Metascheduling of HPC Jobs in Day-Ahead Electricity Markets

High performance grid computing is a key enabler of large scale collaborative computational science. With the promise of exascale computing, high performance grid systems are expected to incur electricity bills that grow super-linearly over time. In order to achieve cost effectiveness in these systems, it is essential for the scheduling algorithms to exploit electricity price variations, both in space and time, that are prevalent in the dynamic electricity price markets. In this paper, we present a metascheduling algorithm to optimize the placement of jobs in a compute grid which consumes electricity from the day-ahead wholesale market. We formulate the scheduling problem as a Minimum Cost Maximum Flow problem and leverage queue waiting time and electricity price predictions to accurately estimate the cost of job execution at a system. Using trace based simulation with real and synthetic workload traces, and real electricity price data sets, we demonstrate our approach on two currently operational grids, XSEDE and NorduGrid. Our experimental setup collectively constitute more than 433K processors spread across 58 compute systems in 17 geographically distributed locations. Experiments show that our approach simultaneously optimizes the total electricity cost and the average response time of the grid, without being unfair to users of the local batch systems.Comment: Appears in IEEE Transactions on Parallel and Distributed System

RLQ: Workload Allocation With Reinforcement Learning in Distributed Queues

Distributed workload queues are nowadays widely used due to their significant advantages in terms of decoupling, resilience, and scaling. Task allocation to worker nodes in distributed queue systems is typically simplistic (e.g., Least Recently Used) or uses hand-crafted heuristics that require task-specific information (e.g., task resource demands or expected time of execution). When such task information is not available and worker node capabilities are not homogeneous, the existing placement strategies may lead to unnecessarily large execution timings and usage costs. In this work, we formulate the task allocation problem in the Markov Decision Process framework, in which an agent assigns tasks to an available resource, and receives a numerical reward signal upon task completion. Our adaptive and learning-based task allocation solution, Reinforcement Learning based Queues (RLQ), is implemented and integrated with the popular Celery task queuing system for Python. We compare RLQ against traditional solutions using both synthetic and real workload traces. On average, using synthetic workloads, RLQ reduces the execution cost by approximately 70%, the execution time by a factor of at least 3×, and the waiting time by almost 7×. Using real traces, we observe an improvement of about 20% for execution cost, around 70% improvement for execution time, and a reduction of approximately 20× in waiting time. We also compare RLQ with a strategy inspired by E-PVM, a state-of-the-art solution used in Google's Borg cluster manager, showing we are able to outperform it in five out of six scenarios

RLQ: Workload Allocation With Reinforcement Learning in Distributed Queues

Distributed workload queues are nowadays widely used due to their significant advantages in terms of decoupling, resilience, and scaling. Task allocation to worker nodes in distributed queue systems is typically simplistic (e.g., Least Recently Used) or uses hand-crafted heuristics that require task-specific information (e.g., task resource demands or expected time of execution). When such task information is not available and worker node capabilities are not homogeneous, the existing placement strategies may lead to unnecessarily large execution timings and usage costs. In this work, we formulate the task allocation problem in the Markov Decision Process framework, in which an agent assigns tasks to an available resource, and receives a numerical reward signal upon task completion. Our adaptive and learning-based task allocation solution, Reinforcement Learning based Queues ( RLQ ), is implemented and integrated with the popular Celery task queuing system for Python. We compare RLQ against traditional solutions using both synthetic and real workload traces. On average, using synthetic workloads, RLQ reduces the execution cost by approximately 70%, the execution time by a factor of at least 3×, and the waiting time by almost 7×. Using real traces, we observe an improvement of about 20% for execution cost, around 70% improvement for execution time, and a reduction of approximately 20× in waiting time. We also compare RLQ with a strategy inspired by E-PVM, a state-of-the-art solution used in Google's Borg cluster manager, showing we are able to outperform it in five out of six scenarios

DESIGN AND EVALUATION OF RESOURCE ALLOCATION AND JOB SCHEDULING ALGORITHMS ON COMPUTATIONAL GRIDS

Grid, an infrastructure for resource sharing, currently has shown its importance in many scientific applications requiring tremendously high computational power. Grid computing enables sharing, selection and aggregation of resources for solving complex and large-scale scientific problems. Grids computing, whose resources are distributed, heterogeneous and dynamic in nature, introduces a number of fascinating issues in resource management. Grid scheduling is the key issue in grid environment in which its system must meet the functional requirements of heterogeneous domains, which are sometimes conflicting in nature also, like user, application, and network. Moreover, the system must satisfy non-functional requirements like reliability, efficiency, performance, effective resource utilization, and scalability. Thus, overall aim of this research is to introduce new grid scheduling algorithms for resource allocation as well as for job scheduling for enabling a highly efficient and effective utilization of the resources in executing various applications. The four prime aspects of this work are: firstly, a model of the grid scheduling problem for dynamic grid computing environment; secondly, development of a new web based simulator (SyedWSim), enabling the grid users to conduct a statistical analysis of grid workload traces and provides a realistic basis for experimentation in resource allocation and job scheduling algorithms on a grid; thirdly, proposal of a new grid resource allocation method of optimal computational cost using synthetic and real workload traces with respect to other allocation methods; and finally, proposal of some new job scheduling algorithms of optimal performance considering parameters like waiting time, turnaround time, response time, bounded slowdown, completion time and stretch time. The issue is not only to develop new algorithms, but also to evaluate them on an experimental computational grid, using synthetic and real workload traces, along with the other existing job scheduling algorithms. Experimental evaluation confirmed that the proposed grid scheduling algorithms possess a high degree of optimality in performance, efficiency and scalability

DESIGN AND EVALUATION OF RESOURCE ALLOCATION AND JOB SCHEDULING ALGORITHMS ON COMPUTATIONAL GRIDS

Grid, an infrastructure for resource sharing, currently has shown its importance in many scientific applications requiring tremendously high computational power. Grid computing enables sharing, selection and aggregation of resources for solving complex and large-scale scientific problems. Grids computing, whose resources are distributed, heterogeneous and dynamic in nature, introduces a number of fascinating issues in resource management. Grid scheduling is the key issue in grid environment in which its system must meet the functional requirements of heterogeneous domains, which are sometimes conflicting in nature also, like user, application, and network. Moreover, the system must satisfy non-functional requirements like reliability, efficiency, performance, effective resource utilization, and scalability. Thus, overall aim of this research is to introduce new grid scheduling algorithms for resource allocation as well as for job scheduling for enabling a highly efficient and effective utilization of the resources in executing various applications. The four prime aspects of this work are: firstly, a model of the grid scheduling problem for dynamic grid computing environment; secondly, development of a new web based simulator (SyedWSim), enabling the grid users to conduct a statistical\ud analysis of grid workload traces and provides a realistic basis for experimentation in resource allocation and job scheduling algorithms on a grid; thirdly, proposal of a new grid resource allocation method of optimal computational cost using synthetic and real workload traces with respect to other allocation methods; and finally, proposal of some new job scheduling algorithms of optimal performance considering parameters like waiting time, turnaround time, response time, bounded slowdown, completion time and stretch time. The issue is not only to develop new algorithms, but also to evaluate them on an experimental computational grid, using synthetic and real workload traces, along with the other existing job scheduling algorithms. Experimental evaluation confirmed that the proposed grid scheduling algorithms possess a high degree of optimality in performance, efficiency and scalability

Predicting Intermediate Storage Performance for Workflow Applications

Configuring a storage system to better serve an application is a challenging task complicated by a multidimensional, discrete configuration space and the high cost of space exploration (e.g., by running the application with different storage configurations). To enable selecting the best configuration in a reasonable time, we design an end-to-end performance prediction mechanism that estimates the turn-around time of an application using storage system under a given configuration. This approach focuses on a generic object-based storage system design, supports exploring the impact of optimizations targeting workflow applications (e.g., various data placement schemes) in addition to other, more traditional, configuration knobs (e.g., stripe size or replication level), and models the system operation at data-chunk and control message level. This paper presents our experience to date with designing and using this prediction mechanism. We evaluate this mechanism using micro- as well as synthetic benchmarks mimicking real workflow applications, and a real application.. A preliminary evaluation shows that we are on a good track to meet our objectives: it can scale to model a workflow application run on an entire cluster while offering an over 200x speedup factor (normalized by resource) compared to running the actual application, and can achieve, in the limited number of scenarios we study, a prediction accuracy that enables identifying the best storage system configuration

A Big Data Analyzer for Large Trace Logs

Current generation of Internet-based services are typically hosted on large data centers that take the form of warehouse-size structures housing tens of thousands of servers. Continued availability of a modern data center is the result of a complex orchestration among many internal and external actors including computing hardware, multiple layers of intricate software, networking and storage devices, electrical power and cooling plants. During the course of their operation, many of these components produce large amounts of data in the form of event and error logs that are essential not only for identifying and resolving problems but also for improving data center efficiency and management. Most of these activities would benefit significantly from data analytics techniques to exploit hidden statistical patterns and correlations that may be present in the data. The sheer volume of data to be analyzed makes uncovering these correlations and patterns a challenging task. This paper presents BiDAl, a prototype Java tool for log-data analysis that incorporates several Big Data technologies in order to simplify the task of extracting information from data traces produced by large clusters and server farms. BiDAl provides the user with several analysis languages (SQL, R and Hadoop MapReduce) and storage backends (HDFS and SQLite) that can be freely mixed and matched so that a custom tool for a specific task can be easily constructed. BiDAl has a modular architecture so that it can be extended with other backends and analysis languages in the future. In this paper we present the design of BiDAl and describe our experience using it to analyze publicly-available traces from Google data clusters, with the goal of building a realistic model of a complex data center.Comment: 26 pages, 10 figure