Revisiting Shor's quantum algorithm for computing general discrete logarithms

We heuristically demonstrate that Shor's algorithm for computing general discrete logarithms, modified to allow the semi-classical Fourier transform to be used with control qubit recycling, achieves a success probability of approximately 60% to 82% in a single run. By slightly increasing the number of group operations that are evaluated quantumly, and by performing a limited search in the classical post-processing, we furthermore show how the algorithm can be modified to achieve a success probability exceeding 99% in a single run. We provide concrete heuristic estimates of the success probability of the modified algorithm, as a function of the group order, the size of the search space in the classical post-processing, and the additional number of group operations evaluated quantumly. In analogy with our earlier works, we show how the modified quantum algorithm may be simulated classically when the logarithm and group order are both known. Furthermore, we show how slightly better tradeoffs may be achieved, compared to our earlier works, if the group order is known when computing the logarithm.Comment: The pre-print has been extended to show how slightly better tradeoffs may be achieved, compared to our earlier works, if the group order is known. A minor issue with an integration limit, that lead us to give a rough success probability estimate of 60% to 70%, as opposed to 60% to 82%, has been corrected. The heuristic and results reported in the original pre-print are otherwise unaffecte