23 research outputs found
Performance Evaluation of Smart Decision Support Systems on Healthcare
Medical activity requires responsibility not only from clinical knowledge and skill but
also on the management of an enormous amount of information related to patient care. It is
through proper treatment of information that experts can consistently build a healthy wellness
policy. The primary objective for the development of decision support systems (DSSs) is
to provide information to specialists when and where they are needed. These systems provide
information, models, and data manipulation tools to help experts make better decisions in a
variety of situations.
Most of the challenges that smart DSSs face come from the great difficulty of dealing
with large volumes of information, which is continuously generated by the most diverse types
of devices and equipment, requiring high computational resources. This situation makes this
type of system susceptible to not recovering information quickly for the decision making. As a
result of this adversity, the information quality and the provision of an infrastructure capable
of promoting the integration and articulation among different health information systems (HIS)
become promising research topics in the field of electronic health (e-health) and that, for this
same reason, are addressed in this research. The work described in this thesis is motivated
by the need to propose novel approaches to deal with problems inherent to the acquisition,
cleaning, integration, and aggregation of data obtained from different sources in e-health environments,
as well as their analysis.
To ensure the success of data integration and analysis in e-health environments, it
is essential that machine-learning (ML) algorithms ensure system reliability. However, in this
type of environment, it is not possible to guarantee a reliable scenario. This scenario makes
intelligent SAD susceptible to predictive failures, which severely compromise overall system
performance. On the other hand, systems can have their performance compromised due to the
overload of information they can support.
To solve some of these problems, this thesis presents several proposals and studies
on the impact of ML algorithms in the monitoring and management of hypertensive disorders
related to pregnancy of risk. The primary goals of the proposals presented in this thesis are
to improve the overall performance of health information systems. In particular, ML-based
methods are exploited to improve the prediction accuracy and optimize the use of monitoring
device resources. It was demonstrated that the use of this type of strategy and methodology
contributes to a significant increase in the performance of smart DSSs, not only concerning precision
but also in the computational cost reduction used in the classification process.
The observed results seek to contribute to the advance of state of the art in methods
and strategies based on AI that aim to surpass some challenges that emerge from the integration
and performance of the smart DSSs. With the use of algorithms based on AI, it is possible to
quickly and automatically analyze a larger volume of complex data and focus on more accurate
results, providing high-value predictions for a better decision making in real time and without
human intervention.A atividade médica requer responsabilidade não apenas com base no conhecimento
e na habilidade clínica, mas também na gestão de uma enorme quantidade de informações
relacionadas ao atendimento ao paciente. É através do tratamento adequado das informações
que os especialistas podem consistentemente construir uma política saudável de bem-estar. O
principal objetivo para o desenvolvimento de sistemas de apoio à decisão (SAD) é fornecer informações
aos especialistas onde e quando são necessárias. Esses sistemas fornecem informações,
modelos e ferramentas de manipulação de dados para ajudar os especialistas a tomar melhores
decisões em diversas situações.
A maioria dos desafios que os SAD inteligentes enfrentam advêm da grande dificuldade
de lidar com grandes volumes de dados, que é gerada constantemente pelos mais diversos
tipos de dispositivos e equipamentos, exigindo elevados recursos computacionais. Essa situação
torna este tipo de sistemas suscetível a não recuperar a informação rapidamente para a
tomada de decisão. Como resultado dessa adversidade, a qualidade da informação e a provisão
de uma infraestrutura capaz de promover a integração e a articulação entre diferentes sistemas
de informação em saúde (SIS) tornam-se promissores tópicos de pesquisa no campo da saúde
eletrônica (e-saúde) e que, por essa mesma razão, são abordadas nesta investigação. O trabalho
descrito nesta tese é motivado pela necessidade de propor novas abordagens para lidar
com os problemas inerentes à aquisição, limpeza, integração e agregação de dados obtidos de
diferentes fontes em ambientes de e-saúde, bem como sua análise.
Para garantir o sucesso da integração e análise de dados em ambientes e-saúde é
importante que os algoritmos baseados em aprendizagem de máquina (AM) garantam a confiabilidade
do sistema. No entanto, neste tipo de ambiente, não é possível garantir um cenário
totalmente confiável. Esse cenário torna os SAD inteligentes suscetíveis à presença de falhas
de predição que comprometem seriamente o desempenho geral do sistema. Por outro lado, os
sistemas podem ter seu desempenho comprometido devido à sobrecarga de informações que
podem suportar.
Para tentar resolver alguns destes problemas, esta tese apresenta várias propostas e
estudos sobre o impacto de algoritmos de AM na monitoria e gestão de transtornos hipertensivos
relacionados com a gravidez (gestação) de risco. O objetivo das propostas apresentadas nesta
tese é melhorar o desempenho global de sistemas de informação em saúde. Em particular, os
métodos baseados em AM são explorados para melhorar a precisão da predição e otimizar o
uso dos recursos dos dispositivos de monitorização. Ficou demonstrado que o uso deste tipo
de estratégia e metodologia contribui para um aumento significativo do desempenho dos SAD
inteligentes, não só em termos de precisão, mas também na diminuição do custo computacional
utilizado no processo de classificação.
Os resultados observados buscam contribuir para o avanço do estado da arte em métodos
e estratégias baseadas em inteligência artificial que visam ultrapassar alguns desafios que
advêm da integração e desempenho dos SAD inteligentes. Como o uso de algoritmos baseados
em inteligência artificial é possível analisar de forma rápida e automática um volume maior de
dados complexos e focar em resultados mais precisos, fornecendo previsões de alto valor para uma melhor tomada de decisão em tempo real e sem intervenção humana
A Novel Ontology and Machine Learning Driven Hybrid Clinical Decision Support Framework for Cardiovascular Preventative Care
Clinical risk assessment of chronic illnesses is a challenging and complex task which requires the utilisation of standardised clinical practice guidelines and documentation procedures in order to ensure consistent and efficient patient care. Conventional cardiovascular decision support systems have significant limitations, which include the inflexibility to deal with complex clinical processes, hard-wired rigid architectures based on branching logic and the inability to deal with legacy patient data without significant software engineering work. In light of these challenges, we are proposing a novel ontology and machine learning-driven hybrid clinical decision support framework for cardiovascular preventative care.
An ontology-inspired approach provides a foundation for information collection, knowledge acquisition and decision support capabilities and aims to develop context sensitive decision support solutions based on ontology engineering principles. The proposed framework incorporates an ontology-driven clinical risk assessment and recommendation system (ODCRARS) and a Machine Learning Driven Prognostic System (MLDPS), integrated as a complete system to provide a cardiovascular preventative care solution. The proposed clinical decision support framework has been developed under the close supervision of clinical domain experts from both UK and US hospitals and is capable of handling multiple cardiovascular diseases.
The proposed framework comprises of two novel key components: (1) ODCRARS (2) MLDPS.
The ODCRARS is developed under the close supervision of consultant cardiologists Professor Calum MacRae from Harvard Medical School and Professor Stephen Leslie from Raigmore Hospital in Inverness, UK. The ODCRARS comprises of various components, which include:
(a) Ontology-driven intelligent context-aware information collection for conducting patient interviews which are driven through a novel clinical questionnaire ontology.
(b) A patient semantic profile, is generated using patient medical records which are collated during patient interviews (conducted through an ontology-driven context aware adaptive information collection component). The semantic transformation of patients’ medical data is carried out through a novel patient semantic profile ontology in order to give patient data an intrinsic meaning and alleviate interoperability issues with third party healthcare systems.
(c) Ontology driven clinical decision support comprises of a recommendation ontology and a NICE/Expert driven clinical rules engine. The recommendation ontology is developed using clinical rules provided by the consultant cardiologist from the US hospital. The recommendation ontology utilises the patient semantic profile for lab tests and medication recommendation.
A clinical rules engine is developed to implement a cardiac risk assessment mechanism for various cardiovascular conditions. The clinical rules engine is also utilised to control the patient flow within the integrated cardiovascular preventative care solution.
The machine learning-driven prognostic system is developed in an iterative manner using state of the art feature selection and machine learning techniques. A prognostic model development process is exploited for the development of MLDPS based on clinical case studies in the cardiovascular domain. An additional clinical case study in the breast cancer domain is also carried out for the development and validation purposes. The prognostic model development process is general enough to handle a variety of healthcare datasets which will enable researchers to develop cost effective and evidence based clinical decision support systems.
The proposed clinical decision support framework also provides a learning mechanism based on machine learning techniques. Learning mechanism is provided through exchange of patient data amongst the MLDPS and the ODCRARS. The machine learning-driven prognostic system is validated using Raigmore Hospital's RACPC, heart disease and breast cancer clinical case studies
Recommended from our members
Ontology driven clinical decision support for early diagnostic recommendations
Diagnostic error is a significant problem in medicine and a major cause of concern for patients and clinicians and is associated with moderate to severe harm to patients. Diagnostic errors are a primary cause of clinical negligence and can result in malpractice claims. Cognitive errors caused by biases such as premature closure and confirmation bias have been identified as major cause of diagnostic error. Researchers have identified several strategies to reduce diagnostic error arising from cognitive factors. This includes considering alternatives, reducing reliance on memory, providing access to clear and well-organized information. Clinical Decision Support Systems (CDSSs) have been shown to reduce diagnostic errors.
Clinical guidelines improve consistency of care and can potentially improve healthcare efficiency. They can alert clinicians to diagnostic tests and procedures that have the greatest evidence and provide the greatest benefit. Clinical guidelines can be used to streamline clinical decision making and provide the knowledge base for guideline based CDSSs and clinical alert systems. Clinical guidelines can potentially improve diagnostic decision making by improving information gathering.
Argumentation is an emerging area for dealing with unstructured evidence in domains such as healthcare that are characterized by uncertainty. The knowledge needed to support decision making is expressed in the form of arguments. Argumentation has certain advantages over other decision support reasoning methods. This includes the ability to function with incomplete information, the ability to capture domain knowledge in an easy manner, using non-monotonic logic to support defeasible reasoning and providing recommendations in a manner that can be easily explained to clinicians. Argumentation is therefore a suitable method for generating early diagnostic recommendations. Argumentation-based CDSSs have been developed in a wide variety of clinical domains. However, the impact of an argumentation-based diagnostic Clinical Decision Support System (CDSS) has not been evaluated yet.
The first part of this thesis evaluates the impact of guideline recommendations and an argumentation-based diagnostic CDSS on clinician information gathering and diagnostic decision making. In addition, the impact of guideline recommendations on management decision making was evaluated. The study found that argumentation is a viable method for generating diagnostic recommendations that can potentially help reduce diagnostic error. The study showed that guideline recommendations do have a positive impact on information gathering of optometrists and can potentially help optometrists in asking the right questions and performing tests as per current standards of care. Guideline recommendations were found to have a positive impact on management decision making. The CDSS is dependent on quality of data that is entered into the system. Faulty interpretation of data can lead the clinician to enter wrong data and cause the CDSS to provide wrong recommendations.
Current generation argumentation-based CDSSs and other diagnostic decision support systems have problems with semantic interoperability that prevents them from using data from the web. The clinician and CDSS is limited to information collected during a clinical encounter and cannot access information on the web that could be relevant to a patient. This is due to the distributed nature of medical information and lack of semantic interoperability between healthcare systems. Current argumentation-based decision support applications require specialized tools for modelling and execution and this prevents widespread use and adoption of these tools especially when these tools require additional training and licensing arrangements.
Semantic web and linked data technologies have been developed to overcome problems with semantic interoperability on the web. Ontology-based diagnostic CDSS applications have been developed using semantic web technology to overcome problems with semantic interoperability of healthcare data in decision support applications. However, these models have problems with expressiveness, requiring specialized software and algorithms for generating diagnostic recommendations.
The second part of this thesis describes the development of an argumentation-based ontology driven diagnostic model and CDSS that can execute this model to generate ranked diagnostic recommendations. This novel model called the Disease-Symptom Model combines strengths of argumentation with strengths of semantic web technology. The model allows the domain expert to model arguments favouring and negating a diagnosis using OWL/RDF language. The model uses a simple weighting scheme that represents the degree of support of each argument within the model. The model uses SPARQL to sum weights and produce a ranked diagnostic recommendation. The model can provide justifications for each recommendation in a manner that clinicians can easily understand. CDSS prototypes that can execute this ontology model to generate diagnostic recommendations were developed. The decision support prototypes demonstrated the ability to use a wide variety of data and access remote data sources using linked data technologies to generate recommendations. The thesis was able to demonstrate the development of an argumentation-based ontology driven diagnostic decision support model and decision support system that can integrate information from a variety of sources to generate diagnostic recommendations. This decision support application was developed without the use of specialized software and tools for modelling and execution, while using a simple modelling method.
The third part of this thesis details evaluation of the Disease-Symptom model across all stages of a clinical encounter by comparing the performance of the model with clinicians. The evaluation showed that the Disease-Symptom Model can provide a ranked diagnostic recommendation in early stages of the clinical encounter that is comparable to clinicians. The diagnostic performance can be improved in the early stages using linked data technologies to incorporate more information into the decision making. With limited information, depending on the type of case, the performance of the Disease-Symptom Model will vary. As more information is collected during the clinical encounter the decision support application can provide recommendations that is comparable to clinicians recruited for the study. The evaluation showed that even with a simple weighting and summation method used in the Disease- Symptom Model the diagnostic ranking was comparable to dentists. With limited information in the early stages of the clinical encounter the Disease-Symptom Model was able to provide an accurately ranked diagnostic recommendation validating the model and methods used in this thesis
Data ethics : building trust : how digital technologies can serve humanity
Data is the magic word of the 21st century. As oil in the 20th century and electricity in the 19th century:
For citizens, data means support in daily life in almost all activities, from watch to laptop, from kitchen to car,
from mobile phone to politics. For business and politics, data means power, dominance, winning the race. Data can be used for good and bad,
for services and hacking, for medicine and arms race. How can we build trust in this complex and ambiguous data world?
How can digital technologies serve humanity? The 45 articles in this book represent a broad range of ethical reflections and recommendations
in eight sections: a) Values, Trust and Law, b) AI, Robots and Humans, c) Health and Neuroscience, d) Religions for Digital Justice, e) Farming, Business, Finance, f) Security, War, Peace, g) Data Governance, Geopolitics, h) Media, Education, Communication.
The authors and institutions come from all continents.
The book serves as reading material for teachers, students, policy makers, politicians, business, hospitals, NGOs and religious organisations alike. It is an invitation for dialogue, debate and building trust!
The book is a continuation of the volume “Cyber Ethics 4.0” published in 2018 by the same editors
Decision Support Systems
Decision support systems (DSS) have evolved over the past four decades from theoretical concepts into real world computerized applications. DSS architecture contains three key components: knowledge base, computerized model, and user interface. DSS simulate cognitive decision-making functions of humans based on artificial intelligence methodologies (including expert systems, data mining, machine learning, connectionism, logistical reasoning, etc.) in order to perform decision support functions. The applications of DSS cover many domains, ranging from aviation monitoring, transportation safety, clinical diagnosis, weather forecast, business management to internet search strategy. By combining knowledge bases with inference rules, DSS are able to provide suggestions to end users to improve decisions and outcomes. This book is written as a textbook so that it can be used in formal courses examining decision support systems. It may be used by both undergraduate and graduate students from diverse computer-related fields. It will also be of value to established professionals as a text for self-study or for reference
Efficient Decision Support Systems
This series is directed to diverse managerial professionals who are leading the transformation of individual domains by using expert information and domain knowledge to drive decision support systems (DSSs). The series offers a broad range of subjects addressed in specific areas such as health care, business management, banking, agriculture, environmental improvement, natural resource and spatial management, aviation administration, and hybrid applications of information technology aimed to interdisciplinary issues. This book series is composed of three volumes: Volume 1 consists of general concepts and methodology of DSSs; Volume 2 consists of applications of DSSs in the biomedical domain; Volume 3 consists of hybrid applications of DSSs in multidisciplinary domains. The book is shaped decision support strategies in the new infrastructure that assists the readers in full use of the creative technology to manipulate input data and to transform information into useful decisions for decision makers
Telemedicine
Telemedicine is a rapidly evolving field as new technologies are implemented for example for the development of wireless sensors, quality data transmission. Using the Internet applications such as counseling, clinical consultation support and home care monitoring and management are more and more realized, which improves access to high level medical care in underserved areas. The 23 chapters of this book present manifold examples of telemedicine treating both theoretical and practical foundations and application scenarios
Interactive Three-Dimensional Simulation and Visualisation of Real Time Blood Flow in Vascular Networks
One of the challenges in cardiovascular disease management is the clinical
decision-making process. When a clinician is dealing with complex and uncertain
situations, the decision on whether or how to intervene is made based upon distinct
information from diverse sources. There are several variables that can affect how
the vascular system responds to treatment. These include: the extent of the damage
and scarring, the efficiency of blood flow remodelling, and any associated pathology.
Moreover, the effect of an intervention may lead to further unforeseen complications
(e.g. another stenosis may be “hidden” further along the vessel). Currently, there is
no tool for predicting or exploring such scenarios.
This thesis explores the development of a highly adaptive real-time simulation of
blood flow that considers patient specific data and clinician interaction. The simulation
should model blood realistically, accurately, and through complex vascular networks
in real-time. Developing robust flow scenarios that can be incorporated into the
decision and planning medical tool set. The focus will be on specific regions of the
anatomy, where accuracy is of the utmost importance and the flow can develop into
specific patterns, with the aim of better understanding their condition and predicting
factors of their future evolution. Results from the validation of the simulation showed
promising comparisons with the literature and demonstrated a viability for clinical
use