Bulk Scheduling with the DIANA Scheduler

Results from the research and development of a Data Intensive and Network Aware (DIANA) scheduling engine, to be used primarily for data intensive sciences such as physics analysis, are described. In Grid analyses, tasks can involve thousands of computing, data handling, and network resources. The central problem in the scheduling of these resources is the coordinated management of computation and data at multiple locations and not just data replication or movement. However, this can prove to be a rather costly operation and efficient sing can be a challenge if compute and data resources are mapped without considering network costs. We have implemented an adaptive algorithm within the so-called DIANA Scheduler which takes into account data location and size, network performance and computation capability in order to enable efficient global scheduling. DIANA is a performance-aware and economy-guided Meta Scheduler. It iteratively allocates each job to the site that is most likely to produce the best performance as well as optimizing the global queue for any remaining jobs. Therefore it is equally suitable whether a single job is being submitted or bulk scheduling is being performed. Results indicate that considerable performance improvements can be gained by adopting the DIANA scheduling approach.Comment: 12 pages, 11 figures. To be published in the IEEE Transactions in Nuclear Science, IEEE Press. 200

Workload Schedulers - Genesis, Algorithms and Comparisons

In this article we provide brief descriptions of three classes of schedulers: Operating Systems Process Schedulers, Cluster Systems, Jobs Schedulers and Big Data Schedulers. We describe their evolution from early adoptions to modern implementations, considering both the use and features of algorithms. In summary, we discuss differences between all presented classes of schedulers and discuss their chronological development. In conclusion, we highlight similarities in the focus of scheduling strategies design, applicable to both local and distributed systems

DIANA Scheduling Hierarchies for Optimizing Bulk Job Scheduling

The use of meta-schedulers for resource management in large-scale distributed systems often leads to a hierarchy of schedulers. In this paper, we discuss why existing meta-scheduling hierarchies are sometimes not sufficient for Grid systems due to their inability to re-organise jobs already scheduled locally. Such a job re-organisation is required to adapt to evolving loads which are common in heavily used Grid infrastructures. We propose a peer-to-peer scheduling model and evaluate it using case studies and mathematical modelling. We detail the DIANA (Data Intensive and Network Aware) scheduling algorithm and its queue management system for coping with the load distribution and for supporting bulk job scheduling. We demonstrate that such a system is beneficial for dynamic, distributed and self-organizing resource management and can assist in optimizing load or job distribution in complex Grid infrastructures.Comment: 8 pages, 9 figures. Presented at the 2nd IEEE Int Conference on eScience & Grid Computing. Amsterdam Netherlands, December 200

Deadline-Aware Reservation-Based Scheduling

The ever-growing need to improve return-on-investment (ROI) for cluster infrastructure that processes data which is being continuously generated at a higher rate than ever before introduces new challenges for big-data processing frameworks. Highly complex mixed workload arriving at modern clusters along with a growing number of time-sensitive critical production jobs necessitates cluster management systems to evolve. Most big-data systems are not only required to guarantee that production jobs will complete before their deadline, but also minimize the latency for best-effort jobs to increase ROI. This research presents DARSS, a deadline-aware reservation-based scheduling system. DARSS addresses the above-stated problem by using a reservation-based approach to scheduling that supports temporal requirements of production jobs while keeping the latency for best-effort jobs low. Fined-grained resource allocation enables DARSS to schedule more tasks than a coarser-grained approach would. Furthermore, DARSS schedules production jobs as close to their deadlines as possible. This scheduling policy allows the system to maximize the number of low-priority tasks that can be scheduled opportunistically. DARSS is a scalable system that can be integrated with YARN. DARSS is evaluated on a simulated cluster of 300 nodes against a workload derived from Google Borg's trace. DARSS is compared with Microsoft's Rayon and YARN's built-in scheduler. DARSS achieves better production job acceptance rate than both YARN and Rayon. The experiments show that all of the production jobs accepted by DARSS complete before their deadlines. Furthermore, DARSS has a higher number of best-effort jobs serviced than Rayon. And finally, DARSS has lower latency for best-effort jobs than Rayon

MACRM: A Multi-agent Cluster Resource Management System

The falling cost of cluster computing has significantly increased its use in the last decade. As a result, the number of users, the size of clusters, and the diversity of jobs that are submitted to clusters have grown. These changes lead to a quest for redesigning of clusters' resource management systems. The growth in the number of users and increase in the size of clusters require a more scalable approach to resource management. Moreover, ever-increasing use of clusters for carrying out a diverse range of computations demands fault-tolerant and highly available cluster management systems. Last, but not the least, serving highly parallel and interactive jobs in a cluster with hundreds of nodes, requires high throughput scheduling with a very short service time. This research presents MACRM, a multi-agent cluster resource management system. MACRM is an adaptive distributed/centralized resource management system which addresses the requirements of scalability, fault-tolerance, high availability, and high throughput scheduling. It breaks up resource management responsibilities and delegates it to different agents to be scalable in various aspects. Also, modularity in MACRM's design increases fault-tolerance because components are replicable and recoverable. Furthermore, MACRM has a very short service time in different loads. It can maintain an average service time of less than 15ms by adaptively switching between centralized and distributed decision making based on a cluster's load. Comparing MACRM with representative centralized and distributed systems (YARN [67] and Sparrow [52]) shows several advantages. We show that MACRM scales better when the number of resources, users, or jobs increase in a cluster. As well, MACRM has faster and less expensive failure recovery mechanisms compared with the two other systems. And finally, our experiments show that MACRM's average service time beats the other systems, particularly in high loads

DIANA Scheduling Hierarchies for Optimizing Bulk Job Scheduling

The use of meta-schedulers for resource management in large-scale distributed systems often leads to a hierarchy of schedulers. In this paper, we discuss why existing meta-scheduling hierarchies are sometimes not sufficient for Grid systems due to their inability to re-organise jobs already scheduled locally. Such a job re-organisation is required to adapt to evolving loads which are common in heavily used Grid infrastructures. We propose a peer-topeer scheduling model and evaluate it using case studies and mathematical modelling. We detail the DIANA (Data Intensive and Network Aware) scheduling algorithm and its queue management system for coping with the load distribution and for supporting bulk job scheduling. We demonstrate that such a system is beneficial for dynamic, distributed and self-organizing resource management and can assist in optimizing load or job distribution in complex Grid infrastructures

A self-mobile skeleton in the presence of external loads

Multicore clusters provide cost-effective platforms for running CPU-intensive and data-intensive parallel applications. To effectively utilise these platforms, sharing their resources is needed amongst the applications rather than dedicated environments. When such computational platforms are shared, user applications must compete at runtime for the same resource so the demand is irregular and hence the load is changeable and unpredictable. This thesis explores a mechanism to exploit shared multicore clusters taking into account the external load. This mechanism seeks to reduce runtime by finding the best computing locations to serve the running computations. We propose a generic algorithmic data-parallel skeleton which is aware of its computations and the load state of the computing environment. This skeleton is structured using the Master/Worker pattern where the master and workers are distributed on the nodes of the cluster. This skeleton divides the problem into computations where all these computations are initiated by the master and coordinated by the distributed workers. Moreover, the skeleton has built-in mobility to implicitly move the parallel computations between two workers. This mobility is data mobility controlled by the application, the skeleton. This skeleton is not problem-specific and therefore it is able to execute different kinds of problems. Our experiments suggest that this skeleton is able to efficiently compensate for unpredictable load variations. We also propose a performance cost model that estimates the continuation time of the running computations locally and remotely. This model also takes the network delay, data size and the load state as inputs to estimate the transfer time of the potential movement. Our experiments demonstrate that this model takes accurate decisions based on estimates in different load patterns to reduce the total execution time. This model is problem-independent because it considers the progress of all current computations. Moreover, this model is based on measurements so it is not dependent on the programming language. Furthermore, this model takes into account the load state of the nodes on which the computation run. This state includes the characteristics of the nodes and hence this model is architecture-independent. Because the scheduling has direct impact on system performance, we support the skeleton with a cost-informed scheduler that uses a hybrid scheduling policy to improve the dynamicity and adaptivity of the skeleton. This scheduler has agents distributed over the participating workers to keep the load information up to date, trigger the estimations, and facilitate the mobility operations. On runtime, the skeleton co-schedules its computations over computational resources without interfering with the native operating system scheduler. We demonstrate that using a hybrid approach the system makes mobility decisions which lead to improved performance and scalability over large number of computational resources. Our experiments suggest that the adaptivity of our skeleton in shared environment improves the performance and reduces resource contention on nodes that are heavily loaded. Therefore, this adaptivity allows other applications to acquire more resources. Finally, our experiments show that the load scheduler has a low incurred overhead, not exceeding 0.6%, compared to the total execution time

Cluster Computing Review

In the past decade there has been a dramatic shift from mainframe or ‘host−centric’ computing to a distributed ‘client−server’ approach. In the next few years this trend is likely to continue with further shifts towards ‘network−centric’ computing becoming apparent. All these trends were set in motion by the invention of the mass−reproducible microprocessor by Ted Hoff of Intel some twenty−odd years ago. The present generation of RISC microprocessors are now more than a match for mainframes in terms of cost and performance. The long−foreseen day when collections of RISC microprocessors assembled together as a parallel computer could out perform the vector supercomputers has finally arrived. Such high−performance parallel computers incorporate proprietary interconnection networks allowing low−latency, high bandwidth inter−processor communications. However, for certain types of applications such interconnect optimization is unnecessary and conventional LAN technology is sufficient. This has led to the realization that clusters of high−performance workstations can be realistically used for a variety of applications either to replace mainframes, vector supercomputers and parallel computers or to better manage already installed collections of workstations. Whilst it is clear that ‘cluster computers’ have limitations, many institutions and companies are exploring this option. Software to manage such clusters is at an early stage of development and this report reviews the current state−of−the−art. Cluster computing is a rapidly maturing technology that seems certain to play an important part in the ‘network−centric’ computing future