Average-case complexity of backtrack search for coloring sparse random graphs

We investigate asymptotically the expected number of steps taken by backtrack search for $k$-coloring random graphs $G_{n,p(n)}$ or proving non-$k$-colorability, where $p(n)$ is an arbitrary sequence tending to 0, and $k$ is constant. Contrary to the case of constant $p$, where the expected runtime is known to be $O(1)$, we prove that here the expected runtime tends to infinity. We establish how the asymptotic behaviour of the expected number of steps depends on the sequence $p(n)$. In particular, for $p(n)=d/n$, where $d$ is a constant, the runtime is always exponential, but it can be also polynomial if $p(n)$ decreases sufficiently slowly, e.g. for $p(n)=1/\ln n$

Experimental evaluation of preprocessing algorithms for constraint satisfaction problems

This paper presents an experimental evaluation of two orthogonal schemes for preprocessing constraint satisfaction problems (CSPs). The first of these schemes involves a class of local consistency techniques that includes directional arc consistency, directional path consistency, and adaptive consistency. The other scheme concerns the prearrangement of variables in a linear order to facilitate an efficient search. In the first series of experiments, we evaluated the effect of each of the local consistency techniques on backtracking and its common enhancement, backjumping. Surprizingly, although adaptive consistency has the best worst-case complexity bounds, we have found that it exhibits the worst performance, unless the constraint graph was very sparse. Directional arc consistency (followed by either backjumping or backtracking) and backjumping (without any pre-processing) outperformed all other techniques; moreover, the former dominated the latter in computationally intensive situations. The second series of experiments suggests that maximum cardinality and minimum width arc the best pre-ordering (i.e., static ordering) strategies, while dynamic search rearrangement is superior to all the preorderings studied

The dynamics of proving uncolourability of large random graphs I. Symmetric Colouring Heuristic

We study the dynamics of a backtracking procedure capable of proving uncolourability of graphs, and calculate its average running time T for sparse random graphs, as a function of the average degree c and the number of vertices N. The analysis is carried out by mapping the history of the search process onto an out-of-equilibrium (multi-dimensional) surface growth problem. The growth exponent of the average running time is quantitatively predicted, in agreement with simulations.Comment: 5 figure

RASCAL: calculation of graph similarity using maximum common edge subgraphs

A new graph similarity calculation procedure is introduced for comparing labeled graphs. Given a minimum similarity threshold, the procedure consists of an initial screening process to determine whether it is possible for the measure of similarity between the two graphs to exceed the minimum threshold, followed by a rigorous maximum common edge subgraph (MCES) detection algorithm to compute the exact degree and composition of similarity. The proposed MCES algorithm is based on a maximum clique formulation of the problem and is a significant improvement over other published algorithms. It presents new approaches to both lower and upper bounding as well as vertex selection

Exact Algorithms for Maximum Clique: a computational study

We investigate a number of recently reported exact algorithms for the maximum clique problem (MCQ, MCR, MCS, BBMC). The program code used is presented and critiqued showing how small changes in implementation can have a drastic effect on performance. The computational study demonstrates how problem features and hardware platforms influence algorithm behaviour. The minimum width order (smallest-last) is investigated, and MCS is broken into its consituent parts and we discover that one of these parts degrades performance. It is shown that the standard procedure used for rescaling published results is unsafe.Comment: 40 pages, 14 figures, 10 tables, 12 short java program listings, code afailable to download at http://www.dcs.gla.ac.uk/~pat/maxClique/distribution

Bicoloring Random Hypergraphs

We study the problem of bicoloring random hypergraphs, both numerically and analytically. We apply the zero-temperature cavity method to find analytical results for the phase transitions (dynamic and static) in the 1RSB approximation. These points appear to be in agreement with the results of the numerical algorithm. In the second part, we implement and test the Survey Propagation algorithm for specific bicoloring instances in the so called HARD-SAT phase.Comment: 14 pages, 10 figure