An empirical study on mutation testing of WS-BPEL programs

Nowadays, applications are increasingly deployed as Web services in the globally distributed cloud computing environment. Multiple services are normally composed to fulfill complex functionalities. Business Process Execution Language for Web Services (WS-BPEL) is an XML-based service composition language that is used to define a complex business process by orchestrating multiple services. Compared with traditional applications, WS-BPEL programs pose many new challenges to the quality assurance, especially testing, of service compositions. A number of techniques have been proposed for testing WS-BPEL programs, but only a few studies have been conducted to systematically evaluate the effectiveness of these techniques. Mutation testing has been widely acknowledged as not only a testing method in its own right but also a popular technique for measuring the fault-detection effectiveness of other testing methods. Several previous studies have proposed a family of mutation operators for generating mutants by seeding various faults into WS-BPEL programs. In this study, we conduct a series of empirical studies to evaluate the applicability and effectiveness of various mutation operators for WS-BPEL programs. The experimental results provide insightful and comprehensive guidance for mutation testing of WS-BPEL programs in practice. In particular, our work is the systematic study in the selection of effective mutation operators specifically for WS-BPEL programs

Automated Testing of WS-BPEL Service Compositions: A Scenario-Oriented Approach

Nowadays, Service Oriented Architecture (SOA) has become one mainstream paradigm for developing distributed applications. As the basic unit in SOA, Web services can be composed to construct complex applications. The quality of Web services and their compositions is critical to the success of SOA applications. Testing, as a major quality assurance technique, is confronted with new challenges in the context of service compositions. In this paper, we propose a scenario-oriented testing approach that can automatically generate test cases for service compositions. Our approach is particularly focused on the service compositions specified by Business Process Execution Language for Web Services (WS-BPEL), a widely recognized executable service composition language. In the approach, a WS-BPEL service composition is first abstracted into a graph model; test scenarios are then derived from the model; finally, test cases are generated according to different scenarios. We also developed a prototype tool implementing the proposed approach, and an empirical study was conducted to demonstrate the applicability and effectiveness of our approach. The experimental results show that the automatic scenario-oriented testing approach is effective in detecting many types of faults seeded in the service compositions

Is XML-based test case prioritization for validating WS-BPEL evolution effective in both average and adverse scenarios?

In real life, a tester can only afford to apply one test case prioritization technique to one test suite against a service-oriented workflow application once in the regression testing of the application, even if it results in an adverse scenario such that the actual performance in the test session is far below the average. It is unclear whether the factors of test case prioritization techniques known to be significant in terms of average performance can be extrapolated to adverse scenarios. In this paper, we examine whether such a factor or technique may consistently affect the rate of fault detection in both the average and adverse scenarios. The factors studied include prioritization strategy, artifacts to provide coverage data, ordering direction of a strategy, and the use of executable and non-executable artifacts. The results show that only a minor portion of the 10 studied techniques, most of which are based on the iterative strategy, are consistently effective in both average and adverse scenarios. To the best of our know-ledge, this paper presents the first piece of empirical evidence regarding the consistency in the effectiveness of test case prioritization techniques and factors of service-oriented workflow applications between average and adverse scenarios.published_or_final_versio

GiGAn: evolutionary mutation testing for C++ object-oriented systems

The reduction of the expenses of mutation testing should be based on well-studied cost reduction techniques to avoid biased results. Evolutionary Mutation Testing (EMT) aims at generating a reduced set of mutants by means of an evolutionary algorithm, which searches for potentially equivalent and difficult to kill mutants to help improve the test suite. However, there is little evidence of its applicability to other contexts beyond WS-BPEL compositions. This study explores its performance when applied to C++ object-oriented programs thanks to a newly developed system, GiGAn. The conducted experiments reveal that EMT shows stable behavior in all the case studies, where the best results are obtained when a low percentage of the mutants is generated. They also support previous studies of EMT when compared to random mutant selection, reinforcing its use for the goal of improving the fault detection capability of the test suite

Quality metrics for mutation testing with applications to WS-BPEL compositions

Mutation testing is a successful testing technique based on fault injection. However, it can be very costly, and several cost-reduction techniques for reducing the number of mutants have been proposed in the literature. Cost reduction can be aided by an analysis of mutation operators, but this requires the definition of specialized metrics. Several metrics have been proposed before, although their effectiveness and relative merits are not easy to assess. A step ahead in the evaluation of mutation-reduction techniques would be a better metric to determine objectively the quality of a set of mutants with respect to a given test suite. This work introduces such a metric, which is naturally extended to mutation operators and may be used to reduce the number of mutants, particularly of equivalent mutants. Finally, a firm mutation analysis tool for WS-BPEL service compositions is presented, and experimental results obtained by comparing different metrics on several compositions are presented

A subsumption hierarchy of test case prioritization for composite services

published_or_final_versio

Preemptive regression testing of workflow-based web services

published_or_final_versio

Evaluation of alternative design choices for evolutionary mutation testing by means of automated configuration

Mutation testing is a well-established but costly technique to assess and improve the fault detection ability of test suites. This technique consists of introducing subtle changes in the code of a program, which are expected to be detected by the designed test cases. Among the strategies conceived to reduce its cost, evolutionary mutation testing (EMT) has been revealed as a promising approach to select a subset of the whole set of mutants based on a genetic algorithm (GA). However, like any other metaheuristic approach, EMT’s execution depends on a set of parameters (both classical of GAs and context-specific ones), so different configurations can greatly vary its performance. Currently, it is difficult to clarify what are the best values for those parameters by applying manual parameter tuning and whether new design choices could improve its effectiveness with other combinations of values. The experience carried out in this paper applying iterated racing, a well-known automated configuration algorithm, reveals that EMT's performance has been undervalued in previous studies; the new configuration found by iterated racing was able to enhance EMT’s results in all C++ object-oriented programs used in the experiments. This study also confirms alternative design choices as convenient options to improve EMT in this context, namely, detecting and penalizing equivalent mutants by means of Trivial Compiler Equivalence, and learning which mutation operators produced live mutants in the past generations.This work was partially supported by the European Commission (European Regional Development Fund - ERDF), the Spanish Ministry of Science, Innovation and Universities under projects RTI2018-093608-B-C33 and TIN2017-88213-R, the excellence network RED2018-102472-T, the University of Malaga, and Consejería de Economía y Conocimiento de la Junta de Andalucía (grant number UMA18-FEDERJA-003

Fault localisation for WS-BPEL programs based on predicate switching and program slicing

Service-Oriented Architecture (SOA) enables the coordination of multiple loosely coupled services. This allows users to choose any service provided by the SOA without knowing implementation details, thus making coding easier and more flexible. Web services are basic units of SOA. However, the functionality of a single Web service is limited, and usually cannot completely satisfy the actual demand. Hence, it is necessary to coordinate multiple independent Web services to achieve complex business processes. Business Process Execution Language for Web Services (WS-BPEL) makes the coordination possible, by helping the integration of multiple Web services and providing an interface for users to invoke. When coordinating these services, however, illegal or faulty operations may be encountered, but current tools are not yet powerful enough to support the localisation and removal of these problems. In this paper, we propose a fault localisation technique for WS-BPEL programs based on predicate switching and program slicing, allowing developers to more precisely locate the suspicious faulty code. Case studies were conducted to investigate the effectiveness of the proposed technique, which was compared with predicate switching only, slicing only, and one existing fault localisation technique, namely Tarantula. The experimental results show that the proposed technique has a higher fault localisation effectiveness and precision than the baseline techniques