Asymptotic normality of maximum likelihood and its variational approximation for stochastic blockmodels

Variational methods for parameter estimation are an active research area, potentially offering computationally tractable heuristics with theoretical performance bounds. We build on recent work that applies such methods to network data, and establish asymptotic normality rates for parameter estimates of stochastic blockmodel data, by either maximum likelihood or variational estimation. The result also applies to various sub-models of the stochastic blockmodel found in the literature.Comment: Published in at http://dx.doi.org/10.1214/13-AOS1124 the Annals of Statistics (http://www.imstat.org/aos/) by the Institute of Mathematical Statistics (http://www.imstat.org

Information-theoretic bounds and phase transitions in clustering, sparse PCA, and submatrix localization

We study the problem of detecting a structured, low-rank signal matrix corrupted with additive Gaussian noise. This includes clustering in a Gaussian mixture model, sparse PCA, and submatrix localization. Each of these problems is conjectured to exhibit a sharp information-theoretic threshold, below which the signal is too weak for any algorithm to detect. We derive upper and lower bounds on these thresholds by applying the first and second moment methods to the likelihood ratio between these "planted models" and null models where the signal matrix is zero. Our bounds differ by at most a factor of root two when the rank is large (in the clustering and submatrix localization problems, when the number of clusters or blocks is large) or the signal matrix is very sparse. Moreover, our upper bounds show that for each of these problems there is a significant regime where reliable detection is information- theoretically possible but where known algorithms such as PCA fail completely, since the spectrum of the observed matrix is uninformative. This regime is analogous to the conjectured 'hard but detectable' regime for community detection in sparse graphs.Comment: For sparse PCA and submatrix localization, we determine the information-theoretic threshold exactly in the limit where the number of blocks is large or the signal matrix is very sparse based on a conditional second moment method, closing the factor of root two gap in the first versio

Optimization via Low-rank Approximation for Community Detection in Networks

Community detection is one of the fundamental problems of network analysis, for which a number of methods have been proposed. Most model-based or criteria-based methods have to solve an optimization problem over a discrete set of labels to find communities, which is computationally infeasible. Some fast spectral algorithms have been proposed for specific methods or models, but only on a case-by-case basis. Here we propose a general approach for maximizing a function of a network adjacency matrix over discrete labels by projecting the set of labels onto a subspace approximating the leading eigenvectors of the expected adjacency matrix. This projection onto a low-dimensional space makes the feasible set of labels much smaller and the optimization problem much easier. We prove a general result about this method and show how to apply it to several previously proposed community detection criteria, establishing its consistency for label estimation in each case and demonstrating the fundamental connection between spectral properties of the network and various model-based approaches to community detection. Simulations and applications to real-world data are included to demonstrate our method performs well for multiple problems over a wide range of parameters.Comment: 45 pages, 7 figures; added discussions about computational complexity and extension to more than two communitie