Progress in AI Planning Research and Applications

Planning has made significant progress since its inception in the 1970s, in terms both of the efficiency and sophistication of its algorithms and representations and its potential for application to real problems. In this paper we sketch the foundations of planning as a sub-field of Artificial Intelligence and the history of its development over the past three decades. Then some of the recent achievements within the field are discussed and provided some experimental data demonstrating the progress that has been made in the application of general planners to realistic and complex problems. The paper concludes by identifying some of the open issues that remain as important challenges for future research in planning

Multi-objective optimisation of machine tool error mapping using automated planning

Error mapping of machine tools is a multi-measurement task that is planned based on expert knowledge. There are no intelligent tools aiding the production of optimal measurement plans. In previous work, a method of intelligently constructing measurement plans demonstrated that it is feasible to optimise the plans either to reduce machine tool downtime or the estimated uncertainty of measurement due to the plan schedule. However, production scheduling and a continuously changing environment can impose conflicting constraints on downtime and the uncertainty of measurement. In this paper, the use of the produced measurement model to minimise machine tool downtime, the uncertainty of measurement and the arithmetic mean of both is investigated and discussed through the use of twelve different error mapping instances. The multi-objective search plans on average have a 3% reduction in the time metric when compared to the downtime of the uncertainty optimised plan and a 23% improvement in estimated uncertainty of measurement metric when compared to the uncertainty of the temporally optimised plan. Further experiments on a High Performance Computing (HPC) architecture demonstrated that there is on average a 3% improvement in optimality when compared with the experiments performed on the PC architecture. This demonstrates that even though a 4% improvement is beneficial, in most applications a standard PC architecture will result in valid error mapping plan

Identifying and Exploiting Features for Effective Plan Retrieval in Case-Based Planning

Case-Based planning can fruitfully exploit knowledge gained by solving a large number of problems, storing the corresponding solutions in a plan library and reusing them for solving similar planning problems in the future. Case-based planning is extremely effective when similar reuse candidates can be efficiently chosen. In this paper, we study an innovative technique based on planning problem features for efficiently retrieving solved planning problems (and relative plans) from large plan libraries. A problem feature is a characteristic of the instance that can be automatically derived from the problem specification, domain and search space analyses, and different problem encodings. Since the use of existing planning features are not always able to effectively distinguish between problems within the same planning domain, we introduce a new class of features. An experimental analysis in this paper shows that our features-based retrieval approach can significantly improve the performance of a state-of-the-art case-based planning system

What Automated Planning Can Do for Business Process Management

Business Process Management (BPM) is a central element of today organizations. Despite over the years its main focus has been the support of processes in highly controlled domains, nowadays many domains of interest to the BPM community are characterized by ever-changing requirements, unpredictable environments and increasing amounts of data that influence the execution of process instances. Under such dynamic conditions, BPM systems must increase their level of automation to provide the reactivity and flexibility necessary for process management. On the other hand, the Artificial Intelligence (AI) community has concentrated its efforts on investigating dynamic domains that involve active control of computational entities and physical devices (e.g., robots, software agents, etc.). In this context, Automated Planning, which is one of the oldest areas in AI, is conceived as a model-based approach to synthesize autonomous behaviours in automated way from a model. In this paper, we discuss how automated planning techniques can be leveraged to enable new levels of automation and support for business processing, and we show some concrete examples of their successful application to the different stages of the BPM life cycle

XSRL: An XML web-services request language

One of the most serious challenges that web-service enabled e-marketplaces face is the lack of formal support for expressing service requests against UDDI-resident web-services in order to solve a complex business problem. In this paper we present a web-service request language (XSRL) developed on the basis of AI planning and the XML database query language XQuery. This framework is designed to handle and execute XSRL requests and is capable of performing planning actions under uncertainty on the basis of refinement and revision as new service-related information is accumulated (via interaction with the user or UDDI) and as execution circumstances necessitate change

Simulation and statistical model-checking of logic-based multi-agent system models

This thesis presents SALMA (Simulation and Analysis of Logic-Based Multi- Agent Models), a new approach for simulation and statistical model checking of multi-agent system models. Statistical model checking is a relatively new branch of model-based approximative verification methods that help to overcome the well-known scalability problems of exact model checking. In contrast to existing solutions, SALMA specifies the mechanisms of the simulated system by means of logical axioms based upon the well-established situation calculus. Leveraging the resulting first-order logic structure of the system model, the simulation is coupled with a statistical model-checker that uses a first-order variant of time-bounded linear temporal logic (LTL) for describing properties. This is combined with a procedural and process-based language for describing agent behavior. Together, these parts create a very expressive framework for modeling and verification that allows direct fine-grained reasoning about the agents’ interaction with each other and with their (physical) environment. SALMA extends the classical situation calculus and linear temporal logic (LTL) with means to address the specific requirements of multi-agent simulation models. In particular, cyber-physical domains are considered where the agents interact with their physical environment. Among other things, the thesis describes a generic situation calculus axiomatization that encompasses sensing and information transfer in multi agent systems, for instance sensor measurements or inter-agent messages. The proposed model explicitly accounts for real-time constraints and stochastic effects that are inevitable in cyber-physical systems. In order to make SALMA’s statistical model checking facilities usable also for more complex problems, a mechanism for the efficient on-the-fly evaluation of first-order LTL properties was developed. In particular, the presented algorithm uses an interval-based representation of the formula evaluation state together with several other optimization techniques to avoid unnecessary computation. Altogether, the goal of this thesis was to create an approach for simulation and statistical model checking of multi-agent systems that builds upon well-proven logical and statistical foundations, but at the same time takes a pragmatic software engineering perspective that considers factors like usability, scalability, and extensibility. In fact, experience gained during several small to mid-sized experiments that are presented in this thesis suggest that the SALMA approach seems to be able to live up to these expectations.In dieser Dissertation wird SALMA (Simulation and Analysis of Logic-Based Multi-Agent Models) vorgestellt, ein im Rahmen dieser Arbeit entwickelter Ansatz für die Simulation und die statistische Modellprüfung (Model Checking) von Multiagentensystemen. Der Begriff „Statistisches Model Checking” beschreibt modellbasierte approximative Verifikationsmethoden, die insbesondere dazu eingesetzt werden können, um den unvermeidlichen Skalierbarkeitsproblemen von exakten Methoden zu entgehen. Im Gegensatz zu bisherigen Ansätzen werden in SALMA die Mechanismen des simulierten Systems mithilfe logischer Axiome beschrieben, die auf dem etablierten Situationskalkül aufbauen. Die dadurch entstehende prädikatenlogische Struktur des Systemmodells wird ausgenutzt um ein Model Checking Modul zu integrieren, das seinerseits eine prädikatenlogische Variante der linearen temporalen Logik (LTL) verwendet. In Kombination mit einer prozeduralen und prozessorientierten Sprache für die Beschreibung von Agentenverhalten entsteht eine ausdrucksstarke und flexible Plattform für die Modellierung und Verifikation von Multiagentensystemen. Sie ermöglicht eine direkte und feingranulare Beschreibung der Interaktionen sowohl zwischen Agenten als auch von Agenten mit ihrer (physischen) Umgebung. SALMA erweitert den klassischen Situationskalkül und die lineare temporale Logik (LTL) um Elemente und Konzepte, die auf die spezifischen Anforderungen bei der Simulation und Modellierung von Multiagentensystemen ausgelegt sind. Insbesondere werden cyber-physische Systeme (CPS) unterstützt, in denen Agenten mit ihrer physischen Umgebung interagieren. Unter anderem wird eine generische, auf dem Situationskalkül basierende, Axiomatisierung von Prozessen beschrieben, in denen Informationen innerhalb von Multiagentensystemen transferiert werden – beispielsweise in Form von Sensor- Messwerten oder Netzwerkpaketen. Dabei werden ausdrücklich die unvermeidbaren stochastischen Effekte und Echtzeitanforderungen in cyber-physischen Systemen berücksichtigt. Um statistisches Model Checking mit SALMA auch für komplexere Problemstellungen zu ermöglichen, wurde ein Mechanismus für die effiziente Auswertung von prädikatenlogischen LTL-Formeln entwickelt. Insbesondere beinhaltet der vorgestellte Algorithmus eine Intervall-basierte Repräsentation des Auswertungszustands, sowie einige andere Optimierungsansätze zur Vermeidung von unnötigen Berechnungsschritten. Insgesamt war es das Ziel dieser Dissertation, eine Lösung für Simulation und statistisches Model Checking zu schaffen, die einerseits auf fundierten logischen und statistischen Grundlagen aufbaut, auf der anderen Seite jedoch auch pragmatischen Gesichtspunkten wie Benutzbarkeit oder Erweiterbarkeit genügt. Tatsächlich legen erste Ergebnisse und Erfahrungen aus mehreren kleinen bis mittelgroßen Experimenten nahe, dass SALMA diesen Zielen gerecht wird