ATNoSFERES revisited

ATNoSFERES is a Pittsburgh style Learning Classifier System (LCS) in which the rules are represented as edges of an Augmented Transition Network. Genotypes are strings of tokens of a stack-based language, whose execution builds the labeled graph. The original ATNoSFERES, using a bitstring to represent the language tokens, has been favorably compared in previous work to several Michigan style LCSs architectures in the context of Non Markov problems. Several modifications of ATNoSFERES are proposed here: the most important one conceptually being a representational change: each token is now represented by an integer, hence the genotype is a string of integers; several other modifications of the underlying grammar language are also proposed. The resulting ATNoSFERES-II is validated on several standard animat Non Markov problems, on which it outperforms all previously published results in the LCS literature. The reasons for these improvement are carefully analyzed, and some assumptions are proposed on the underlying mechanisms in order to explain these good results

Discrete and fuzzy dynamical genetic programming in the XCSF learning classifier system

A number of representation schemes have been presented for use within learning classifier systems, ranging from binary encodings to neural networks. This paper presents results from an investigation into using discrete and fuzzy dynamical system representations within the XCSF learning classifier system. In particular, asynchronous random Boolean networks are used to represent the traditional condition-action production system rules in the discrete case and asynchronous fuzzy logic networks in the continuous-valued case. It is shown possible to use self-adaptive, open-ended evolution to design an ensemble of such dynamical systems within XCSF to solve a number of well-known test problems

An Experimental Comparison between ATNoSFERES and ACS

International audienceAfter two papers comparing ATNoSFERES with XCSM, a Learning Classifier System with internal states, this paper is devoted to a comparison between ATNoSFERES and ACS (an Anticipatory Learning Classifier System). As previously, we focus on the way perceptual aliazing problems encountered in non-Markov environments are solved with both kinds of systems. We shortly present ATNoSFERES, a framework based on an indirect encoding Genetic Algorithm which builds finite-state automata controllers, and we compare it with ACS through two benchmark experiments. The comparison shows that the difference in performance between both system depends on the environment. This raises a discussion of the adequacy of both adaptive mechanisms to particular subclasses of non-Markov problems. Furthermore, since ACS converges much faster than ATNoSFERES, we discuss the need to introduce learning capabilities in our model. As a conclusion, we advocate for the need of more experimental comparisons between different systems in the Learning Classifier System community

An Experimental Comparison between ATNoSFERES and ACS

After two papers comparing ATNoSFERES with XCSM, a Learning Classifier System with internal states, this paper is devoted to a comparison between ATNoSFERES and ACS (an Anticipatory Learning Classifier System). As previously, we focus on the way perceptual aliazing problems encountered in non-Markov environments are solved with both kinds of systems. We shortly present ATNoSFERES, a framework based on an indirect encoding Genetic Algorithm which builds finite-state automata controllers, and we compare it with ACS through two benchmark experiments. The comparison shows that the difference in performance between both system depends on the environment. This raises a discussion of the adequacy of both adaptive mechanisms to particular subclasses of non-Markov problems. Furthermore, since ACS converges much faster than ATNoSFERES, we discuss the need to introduce learning capabilities in our model. As a conclusion, we advocate for the need of more experimental comparisons between different systems in the Learning Classifier System community