Attacking (EC)DSA scheme with ephemeral keys sharing specific bits

In this paper, we present a deterministic attack on (EC)DSA signature scheme, providing that several signatures are known such that the corresponding ephemeral keys share a certain amount of bits without knowing their value. By eliminating the shared blocks of bits between the ephemeral keys, we get a lattice of dimension equal to the number of signatures having a vector containing the private key. We compute an upper bound for the distance of this vector from a target vector, and next, using Kannan's enumeration algorithm, we determine it and hence the secret key. The attack can be made highly efficient by appropriately selecting the number of shared bits and the number of signatures

New Lattice Attacks on DSA Schemes

We prove that a system of linear congruences of a particular form has at most a unique solution below a certain bound which can be computed efficiently. Using this result we develop attacks against the DSA schemes which, under some assumptions, can provide the secret key in the case where one or several signed messages are available

Minerva: The curse of ECDSA nonces

We present our discovery of a group of side-channel vulnerabilities in implementations of the ECDSA signature algorithm in a widely used Atmel AT90SC FIPS 140-2 certified smartcard chip and five cryptographic libraries (libgcrypt, wolfSSL, MatrixSSL, SunEC/OpenJDK/Oracle JDK, Crypto++). Vulnerable implementations leak the bit-length of the scalar used in scalar multiplication via timing. Using leaked bit-length, we mount a lattice attack on a 256-bit curve, after observing enough signing operations. We propose two new methods to recover the full private key requiring just 500 signatures for simulated leakage data, 1200 for real cryptographic library data, and 2100 for smartcard data. The number of signatures needed for a successful attack depends on the chosen method and its parameters as well as on the noise profile, influenced by the type of leakage and used computation platform. We use the set of vulnerabilities reported in this paper, together with the recently published TPM-FAIL vulnerability as a basis for real-world benchmark datasets to systematically compare our newly proposed methods and all previously published applicable lattice-based key recovery methods. The resulting exhaustive comparison highlights the methods\u27 sensitivity to its proper parametrization and demonstrates that our methods are more efficient in most cases. For the TPM-FAIL dataset, we decreased the number of required signatures from approximately 40 000 to mere 900

Lattice Attacks against Elliptic-Curve Signatures with Blinded Scalar Multiplication

International audienceElliptic curve cryptography is today the prevailing approach to get efficient public-key cryptosystems and digital signatures. Most of elliptic curve signature schemes use a \emph{nonce} in the computation of each signature and the knowledge of this nonce is sufficient to fully recover the secret key of the scheme. Even a few bits of the nonce over several signatures allow a complete break of the scheme by lattice-based attacks. Several works have investigated how to efficiently apply such attacks when partial information on the nonce can be recovered through side-channel attacks. However, these attacks usually target unprotected implementation and/or make ideal assumptions on the recovered information, and it is not clear how they would perform in a scenario where common countermeasures are included and where only noisy information leaks via side channels. In this paper, we close this gap by applying such attack techniques against elliptic-curve signature implementations based on a blinded scalar multiplication. Specifically, we extend the famous Howgrave-Graham and Smart lattice attack when the nonces are blinded by the addition of a random multiple of the elliptic-curve group order or by a random Euclidean splitting. We then assume that noisy information on the blinded nonce can be obtained through a template attack targeting the underlying scalar multiplication and we show how to characterize the obtained likelihood scores under a realistic leakage assumption. To deal with this scenario, we introduce a filtering method which given a set of signatures and associated likelihood scores maximizes the success probability of the lattice attack. Our approach is backed up with attack simulation results for several signal-to-noise ratio of the exploited leakage

Attacks Against White-Box ECDSA and Discussion of Countermeasures

This paper deals with white-box implementations of the Elliptic Curve Digital Signature Algorithm (ECDSA): First, we consider attack paths to break such implementations. In particular, we provide a systematic overview of various fault attacks, to which ECDSA white-box implementations are especially susceptible. Then, we propose different mathematical countermeasures, mainly based on masking/blinding of sensitive variables, in order to prevent or at least make such attacks more difficult. We also briefly mention some typical implementational countermeasures and their challenges in the ECDSA white-box scenario. Our work has been initiated by the CHES challenge WhibOx Contest 2021, which consisted of designing and breaking white-box ECDSA implementations, so called challenges. We illustrate our results and findings by means of the submitted challenges and provide a comprehensive overview which challenge could be solved in which way. Furthermore, we analyze selected challenges in more details

ECDSA White-Box Implementations: Attacks and Designs from CHES 2021 Challenge

Despite the growing demand for software implementations of ECDSA secure against attackers with full control of the execution environment, scientific literature on ECDSA white-box design is scarce. The CHES 2021 WhibOx contest was thus held to assess the state-of-the-art and encourage relevant practical research, inviting developers to submit ECDSA white-box implementations and attackers to break the corresponding submissions. In this work, attackers (team TheRealIdefix) and designers (team zerokey) join to describe several attack techniques and designs used during this contest. We explain the methods used by the team TheRealIdefix, which broke the most challenges, and we show the efficiency of each of these methods against all the submitted implementations. Moreover, we describe the designs of the two winning challenges submitted by the team zerokey; these designs represent the ECDSA signature algorithm by a sequence of systems of low-degree equations, which are obfuscated with affine encodings and extra random variables and equations. The WhibOx contest has shown that securing ECDSA in the white-box model is an open and challenging problem, as no implementation survived more than two days. In this context, our designs provide a starting methodology for further research, and our attacks highlight the weak points future work should address

ECDSA White-Box Implementations: Attacks and Designs from WhibOx 2021 Contest

Despite the growing demand for software implementations of ECDSA secure against attackers with full control of the execution environment, the scientific literature on white-box ECDSA design is scarce. To assess the state-of-the-art and encourage practical research on this topic, the WhibOx 2021 contest invited developers to submit white-box ECDSA implementations and attackers to break the corresponding submissions. In this work we describe several attack techniques and designs used during the WhibOx 2021 contest. We explain the attack methods used by the team TheRealIdefix, who broke the largest number of challenges, and we show the success of each method against all the implementations in the contest. Moreover, we describe the designs, submitted by the team zerokey, of the two winning challenges; these designs represent the ECDSA signature algorithm by a sequence of systems of low-degree equations, which are obfuscated with affine encodings and extra random variables and equations. The WhibOx contest has shown that securing ECDSA in the white-box model is an open and challenging problem, as no implementation survived more than two days. To this end, our designs provide a starting methodology for further research, and our attacks highlight the weak points future work should address

Attacking (EC)DSA Given Only an Implicit Hint

We describe a lattice attack on DSA-like signature schemes under the assumption that implicit information on the ephemeral keys is known. Inspired by the implicit oracle of May and Ritzenhofen presented in the context of RSA (PKC2009), we assume that the ephemeral keys share a certain amount of bits without knowing the value of the shared bits. This work also extends results of Leadbitter, Page and Smart (CHES2004) which use a very similar type of partial information leakage. By eliminating the shared blocks of bits between the ephemeral keys, we provide lattices of small dimension (e.g. equal to the number of signatures) and thus obtain an efficient attack. More precisely, by using the LLL algorithm, the complexity of the attack is polynomial. We show that this method can work when ephemeral keys share certain amount of MSBs and/or LSBs, as well as contiguous blocks of shared bits in the middle. Under the Gaussian heuristic assumption, theoretical bounds on the number of shared bits in function of the number of signed messages are proven. Experimental results show that we are often able to go a few bits beyond the theoretical bound. For instance, if only 2 shared LSBs on each ephemeral keys of 200 signed messages (with no knowledge about the secret key) then the attack reveals the secret key. The success rate of this attack is about 90 % when only 1 LSB is shared on each ephemeral keys associated with about 400 signed messages

Papillary Thyroid Carcinoma Intertwined with Hashimoto’s Thyroiditis: An Intriguing Correlation

Illustrating the ancient link connecting inflammation with cancer, the correlation of papillary thyroid carcinoma (PTC) with Hashimoto’s thyroiditis (HT) has long been pursued as intersection of autoimmunity-induced chronic inflammation and tumor-induced immunity. The dramatic rise of the incidence of PTC οver the last decades—the main culprit for “thyroid cancer (TC) epidemic”—parallels the increasing incidence of HT, potentially reflecting a pathogenetic link that could be harnessed in diagnostics and therapeutics. Prompted by this perspective, in the present chapter, we dissect the hitherto elusive interrelationship of PTC with HT, focusing on four issues: firstly, an unresolved conundrum is whether PTC emerges due to or notwithstanding immune response or mirrors the “tumor defense-induced autoimmunity.” Secondly, the interrelationship of HT with PTC may be merely epiphenomenon of selection bias inherent in thyroidectomy series. Thirdly, the impact of HT on coexistent PTC is equivocal—host protective versus tumor protective. Fourthly, translating serum concentrations of thyroid autoantibodies and thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) into predictive and prognostic PTC biomarkers dichotomizes, till now, the researchers. In the era of precision medicine, illuminating whether HT precipitates PTC or vice versa is awaited with anticipation in order to refine the preventive and therapeutic policy counteracting “TC epidemic.