Development of an Improved Rotational Orthosis for Walking With Arm Swing and Active Ankle Control

Based on interlimb neural coupling, gait robotic systems should produce walking-like movement in both upper and lower limbs for effective walking restoration. Two orthoses were previously designed in our lab to provide passive walking with arm swing. However, an active system for walking with arm swing is desirable to serve as a testbed for investigation of interlimb neural coupling in response to voluntary input. Given the important function of the ankle joint during normal walking, this work aimed to develop an improved rotational orthosis for walking with arm swing, which is called ROWAS II, and especially to develop and evaluate the algorithms for active ankle control. After description of the mechanical structure and control schemes of the overall ROWAS II system, the closed-loop position control and adjustable admittance control algorithms were firstly deduced, then simulated in Matlab/Simulink and finally implemented in the ROWAS II system. Six able-bodied participants were recruited to use the ROWAS II system in passive mode, and then to estimate the active ankle mechanism. It was showed that the closed-loop position control algorithms enabled the ROWAS II system to track the target arm-leg walking movement patterns well in passive mode, with the tracking error of each joint <0.7°. The adjustable admittance control algorithms enabled the participants to voluntarily adjust the ankle movement by exerting various active force. Higher admittance gains enabled the participants to more easily adjust the movement trajectory of the ankle mechanism. The ROWAS II system is technically feasible to produce walking-like movement in the bilateral upper and lower limbs in passive mode, and the ankle mechanism has technical potential to provide various active ankle training during gait rehabilitation. This novel ROWAS II system can serve as a testbed for further investigation of interlimb neural coupling in response to voluntary ankle movement and is technically feasible to provide a new training paradigm of walking with arm swing and active ankle control

A novel approach to user controlled ambulation of lower extremity exoskeletons using admittance control paradigm

The robotic lower extremity exoskeletons address the ambulatory problems confronting individuals with paraplegia. Paraplegia due to spinal cord injury (SCI) can cause motor deficit to the lower extremities leading to inability to walk. Though wheelchairs provide mobility to the user, they do not provide support to all activities of everyday living to individuals with paraplegia. Current research is addressing the issue of ambulation through the use of wearable exoskeletons that are pre-programmed. There are currently four exoskeletons in the U.S. market: Ekso, Rewalk, REX and Indego. All of the currently available exoskeletons have 2 active Degrees of Freedom (DOF) except for REX which has 5 active DOF. All of them have pre-programmed gait giving the user the ability to initiate a gait but not the ability to control the stride amplitude (height), stride frequency or stride length, and hence restricting users’ ability to navigate across different surfaces and obstacles that are commonly encountered in the community. Most current exoskeletons do not have motors for abduction or adduction to provide users with the option for movement in coronal plane, hence restricting user’s ability to effectively use the exoskeletons. These limitations of currently available pre-programmed exoskeleton models are sought to be overcome by an intuitive, real time user-controlled control mechanism employing admittance control by using hand-trajectory as a surrogate for foot trajectory. Preliminary study included subjects controlling the trajectory of the foot in a virtual environment using their contralateral hand. The study proved that hands could produce trajectories similar to human foot trajectories when provided with haptic and visual feedback. A 10 DOF 1/2 scale biped robot was built to test the control paradigm. The robot has 5 DOF on each leg with 2 DOF at the hip to provide flexion/extension and abduction/adduction, 1 DOF at the knee to provide flexion and 2 DOF at the ankle to provide flexion/extension and inversion/eversion. The control mechanism translates the trajectory of each hand into the trajectory of the ipsilateral foot in real time, thus providing the user with the ability to control each leg in both sagittal and coronal planes using the admittance control paradigm. The efficiency of the control mechanism was evaluated in a study using healthy subjects controlling the robot on a treadmill. A trekking pole was attached to each foot of the biped. The subjects controlled the trajectory of the foot of the biped by applying small forces in the direction of the required movement to the trekking pole through a force sensor. The algorithm converted the forces to Cartesian position of the foot in real time using admittance control; the Cartesian position was converted to joint angles of the hip and knee using inverse kinematics. The kinematics, synchrony and smoothness of the trajectory produced by the biped robot was evaluated at different speeds, with and without obstacles, and compared with typical walking by human subjects on the treadmill. Further, the cognitive load required to control the biped on the treadmill was evaluated and the effect of speed and obstacles with cognitive load on the kinematics, synchrony and smoothness was analyzed

Ankle-Foot Orthosis Stiffness: Biomechanical Effects, Measurement and Emulation

Ankle-foot orthoses (AFOs) are braces worn by individuals with gait impairments to provide support about the ankle. AFOs come in a variety of designs for clinicians to choose from. However, as the effects of different design parameters on AFO properties and AFO users have not been adequately quantified, it is not clear which design choices are most likely to improve patient outcomes. Recent advances in manufacturing have further expanded the design space, adding urgency and complexity to the challenge of selecting optimal designs. A key AFO property affected by design decisions is sagittal-plane rotational stiffness. To evaluate the effectiveness of different AFO designs, we need: 1) a better understanding of the biomechanical effects of AFO stiffness and 2) more precise and repeatable stiffness measurement methods. This dissertation addresses these needs by accomplishing four aims. First, we conducted a systematic literature review on the influence of AFO stiffness on gait biomechanics. We found that ankle and knee kinematics are affected by increasing stiffness, with minimal effects on hip kinematics and kinetics. However, the lack of effective stiffness measurement techniques made it difficult to determine which specific values or ranges of stiffness influence biomechanics. Therefore, in Aim2, we developed an AFO stiffness measurement apparatus (SMApp). The SMApp is an automated device that non-destructively flexes an AFO to acquire operator- and trial-independent measurements of its torque-angle dynamics. The SMApp was designed to test a variety of AFO types and sizes across a wide range of flexion angles and speeds exceeding current alternatives. Common models of AFO torque-angle dynamics in literature have simplified the relationship to a linear fit whose slope represents stiffness. This linear approximation ignores damping parameters. However, as previous studies were unable to precisely control AFO flexion speed, the presence of speed effects has not been adequately investigated. Thus, in Aim3, we used the SMApp to test whether AFOs exhibit viscoelastic behaviors over the range of speeds typically achieved during walking. This study revealed small but statistically significant effects of flexion speed on AFO stiffness for samples of both traditional AFOs and novel 3-D printed AFOs, suggesting that more complex models that include damping parameters could be more suitable for modeling AFO dynamics. Finally, in Aim 4, we investigated the use of an active exoskeleton, that can haptically-emulate different AFOs, as a potential test bed for studying the effects of AFO parameters on human movement. Prior work has used emulation for rapid prototyping of candidate assistive devices. While emulators can mimic a physical device's torque-angle profile, the physical and emulated devices may have other differences that influence user biomechanics. Current studies have not investigated these differences, which limits translation of findings from emulated to physical devices. To evaluate the efficacy of AFO emulation as a research tool, we conducted a single-subject pilot study with a custom-built AFO emulator device. We compared user kinematics while walking with a physical AFO against those with an emulated AFO and found they elicited similar ankle trajectories. This dissertation resulted in the successful development and evaluation of a framework consisting of two test beds, one to assess AFO mechanical properties and another to assess the effects of these properties on the AFO user. These tools enable innovations in AFO design that can translate to measurable improvements in patient outcomes.PHDMechanical EngineeringUniversity of Michigan, Horace H. Rackham School of Graduate Studieshttp://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/163219/1/deema_1.pd

DEVELOPMENT AND EVALUATION OF A NOVEL OVER-GROUND WALKING DEVICE: A ROBOTIC WALKER

Ph.DDOCTOR OF PHILOSOPH

Hybrid walking therapy with fatigue management for spinal cord injured individuals

In paraplegic individuals with upper motor neuron lesions the descending path for signals from central nervous system to the muscles are lost or diminished. Motor neuroprosthesis based on electrical stimulation can be applied to induce restoration of motor function in paraplegic patients. Furthermore, electrical stimulation of such motor neuroprosthesis can be more efficiently managed and delivered if combined with powered exoskeletons that compensate the limited force in the stimulated muscles and bring additional support to the human body. Such hybrid overground gait therapy is likely to be more efficient to retrain the spinal cord in incomplete injuries than conventional, robotic or neuroprosthetic approaches. However, the control of bilateral joints is difficult due to the complexity, non-linearity and time-variance of the system involved. Also, the effects of muscle fatigue and spasticity in the stimulated muscles complicate the control task. Furthermore, a compliant joint actuation is required to allow for a cooperative control approach that is compatible with the assist-as-needed rehabilitation paradigm. These were direct motivations for this research. The overall aim was to generate the necessary knowledge to design a novel hybrid walking therapy with fatigue management for incomplete spinal cord injured subjects. Research activities were conducted towards the establishment of the required methods and (hardware and software) systems that required to proof the concept with a pilot clinical evaluation. Speciffically, a compressive analysis of the state of the art on hybrid exoskeletons revealed several challenges which were tackled by this dissertation. Firstly, assist-as-needed was implemented over the basis of a compliant control of the robotic exoskeleton and a closed-loop control of the neuroprosthesis. Both controllers are integrated within a hybrid-cooperative strategy that is able to balance the assistance of the robotic exoskeleton regarding muscle performance. This approach is supported on the monitoring of the leg-exoskeleton physical interaction. Thus the fatigue caused by neuromuscular stimulation was also subject of speciffic research. Experimental studies were conducted with paraplegic patients towards the establishment of an objective criteria for muscle fatigue estimation and management. The results of these studies were integrated in the hybrid-cooperative controller in order to detect and manage muscle fatigue while providing walking therapy. Secondly closed-loop control of the neuroprosthesis was addressed in this dissertation. The proposed control approach allowed to tailor the stimulation pattern regarding the speciffic residual motor function of the lower limb of the patient. In order to uncouple the closed-loop control from muscle performance monitoring, the hybrid-cooperative control approach implemented a sequential switch between closed-loop and open-loop control of the neuroprosthesis. Lastly, a comprehensive clinical evaluation protocol allowed to assess the impact of the hybrid walking therapy on the gait function of a sample of paraplegic patients. Results demonstrate that: 1) the hybrid controller adapts to patient residual function during walking, 2) the therapy is tolerated by patients, and 3) the walking function of patients was improved after participating in the study. In conclusion, the hybrid walking therapy holds potential for rehabilitate walking in motor incomplete paraplegic patients, guaranteeing further research on this topic. This dissertation is framed within two research projects: REHABOT (Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovación, grant DPI2008-06772-C03-02) and HYPER (Hybrid Neuroprosthetic and Neurorobotic Devices for Functional Compensation and Rehabilitation of Motor Disorders, grant CSD2009-00067 CONSOLIDER INGENIO 2010). Within these research projects, cutting-edge research is conducted in the eld of hybrid actuation and control for rehabilitation of motor disorders. This dissertation constitutes proof-of concept of the hybrid walking therapy for paraplegic individuals for these projects. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------En individuos parapléjicos con lesiones de la motoneurona superior, la conexión descendente para la transmisión de las señales del sistema nervioso central a los músculos se ve perdida o disminuida. Las neuroprótesis motoras basadas en la estimulación eléctrica pueden ser aplicadas para inducir la restauración de la función motora en pacientes con paraplejia. Además, la estimulación eléctrica de tales neuroprótesis motoras se puede gestionar y aplicar de manera más eficiente mediante la combinación con exoesqueletos robóticos que compensen la generación limitada de fuerza de los músculos estimulados, y proporcionen soporte adicional para el cuerpo. Dicha terapia de marcha ambulatoria puede ser probablemente más eficaz para la recuperación de las funciones de la médula espinal en lesiones incompletas que las terapias convencionales, robóticas o neuroprotesicas. Sin embargo, el control bilateral de las articulaciones es difícil debido a la complejidad, no-linealidad y la variación con el tiempo de las características del sistema en cuestión. Además, la fatiga muscular y la espasticidad de los músculos estimulados complican la tarea de control. Por otra parte, se requiere una actuación robótica modulable para permitir un enfoque de control cooperativo compatible con el paradigma de rehabilitación de asistencia bajo demanda. Todo lo anterior constituyó las motivaciones directas para esta investigación. El objetivo general fue generar el conocimiento necesario para diseñar un nuevo tratamiento híbrido de rehabilitación marcha con gestión de la fatiga para lesionados medulares incompletos. Se llevaron a cabo actividades de investigación para el establecimiento de los métodos necesarios y los sistemas (hardware y software) requeridos para probar el concepto mediante una evaluación clínica piloto. Específicamente, un análisis del estado de la técnica sobre exoesqueletos híbridos reveló varios retos que fueron abordados en esta tesis. En primer lugar, el paradigma de asistencia bajo demanda se implementó sobre la base de un control adaptable del exoesqueleto robótico y un control en lazo cerrado de la neuroprótesis. Ambos controladores están integrados dentro de una estrategia híbrida cooperativa que es capaz de equilibrar la asistencia del exoesqueleto robótico en relación con el rendimiento muscular. Este enfoque se soporta sobre la monitorización de la interacción física entre la pierna y el exoesqueleto. Por tanto, la fatiga causada por la estimulación neuromuscular también fue objeto de una investigación específica. Se realizaron estudios experimentales con pacientes parapléjicos para el establecimiento de un criterio objetivo para la detección y la gestión de la fatiga muscular. Los resultados de estos estudios fueron integrados en el controlador híbrido-cooperativo con el fin de detectar y gestionar la fatiga muscular mientras se realiza la terapia híbrida de rehabilitación de la marcha. En segundo lugar, el control en lazo cerrado de la neuroprótesis fue abordado en esta tesis. El método de control propuesto permite adaptar el patrón de estimulación en relación con la funcionalidad residual específica de la extremidad inferior del paciente. Sin embargo, con el n de desacoplar el control en lazo cerrado de la monitorización del rendimiento muscular, el enfoque de control híbrido-cooperativo incorpora una conmutación secuencial entre el control en lazo cerrado y en lazo abierto de la neuropr otesis. Por último, un protocolo de evaluación clínica global permitido evaluar el impacto de la terapia híbrida de la marcha en la función de la marcha de una muestra de pacientes parapléjicos. Los resultados demuestran que: 1) el controlador híbrido se adapta a la función residual del paciente durante la marcha, 2) la terapia es tolerada por los pacientes, y 3) la funci on de marcha del paciente mejora despu es de participar en el estudio. En conclusión, la terapia de híbrida de la marcha alberga un potencial para la rehabilitación de la marcha en pacientes parapléjicos incompletos motor, garantizando realizar investigación más profunda sobre este tema. Esta tesis se enmarca dentro de los dos proyectos de investigación: REHABOT (Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovación, referencia DPI2008-06772-C03-02) y HYPER (Hybrid Neuroprosthetic and Neurorobotic Devices for Functional Compensation and Rehabilitation of Motor Disorders, referencia CSD2009-00067 CONSOLIDER INGENIO 2010). Dentro de estos proyectos se lleva a cabo investigación de vanguardia en el campo de la actuación y el control híbrido de la combinación robot-neuroprótesis para la rehabilitación de trastornos motores. Esta tesis constituye la prueba de concepto de la terapia de híbrida de la marcha para individuos parapléjicos en estos proyectos.This dissertation is framed within two research projects: REHABOT (Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovación, grant DPI2008-06772-C03-02) and HYPER (Hybrid Neuroprosthetic and Neurorobotic Devices for Functional Compensation and Rehabilitation of Motor Disorders, grant CSD2009-00067 CONSOLIDER INGENIO 2010

An admittance shaping controller for exoskeleton assistance of the lower extremities

We present a method for lower-limb exoskeleton control that defines assistance as a desired dynamic response for the human leg. Wearing the exoskeleton can be seen as replacing the leg's natural admittance with the equivalent admittance of the coupled system. The control goal is to make the leg obey an admittance model defined by target values of natural frequency, peak magnitude and zero-frequency response. No estimation of muscle torques or motion intent is necessary. Instead, the controller scales up the coupled system's sensitivity transfer function by means of a compensator employing positive feedback. This approach increases the leg's mobility and makes the exoskeleton an active device capable of performing net positive work on the limb. Although positive feedback is usually considered destabilizing, here performance and robust stability are successfully achieved through a constrained optimization that maximizes the system's gain margins while ensuring the desired location of its dominant poles