On a Vehicle Routing Problem with Customer Costs and Multi Depots

The Vehicle Routing Problem with Customer Costs (short VRPCC) was developed for railway maintenance scheduling. In detail, corrective maintenance jobs for unexpected occurring failures are planned to a short time horizon. These jobs are geographically distributed in the railway net. Furthermore, dependent on the severity of the failure, it can be necessary to reduce the top speed on the track section in order to avoid safety risks or a too fast deterioration. For fatal failures, it can even be necessary to close the track section. The resulting limitations on railway service lead to penalty costs for the maintenance operator. These must be paid until the track is repaired and the restrictions are removed. By scheduling the maintenance tasks, these penalty costs can be reduced by proceeding corresponding maintenance tasks earlier. However, this may in return lead to increased costs for moving the maintenance machines and crews. For this scheduling problem, the VRPCC was developed. With it, for each maintenance vehicle and crew, a route is defined that describes the order to proceed maintenance tasks. Two kinds of costs are considered: Firstly, travel costs for machinery and crew; and secondly, penalty costs for an unsafe track condition that have to be paid for each day from failure detection to maintenance completion. To model the penalties, the novel customer costs are defined. In detail, for each maintenance activity a customer cost coefficient is given which incur for each day between failure detection and failure repair. The objective function of this problem is defined by the sum of travel costs and time-dependent customer costs. With it, the priority of customers can be taken into account without losing the sight on travel costs. This new vehicle routing problem was introduced in this thesis by a non-linear partition and permutation model. In this model, a feasible solution is defined by a partition of the job set into subsets that represent the allocation of jobs to vehicles and a permutation for each subset that represent the order of processing the jobs. Then, the start times of the jobs were calculated based on the order given by the permutations. It was taken into account that work can only be done in eight hour shifts during the night. Based on the start times, the customer cost value of each job is computed which equals to the paid penalty costs. Then, the costs of a schedule are calculated via the sum of travel costs and customer costs. To solve the VRPCC by a commercial linear programming solver, different formulations of the VRPCC as mixed-integer linear program were developed. In doing so, the start times became decision variables. It turned out that including customer costs led to problems harder to solve than vehicle routing problems where only travel costs are minimized. Further, in the thesis several construction heuristics for the VRPCC were designed and investigated. Also two local search algorithms, first and best improvement, were applied. The computational experiments showed that the solutions generated by the local search algorithm were much better than the solutions of the construction heuristics. The main part of this thesis was to design a Branch-and-Bound algorithm for the VRPCC. For this purpose, new lower bounds for the customer cost part of the objective function were formulated. The computational experiments showed that a lower bound computed from the LP relaxation of a specific bin packing problem had the best trade-off between computational effort and bound quality. For the travel cost part of the objective function, several known lower bounds from the TSP were compared. To design a Branch-and-Bound algorithm, beside efficient lower bound, also suitable branching strategies are necessary to split the problem space into smaller subspaces. In this thesis two branching strategies were developed which are based on the non-linear partition and permutation model to take advantage from the problem structure. To be more precise, new branches are generated by appending or including a job to an uncompleted schedule. Consequently, the start times can be computed directly from the so far planned jobs and more tight lower bounds can be computed for the so far unplanned jobs. By means of computational experiments, the developed Branch-and-Bound algorithms were compared with the classical approach, which means solving a mixed-integer linear program of the VRPCC by a commercial solver. The results showed that both Branch-and-Bound algorithms solved the small instances faster than the classical approach

Multi-objective model for optimizing railway infrastructure asset renewal

Trabalho inspirado num problema real da empresa Infraestruturas de Portugal, EP.A multi-objective model for managing railway infrastructure asset renewal is presented. The model aims to optimize three objectives, while respecting operational constraints: levelling investment throughout multiple years, minimizing total cost and minimizing work start postponements. Its output is an optimized intervention schedule. The model is based on a case study from a Portuguese infrastructure management company, which specified the objectives and constraints, and reflects management practice on railway infrastructure. The results show that investment levelling greatly influences the other objectives and that total cost fluctuations may range from insignificant to important, depending on the condition of the infrastructure. The results structure is argued to be general and suggests a practical methodology for analysing trade-offs and selecting a solution for implementation.info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersio

Generation of the transport service offer with application to timetable planning considering constraints due to maintenance work

Line planning is an important step in strategic timetable planning in public transport. In this step the transport offer for the customer is generated by the public transport operator, whereby the resulting costs for the operator should be as deep as possible. Mathematical models for line planning allow to create optimized line plans quickly. Planners can use these models to rate and select different alternatives. This is particularly valuable under the aspect of increasing maintenance and construction tasks of the railway infrastructure. We show, that in this case, it is possible to create functional requirements for automated timetable creation from the result of line planning step. The practical use of the involved models is illustrated by a real application example

Crew Scheduling for Netherlands Railways: "destination: customer"

: In this paper we describe the use of a set covering model with additional constraints for scheduling train drivers and conductors for the Dutch railway operator NS Reizigers. The schedules were generated according to new rules originating from the project "Destination: Customer" ("Bestemming: Klant" in Dutch). This project is carried out by NS Reizigers in order to increase the quality and the punctuality of its train services. With respect to the scheduling of drivers and conductors, this project involves the generation of efficient and acceptable duties with a high robustness against the transfer of delays of trains. A key issue for the acceptability of the duties is the included amount of variation per duty. The applied set covering model is solved by dynamic column generation techniques, Lagrangean relaxation and powerful heuristics. The model and the solution techniques are part of the TURNI system, which is currently used by NS Reizigers for carrying out several analyses concerning the required capacities of the depots. The latter are strongly influenced by the new rules.crew scheduling;dynamic column generation;lagrange relaxation;railways;set covering model

Optimal Scheduling of Trains on a Single Line Track

This paper describes the development and use of a model designed to optimise train schedules on single line rail corridors. The model has been developed with two major applications in mind, namely: as a decision support tool for train dispatchers to schedule trains in real time in an optimal way; and as a planning tool to evaluate the impact of timetable changes, as well as railroad infrastructure changes. The mathematical programming model described here schedules trains over a single line track. The priority of each train in a conflict depends on an estimate of the remaining crossing and overtaking delay, as well as the current delay. This priority is used in a branch and bound procedure to allow and optimal solution to reasonable size train scheduling problems to be determined efficiently. The use of the model in an application to a 'real life' problem is discussed. The impacts of changing demand by increasing the number of trains, and reducing the number of sidings for a 150 kilometre section of single line track are discussed. It is concluded that the model is able to produce useful results in terms of optimal schedules in a reasonable time for the test applications shown here

A review of key planning and scheduling in the rail industry in Europe and UK

Planning and scheduling activities within the rail industry have benefited from developments in computer-based simulation and modelling techniques over the last 25 years. Increasingly, the use of computational intelligence in such tasks is featuring more heavily in research publications. This paper examines a number of common rail-based planning and scheduling activities and how they benefit from five broad technology approaches. Summary tables of papers are provided relating to rail planning and scheduling activities and to the use of expert and decision systems in the rail industry.EPSR

Competition in network industries

A wave of privatization is sweeping the globe, affecting about 100 countries and adding up to an average of more than $60 billion a year in business in the past decade. The challenge is to ensure that privatization yields clear benefits. Empirical studies suggest that ownership change by itself will often yield results, especially when it reduces government interference. But the regulation required in areas of natural monopoly can become overly intrusive and undermine progress. Real competition is required to generate sizable and lasting welfare improvements. But in infrastructure sectors, the introduction of competition is complicated by the existence of complex transport and communications networks. Debate about whether and how to introduce competition in network industries is sometimes heated. Certain questions recur: Will continuing regulation be needed? Whether and at what terms will private finance be forthcoming? The author argues that policymakers need to understand how competitive forces can be brought to bear in network industries. He explains the following: 1) common principles that are often lost in"technical"debates about specific sectors; 2) various methods for introducing competition in network industries; 3) competition for the market, and bidding for franchises; 4) options for competition for existing networks; 5) options for expanding competitive systems by decentralizing investment in new network capacity; 6) the option of allowing competition among multiple networks; and 7) the implications of these options for the sectors and for financing industry expansion. In case of doubt, he contends, policymakers should not restrict the entry of competitive firms in such networks. If they do, entry restrictions should be subject to an automatic test after a set period, and reviewed for costs and benefits.Economic Theory&Research,Decentralization,Markets and Market Access,Environmental Economics&Policies,Labor Policies,Education for the Knowledge Economy,Economic Theory&Research,Access to Markets,Markets and Market Access,Environmental Economics&Policies

Operations research in passenger railway transportation

In this paper, we give an overview of state-of-the-art OperationsResearch models and techniques used in passenger railwaytransportation. For each planning phase (strategic, tactical andoperational), we describe the planning problems arising there anddiscuss some models and algorithms to solve them. We do not onlyconsider classical, well-known topics such as timetabling, rollingstock scheduling and crew scheduling, but we also discuss somerecently developed topics as shunting and reliability oftimetables.Finally, we focus on several practical aspects for each of theseproblems at the largest Dutch railway operator, NS Reizigers.passenger railway transportation;operation research;planning problems

AI and OR in management of operations: history and trends

The last decade has seen a considerable growth in the use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) for operations management with the aim of finding solutions to problems that are increasing in complexity and scale. This paper begins by setting the context for the survey through a historical perspective of OR and AI. An extensive survey of applications of AI techniques for operations management, covering a total of over 1200 papers published from 1995 to 2004 is then presented. The survey utilizes Elsevier's ScienceDirect database as a source. Hence, the survey may not cover all the relevant journals but includes a sufficiently wide range of publications to make it representative of the research in the field. The papers are categorized into four areas of operations management: (a) design, (b) scheduling, (c) process planning and control and (d) quality, maintenance and fault diagnosis. Each of the four areas is categorized in terms of the AI techniques used: genetic algorithms, case-based reasoning, knowledge-based systems, fuzzy logic and hybrid techniques. The trends over the last decade are identified, discussed with respect to expected trends and directions for future work suggested

A column generation approach to solve the crew re-scheduling problem

When tracks are out of service for maintenance during a certainperiod, trains cannot be operated on those tracks. This leads to amodified timetable, and results in infeasible rolling stock andcrew schedules. Therefore, these schedules need to be repaired.The topic of this paper is the rescheduling of crew.In this paper, we define the Crew Re-Scheduling Problem (CRSP).Furthermore, we show that it can be formulated as a large-scaleset covering problem. The problem is solved with a columngeneration based algorithm. The performance of the algorithm istested on real-world instances of NS, the largest passengerrailway operator in the Netherlands. Finally, we discuss somebenefits of the proposed methodology for the company.column generation;transportation;railways;crew re-scheduling;large-scale optimization