A framework for distributed manufacturing applications

The new organisational structures used in world wide manufacturing systems require the development of distributed applications, which present solutions to their requirements. The work research in the distributed manufacturing control leads to emergent paradigms, such as Holonic Manufacturing Systems (HMS) and Bionic Manufacturing Systems (BMS), which translates the concepts from social organisations and biological systems to the manufacturing world. This paper present a Framework for the development of distributed manufacturing applications, based in an agent-based architecture, which implements some Holonic and Bionic Manufacturing Systems concepts

A holonic manufacturing architecture for line-less mobile assembly systems operations planning and control

Dissertação (mestrado) - Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina, Centro Tecnológico, Programa de Pós-Graduação em Engenharia de Automação e Sistemas, Florianópolis, 2022.O Line-Less Mobile Assembly Systems (LMAS) é um paradigma de fabricação que visa maximizar a resposta às tendências do mercado através de configurações adaptáveis de fábrica utilizando recursos de montagem móvel. Tais sistemas podem ser caracterizados como holonic manufacturing systems (HMS), cujas chamadas holonic control architecture (HCA) são recentemente retratadas como abordagens habilitadoras da Indústria 4.0 devido a suas relações de entidades temporárias (hierárquicas e/ou heterárquicas). Embora as estruturas de referência HCA como PROSA ou ADACOR/ADACOR² tenham sido muito discutidas na literatura, nenhuma delas pode ser aplicada diretamente ao contexto LMAS. Assim, esta dissertação visa responder à pergunta \"Como uma arquitetura de produção e sistema de controle LMAS precisa ser projetada?\" apresentando os modelos de projeto de arquitetura desenvolvidos de acordo com as etapas da metodologia para desenvolvimento de sistemas holônicos multi-agentes ANEMONA. A fase de análise da ANEMONA resulta em uma especificação do caso de uso, requisitos, objetivos do sistema, simplificações e suposições. A fase de projeto resulta nos modelos de organização, interação e agentes, seguido de uma breve análise de sua cobertura comportamental. O resultado da fase de implementação é um protótipo (realizado com o Robot Operation System) que implementa os modelos ANEMONA e uma ontologia LMAS, que reutiliza elementos de ontologias de referência do domínio de manufatura. A fim de testar o protótipo, um algoritmo para geração de dados para teste baseado na complexidade dos produtos e na flexibilidade do chão de fábrica é apresentado. A validação qualitativa dos modelos HCA é baseada em como o HCA proposto atende a critérios específicos para avaliar sistemas HCA. A validação é complementada por uma análise quantitativa considerando o comportamento dos modelos implementados durante a execução normal e a execução interrompida (e.g. equipamento defeituoso) em um ambiente simulado. A validação da execução normal concentra-se no desvio de tempo entre as agendas planejadas e executadas, o que provou ser em média irrelevante dentro do caso simulado considerando a ordem de magnitude das operações típicas demandadas. Posteriormente, durante a execução do caso interrompido, o sistema é testado sob a simulação de uma falha, onde duas estratégias são aplicadas, LOCAL\_FIX e REORGANIZATION, e seu resultado é comparado para decidir qual é a opção apropriada quando o objetivo é reduzir o tempo total de execução. Finalmente, é apresentada uma análise sobre a cobertura desta dissertação culminando em diretrizes que podem ser vistas como uma resposta possível (entre muitas outras) para a questão de pesquisa apresentada. Além disso, são apresentados pontos fortes e fracos dos modelos desenvolvidos, e possíveis melhorias e idéias para futuras contribuições para a implementação de sistemas de controle holônico para LMAS.Abstract: The Line-Less Mobile Assembly Systems (LMAS) is a manufacturing paradigm aiming to maximize responsiveness to market trends (product-individualization and ever-shortening product lifecycles) by adaptive factory configurations utilizing mobile assembly resources. Such responsive systems can be characterized as holonic manufacturing systems (HMS), whose so-called holonic control architectures (HCA) are recently portrayed as Industry 4.0-enabling approaches due to their mixed-hierarchical and -heterarchical temporary entity relationships. They are particularly suitable for distributed and flexible systems as the Line-Less Mobile Assembly or Matrix-Production, as they meet reconfigurability capabilities. Though HCA reference structures as PROSA or ADACOR/ADACOR² have been heavily discussed in the literature, neither can directly be applied to the LMAS context. Methodologies such as ANEMONA provide guidelines and best practices for the development of holonic multi-agent systems. Accordingly, this dissertation aims to answer the question \"How does an LMAS production and control system architecture need to be designed?\" presenting the architecture design models developed according to the steps of the ANEMONA methodology. The ANEMONA analysis phase results in a use case specification, requirements, system goals, simplifications, and assumptions. The design phase results in an LMAS architecture design consisting of the organization, interaction, and agent models followed by a brief analysis of its behavioral coverage. The implementation phase result is an LMAS ontology, which reuses elements from the widespread manufacturing domain ontologies MAnufacturing's Semantics Ontology (MASON) and Manufacturing Resource Capability Ontology (MaRCO) enriched with essential holonic concepts. The architecture approach and ontology are implemented using the Robot Operating System (ROS) robotic framework. In order to create test data sets validation, an algorithm for test generation based on the complexity of products and the shopfloor flexibility is presented considering a maximum number of operations per work station and the maximum number of simultaneous stations. The validation phase presents a two-folded validation: qualitative and quantitative. The qualitative validation of the HCA models is based on how the proposed HCA attends specific criteria for evaluating HCA systems (e.g., modularity, integrability, diagnosability, fault tolerance, distributability, developer training requirements). The validation is complemented by a quantitative analysis considering the behavior of the implemented models during the normal execution and disrupted execution (e.g.; defective equipment) in a simulated environment (in the form of a software prototype). The normal execution validation focuses on the time drift between the planned and executed schedules, which has proved to be irrelevant within the simulated case considering the order of magnitude of the typical demanded operations. Subsequently, during the disrupted case execution, the system is tested under the simulation of a failure, where two strategies are applied, LOCAL\_FIX and REORGANIZATION, and their outcome is compared to decide which one is the appropriate option when the goal is to reduce the overall execution time. Ultimately, it is presented an analysis about the coverage of this dissertation culminating into guidelines that can be seen as one possible answer (among many others) for the presented research question. Furthermore, strong and weak points of the developed models are presented, and possible improvements and ideas for future contributions towards the implementation of holonic control systems for LMAS

A holonic multi-agent methodology to design sustainable intelligent manufacturing control systems

[EN] The urgent need for sustainable development is imposing radical changes in the way manufacturing systems are designed and implemented. The overall sustainability in industrial activities of manufacturing companies must be achieved at the same time that they face unprecedented levels of global competition. Therefore, there is a well-known need for tools and methods that can support the design and implementation of these systems in an effective way. This paper proposes an engineering method that helps researchers to design sustainable intelligent manufacturing systems. The approach is focused on the identification of the manufacturing components and the design and integration of sustainability-oriented mechanisms in the system specification, providing specific development guidelines and tools with built-in support for sustainable features. Besides, a set of case studies is presented in order to assess the proposed method.This research was supported by research projects TIN2015-65515-C4-1-R and TIN2016-80856-R from the Spanish government. The authors would like to acknowledge T. Bonte for her contribution to the NetLogo simulator of the AIP PRIMECA cell.Giret Boggino, AS.; Trentesaux, D.; Salido Gregorio, MÁ.; Garcia, E.; Adam, E. (2017). A holonic multi-agent methodology to design sustainable intelligent manufacturing control systems. Journal of Cleaner Production. 167(1):1370-1386. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2017.03.079S13701386167

An agile and adaptive holonic architecture for manufacturing control

In the last decades significant changes in the manufacturing environment have been noticed: moving from a local economy towards a global economy, with markets asking for products with high quality at lower costs, highly customised and with short life cycle. In this environment, the manufacturing enterprises, to avoid the risk to lose competitiveness, search to answer more closely to the customer demands, by improving their flexibility and agility, while maintaining their productivity and quality. Actually, the dynamic response to emergence is becoming a key issue, due to the weak response of the traditional manufacturing control systems to unexpected disturbances, mainly because of the rigidity of their control architectures. In these circumstances, the challenge is to develop manufacturing control systems with autonomy and intelligence capabilities, fast adaptation to the environment changes, more robustness against the occurrence of disturbances, and easier integration of manufacturing resources and legacy systems. Several architectures using emergent concepts and technologies have been proposed, in particular those based in the holonic manufacturing paradigm. Holonic manufacturing is a paradigm based in the ideas of the philosopher Arthur Koestler, who proposed the word holon to describe a basic unit of organisation in biological and social systems. A holon, as Koestler devised the term, is an identifiable part of a (manufacturing) system that has a unique identity, yet is made up of sub-ordinate parts and in turn is part of a larger whole. The introduction of the holonic manufacturing paradigm allows a new approach to the manufacturing problem, bringing the advantages of modularity, decentralisation, autonomy, scalability, and re-use of software components. This dissertation intends to develop an agile and adaptive manufacturing control architecture to face the current requirements imposed to the manufacturing enterprises. The architecture proposed in this dissertation addresses the need for the fast reaction to disturbances at the shop floor level, increasing the agility and flexibility of the enterprise, when it works in volatile environments, characterised by the frequent occurrence of unexpected disturbances. The proposed architecture, designated by ADACOR (ADAptive holonic COntrol aRchitecture for distributed manufacturing systems), is based in the holonic manufacturing paradigm, build upon autonomous and cooperative holons, allowing the development of manufacturing control applications that present all the features of decentralised and holonic systems. ADACOR holonic architecture introduces an adaptive control that balances dynamically between a more centralised structure and a more decentralised one, allowing to combine the global production optimisation with agile reaction to unexpected disturbances. Nas últimas décadas têm-se assistido a mudanças significativas no ambiente de fabrico: evoluindo de uma economia local para um economia global, com os mercados a procurar produtos com elevada qualidade a baixos preços, altamente customizados e com um ciclo de vida curto. Neste ambiente, as empresas de manufactura, para evitar o risco de perda de competitividade, procuram responder às solicitações dos clientes, melhorando a sua flexibilidade e agilidade, mantendo os mesmos índices de produtividade e qualidade. Na verdade, a resposta dinâmica à emergência está a tornar-se num assunto chave, devido `a fraca resposta a perturbações que os sistemas de controlo de fabrico tradicionais apresentam, principalmente devido à rigidez das suas arquitecturas de controlo. Nestas circunstâncias, é fundamental o desenvolvimento de sistemas de controlo de fabrico com capacidades de autonomia e inteligência, rápida adaptação às mudanças, maior robustez à ocorrência de perturbações e fácil integração de recursos físicos e sistemas legados. Diversas arquitecturas usando conceitos e tecnologias emergentes têm sido propostas, em particular algumas baseadas no paradigma da produção holónica. O paradigma da produção holónica é inspirado nas ideias de Arthur Koestler, que propôs a palavra holon para descrever uma unidade básica de organização de sistemas biológicos e sociais. Um holon, de acordo com a definição de Koestler, é uma parte identificável do sistema com identidade única, composta por sub-partes e fazendo simultaneamente parte do todo. A introdução do paradigma da produção holónica permite uma nova abordagem aos sistemas de controlo de fabrico, trazendo vantagens de modularidade, descentralização, autonomia, escalabilidade e reutilização de componentes. Esta dissertação pretende desenvolver uma arquitectura de controlo ágil e adaptativa que suporte os requisitos actuais impostos `as empresas de manufactura. A arquitectura proposta visa a necessidade de uma reacção rápida a perturbações, ao nível da planta fabril, melhorando a flexibilidade e agilidade da empresa quando esta opera em ambientes voláteis, caracterizados pela ocorrência frequente de perturbações inesperadas. A arquitectura proposta, designada por ADACOR (ADAptive holonic COntrol aRchitecture for distributed manufacturing systems), é baseada no paradigma da produção holónica e construída sobre holons autónomos e cooperativos, permitindo o desenvolvimento de aplicações de controlo de fabrico que apresentem todas as características dos sistemas descentralizados e holónicos. A arquitectura holónica ADACOR introduz um controlo adaptativo que balança dinamicamente entre uma estrutura de controlo mais centralizada e uma mais descentralizada, permitindo combinar a optimização da produção com a ágil reacção a perturbações

Life Cycle Engineering 4.0: A Proposal to Conceive Manufacturing Systems for Industry 4.0 Centred on the Human Factor (DfHFinI4.0)

Engineering 4.0 environments are characterised by the digitisation, virtualisation, and connectivity of products, processes, and facilities composed of reconfigurable and adaptive socio-technical cyber-physical manufacturing systems (SCMS), in which Operator 4.0 works in real time in VUCA (volatile, uncertain, complex and ambiguous) contexts and markets. This situation gives rise to the interest in developing a framework for the conception of SCMS that allows the integration of the human factor, management, training, and development of the competencies of Operator 4.0 as fundamental aspects of the aforementioned system. The present paper is focused on answering how to conceive the adaptive manufacturing systems of Industry 4.0 through the operation, growth, and development of human talent in VUCA contexts. With this objective, exploratory research is carried, out whose contribution is specified in a framework called Design for the Human Factor in Industry 4.0 (DfHFinI4.0). From among the conceptual frameworks employed therein, the connectivist paradigm, Ashby's law of requisite variety and Vigotsky's activity theory are taken into consideration, in order to enable the affective-cognitive and timeless integration of the human factor within the SCMS. DfHFinI4.0 can be integrated into the life cycle engineering of the enterprise reference architectures, thereby obtaining manufacturing systems for Industry 4.0 focused on the human factor. The suggested framework is illustrated as a case study for the Purdue Enterprise Reference Architecture (PERA) methodology, which transforms it into PERA 4.0

Arquitectura Basada en Roles Aplicada en Equipos de Fútbol de Robots con Control Centralizado

[EN] Borrar Robot soccer offers an adequate domain in order to design and validate architectures for robot-coordination. One classification refers to centralized architectures, which correspond to robot soccer environments with global perception and centralized control of the robots, using only one decision-making system. In this paper it is presented a centralized robot soccer architecture based on roles, where one role is assigned to each player in order to select a specific behaviour depending on game conditions. Roles are assigned using an assignment function, which is activated when the ball changes of the quadrant in the playing field. This strategy has been compared by simulation in games against an opposition team with constant roles, and other team with a hierarchical strategy which assigns roles depending on a tactic previously selected. The results showed a better performance in the team with the role-based[ES] El fútbol de robots ofrece un entorno adecuado para el diseño y la validación de arquitecturas de sistemas multi-robot. Al clasificar las ligas de fútbol de robots existentes se encuentran ligas con arquitecturas centralizadas que poseen percepción global del entorno y donde los robots son controlados desde un ordenador a través de un único sistema de toma de decisiones. En este artículo se presenta una arquitectura basada en roles para equipos de fútbol de robots con percepción global y control centralizado. En esta arquitectura un rol es seleccionado para cada jugador por medio de una función. A partir de este rol y de las condiciones de juego presentes se selecciona un comportamiento que el jugador deberá ejecutar. La función que es utilizada para la asignación de roles es activada cuando el balón cambia de cuadrante en el campo de juego. La estrategia presentada es comparada en simulación realizando partidos contra un equipo que posee una estrategia de roles constantes y un equipo con una estrategia jerárquica basada en selección de tácticas y posteriormente asignación de roles a partir de la táctica seleccionada. Los resultados mostraron no solo un mejor rendimiento del equipo con la estrategia basada en roles, sino también uniformidad en los comportamientos realizados por los jugadores del equipo durante las transiciones de roles y comportamientos.Jose Guillermo Guarnizo há sido financiado por una beca del Departamento Administrativo de Ciencia, Tecnologia e Innovación COLCIENCIAS, Colombia.Guarnizo Marín, JG.; Mellado Arteche, M. (2016). Arquitectura Basada en Roles Aplicada en Equipos de Fútbol de Robots con Control Centralizado. Revista Iberoamericana de Automática e Informática Industrial RIAI. 13(3):370-380. doi:10.1016/j.riai.2016.05.005S37038013