Large artefacts compromise EEG data quality during simultaneous fMRI. These artefact voltages pose heavy demands on the bandwidth and dynamic range of EEG amplifiers and mean that even small fractional variations in the artefact voltages give rise to significant residual artefacts after correction, which can easily swamp signals from brain activity. Therefore any intrinsic reduction in the magnitude of the artefacts would be highly advantageous, allowing data with a higher bandwidth to be acquired without amplifier saturation, and facilitating improved detection of brain activity. This thesis firstly explores a new method for reducing the gradient artefact (GA), which is induced in EEG data recorded during concurrent MRI, by investigating the effects of the cable configuration on the characteristics of the GA. This work showed that the GA amplitude and its sensitivity to movement of the cabling is reduced by minimising wire loop areas in the cabling between the EEG cap and amplifier. Another novel approach for reducing the magnitude and variability of the artefacts is the use of an EEG cap that incorporates electrodes embedded in a reference layer, which has a similar conductivity to tissue and is electrically isolated from the scalp. With this arrangement, the artefact voltages produced on the reference layer leads are theoretically similar to those induced in the scalp leads, but neuronal signals are not detected in the reference layer. Therefore taking the difference of the voltages in the reference and scalp channels should reduce the artefacts, without affecting sensitivity to neuronal signals. The theoretical efficacy of artefact correction that can be achieved by using this new reference layer artefact subtraction (RLAS) method was investigated. This was done through separate electromagnetic simulations of the artefacts induced in a hemispherical reference layer and a spherical volume conductor in a time-varying magnetic field and the results showed that similar artefacts are induced on the surface of both conductors. Simulations are also performed to find the optimal design for an RLAS system, by varying the geometry of the system. A simple experimental realisation of the RLAS system was implemented to investigate the degree of artefact attenuation that can be achieved via RLAS. Through a series of experiments on phantoms and human subjects, it is shown here that RLAS significantly reduces the GA, pulse (PA) and motion (MA) artefacts, while allowing accurate recording of neuronal signals. The results indicate that RLAS generally outperforms the standard artefact correction method, average artefact subtraction (AAS), in the removal of the GA and PA when motion is present, while the combination of RLAS and AAS always produces higher artefact attenuation than AAS alone. Additionally, this work demonstrates that RLAS greatly attenuates the unpredictable and highly variable MA that are very hard to remove using post-processing methods

Simultaneous EEG-fMRI at ultra-high field for the study of human brain function

Scalp electroencephalography (EEG) and functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) have highly complementary domains, and their combination has been actively sought within neuroscience research. The important gains in fMRI sensitivity achieved with higher field strengths open exciting perspectives for combined EEG-fMRI; however, simultaneous acquisitions are subject to highly undesirable interactions between the two modalities, which can strongly compromise data quality and subject safety, and most of these interactions are increased at higher fields. The work described in this thesis was centered on the development of simultaneous EEG-fMRI in humans at 7T, covering aspects of subject safety, signal quality assessment, and quality improvement. Additionally, given the potential value of high-field EEG-fMRI to study the neuronal correlates of so-called negative BOLD responses, an initial fMRI study was dedicated to these phenomena. The initial fMRI study aimed to characterize positive (PBR) and negative BOLD responses (NBR) to visual checkerboard stimulation of varying contrast and duration, focusing on NBRs occurring in visual and in auditory cortical regions. Results showed that visual PBRs and both visual and auditory NBRs significantly depend on stimulus contrast and duration, suggesting a dynamic system of visual-auditory interactions, sensitive to stimulus contrast and duration. The neuronal correlates of these interactions could not be addressed in higher detail with fMRI alone, yet could potentially be clarified in future work with combined EEG-fMRI. Moving on to simultaneous EEG-fMRI implementation, the first stage comprised an assessment of potential safety concerns at 7T. The safety tests comprised numerical simulations of RF power distribution and real temperature measurements on a phantom during acquisition. Overall, no significant safety concerns were found for the setup tested. A characterization of artifacts induced on MRI data due to the presence of EEG components was then performed. With the introduction of the EEG system, functional and anatomical images exhibited general losses in spatial SNR, with a smaller loss in temporal SNR in fMRI data. B0 and B1 field mapping pointed towards RF pulse disruption as the major degradation mechanism affecting MRI data. The main part of this work focused on EEG artifacts induced by MRI. The first step focused on optimizing signal transmission between the EEG cap and amplifiers, to minimize artifact contamination at this important stage. Along this line, adequate cable shortening and bundling effectively reduced environment noise in EEG recordings. Simultaneous acquisitions were then performed on humans using the optimized setup. On average, EEG data exhibited clear alpha modulation and average visual evoked potentials (VEP), with concomitant BOLD signal changes. In the second step, a novel approach for head motion artifact detection was developed, based on a simple modification of the EEG cap, and simultaneous acquisitions were performed in volunteers undergoing visual checkerboard stimulation. After gradient artifact correction, EEG signal variance was found to be largely dominated by pulse artifacts, but contributions from spontaneous motion were still comparable to those of neuronal activity. Using a combination of pulse artifact correction, motion artifact correction and ICA denoising, strong improvements in data quality could be obtained, especially at a single-trial level

EEG-fMRI: novel methods for gradient artefact correction

The general aim of the work detailed in this thesis is to improve the quality of electroencepholography (EEG) recordings acquired simultaneously with functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) data. Simultaneous EEG-fMRI recordings offer significant advantages over the isolated use of each modality for measuring brain function. The high temporal resolution associated with EEG complements the high spatial resolution provided by fMRI. However, combining the two modalities can have significant effects on the overall data quality. The gradient artefact (GA), which is induced on the EEG cables by the time varying magnetic fields associated with fMRI sequences, can be particularly problematic to correct for in experiments containing any subject movement. In this thesis, two novel, movement-invariant methods are introduced for correcting the GA. The first method is named the gradient model fit (GMF) and relies upon the assumption that the GA can be modelled as a linear combination of basis components, where the relative weighting of each component varies dependent upon subject position. By modelling these underlying components, it is possible to characterise and remove the GA, which is particularly beneficial in the presence of subject movement. The second method named the difference model subtraction (DMS) relies on the assumption that the GA varies linearly for small changes in subject position. By modelling the change in GA for a basis set of likely head movements, it was shown to be possible to combine DMS with standard GA correction methods to improve the attenuation of the GA for data acquired during subject movement. Both methods showed a significant improvement over the existing GA correction techniques, particularly for experiments containing subject movement. These methods are therefore relevant to any experimenter interested in working with subject groups such as children or patients where movement is likely to occur

Simultaneous EEG-fMRI : novel methods for EEG artefacts reduction at source

This thesis describes the development and application of novel techniques to reduce the EEG artefacts at source during the simultaneous acquisition of EEG and fMRI data. The work described in this thesis was carried out by the author in the Sir Peter Mansfield Magnetic Resonance Centre, School of Physics & Astronomy at the University of Nottingham, between October 2010 and January 2013. Large artefacts compromise EEG data quality during simultaneous fMRI. These artefact voltages pose heavy demands on the bandwidth and dynamic range of EEG amplifiers and mean that even small fractional variations in the artefact voltages give rise to significant residual artefacts after correction, which can easily swamp signals from brain activity. Therefore any intrinsic reduction in the magnitude of the artefacts would be highly advantageous, allowing data with a higher bandwidth to be acquired without amplifier saturation, and facilitating improved detection of brain activity. This thesis firstly explores a new method for reducing the gradient artefact (GA), which is induced in EEG data recorded during concurrent MRI, by investigating the effects of the cable configuration on the characteristics of the GA. This work showed that the GA amplitude and its sensitivity to movement of the cabling is reduced by minimising wire loop areas in the cabling between the EEG cap and amplifier. Another novel approach for reducing the magnitude and variability of the artefacts is the use of an EEG cap that incorporates electrodes embedded in a reference layer, which has a similar conductivity to tissue and is electrically isolated from the scalp. With this arrangement, the artefact voltages produced on the reference layer leads are theoretically similar to those induced in the scalp leads, but neuronal signals are not detected in the reference layer. Therefore taking the difference of the voltages in the reference and scalp channels should reduce the artefacts, without affecting sensitivity to neuronal signals. The theoretical efficacy of artefact correction that can be achieved by using this new reference layer artefact subtraction (RLAS) method was investigated. This was done through separate electromagnetic simulations of the artefacts induced in a hemispherical reference layer and a spherical volume conductor in a time-varying magnetic field and the results showed that similar artefacts are induced on the surface of both conductors. Simulations are also performed to find the optimal design for an RLAS system, by varying the geometry of the system. A simple experimental realisation of the RLAS system was implemented to investigate the degree of artefact attenuation that can be achieved via RLAS. Through a series of experiments on phantoms and human subjects, it is shown here that RLAS significantly reduces the GA, pulse (PA) and motion (MA) artefacts, while allowing accurate recording of neuronal signals. The results indicate that RLAS generally outperforms the standard artefact correction method, average artefact subtraction (AAS), in the removal of the GA and PA when motion is present, while the combination of RLAS and AAS always produces higher artefact attenuation than AAS alone. Additionally, this work demonstrates that RLAS greatly attenuates the unpredictable and highly variable MA that are very hard to remove using post-processing methods

EEG-fMRI: novel methods for gradient artefact correction

The general aim of the work detailed in this thesis is to improve the quality of electroencepholography (EEG) recordings acquired simultaneously with functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) data. Simultaneous EEG-fMRI recordings offer significant advantages over the isolated use of each modality for measuring brain function. The high temporal resolution associated with EEG complements the high spatial resolution provided by fMRI. However, combining the two modalities can have significant effects on the overall data quality. The gradient artefact (GA), which is induced on the EEG cables by the time varying magnetic fields associated with fMRI sequences, can be particularly problematic to correct for in experiments containing any subject movement. In this thesis, two novel, movement-invariant methods are introduced for correcting the GA. The first method is named the gradient model fit (GMF) and relies upon the assumption that the GA can be modelled as a linear combination of basis components, where the relative weighting of each component varies dependent upon subject position. By modelling these underlying components, it is possible to characterise and remove the GA, which is particularly beneficial in the presence of subject movement. The second method named the difference model subtraction (DMS) relies on the assumption that the GA varies linearly for small changes in subject position. By modelling the change in GA for a basis set of likely head movements, it was shown to be possible to combine DMS with standard GA correction methods to improve the attenuation of the GA for data acquired during subject movement. Both methods showed a significant improvement over the existing GA correction techniques, particularly for experiments containing subject movement. These methods are therefore relevant to any experimenter interested in working with subject groups such as children or patients where movement is likely to occur