Automated Semiconductor Defect Inspection in Scanning Electron Microscope Images: a Systematic Review

A growing need exists for efficient and accurate methods for detecting defects in semiconductor materials and devices. These defects can have a detrimental impact on the efficiency of the manufacturing process, because they cause critical failures and wafer-yield limitations. As nodes and patterns get smaller, even high-resolution imaging techniques such as Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) produce noisy images due to operating close to sensitivity levels and due to varying physical properties of different underlayers or resist materials. This inherent noise is one of the main challenges for defect inspection. One promising approach is the use of machine learning algorithms, which can be trained to accurately classify and locate defects in semiconductor samples. Recently, convolutional neural networks have proved to be particularly useful in this regard. This systematic review provides a comprehensive overview of the state of automated semiconductor defect inspection on SEM images, including the most recent innovations and developments. 38 publications were selected on this topic, indexed in IEEE Xplore and SPIE databases. For each of these, the application, methodology, dataset, results, limitations and future work were summarized. A comprehensive overview and analysis of their methods is provided. Finally, promising avenues for future work in the field of SEM-based defect inspection are suggested.Comment: 16 pages, 12 figures, 3 table

제조 시스템에서의 예측 모델링을 위한 지능적 데이터 획득

학위논문 (박사) -- 서울대학교 대학원 : 공과대학 산업공학과, 2021. 2. 조성준.Predictive modeling is a type of supervised learning to find the functional relationship between the input variables and the output variable. Predictive modeling is used in various aspects in manufacturing systems, such as automation of visual inspection, prediction of faulty products, and result estimation of expensive inspection. To build a high-performance predictive model, it is essential to secure high quality data. However, in manufacturing systems, it is practically impossible to acquire enough data of all kinds that are needed for the predictive modeling. There are three main difficulties in the data acquisition in manufacturing systems. First, labeled data always comes with a cost. In many problems, labeling must be done by experienced engineers, which is costly. Second, due to the inspection cost, not all inspections can be performed on all products. Because of time and monetary constraints in the manufacturing system, it is impossible to obtain all the desired inspection results. Third, changes in the manufacturing environment make data acquisition difficult. A change in the manufacturing environment causes a change in the distribution of generated data, making it impossible to obtain enough consistent data. Then, the model have to be trained with a small amount of data. In this dissertation, we overcome this difficulties in data acquisition through active learning, active feature-value acquisition, and domain adaptation. First, we propose an active learning framework to solve the high labeling cost of the wafer map pattern classification. This makes it possible to achieve higher performance with a lower labeling cost. Moreover, the cost efficiency is further improved by incorporating the cluster-level annotation into active learning. For the inspection cost for fault prediction problem, we propose a active inspection framework. By selecting products to undergo high-cost inspection with the novel uncertainty estimation method, high performance can be obtained with low inspection cost. To solve the recipe transition problem that frequently occurs in faulty wafer prediction in semiconductor manufacturing, a domain adaptation methods are used. Through sequential application of unsupervised domain adaptation and semi-supervised domain adaptation, performance degradation due to recipe transition is minimized. Through experiments on real-world data, it was demonstrated that the proposed methodologies can overcome the data acquisition problems in the manufacturing systems and improve the performance of the predictive models.예측 모델링은 지도 학습의 일종으로, 학습 데이터를 통해 입력 변수와 출력 변수 간의 함수적 관계를 찾는 과정이다. 이런 예측 모델링은 육안 검사 자동화, 불량 제품 사전 탐지, 고비용 검사 결과 추정 등 제조 시스템 전반에 걸쳐 활용된다. 높은 성능의 예측 모델을 달성하기 위해서는 양질의 데이터가 필수적이다. 하지만 제조 시스템에서 원하는 종류의 데이터를 원하는 만큼 획득하는 것은 현실적으로 거의 불가능하다. 데이터 획득의 어려움은 크게 세가지 원인에 의해 발생한다. 첫번째로, 라벨링이 된 데이터는 항상 비용을 수반한다는 점이다. 많은 문제에서, 라벨링은 숙련된 엔지니어에 의해 수행되어야 하고, 이는 큰 비용을 발생시킨다. 두번째로, 검사 비용 때문에 모든 검사가 모든 제품에 대해 수행될 수 없다. 제조 시스템에는 시간적, 금전적 제약이 존재하기 때문에, 원하는 모든 검사 결과값을 획득하는 것이 어렵다. 세번째로, 제조 환경의 변화가 데이터 획득을 어렵게 만든다. 제조 환경의 변화는 생성되는 데이터의 분포를 변형시켜, 일관성 있는 데이터를 충분히 획득하지 못하게 한다. 이로 인해 적은 양의 데이터만으로 모델을 재학습시켜야 하는 상황이 빈번하게 발생한다. 본 논문에서는 이런 데이터 획득의 어려움을 극복하기 위해 능동 학습, 능동 피쳐값 획득, 도메인 적응 방법을 활용한다. 먼저, 웨이퍼 맵 패턴 분류 문제의 높은 라벨링 비용을 해결하기 위해 능동학습 프레임워크를 제안한다. 이를 통해 적은 라벨링 비용으로 높은 성능의 분류 모델을 구축할 수 있다. 나아가, 군집 단위의 라벨링 방법을 능동학습에 접목하여 비용 효율성을 한차례 더 개선한다. 제품 불량 예측에 활용되는 검사 비용 문제를 해결하기 위해서는 능동 검사 방법을 제안한다. 제안하는 새로운 불확실성 추정 방법을 통해 고비용 검사 대상 제품을 선택함으로써 적은 검사 비용으로 높은 성능을 얻을 수 있다. 반도체 제조의 웨이퍼 불량 예측에서 빈번하게 발생하는 레시피 변경 문제를 해결하기 위해서는 도메인 적응 방법을 활용한다. 비교사 도메인 적응과 반교사 도메인 적응의 순차적인 적용을 통해 레시피 변경에 의한 성능 저하를 최소화한다. 본 논문에서는 실제 데이터에 대한 실험을 통해 제안된 방법론들이 제조시스템의 데이터 획득 문제를 극복하고 예측 모델의 성능을 높일 수 있음을 확인하였다.1. Introduction 1 2. Literature Review 9 2.1 Review of Related Methodologies 9 2.1.1 Active Learning 9 2.1.2 Active Feature-value Acquisition 11 2.1.3 Domain Adaptation 14 2.2 Review of Predictive Modelings in Manufacturing 15 2.2.1 Wafer Map Pattern Classification 15 2.2.2 Fault Detection and Classification 16 3. Active Learning for Wafer Map Pattern Classification 19 3.1 Problem Description 19 3.2 Proposed Method 21 3.2.1 System overview 21 3.2.2 Prediction model 25 3.2.3 Uncertainty estimation 25 3.2.4 Query wafer selection 29 3.2.5 Query wafer labeling 30 3.2.6 Model update 30 3.3 Experiments 31 3.3.1 Data description 31 3.3.2 Experimental design 31 3.3.3 Results and discussion 34 4. Active Cluster Annotation for Wafer Map Pattern Classification 42 4.1 Problem Description 42 4.2 Proposed Method 44 4.2.1 Clustering of unlabeled data 46 4.2.2 CNN training with labeled data 48 4.2.3 Cluster-level uncertainty estimation 49 4.2.4 Query cluster selection 50 4.2.5 Cluster-level annotation 50 4.3 Experiments 51 4.3.1 Data description 51 4.3.2 Experimental setting 51 4.3.3 Clustering results 53 4.3.4 Classification performance 54 4.3.5 Analysis for label noise 57 5. Active Inspection for Fault Prediction 60 5.1 Problem Description 60 5.2 Proposed Method 65 5.2.1 Active inspection framework 65 5.2.2 Acquisition based on Expected Prediction Change 68 5.3 Experiments 71 5.3.1 Data description 71 5.3.2 Fault prediction models 72 5.3.3 Experimental design 73 5.3.4 Results and discussion 74 6. Adaptive Fault Detection for Recipe Transition 76 6.1 Problem Description 76 6.2 Proposed Method 78 6.2.1 Overview 78 6.2.2 Unsupervised adaptation phase 81 6.2.3 Semi-supervised adaptation phase 83 6.3 Experiments 85 6.3.1 Data description 85 6.3.2 Experimental setting 85 6.3.3 Performance degradation caused by recipe transition 86 6.3.4 Effect of unsupervised adaptation 87 6.3.5 Effect of semi-supervised adaptation 88 7. Conclusion 91 7.1 Contributions 91 7.2 Future work 94Docto

Deep CNN-Based Automated Optical Inspection for Aerospace Components

ABSTRACT The defect detection problem is of outmost importance in high-tech industries such as aerospace manufacturing and is widely employed using automated industrial quality control systems. In the aerospace manufacturing industry, composite materials are extensively applied as structural components in civilian and military aircraft. To ensure the quality of the product and high reliability, manual inspection and traditional automatic optical inspection have been employed to identify the defects throughout production and maintenance. These inspection techniques have several limitations such as tedious, time- consuming, inconsistent, subjective, labor intensive, expensive, etc. To make the operation effective and efficient, modern automated optical inspection needs to be preferred. In this dissertation work, automatic defect detection techniques are tested on three levels using a novel aerospace composite materials image dataset (ACMID). First, classical machine learning models, namely, Support Vector Machine and Random Forest, are employed for both datasets. Second, deep CNN-based models, such as improved ResNet50 and MobileNetV2 architectures are trained on ACMID datasets. Third, an efficient defect detection technique that combines the features of deep learning and classical machine learning model is proposed for ACMID dataset. To assess the aerospace composite components, all the models are trained and tested on ACMID datasets with distinct sizes. In addition, this work investigates the scenario when defective and non-defective samples are scarce and imbalanced. To overcome the problems of imbalanced and scarce datasets, oversampling techniques and data augmentation using improved deep convolutional generative adversarial networks (DCGAN) are considered. Furthermore, the proposed models are also validated using one of the benchmark steel surface defects (SSD) dataset

A Review and Analysis of Automatic Optical Inspection and Quality Monitoring Methods in Electronics Industry

Electronics industry is one of the fastest evolving, innovative, and most competitive industries. In order to meet the high consumption demands on electronics components, quality standards of the products must be well-maintained. Automatic optical inspection (AOI) is one of the non-destructive techniques used in quality inspection of various products. This technique is considered robust and can replace human inspectors who are subjected to dull and fatigue in performing inspection tasks. A fully automated optical inspection system consists of hardware and software setups. Hardware setup include image sensor and illumination settings and is responsible to acquire the digital image, while the software part implements an inspection algorithm to extract the features of the acquired images and classify them into defected and non-defected based on the user requirements. A sorting mechanism can be used to separate the defective products from the good ones. This article provides a comprehensive review of the various AOI systems used in electronics, micro-electronics, and opto-electronics industries. In this review the defects of the commonly inspected electronic components, such as semiconductor wafers, flat panel displays, printed circuit boards and light emitting diodes, are first explained. Hardware setups used in acquiring images are then discussed in terms of the camera and lighting source selection and configuration. The inspection algorithms used for detecting the defects in the electronic components are discussed in terms of the preprocessing, feature extraction and classification tools used for this purpose. Recent articles that used deep learning algorithms are also reviewed. The article concludes by highlighting the current trends and possible future research directions.Framework of the IQONIC Project; European Union’s Horizon 2020 Research and Innovation Program

YOLOv8 for Defect Inspection of Hexagonal Directed Self-Assembly Patterns: A Data-Centric Approach

Shrinking pattern dimensions leads to an increased variety of defect types in semiconductor devices. This has spurred innovation in patterning approaches such as Directed self-assembly (DSA) for which no traditional, automatic defect inspection software exists. Machine Learning-based SEM image analysis has become an increasingly popular research topic for defect inspection with supervised ML models often showing the best performance. However, little research has been done on obtaining a dataset with high-quality labels for these supervised models. In this work, we propose a method for obtaining coherent and complete labels for a dataset of hexagonal contact hole DSA patterns while requiring minimal quality control effort from a DSA expert. We show that YOLOv8, a state-of-the-art neural network, achieves defect detection precisions of more than 0.9 mAP on our final dataset which best reflects DSA expert defect labeling expectations. We discuss the strengths and limitations of our proposed labeling approach and suggest directions for future work in data-centric ML-based defect inspection.Comment: 8 pages, 10 figures, accepted for the 38th EMLC Conference 202

AI/ML Algorithms and Applications in VLSI Design and Technology

An evident challenge ahead for the integrated circuit (IC) industry in the nanometer regime is the investigation and development of methods that can reduce the design complexity ensuing from growing process variations and curtail the turnaround time of chip manufacturing. Conventional methodologies employed for such tasks are largely manual; thus, time-consuming and resource-intensive. In contrast, the unique learning strategies of artificial intelligence (AI) provide numerous exciting automated approaches for handling complex and data-intensive tasks in very-large-scale integration (VLSI) design and testing. Employing AI and machine learning (ML) algorithms in VLSI design and manufacturing reduces the time and effort for understanding and processing the data within and across different abstraction levels via automated learning algorithms. It, in turn, improves the IC yield and reduces the manufacturing turnaround time. This paper thoroughly reviews the AI/ML automated approaches introduced in the past towards VLSI design and manufacturing. Moreover, we discuss the scope of AI/ML applications in the future at various abstraction levels to revolutionize the field of VLSI design, aiming for high-speed, highly intelligent, and efficient implementations

Machine Learning in Manufacturing towards Industry 4.0: From ‘For Now’ to ‘Four-Know’

While attracting increasing research attention in science and technology, Machine Learning (ML) is playing a critical role in the digitalization of manufacturing operations towards Industry 4.0. Recently, ML has been applied in several fields of production engineering to solve a variety of tasks with different levels of complexity and performance. However, in spite of the enormous number of ML use cases, there is no guidance or standard for developing ML solutions from ideation to deployment. This paper aims to address this problem by proposing an ML application roadmap for the manufacturing industry based on the state-of-the-art published research on the topic. First, this paper presents two dimensions for formulating ML tasks, namely, ’Four-Know’ (Know-what, Know-why, Know-when, Know-how) and ’Four-Level’ (Product, Process, Machine, System). These are used to analyze ML development trends in manufacturing. Then, the paper provides an implementation pipeline starting from the very early stages of ML solution development and summarizes the available ML methods, including supervised learning methods, semi-supervised methods, unsupervised methods, and reinforcement methods, along with their typical applications. Finally, the paper discusses the current challenges during ML applications and provides an outline of possible directions for future developments

A novel approach for wafer defect pattern classification based on topological data analysis

In semiconductor manufacturing, wafer map defect pattern provides critical information for facility maintenance and yield management, so the classification of defect patterns is one of the most important tasks in the manufacturing process. In this paper, we propose a novel way to represent the shape of the defect pattern as a finite-dimensional vector, which will be used as an input for a neural network algorithm for classification. The main idea is to extract the topological features of each pattern by using the theory of persistent homology from topological data analysis (TDA). Through some experiments with a simulated dataset, we show that the proposed method is faster and much more efficient in training with higher accuracy, compared with the method using convolutional neural networks (CNN) which is the most common approach for wafer map defect pattern classification. Moreover, our method outperforms the CNN-based method when the number of training data is not enough and is imbalanced