Kinematic Performance Measures and Optimization of Parallel Kinematics Manipulators: A Brief Review

This chapter covers a number of kinematic performance indices that are instrumental in designing parallel kinematics manipulators. These indices can be used selectively based on manipulator requirements and functionality. This would provide the very practical tool for designers to approach their needs in a very comprehensive fashion. Nevertheless, most applications require a more composite set of requirements that makes optimizing performance more challenging. The later part of this chapter will discuss single-objective and multi-objectives optimization that could handle certain performance indices or a combination of them. A brief description of most common techniques in the literature will be provided

Multi-objective particle swarm optimization for the structural design of concentric tube continuum robots for medical applications

Concentric tube robots belong to the class of continuum robotic systems whose morphology is described by continuous tangent curvature vectors. They are composed of multiple, interacting tubes nested inside one another and are characterized by their inherent flexibility. Concentric tube continuum robots equipped with tools at their distal end have high potential in minimally invasive surgery. Their morphology enables them to reach sites within the body that are inaccessible with commercial tools or that require large incisions. Further, they can be deployed through a tight lumen or follow a nonlinear path. Fundamental research has been the focus during the last years bringing them closer to the operating room. However, there remain challenges that require attention. The structural synthesis of concentric tube continuum robots is one of these challenges, as these types of robots are characterized by their large parameter space. On the one hand, this is advantageous, as they can be deployed in different patients, anatomies, or medical applications. On the other hand, the composition of the tubes and their design is not a straightforward task but one that requires intensive knowledge of anatomy and structural behavior. Prior to the utilization of such robots, the composition of tubes (i.e. the selection of design parameters and application-specific constraints) must be solved to determine a robotic design that is specifically targeted towards an application or patient. Kinematic models that describe the change in morphology and complex motion increase the complexity of this synthesis, as their mathematical description is highly nonlinear. Thus, the state of the art is concerned with the structural design of these types of robots and proposes optimization algorithms to solve for a composition of tubes for a specific patient case or application. However, existing approaches do not consider the overall parameter space, cannot handle the nonlinearity of the model, or multiple objectives that describe most medical applications and tasks. This work aims to solve these fundamental challenges by solving the parameter optimization problem by utilizing a multi-objective optimization algorithm. The main concern of this thesis is the general methodology to solve for patient- and application-specific design of concentric tube continuum robots and presents key parameters, objectives, and constraints. The proposed optimization method is based on evolutionary concepts that can handle multiple objectives, where the set of parameters is represented by a decision vector that can be of variable dimension in multidimensional space. Global optimization algorithms specifically target the constrained search space of concentric tube continuum robots and nonlinear optimization enables to handle the highly nonlinear elasticity modeling. The proposed methodology is then evaluated based on three examples that include cooperative task deployment of two robotic arms, structural stiffness optimization under the consideration of workspace constraints and external forces, and laser-induced thermal therapy in the brain using a concentric tube continuum robot. In summary, the main contributions are 1) the development of an optimization methodology that describes the key parameters, objectives, and constraints of the parameter optimization problem of concentric tube continuum robots, 2) the selection of an appropriate optimization algorithm that can handle the multidimensional search space and diversity of the optimization problem with multiple objectives, and 3) the evaluation of the proposed optimization methodology and structural synthesis based on three real applications

Design and analysis of kinematically redundant planar parallel manipulator for isotropic stiffness condition

Parallel manipulators are a form of closed loop linkages and have a wide range of applications e.g. surgical robots, flight simulators, pointing devices etc. Parallel mechanisms have many advantages over serial manipulator. Higher accuracy, stiffness and increased payload capacity are the characteristics of parallel manipulator. In spite of many advantages, they have limited workspace and more singularity regions. So, redundant architectures have become popular. However, redundancy leads to infinite solutions for inverse kinematic problem. The current work addresses this issue of resolving the redundancy of kinematically redundant planar parallel manipulators using optimization based approach. First the conventional non-redundant 3-RPR planar parallel manipulator is presented. Afterwards the kinematically redundant counterpart 3-PRPR is discussed and actuation redundant 4-RPR has been touched upon briefly. Computer simulations have been performed for the kinematic issues using MATLAB programme . The workspace of redundant and non-redundant parallel manipulators have been obtained. The generalized stiffness matrix has been derived based upon the Jacobian model and the principle of duality between kinematics and statics. A stiffness index has been formulated and the isotropy of stiffness index is used as the criterion for resolving redundancy. A novel spiral optimization metaheuristics has been used to achieve the isotropic stiffness within the selected workshape and the results are compared against particle swarm optimization. The results obtained from the novel Spiral optimization are found to be more effective and closer to the objective function as compared to the particle swarm optimization. Optimum redundant parameters are obtained as a result of the analysis. A wooden skeletal prototype has also been fabricated to enhance the understanding of the mechanism workability

Modeling, Control and Estimation of Reconfigurable Cable Driven Parallel Robots

The motivation for this thesis was to develop a cable-driven parallel robot (CDPR) as part of a two-part robotic device for concrete 3D printing. This research addresses specific research questions in this domain, chiefly, to present advantages offered by the addition of kinematic redundancies to CDPRs. Due to the natural actuation redundancy present in a fully constrained CDPR, the addition of internal mobility offers complex challenges in modeling and control that are not often encountered in literature. This work presents a systematic analysis of modeling such kinematic redundancies through the application of reciprocal screw theory (RST) and Lie algebra while further introducing specific challenges and drawbacks presented by cable driven actuators. It further re-contextualizes well-known performance indices such as manipulability, wrench closure quality, and the available wrench set for application with reconfigurable CDPRs. The existence of both internal redundancy and static redundancy in the joint space offers a large subspace of valid solutions that can be condensed through the selection of appropriate objective priorities, constraints or cost functions. Traditional approaches to such redundancy resolution necessitate computationally expensive numerical optimization. The control of both kinematic and actuation redundancies requires cascaded control frameworks that cannot easily be applied towards real-time control. The selected cost functions for numerical optimization of rCDPRs can be globally (and sometimes locally) non-convex. In this work we present two applied examples of redundancy resolution control that are unique to rCDPRs. In the first example, we maximize the directional wrench ability at the end-effector while minimizing the joint torque requirement by utilizing the fitness of the available wrench set as a constraint over wrench feasibility. The second example focuses on directional stiffness maximization at the end-effector through a variable stiffness module (VSM) that partially decouples the tension and stiffness. The VSM introduces an additional degrees of freedom to the system in order to manipulate both reconfigurability and cable stiffness independently. The controllers in the above examples were designed with kinematic models, but most CDPRs are highly dynamic systems which can require challenging feedback control frameworks. An approach to real-time dynamic control was implemented in this thesis by incorporating a learning-based frameworks through deep reinforcement learning. Three approaches to rCDPR training were attempted utilizing model-free TD3 networks. Robustness and safety are critical features for robot development. One of the main causes of robot failure in CDPRs is due to cable breakage. This not only causes dangerous dynamic oscillations in the workspace, but also leads to total robot failure if the controllability (due to lack of cables) is lost. Fortunately, rCDPRs can be utilized towards failure tolerant control for task recovery. The kinematically redundant joints can be utilized to help recover the lost degrees of freedom due to cable failure. This work applies a Multi-Model Adaptive Estimation (MMAE) framework to enable online and automatic objective reprioritization and actuator retasking. The likelihood of cable failure(s) from the estimator informs the mixing of the control inputs from a bank of feedforward controllers. In traditional rigid body robots, safety procedures generally involve a standard emergency stop procedure such as actuator locking. Due to the flexibility of cable links, the dynamic oscillations of the end-effector due to cable failure must be actively dampened. This work incorporates a Linear Quadratic Regulator (LQR) based feedback stabilizer into the failure tolerant control framework that works to stabilize the non-linear system and dampen out these oscillations. This research contributes to a growing, but hitherto niche body of work in reconfigurable cable driven parallel manipulators. Some outcomes of the multiple engineering design, control and estimation challenges addressed in this research warrant further exploration and study that are beyond the scope of this thesis. This thesis concludes with a thorough discussion of the advantages and limitations of the presented work and avenues for further research that may be of interest to continuing scholars in the community

Inverse Kinematic Analysis of Robot Manipulators

An important part of industrial robot manipulators is to achieve desired position and orientation of end effector or tool so as to complete the pre-specified task. To achieve the above stated goal one should have the sound knowledge of inverse kinematic problem. The problem of getting inverse kinematic solution has been on the outline of various researchers and is deliberated as thorough researched and mature problem. There are many fields of applications of robot manipulators to execute the given tasks such as material handling, pick-n-place, planetary and undersea explorations, space manipulation, and hazardous field etc. Moreover, medical field robotics catches applications in rehabilitation and surgery that involve kinematic, dynamic and control operations. Therefore, industrial robot manipulators are required to have proper knowledge of its joint variables as well as understanding of kinematic parameters. The motion of the end effector or manipulator is controlled by their joint actuator and this produces the required motion in each joints. Therefore, the controller should always supply an accurate value of joint variables analogous to the end effector position. Even though industrial robots are in the advanced stage, some of the basic problems in kinematics are still unsolved and constitute an active focus for research. Among these unsolved problems, the direct kinematics problem for parallel mechanism and inverse kinematics for serial chains constitute a decent share of research domain. The forward kinematics of robot manipulator is simpler problem and it has unique or closed form solution. The forward kinematics can be given by the conversion of joint space to Cartesian space of the manipulator. On the other hand inverse kinematics can be determined by the conversion of Cartesian space to joint space. The inverse kinematic of the robot manipulator does not provide the closed form solution. Hence, industrial manipulator can achieve a desired task or end effector position in more than one configuration. Therefore, to achieve exact solution of the joint variables has been the main concern to the researchers. A brief introduction of industrial robot manipulators, evolution and classification is presented. The basic configurations of robot manipulator are demonstrated and their benefits and drawbacks are deliberated along with the applications. The difficulties to solve forward and inverse kinematics of robot manipulator are discussed and solution of inverse kinematic is introduced through conventional methods. In order to accomplish the desired objective of the work and attain the solution of inverse kinematic problem an efficient study of the existing tools and techniques has been done. A review of literature survey and various tools used to solve inverse kinematic problem on different aspects is discussed. The various approaches of inverse kinematic solution is categorized in four sections namely structural analysis of mechanism, conventional approaches, intelligence or soft computing approaches and optimization based approaches. A portion of important and more significant literatures are thoroughly discussed and brief investigation is made on conclusions and gaps with respect to the inverse kinematic solution of industrial robot manipulators. Based on the survey of tools and techniques used for the kinematic analysis the broad objective of the present research work is presented as; to carry out the kinematic analyses of different configurations of industrial robot manipulators. The mathematical modelling of selected robot manipulator using existing tools and techniques has to be made for the comparative study of proposed method. On the other hand, development of new algorithm and their mathematical modelling for the solution of inverse kinematic problem has to be made for the analysis of quality and efficiency of the obtained solutions. Therefore, the study of appropriate tools and techniques used for the solution of inverse kinematic problems and comparison with proposed method is considered. Moreover, recommendation of the appropriate method for the solution of inverse kinematic problem is presented in the work. Apart from the forward kinematic analysis, the inverse kinematic analysis is quite complex, due to its non-linear formulations and having multiple solutions. There is no unique solution for the inverse kinematics thus necessitating application of appropriate predictive models from the soft computing domain. Artificial neural network (ANN) can be gainfully used to yield the desired results. Therefore, in the present work several models of artificial neural network (ANN) are used for the solution of the inverse kinematic problem. This model of ANN does not rely on higher mathematical formulations and are adept to solve NP-hard, non-linear and higher degree of polynomial equations. Although intelligent approaches are not new in this field but some selected models of ANN and their hybridization has been presented for the comparative evaluation of inverse kinematic. The hybridization scheme of ANN and an investigation has been made on accuracies of adopted algorithms. On the other hand, any Optimization algorithms which are capable of solving various multimodal functions can be implemented to solve the inverse kinematic problem. To overcome the problem of conventional tool and intelligent based method the optimization based approach can be implemented. In general, the optimization based approaches are more stable and often converge to the global solution. The major problem of ANN based approaches are its slow convergence and often stuck in local optimum point. Therefore, in present work different optimization based approaches are considered. The formulation of the objective function and associated constrained are discussed thoroughly. The comparison of all adopted algorithms on the basis of number of solutions, mathematical operations and computational time has been presented. The thesis concludes the summary with contributions and scope of the future research work

Determining Singularity-Free Inner Workspace through Offline Conversion of Assembly Modes for a 3-RRR PPM

The existing singularity avoidance methods have deficiencies, such as the conditionality of the online conversion of the assembly modes (AMs) and the kinematically redundant manipulator with the predicament of the prototype design and added complexity of the mechanism. To address these issues, a method to determine a singularity-free inner workspace through offline conversion of the AMs of the 3-RRR planar parallel manipulator (PPM) is presented. Based on the geometric relations among rods of the manipulator during the occurrence of singularity, and the singular points at or near the boundary of the workspace are permitted, the AMs and ranges of the orientation angle of the moving platform corresponding to the inner singularity-free workspace are determined through a three-dimensional search method. The simulation and experimental comparisons indicate that singular-free paths related to the constant or variable orientation angle of the moving platform can be planned on the singularity-free inner workspace

Optimizing task placement in robotic cells

The primary objective of this dissertation is to develop novel and practical techniques for optimal task placement in robotic cells. To this end, it is shown how task placement affect the efficiency of the cell, whether the task is automated fiber placement to create composite materials, gluing or inspection. Here, efficiency of the cell is defined by either cycle time of the production or distance to singularity, having collision avoidance as a constraint. Task placement, even for one robotic arm, is an under-constrained problem in nature. This issue drastically grows in case of redundant robotic cells. Actuator redundancy in robotic cells is added by either a positioner or another manipulator. This work is focused on taking advantage of redundancy in robotic cells and optimizing it for better performance. One of the main challenges here is to identify the number of independent placement parameters. Therefore, we ignore ineffective variables and only focus on minimum number of parameters possible. Hence, faster optimization process and more precise results are obtained. Another challenge is in motion planning of redundant cells. Because there can be infinite solutions for such cells, there is room for optimization. In this work, we propose methods to fix the optimal placement of the task and, furthermore, assign the optimal motion planning to all manipulators in the cell, simultaneously. A novel method is proposed to identify the number of independent parameters and applied to a gluing path for a coordinated redundant robotic workcell. The workcell consists of a generic six-DOF serial manipulator and a one-DOF redundancy provider (RP). Two cases of RPs are investigated, namely a rotary table and a linear guide. An innovative method using swept volume is proposed for determining the number of independent parameters for both cases under study. The outcome of this study is an intuitive method to identify the number of independent parameters in redundant cells. The results are compared between using all initial parameters, as contrary to only the independent ones. It is proven that the proposed method improves the optimization efficiency by 32%. Moreover, the performance of the rotary table is compared to the linear guide, for a specific gluing application. Optimization methods in this work are based on Particle Swarm Optimization (PSO). A workcell consisting of a six degrees of freedom (DOF) serial manipulator, a six-DOF parallel manipulator and a rotary table mounted on the parallel manipulator is studies for automated fiber placement task. The solution to motion planning is obtained considering the singularities of the serial manipulator and the workspace boundaries of all manipulators. The algorithm to obtain the optimum path placement is explained through a simple example and the results for a helix path with nearly 2,700 points around the workpiece is represented. The results for motion planning are represented where distance to singularity is maximized, collision avoidance and workspace boundaries are respected. The result is obtained after 10 iterations with 20 particles. This outcome of this study is a reliable and easy to apply motion planning algorithm to be used in redundant cells. Another challenge in this work is combinatorial task placement that arises in robotic inspection cells. The goal is to improve the efficiency of a turbine blade inspection cell through optimizing the placement of the camera and optimizing the sequence of the images. The workcell contains a six-DOF serial manipulator that is holding the blade and shows it to the camera from different angles, whereas the camera takes inspection images. The problem at hand consists of a six-DOF continuous optimization for camera placement and discrete combinatorial optimization of sequence of images (end-effector poses). A novel combined approach is introduced, called Blind Dynamic Particle Swarm Optimization (BD-PSO), to simultaneously obtain the optimal design for both domains. Our objective is to minimize the cycle time, while avoiding any collisions in the workcell during the inspection operation. Even though PSO is vastly used in engineering problems, novelty of the proposed combinatorial optimization method is in its ability to be used efficiently in the traveling salesman problems where the distances between cities are unknown (blind) and the distances are subject to change (dynamic). This highly unpredictable domain is the case of the inspection cell where the cycle time between images will change for different camera placements. The cycle time is calculated based on weighted joint travel time of the robot. All the eight configurations of the robot are taken into the consideration, therefore, robot’s configuration is optimized in the final result as well. The outcome of this study is an innovative hybrid algorithm to simultaneously solve combinatorial and continues problems. Results show fast convergence and reliable motions. The test of benchmarks selected from TSPLIB shows that the results obtained by this algorithm are better and closer to the theoretical optimal values with better robustness than those obtained by other methods. The best placement of camera and best image sequence (for 8 images) is obtained after 11 iterations using 30 particles. In general, the main results of this thesis are three algorithms: an algorithm to obtain minimum number of placement parameters in redundant robotic workcells; an algorithm for motion planning of highly redundant cells; and an algorithm to optimize camera placement and simultaneously obtain the optimal image sequence in an inspection cell

Design, analysis and kinematic control of highly redundant serial robotic arms

The use of robotic manipulators in industry has grown in the last decades to improve and speed up industrial processes. Industrial manipulators started to be investigated for machining tasks since they can cover larger workspaces, increasing the range of achievable operations and improving flexibility. The company Nimbl’Bot developed a new mechanism, or module, to build stiffer flexible serial modular robots for machining applications. This manipulator is a kinematic redundant robot with 21 degrees of freedom. This thesis thoroughly analysis the Nimbl’Bot robot features and is divided into three main topics. The first topic regards using a task priority kinematic redundancy resolution algorithm for the Nimbl’Bot robot tracking trajectory while optimizing its kinetostatic performances. The second topic is the kinematic redundant robot design optimization with respect to a desired application and its kinetostatic performance. For the third topic, a new workspace determination algorithm is proposed for kinematic redundant manipulators. Several simulation tests are proposed and tested on some Nimbl’Bot robot designs for each subjects