Nonlinear Attitude Filtering: A Comparison Study

This paper contains a concise comparison of a number of nonlinear attitude filtering methods that have attracted attention in the robotics and aviation literature. With the help of previously published surveys and comparison studies, the vast literature on the subject is narrowed down to a small pool of competitive attitude filters. Amongst these filters is a second-order optimal minimum-energy filter recently proposed by the authors. Easily comparable discretized unit quaternion implementations of the selected filters are provided. We conduct a simulation study and compare the transient behaviour and asymptotic convergence of these filters in two scenarios with different initialization and measurement errors inspired by applications in unmanned aerial robotics and space flight. The second-order optimal minimum-energy filter is shown to have the best performance of all filters, including the industry standard multiplicative extended Kalman filter (MEKF)

Q-Method Extended Kalman Filter

A new algorithm is proposed that smoothly integrates non-linear estimation of the attitude quaternion using Davenport s q-method and estimation of non-attitude states through an extended Kalman filter. The new method is compared to a similar existing algorithm showing its similarities and differences. The validity of the proposed approach is confirmed through numerical simulations

Statistical Attitude Determination

All spacecraft require attitude determination at some level of accuracy. This can be a very coarse requirement of tens of degrees, in order to point solar arrays at the sun, or a very fine requirement in the milliarcsecond range, as required by Hubble Space Telescope. A toolbox of attitude determination methods, applicable across this wide range, has been developed over the years. There have been many advances in the thirty years since the publication of Reference, but the fundamentals remain the same. One significant change is that onboard attitude determination has largely superseded ground-based attitude determination, due to the greatly increased power of onboard computers. The availability of relatively inexpensive radiation-hardened microprocessors has led to the development of "smart" sensors, with autonomous star trackers being the first spacecraft application. Another new development is attitude determination using interferometry of radio signals from the Global Positioning System (GPS) constellation. This article reviews both the classic material and these newer developments at approximately the level of, with emphasis on. methods suitable for use onboard a spacecraft. We discuss both "single frame" methods that are based on measurements taken at a single point in time, and sequential methods that use information about spacecraft dynamics to combine the information from a time series of measurements

Rigid Body Attitude Estimation: An Overview and Comparative Study

The attitude estimation of rigid body systems has attracted the attention of many researchers over the years. The development of efficient estimation algorithms that can accurately estimate the orientation of a rigid body is a crucial step towards a reliable implementation of control schemes for underwater and flying vehicles. The primary focus of this thesis consists in investigating various attitude estimation techniques and their applications. Two major classes are discussed. The first class consists of the earliest static attitude determination techniques relying solely on a set of body vector measurements of known vectors in the inertial frame. The second class consists of dynamic attitude estimation and filtering techniques, relying on body vector measurements as well other measurements, and using the dynamical equations of the system under consideration. Various attitude estimation algorithms, including the latest nonlinear attitude observers, are presented and discussed, providing a survey that covers the evolution and structural differences of these estimation methods. Simulation results have been carried out for a selected number of such attitude estimators. Their performance in the presence of noisy measurements, as well as their advantages and disadvantages are discussed

Manual Optical Attitude Re-initialization of a Crew Vehicle in Space Using Bias Corrected Gyro Data

NASA and other space agencies have shown interest in sending humans on missions beyond low Earth orbit. Proposed is an algorithm that estimates the attitude of a manned spacecraft using measured line-of-sight (LOS) vectors to stars and gyroscope measurements. The Manual Optical Attitude Reinitialization (MOAR) algorithm and corresponding device draw inspiration from existing technology from the Gemini, Apollo and Space Shuttle programs. The improvement over these devices is the capability of estimating gyro bias completely independent from re-initializing attitude. It may be applied to the lost-in-space problem, where the spacecraft\u27s attitude is unknown.;In this work, a model was constructed that simulated gyro data using the Farrenkopf gyro model, and LOS measurements from a spotting scope were then computed from it. Using these simulated measurements, gyro bias was estimated by comparing measured interior star angles to those derived from a star catalog and then minimizing the difference using an optimization technique. Several optimization techniques were analyzed, and it was determined that the Broyden-Fletcher-Goldfarb-Shanno (BFGS) algorithm performed the best when combined with a grid search technique. Once estimated, the gyro bias was removed and attitude was determined by solving the Wahba Problem via the Singular Value Decomposition (SVD) approach. Several Monte Carlo simulations were performed that looked at different operating conditions for the MOAR algorithm. These included the effects of bias instability, using different constellations for data collection, sampling star measurements in different orders, and varying the time between measurements. A common method of estimating gyro bias and attitude in a Multiplicative Extended Kalman Filter (MEKF) was also explored and disproven for use in the MOAR algorithm.;A prototype was also constructed to validate the proposed concepts. It was built using a simple spotting scope, MEMS grade IMU, and a Raspberry Pi computer. It was mounted on a tripod, used to target stars with the scope and measure the rotation between them using the IMU. The raw measurements were then post-processed using the MOAR algorithm, and attitude estimates were determined. Two different constellations---the Big Dipper and Orion---were used for experimental data collection. The results suggest that the novel method of estimating gyro bias independently from attitude in this document is credible for use onboard a spacecraft

Advanced navigation algorithms for precision landing

A detailed analysis of autonomous navigation algorithms to achieve autonomous precision landing is presented. The problem of integrated attitude determination and inertial navigation is solved. The theoretical results are applied and tested in three different applications. Optimality conditions for constrained quaternion estimation using the Kalman filter are derived. It is common in spacecraft applications to separate the attitude determination from the inertial navigation system. While this approach has worked in the past, it inevitably degrades the navigation performance when the correlations between the two systems are not correctly accounted for. It is shown how to optimally include an attitude determination algorithm into the Kalman filter. When the conditions to achieve optimality are not met, it is shown how to achieve sub-optimality by properly accounting for the correlation. The traditional approach to inertial navigation is to employ the inertial measurement unit (IMU) outputs to propagate the estimated states forward in time, rather then use them to update the state. A detailed covariance analysis of deadreckoning Mars entry navigation is performed. The contribution of various sources of IMU errors are explicitly accounted for and the filter performance is validated through Monte Carlo analysis. The drawback of dead-reckoning is that this approach prevents the inertial measurements from reducing the uncertainty of the estimated states. While this shortcoming can be compensated by the availability of other measurements, it becomes crucial when the IMU is the only sensor to provide measurements. Such a situation arises, for example, during Mars atmospheric entry. In the second application of this work, IMU measurements from a NASA mission are processed in an extended Kalman filter, and the results are compared to dead-reckoning. It is shown that is possible to reduce the uncertainty of the inertial states by filtering the IMU. The final application is lunar descent to landing navigation. In this example the IMU is filtered and the algorithms to include an attitude estimate into the Kalman filter are tested. The design performance is confirmed by Monte Carlo analysis.Aerospace Engineering and Engineering Mechanic

An aircraft sensor fault tolerant system

The design of a sensor fault tolerant system which uses analytical redundancy for the Terminal Configured Vehicle (TCV) research aircraft in a Microwave Landing System (MLS) environment was studied. The fault tolerant system provides reliable estimates for aircraft position, velocity, and attitude in the presence of possible failures in navigation aid instruments and onboard sensors. The estimates, provided by the fault tolerant system, are used by the automated guidance and control system to land the aircraft along a prescribed path. Sensor failures are identified by utilizing the analytic relationship between the various sensor outputs arising from the aircraft equations of motion

Attitude Estimation for Large Field-of-View Sensors

The QUEST measurement noise model for unit vector observations has been widely used in spacecraft attitude estimation for more than twenty years. It was derived under the approximation that the noise lies in the tangent plane of the respective unit vector and is axially symmetrically distributed about the vector. For large field-of-view sensors, however, this approximation may be poor, especially when the measurement falls near the edge of the field of view. In this paper a new measurement noise model is derived based on a realistic noise distribution in the focal-plane of a large field-of-view sensor, which shows significant differences from the QUEST model for unit vector observations far away from the sensor boresight. An extended Kalman filter for attitude estimation is then designed with the new measurement noise model. Simulation results show that with the new measurement model the extended Kalman filter achieves better estimation performance using large field-of-view sensor observations