Secure Watermarking for Multimedia Content Protection: A Review of its Benefits and Open Issues

Distribution channels such as digital music downloads, video-on-demand, multimedia social networks, pose new challenges to the design of content protection measures aimed at preventing copyright violations. Digital watermarking has been proposed as a possible brick of such protection systems, providing a means to embed a unique code, as a fingerprint, into each copy of the distributed content. However, application of watermarking for multimedia content protection in realistic scenarios poses several security issues. Secure signal processing, by which name we indicate a set of techniques able to process sensitive signals that have been obfuscated either by encryption or by other privacy-preserving primitives, may offer valuable solutions to the aforementioned issues. More specifically, the adoption of efficient methods for watermark embedding or detection on data that have been secured in some way, which we name in short secure watermarking, provides an elegant way to solve the security concerns of fingerprinting applications. The aim of this contribution is to illustrate recent results regarding secure watermarking to the signal processing community, highlighting both benefits and still open issues. Some of the most interesting challenges in this area, as well as new research directions, will also be discussed

TTP-free Asymmetric Fingerprinting based on Client Side Embedding

In this paper, we propose a solution for implementing an asymmetric fingerprinting protocol within a client-side embedding distribution framework. The scheme is based on two novel client-side embedding techniques that are able to reliably transmit a binary fingerprint. The first one relies on standard spread-spectrum like client-side embedding, while the second one is based on an innovative client-side informed embedding technique. The proposed techniques enable secure distribution of personalized decryption keys containing the Buyer's fingerprint by means of existing asymmetric protocols, without using a trusted third party. Simulation results show that the fingerprint can be reliably recovered by using either non-blind decoding with standard embedding or blind decoding with informed embedding, and in both cases it is robust with respect to common attacks. To the best of our knowledge, the proposed scheme is the first solution addressing asymmetric fingerprinting within a clientside framework, representing a valid solution to both customer's rights and scalability issues in multimedia content distributio

Analysis of a buyer-seller watermarking protocol for trustworthy purchasing of digital contents

In ubiquitous environments where human users get to access diverse kinds of (often multimedia enabled) services irrespective of where they are, the issue of security is a major concern. Security in this setting encompasses both in the interest of the human users as well as their information and objects that they own. A typical kind of transaction interaction among users and/or machines in these environments is that of exchanging digital objects via purchases and/or ownership transfers, e.g. someone buying a song from iTunes via his iPhone, or downloading either bought or rented movies onto a portable DVD player. Here, there is a need to provide trustworthy protection of the rights of both parties; i.e. the seller’s copyright needs to be protected against piracy, while on the other hand it has been highlighted in literature the need to protect innocent buyers from being framed. Indeed, if either party cannot be assured that his rights are protected when he is involved in transactions within such environments, he would shy away and instead prefer for instance the more conventional non-digital means of buying and selling. And therefore without active participation from human users and object owners it is difficult to fully kick off the actual realization of intelligent environments. Zhang et al. recently proposed a buyer–seller watermarking protocol without a trusted third party based on secret sharing. While it is a nice idea to eliminate the need of a trusted third party by distributing secret shares between the buyer and the seller such that neither party has knowledge of the fingerprint embedded in a content, we show that it is possible for a buyer to remove his part of the fingerprint from the content he bought. This directly disproves the piracy tracing property claimed by the protocol. In fact, since piracy tracing is one of the earliest security applications of watermarking schemes, it raises doubts as to the soundness of the design of this protocol

Design and Analysis of Fair Content Tracing Protocols

The work in this thesis examines protocols designed to address the issues of tracing illegal distribution of digital content in a fair manner. In digital content distribution, a client requests content from a distributor, and the distributor sends content to the client. The main concern is misuse of content by the client, such as illegal distribution. As a result, digital watermarking schemes that enable the distributor to trace copies of content and identify the perpetrator were proposed. However, such schemes do not provide a mechanism for the distributor to prove to a third party that a client illegally distributed copies of content. Furthermore, it is possible that the distributor falsely accuses a client as he has total control of the tracing mechanisms. Fair content tracing (FaCT) protocols were thus proposed to allow tracing of content that does not discriminate either the distributor or the client. Many FaCT protocols have been proposed, mostly without an appropriate design framework, and so there is no obvious and systematic way to evaluate them. Therefore, we propose a framework that provides a definition of security and which enables classification of FaCT protocols so that they can be analysed in a systematic manner. We define, based on our framework, four main categories of FaCT protocols and propose new approaches to designing them. The first category is protocols without trusted third parties. As the name suggests, these protocols do not rely on a central trusted party for fair tracing of content. It is difficult to design such a protocol without drawing on extra measures that increase communication and computation costs. We show this is the case by demonstrating flaws in two recent proposals. We also illustrate a possible repair based on relaxing the assumption of trust on the distributor. The second category is protocols with online trusted third parties, where a central online trusted party is deployed. This means a trusted party must always be available during content distribution between the distributor and the client. While the availability of a trusted third party may simplify the design of such protocols, efficiency may suffer due to the need to communicate with this third party. The third category is protocols with offline trusted third parties, where a central offline trusted party is deployed. The difference between the offline and the online trusted party is that the offline trusted party need not be available during content distribution. It only needs to be available during the initial setup and when there is a dispute between the distributor and the client. This reduces the communication requirements compared to using an online trusted party. Using a symmetric-based cryptographic primitive known as Chameleon encryption, we proposed a new approach to designing such protocols. The fourth category is protocols with trusted hardware. Previous protocols proposed in this category have abstracted away from a practical choice of the underlying trusted hardware. We propose new protocols based on a Trusted Platform Module (TPM). Finally, we examine the inclusion of payment in a FaCT protocol, and how adding payment motivates the requirement for fair exchange of buying and selling digital content

A New Joint Fingerprinting and Decryption Scheme based on a Lattice Problem

We propose a new encryption scheme that supports joint fingerprinting and decryption. The scheme is remarkably resistant to known-plaintext attack and collusion attack (e.g. average attack or other linear combination attack) on keys. Interestingly, the security of our scheme is relied on a lattice problem: Given a collection of random lattice points generated from a short basis of a lattice, find the short basis. The scheme can be used as a traitor-tracing scheme or a buyer-seller watermarking scheme

Anticollusion solutions for asymmetric fingerprinting protocols based on client side embedding

In this paper, we propose two different solutions for making a recently proposed asymmetric fingerprinting protocol based on client-side embedding robust to collusion attacks. The first solution is based on projecting a client-owned random fingerprint, securely obtained through existing cryptographic protocols, using for each client a different random matrix generated by the server. The second solution consists in assigning to each client a Tardos code, which can be done using existing asymmetric protocols, and modulating such codes using a specially designed random matrix. Suitable accusation strategies are proposed for both solutions, and their performance under the averaging attack followed by the addition of Gaussian noise is analytically derived. Experimental results show that the analytical model accurately predicts the performance of a realistic system. Moreover, the results also show that the solution based on independent random projections outperforms the solution based on Tardos codes, for different choices of parameters and under different attack models

Fall 2016 Supplement to Brauneis & Schechter, Copyright: A Contemporary Approach

This cumulative supplement contains additional materials for Brauneis and Schechter, Copyright: A Contemporary Approach (1st ed. 2012) that make it current through July 2016. Special features include a hyperlinked table of references to 19 recent cases decided since July 2015, which may be helpful in getting an overview of developments over this past year; a hyperlinked table of contents to all inserts; and a chapter-by-chapter guide to using the supplement, intended for professors who are creating or updating syllabi. The supplement contains nine principal cases with notes, as well as dozens of other updates

Fall 2016 Supplement to Brauneis & Schechter, Copyright: A Contemporary Approach

This cumulative supplement contains additional materials for Brauneis and Schechter, Copyright: A Contemporary Approach (1st ed. 2012) that make it current through July 2016. Special features include a hyperlinked table of references to 19 recent cases decided since July 2015, which may be helpful in getting an overview of developments over this past year; a hyperlinked table of contents to all inserts; and a chapter-by-chapter guide to using the supplement, intended for professors who are creating or updating syllabi. The supplement contains nine principal cases with notes, as well as dozens of other updates

Free Culture and the Digital Library Symposium Proceedings 2005: Proceedings of a Symposium held on October 14, 2005 at Emory University, Atlanta, Georgia.

Outlines the themes and contributions of the Free Culture and the Digital Library Symposium.The article provides a summary of the conflict of interests between those who seek to preserve ashared commons of information for society and those who seek to commodify information. Iintroduce a theoretical framework called Transmediation to help explain the changes in mediathat society is currently experiencing