MinoanER: Schema-Agnostic, Non-Iterative, Massively Parallel Resolution of Web Entities

Entity Resolution (ER) aims to identify different descriptions in various Knowledge Bases (KBs) that refer to the same entity. ER is challenged by the Variety, Volume and Veracity of entity descriptions published in the Web of Data. To address them, we propose the MinoanER framework that simultaneously fulfills full automation, support of highly heterogeneous entities, and massive parallelization of the ER process. MinoanER leverages a token-based similarity of entities to define a new metric that derives the similarity of neighboring entities from the most important relations, as they are indicated only by statistics. A composite blocking method is employed to capture different sources of matching evidence from the content, neighbors, or names of entities. The search space of candidate pairs for comparison is compactly abstracted by a novel disjunctive blocking graph and processed by a non-iterative, massively parallel matching algorithm that consists of four generic, schema-agnostic matching rules that are quite robust with respect to their internal configuration. We demonstrate that the effectiveness of MinoanER is comparable to existing ER tools over real KBs exhibiting low Variety, but it outperforms them significantly when matching KBs with high Variety.Comment: Presented at EDBT 2001

Heterogeneous Entity Matching with Complex Attribute Associations using BERT and Neural Networks

Across various domains, data from different sources such as Baidu Baike and Wikipedia often manifest in distinct forms. Current entity matching methodologies predominantly focus on homogeneous data, characterized by attributes that share the same structure and concise attribute values. However, this orientation poses challenges in handling data with diverse formats. Moreover, prevailing approaches aggregate the similarity of attribute values between corresponding attributes to ascertain entity similarity. Yet, they often overlook the intricate interrelationships between attributes, where one attribute may have multiple associations. The simplistic approach of pairwise attribute comparison fails to harness the wealth of information encapsulated within entities.To address these challenges, we introduce a novel entity matching model, dubbed Entity Matching Model for Capturing Complex Attribute Relationships(EMM-CCAR),built upon pre-trained models. Specifically, this model transforms the matching task into a sequence matching problem to mitigate the impact of varying data formats. Moreover, by introducing attention mechanisms, it identifies complex relationships between attributes, emphasizing the degree of matching among multiple attributes rather than one-to-one correspondences. Through the integration of the EMM-CCAR model, we adeptly surmount the challenges posed by data heterogeneity and intricate attribute interdependencies. In comparison with the prevalent DER-SSM and Ditto approaches, our model achieves improvements of approximately 4% and 1% in F1 scores, respectively. This furnishes a robust solution for addressing the intricacies of attribute complexity in entity matching

Entity reconciliation in big data sources: A systematic mapping study

The entity reconciliation (ER) problem aroused much interest as a research topic in today’s Big Dataera, full of big and open heterogeneous data sources. This problem poses when relevant information ona topic needs to be obtained using methods based on: (i) identifying records that represent the samereal world entity, and (ii) identifying those records that are similar but do not correspond to the samereal-world entity. ER is an operational intelligence process, whereby organizations can unify differentand heterogeneous data sources in order to relate possible matches of non-obvious entities. Besides, thecomplexity that the heterogeneity of data sources involves, the large number of records and differencesamong languages, for instance, must be added. This paper describes a Systematic Mapping Study (SMS) ofjournal articles, conferences and workshops published from 2010 to 2017 to solve the problem describedbefore, first trying to understand the state-of-the-art, and then identifying any gaps in current research.Eleven digital libraries were analyzed following a systematic, semiautomatic and rigorous process thathas resulted in 61 primary studies. They represent a great variety of intelligent proposals that aim tosolve ER. The conclusion obtained is that most of the research is based on the operational phase asopposed to the design phase, and most studies have been tested on real-world data sources, where a lotof them are heterogeneous, but just a few apply to industry. There is a clear trend in research techniquesbased on clustering/blocking and graphs, although the level of automation of the proposals is hardly evermentioned in the research work.Ministerio de Economía y Competitividad TIN2013-46928-C3-3-RMinisterio de Economía y Competitividad TIN2016-76956-C3-2-RMinisterio de Economía y Competitividad TIN2015-71938-RED

End-to-End Entity Resolution for Big Data: A Survey

One of the most important tasks for improving data quality and the reliability of data analytics results is Entity Resolution (ER). ER aims to identify different descriptions that refer to the same real-world entity, and remains a challenging problem. While previous works have studied specific aspects of ER (and mostly in traditional settings), in this survey, we provide for the first time an end-to-end view of modern ER workflows, and of the novel aspects of entity indexing and matching methods in order to cope with more than one of the Big Data characteristics simultaneously. We present the basic concepts, processing steps and execution strategies that have been proposed by different communities, i.e., database, semantic Web and machine learning, in order to cope with the loose structuredness, extreme diversity, high speed and large scale of entity descriptions used by real-world applications. Finally, we provide a synthetic discussion of the existing approaches, and conclude with a detailed presentation of open research directions

STEM: stacked threshold-based entity matching for knowledge base generation

One of the major issues encountered in the generation of knowledge bases is the integration of data coming from a collection of heterogeneous data sources. A key essential task when integrating data instances is the entity matching. Entity matching is based on the definition of a similarity measure among entities and on the classification of the entity pair as a match if the similarity exceeds a certain threshold. This parameter introduces a trade-off between the precision and the recall of the algorithm, as higher values of the threshold lead to higher precision and lower recall, and lower values lead to higher recall and lower precision. In this paper, we propose a stacking approach for threshold-based classifiers. It runs several instances of classifiers corresponding to different thresholds and use their predictions as a feature vector for a supervised learner. We show that this approach is able to break the trade-off between the precision and recall of the algorithm, increasing both at the same time and enhancing the overall performance of the algorithm. We also show that this hybrid approach performs better and is less dependent on the amount of available training data with respect to a supervised learning approach that directly uses properties’ similarity values. In order to test the generality of the claim, we have run experimental tests using two different threshold-based classifiers on two different data sets. Finally, we show a concrete use case describing the implementation of the proposed approach in the generation of the 3cixty Nice knowledge base

Named Entity Resolution in Personal Knowledge Graphs

Entity Resolution (ER) is the problem of determining when two entities refer to the same underlying entity. The problem has been studied for over 50 years, and most recently, has taken on new importance in an era of large, heterogeneous 'knowledge graphs' published on the Web and used widely in domains as wide ranging as social media, e-commerce and search. This chapter will discuss the specific problem of named ER in the context of personal knowledge graphs (PKGs). We begin with a formal definition of the problem, and the components necessary for doing high-quality and efficient ER. We also discuss some challenges that are expected to arise for Web-scale data. Next, we provide a brief literature review, with a special focus on how existing techniques can potentially apply to PKGs. We conclude the chapter by covering some applications, as well as promising directions for future research.Comment: To appear as a book chapter by the same name in an upcoming (Oct. 2023) book `Personal Knowledge Graphs (PKGs): Methodology, tools and applications' edited by Tiwari et a

How does prompt engineering affect ChatGPT performance on unsupervised entity resolution?

Entity Resolution (ER) is the problem of semi-automatically determining when two entities refer to the same underlying entity, with applications ranging from healthcare to e-commerce. Traditional ER solutions required considerable manual expertise, including feature engineering, as well as identification and curation of training data. In many instances, such techniques are highly dependent on the domain. With recent advent in large language models (LLMs), there is an opportunity to make ER much more seamless and domain-independent. However, it is also well known that LLMs can pose risks, and that the quality of their outputs can depend on so-called prompt engineering. Unfortunately, a systematic experimental study on the effects of different prompting methods for addressing ER, using LLMs like ChatGPT, has been lacking thus far. This paper aims to address this gap by conducting such a study. Although preliminary in nature, our results show that prompting can significantly affect the quality of ER, although it affects some metrics more than others, and can also be dataset dependent

Mining complex trees for hidden fruit : a graph–based computational solution to detect latent criminal networks : a thesis presented in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Information Technology at Massey University, Albany, New Zealand.

The detection of crime is a complex and difficult endeavour. Public and private organisations – focusing on law enforcement, intelligence, and compliance – commonly apply the rational isolated actor approach premised on observability and materiality. This is manifested largely as conducting entity-level risk management sourcing ‘leads’ from reactive covert human intelligence sources and/or proactive sources by applying simple rules-based models. Focusing on discrete observable and material actors simply ignores that criminal activity exists within a complex system deriving its fundamental structural fabric from the complex interactions between actors - with those most unobservable likely to be both criminally proficient and influential. The graph-based computational solution developed to detect latent criminal networks is a response to the inadequacy of the rational isolated actor approach that ignores the connectedness and complexity of criminality. The core computational solution, written in the R language, consists of novel entity resolution, link discovery, and knowledge discovery technology. Entity resolution enables the fusion of multiple datasets with high accuracy (mean F-measure of 0.986 versus competitors 0.872), generating a graph-based expressive view of the problem. Link discovery is comprised of link prediction and link inference, enabling the high-performance detection (accuracy of ~0.8 versus relevant published models ~0.45) of unobserved relationships such as identity fraud. Knowledge discovery uses the fused graph generated and applies the “GraphExtract” algorithm to create a set of subgraphs representing latent functional criminal groups, and a mesoscopic graph representing how this set of criminal groups are interconnected. Latent knowledge is generated from a range of metrics including the “Super-broker” metric and attitude prediction. The computational solution has been evaluated on a range of datasets that mimic an applied setting, demonstrating a scalable (tested on ~18 million node graphs) and performant (~33 hours runtime on a non-distributed platform) solution that successfully detects relevant latent functional criminal groups in around 90% of cases sampled and enables the contextual understanding of the broader criminal system through the mesoscopic graph and associated metadata. The augmented data assets generated provide a multi-perspective systems view of criminal activity that enable advanced informed decision making across the microscopic mesoscopic macroscopic spectrum