A Comparative Case Study of HTTP Adaptive Streaming Algorithms in Mobile Networks

HTTP Adaptive Streaming (HAS) techniques are now the dominant solution for video delivery in mobile networks. Over the past few years, several HAS algorithms have been introduced in order to improve user quality-of-experience (QoE) by bit-rate adaptation. Their difference is mainly the required input information, ranging from network characteristics to application-layer parameters such as the playback buffer. Interestingly, despite the recent outburst in scientific papers on the topic, a comprehensive comparative study of the main algorithm classes is still missing. In this paper we provide such comparison by evaluating the performance of the state-of-the-art HAS algorithms per class, based on data from field measurements. We provide a systematic study of the main QoE factors and the impact of the target buffer level. We conclude that this target buffer level is a critical classifier for the studied HAS algorithms. While buffer-based algorithms show superior QoE in most of the cases, their performance may differ at the low target buffer levels of live streaming services. Overall, we believe that our findings provide valuable insight for the design and choice of HAS algorithms according to networks conditions and service requirements.Comment: 6 page

Understanding user experience of mobile video: Framework, measurement, and optimization

Since users have become the focus of product/service design in last decade, the term User eXperience (UX) has been frequently used in the field of Human-Computer-Interaction (HCI). Research on UX facilitates a better understanding of the various aspects of the user’s interaction with the product or service. Mobile video, as a new and promising service and research field, has attracted great attention. Due to the significance of UX in the success of mobile video (Jordan, 2002), many researchers have centered on this area, examining users’ expectations, motivations, requirements, and usage context. As a result, many influencing factors have been explored (Buchinger, Kriglstein, Brandt & Hlavacs, 2011; Buchinger, Kriglstein & Hlavacs, 2009). However, a general framework for specific mobile video service is lacking for structuring such a great number of factors. To measure user experience of multimedia services such as mobile video, quality of experience (QoE) has recently become a prominent concept. In contrast to the traditionally used concept quality of service (QoS), QoE not only involves objectively measuring the delivered service but also takes into account user’s needs and desires when using the service, emphasizing the user’s overall acceptability on the service. Many QoE metrics are able to estimate the user perceived quality or acceptability of mobile video, but may be not enough accurate for the overall UX prediction due to the complexity of UX. Only a few frameworks of QoE have addressed more aspects of UX for mobile multimedia applications but need be transformed into practical measures. The challenge of optimizing UX remains adaptations to the resource constrains (e.g., network conditions, mobile device capabilities, and heterogeneous usage contexts) as well as meeting complicated user requirements (e.g., usage purposes and personal preferences). In this chapter, we investigate the existing important UX frameworks, compare their similarities and discuss some important features that fit in the mobile video service. Based on the previous research, we propose a simple UX framework for mobile video application by mapping a variety of influencing factors of UX upon a typical mobile video delivery system. Each component and its factors are explored with comprehensive literature reviews. The proposed framework may benefit in user-centred design of mobile video through taking a complete consideration of UX influences and in improvement of mobile videoservice quality by adjusting the values of certain factors to produce a positive user experience. It may also facilitate relative research in the way of locating important issues to study, clarifying research scopes, and setting up proper study procedures. We then review a great deal of research on UX measurement, including QoE metrics and QoE frameworks of mobile multimedia. Finally, we discuss how to achieve an optimal quality of user experience by focusing on the issues of various aspects of UX of mobile video. In the conclusion, we suggest some open issues for future study

Distribuição de conteúdos over-the-top multimédia em redes sem fios

mestrado em Engenharia Eletrónica e TelecomunicaçõesHoje em dia a Internet é considerada um bem essencial devido ao facto de haver uma constante necessidade de comunicar, mas também de aceder e partilhar conteúdos. Com a crescente utilização da Internet, aliada ao aumento da largura de banda fornecida pelos operadores de telecomunicações, criaram-se assim excelentes condições para o aumento dos serviços multimédia Over-The-Top (OTT), demonstrado pelo o sucesso apresentado pelos os serviços Netflix e Youtube. O serviço OTT engloba a entrega de vídeo e áudio através da Internet sem um controlo direto dos operadores de telecomunicações, apresentando uma proposta atractiva de baixo custo e lucrativa. Embora a entrega OTT seja cativante, esta padece de algumas limitações. Para que a proposta se mantenha em crescimento e com elevados padrões de Qualidade-de-Experiência (QoE) para os consumidores, é necessário investir na arquitetura da rede de distribuição de conteúdos, para que esta seja capaz de se adaptar aos diversos tipos de conteúdo e obter um modelo otimizado com um uso cauteloso dos recursos, tendo como objectivo fornecer serviços OTT com uma boa qualidade para o utilizador, de uma forma eficiente e escalável indo de encontro aos requisitos impostos pelas redes móveis atuais e futuras. Esta dissertação foca-se na distribuição de conteúdos em redes sem fios, através de um modelo de cache distribuída entre os diferentes pontos de acesso, aumentando assim o tamanho da cache e diminuindo o tráfego necessário para os servidores ou caches da camada de agregação acima. Assim, permite-se uma maior escalabilidade e aumento da largura de banda disponível para os servidores de camada de agregação acima. Testou-se o modelo de cache distribuída em três cenários: o consumidor está em casa em que se considera que tem um acesso fixo, o consumidor tem um comportamento móvel entre vários pontos de acesso na rua, e o consumidor está dentro de um comboio em alta velocidade. Testaram-se várias soluções como Redis2, Cachelot e Memcached para servir de cache, bem como se avaliaram vários proxies para ir de encontro ás características necessárias. Mais ainda, na distribuição de conteúdos testaram-se dois algoritmos, nomeadamente o Consistent e o Rendezvouz Hashing. Ainda nesta dissertação utilizou-se uma proposta já existente baseada na previsão de conteúdos (prefetching ), que consiste em colocar o conteúdo nas caches antes de este ser requerido pelos consumidores. No final, verificou-se que o modelo distribuído com a integração com prefecthing melhorou a qualidade de experiência dos consumidores, bem como reduziu a carga nos servidores de camada de agregação acima.Nowadays, the Internet is considered an essential good, due to the fact that there is a need to communicate, but also to access and share information. With the increasing use of the Internet, allied with the increased bandwidth provided by telecommunication operators, it has created conditions for the increase of Over-the-Top (OTT) Multimedia Services, demonstrated by the huge success of Net ix and Youtube. The OTT service encompasses the delivery of video and audio through the Internet without direct control of telecommunication operators, presenting an attractive low-cost and pro table proposal. Although the OTT delivery is captivating, it has some limitations. In order to increase the number of clients and keep the high Quality of Experience (QoE) standards, an enhanced architecture for content distribution network is needed. Thus, the enhanced architecture needs to provide a good quality for the user, in an e cient and scalable way, supporting the requirements imposed by future mobile networks. This dissertation aims to approach the content distribution in wireless networks, through a distributed cache model among the several access points, thus increasing the cache size and decreasing the load on the upstream servers. The proposed architecture was tested in three di erent scenarios: the consumer is at home and it is considered that it has a xed access, the consumer is mobile between several access points in the street, the consumer is in a high speed train. Several solutions were evaluated, such as Redis2, Cachelot and Memcached to serve as caches, along with the evaluation of several proxies server in order to ful ll the required features. Also, it was tested two distributed algorithms, namely the Consistent and Rendezvous Hashing. Moreover, in this dissertation it was integrated a prefetching mechanism, which consists of inserting the content in caches before being requested by the consumers. At the end, it was veri ed that the distributed model with prefetching improved the consumers QoE as well as it reduced the load on the upstream servers

QoE for Mobile Streaming

No abstract