Applying Formal Methods to Networking: Theory, Techniques and Applications

Despite its great importance, modern network infrastructure is remarkable for the lack of rigor in its engineering. The Internet which began as a research experiment was never designed to handle the users and applications it hosts today. The lack of formalization of the Internet architecture meant limited abstractions and modularity, especially for the control and management planes, thus requiring for every new need a new protocol built from scratch. This led to an unwieldy ossified Internet architecture resistant to any attempts at formal verification, and an Internet culture where expediency and pragmatism are favored over formal correctness. Fortunately, recent work in the space of clean slate Internet design---especially, the software defined networking (SDN) paradigm---offers the Internet community another chance to develop the right kind of architecture and abstractions. This has also led to a great resurgence in interest of applying formal methods to specification, verification, and synthesis of networking protocols and applications. In this paper, we present a self-contained tutorial of the formidable amount of work that has been done in formal methods, and present a survey of its applications to networking.Comment: 30 pages, submitted to IEEE Communications Surveys and Tutorial

Cloudarmor: Supporting Reputation-Based Trust Management for Cloud Services

Cloud services have become predominant in the current technological era. For the rich set of features provided by cloud services, consumers want to access the services while protecting their privacy. In this kind of environment, protection of cloud services will become a significant problem. So, research has started for a system, which lets the users access cloud services without losing the privacy of their data. Trust management and identity model makes sense in this case. The identity model maintains the authentication and authorization of the components involved in the system and trust-based model provides us with a dynamic way of identifying issues and attacks with the system and take appropriate actions. Further, a trust management-based system provides us with a new set of challenges such as reputation-based attacks, availability of components, and misleading trust feedbacks. Collusion attacks and Sybil attacks form a significant part of these challenges. This paper aims to solve the above problems in a trust management-based model by introducing a credibility model on top of a new trust management model, which addresses these use-cases, and also provides reliability and availability

Engineering Crowdsourced Stream Processing Systems

A crowdsourced stream processing system (CSP) is a system that incorporates crowdsourced tasks in the processing of a data stream. This can be seen as enabling crowdsourcing work to be applied on a sample of large-scale data at high speed, or equivalently, enabling stream processing to employ human intelligence. It also leads to a substantial expansion of the capabilities of data processing systems. Engineering a CSP system requires the combination of human and machine computation elements. From a general systems theory perspective, this means taking into account inherited as well as emerging properties from both these elements. In this paper, we position CSP systems within a broader taxonomy, outline a series of design principles and evaluation metrics, present an extensible framework for their design, and describe several design patterns. We showcase the capabilities of CSP systems by performing a case study that applies our proposed framework to the design and analysis of a real system (AIDR) that classifies social media messages during time-critical crisis events. Results show that compared to a pure stream processing system, AIDR can achieve a higher data classification accuracy, while compared to a pure crowdsourcing solution, the system makes better use of human workers by requiring much less manual work effort

Compositional modelling: The formal perspective

We provide a formal framework within which an Information System (IS) could be modelled, analysed, and verified in a compositional manner. Our work is based on Interval Temporal Logic (ITL) and its programming language subset, Tempura. This is achieved by considering IS, of an enterprise, as a class of reactive systems in which it is continually reacting to asynchronously occurring events within a given period of time. Such a reactive nature permits an enterprise to pursue its business activities to best compete with others in the market place. The technique is illustrated by applying it to a small case study from Public Service Systems (PSS).Funding received from the UK Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) through the Research Grant GR/M/0258

Runtime observable and adaptable UML state machine-based software components generation and verification: [email protected] approach

Cyber-Physical Systems (CPSs) are embedded computing systems in which computation interacts closely with the physical world through sensors and actuators. CPSs are used to control context aware systems. These types of systems are complex systems that will have different configurations and their control strategy can be configured depending the environmental data and current situation of the context. Therefore, in current industrial environments, the software of embedded and Cyber-Physical systems have to cope with increasing complexity, uncertain scenarios and safe requirements at runtime. The UML State Machine is a powerful formalism to model the logical behaviour of these types of systems, and in Model Driven Engineering (MDE) we can generate code automatically from these models. MDE aims to overcome the complexity of software construction by allowing developers to work at the high-level models of software systems instead of low-level codes. However, determining and evaluating the runtime behaviour and performance of models of CPSs using commercial MDE tools is a challenging task. Such tools provide little support to observe at model-level the execution of the code generated from the model, and to collect the runtime information necessary to, for example, check whether defined safe properties are met or not. One solution to address these requirements is having the software components information in model terms at runtime ([email protected]). Work on [email protected] seeks to extend the applicability of models produced in MDE approaches to the runtime environment. Having the model at runtime is the first step towards the runtime verification. Runtime verification can be performed using the information of model elements (current state, event, next state,etc.) This thesis aims at advancing the current practice on generating automatically Unified Modeling Language - State Machine (UML-SM) based software components that are able to provide their internal information in model terms at runtime. Regarding automation, we propose a tool supported methodology to automatically generate these software components. As for runtime monitoring, verification and adaptation, we propose an externalized runtime module that is able to monitor and verify the correctness of the software components based on their internal status in model terms at component and system level. In addition, if an error is detected, the runtime adaptation module is activated and the safe adaptation process starts in the involved software components. All things considered, the overall safe level of the software components and CPSs is enhanced.Sistema Ziber-Fisikoak, konputazio sistema txertatuez osatuta daude. Konputazio sistema txertatu hauek, mundu birtuala mundu fisikoarekin uztartzeko gaitasuna eskaintzen dute. Sistema ziberfisikoak orokorrean sistema konplexuak izan ohi dira eta inguruan gertazen denaren araberako konfigurazio desberdinak izan ohi dituzte. Gaur egungo industria ingurunetan, sistema hauek daramaten kontroleko softwarea asko handitu da eta beren konplexutasunak ere gorakada handia izan du: aurrez ezagunak ez diren baldintza eta inguruetan lan egin beharra dute askotan, denbora errealeko eskakizunak eta segurtasun eskakizunak ere beteaz. UML State Machine formalismoa, goian aipaturiko sistema mota horien portaera logikoa modelizatzeko erabiltzen den formalismo indartsu bat da. Formalismo honen baitan eta Model Driven Engineering (MDE) enfokea jarraituaz, sistema modelatzeko erabilitako grafikoetatik sisteman txertatua izango den kodea automatikoki sor genezake. MDEk softwarea sortzeko orduan izan genezakeen konplexutasuna gainditu nahi du, garatzailei software-sistemen goi-mailako ereduetan lan egiteko aukera emanez. Hala ere, MDE-an oinarrituriko tresna komertzialak erabiliaz, zaila izaten da berauen bidez sorturiko kodearen errendimendua eta portaera sistema exekuzioan dagoenean ebaluatzea. Tresna horiek laguntza gutxi eskaintzen dute modelotatik sortutako kodea exekutatzen ari denean sisteman zer gertatzen ari denaren informazioa modeloaren terminoetan jasotzeko. Beraz, exekuzio denboran, oso zaila izaten da sistemaren portaera egokia den edo ez aztertzea modelo mailako informazio hori erabiliaz. Eskakizun horiek kudeatzeko modu bat, software modeloaren informazioa denbora errealean izatea da ([email protected] enfokea). [email protected] enfokearen helburu nagusietako bat, MDE enfokearekin garapen fasean sortutako modeloak exekuzio denboran (runtime-en) erabilgarri izatean datza. Exekuzio denboran egiaztapen edo testing-a egin ahal izateko lehen urratsa, testeatu nahi den software horren modeloa exekuzio denboran eskuragarri izatea da. Honela, exekuzio denborako egiaztapen edo berifikazioak softwarea modelatzeko erabili ditugun elementu berberak erabiliaz egin daitke (egungo egoera, gertaera, hurrengo egoera, eta abar). Tesi honen helburutako bat UML-State Machine modeloetan oinarritutako eta exekuzio denboran beren barne egoeraren informazioa modeloko elementu bidez probestu ahalko duten software osagaiak modu automatikoan sortzea da. Automatizazioari dagokionez, lehenik eta behin, software-osagai horiek automatikoki sortzen dituzten tresnak eskaintzen dituen metodologia proposatzen dugu. Bigarrenik, UMLSM oinarritutako software osagaiak automatikoki sortuko dituen herraminta bera proposatzen dugu. Exekuzio denboran eguneraketen jarraipenari, egiaztatzeari eta egokitzeari dagokionez, barne egoera UML-SM modelo terminoetan eskaintzen duten software osagaiak egiaztatzeko eta egokitzeko gai den kanpo exekuzio modulo bat proposatzen dugu. Honela, errore bat detektatzen bada, exekuzio garaian egokitze modulua aktibatuko da egokitzapen prozesu segurua martxan jarriaz. Honek, dagokion software osagaiari abixua bidaliko dio egokitzapena egin dezan. Gauza guztiak kontuan hartuta, software osagaien eta CPSen segurtasun maila orokorra hobetua izango da.Los sistemas cyber-físicos (CPSs) son sistemas de computación embebidos en los que la computación interactúa estrechamente con el mundo físico a través de sensores y actuadores. Los CPS se utilizan para controlar sistemas que proveen conocimiento del contexto. Este tipo de sistemas son sistemas complejos que suelen tener diferentes configuraciones y su estrategia de control puede configurarse en función de los datos del entorno y de la situación actual del contexto. Por lo tanto, en los entornos industriales actuales, el software de los sistemas embebidos tiene que hacer frente a la creciente complejidad, los escenarios inciertos y los requisitos de seguridad en tiempo de ejecución. Las máquinas de estado UML son un formalismo muy utilizado en industria para modelar el comportamiento lógico de este tipo de sistemas, y siguiendo el enfoque Model Driven Engineering (MDE) podemos generar código automáticamente a partir de estos modelos. El objetivo de MDE es superar la complejidad de la construcción de software permitiendo a los desarrolladores trabajar en los modelos de alto nivel de los sistemas de software en lugar de tener que codificar el control mediante lenguajes de programación de bajo nivel. Sin embargo, determinar y evaluar el comportamiento y el rendimiento en tiempo de ejecución de estos modelos generados mediante herramientas comerciales de MDE es una tarea difícil. Estas herramientas proporcionan poco apoyo para observar a nivel de modelo la ejecución del código generado a partir del modelo. Por lo tanto, no son muy adecuadas para poder recopilar la información de tiempo de ejecución necesaria para, por ejemplo, comprobar si se cumplen o no las restricciones definidas. Un enfoque para gestionar estos requisitos, es tener la información de los componentes de software en términos de modelo en tiempo de ejecución ([email protected]). El trabajo en [email protected] busca ampliar la aplicabilidad de los modelos producidos en fase de desarrollo mediante el enfoque MDE al entorno de tiempo de ejecución. Tener el modelo en tiempo de ejecución es el primer paso para poder llevar a cabo la verificación en tiempo de ejecución. Así, esta verificación se podrá realizar utilizando la información de los elementos del modelo (estado actual, evento, siguiente estado, etc.). El objetivo de esta tesis es avanzar en la práctica actual de generar automáticamente componentes software basados en Unified Modeling Language - State Machine (UML-SM) que sean capaces de proporcionar información interna en términos de modelos en tiempo de ejecución. En cuanto a la automatización, en primer lugar, proponemos una metodología soportada por herramientas para generar automáticamente estos componentes de software. En segundo lugar, proponemos un marco de trabajo de generación de componentes de software basado en UML-SM. En cuanto a la monitorización, verificación y adaptación en tiempo de ejecución, proponemos un módulo de tiempo de ejecución externalizado que es capaz de monitorizar y verificar la validez de los componentes del software en función de su estado interno en términos de modelo. Además, si se detecta un error, se activa el módulo de adaptación en tiempo de ejecución y se inicia el proceso de adaptación seguro en el componente de software correspondiente. Teniendo en cuenta todo esto, el nivel de seguridad global de los componentes del software y de los CPS se ve mejorado

Synthesis of Specifications and Refinement Maps for Real-Time Object Code Verification

Formal verification methods have been shown to be very effective in finding corner-case bugs and ensuring the safety of embedded software systems. The use of formal verification requires a specification, which is typically a high-level mathematical model that defines the correct behavior of the system to be verified. However, embedded software requirements are typically described in natural language. Transforming these requirements into formal specifications is currently a big gap. While there is some work in this area, we proposed solutions to address this gap in the context of refinement-based verification, a class of formal methods that have shown to be effective for embedded object code verification. The proposed approach also addresses both functional and timing requirements and has been demonstrated in the context of safety requirements for software control of infusion pumps. The next step in the verification process is to develop the refinement map, which is a mapping function that can relate an implementation state (in this context, the state of the object code program to be verified) with the specification state. Actually, constructing refinement maps often requires deep understanding and intuitions about the specification and implementation, it is shown very difficult to construct refinement maps manually. To go over this obstacle, the construction of refinement maps should be automated. As a first step toward the automation process, we manually developed refinement maps for various safety properties concerning the software control operation of infusion pumps. In addition, we identified possible generic templates for the construction of refinement maps. Recently, synthesizing procedures of refinement maps for functional and timing specifications are proposed. The proposed work develops a process that significantly increases the automation in the generation of these refinement maps. The refinement maps can then be used for refinement-based verification. This automation procedure has been successfully applied on the transformed safety requirements in the first part of our work. This approach is based on the identified generic refinement map templates which can be increased in the future as the application required

Payload training methodology study

The results of the Payload Training Methodology Study (PTMS) are documented. Methods and procedures are defined for the development of payload training programs to be conducted at the Marshall Space Flight Center Payload Training Complex (PCT) for the Space Station Freedom program. The study outlines the overall training program concept as well as the six methodologies associated with the program implementation. The program concept outlines the entire payload training program from initial identification of training requirements to the development of detailed design specifications for simulators and instructional material. The following six methodologies are defined: (1) The Training and Simulation Needs Assessment Methodology; (2) The Simulation Approach Methodology; (3) The Simulation Definition Analysis Methodology; (4) The Simulator Requirements Standardization Methodology; (5) The Simulator Development Verification Methodology; and (6) The Simulator Validation Methodology

Tools and Algorithms for the Construction and Analysis of Systems

This open access book constitutes the proceedings of the 28th International Conference on Tools and Algorithms for the Construction and Analysis of Systems, TACAS 2022, which was held during April 2-7, 2022, in Munich, Germany, as part of the European Joint Conferences on Theory and Practice of Software, ETAPS 2022. The 46 full papers and 4 short papers presented in this volume were carefully reviewed and selected from 159 submissions. The proceedings also contain 16 tool papers of the affiliated competition SV-Comp and 1 paper consisting of the competition report. TACAS is a forum for researchers, developers, and users interested in rigorously based tools and algorithms for the construction and analysis of systems. The conference aims to bridge the gaps between different communities with this common interest and to support them in their quest to improve the utility, reliability, exibility, and efficiency of tools and algorithms for building computer-controlled systems

Multilevel Runtime Verification for Safety and Security Critical Cyber Physical Systems from a Model Based Engineering Perspective

Advanced embedded system technology is one of the key driving forces behind the rapid growth of Cyber-Physical System (CPS) applications. CPS consists of multiple coordinating and cooperating components, which are often software-intensive and interact with each other to achieve unprecedented tasks. Such highly integrated CPSs have complex interaction failures, attack surfaces, and attack vectors that we have to protect and secure against. This dissertation advances the state-of-the-art by developing a multilevel runtime monitoring approach for safety and security critical CPSs where there are monitors at each level of processing and integration. Given that computation and data processing vulnerabilities may exist at multiple levels in an embedded CPS, it follows that solutions present at the levels where the faults or vulnerabilities originate are beneficial in timely detection of anomalies. Further, increasing functional and architectural complexity of critical CPSs have significant safety and security operational implications. These challenges are leading to a need for new methods where there is a continuum between design time assurance and runtime or operational assurance. Towards this end, this dissertation explores Model Based Engineering methods by which design assurance can be carried forward to the runtime domain, creating a shared responsibility for reducing the overall risk associated with the system at operation. Therefore, a synergistic combination of Verification & Validation at design time and runtime monitoring at multiple levels is beneficial in assuring safety and security of critical CPS. Furthermore, we realize our multilevel runtime monitor framework on hardware using a stream-based runtime verification language