Hardware-Conscious Wireless Communication System Design

The work at hand is a selection of topics in efficient wireless communication system design, with topics logically divided into two groups.One group can be described as hardware designs conscious of their possibilities and limitations. In other words, it is about hardware that chooses its configuration and properties depending on the performance that needs to be delivered and the influence of external factors, with the goal of keeping the energy consumption as low as possible. Design parameters that trade off power with complexity are identified for analog, mixed signal and digital circuits, and implications of these tradeoffs are analyzed in detail. An analog front end and an LDPC channel decoder that adapt their parameters to the environment (e.g. fluctuating power level due to fading) are proposed, and it is analyzed how much power/energy these environment-adaptive structures save compared to non-adaptive designs made for the worst-case scenario. Additionally, the impact of ADC bit resolution on the energy efficiency of a massive MIMO system is examined in detail, with the goal of finding bit resolutions that maximize the energy efficiency under various system setups.In another group of themes, one can recognize systems where the system architect was conscious of fundamental limitations stemming from hardware.Put in another way, in these designs there is no attempt of tweaking or tuning the hardware. On the contrary, system design is performed so as to work around an existing and unchangeable hardware limitation. As a workaround for the problematic centralized topology, a massive MIMO base station based on the daisy chain topology is proposed and a method for signal processing tailored to the daisy chain setup is designed. In another example, a large group of cooperating relays is split into several smaller groups, each cooperatively performing relaying independently of the others. As cooperation consumes resources (such as bandwidth), splitting the system into smaller, independent cooperative parts helps save resources and is again an example of a workaround for an inherent limitation.From the analyses performed in this thesis, promising observations about hardware consciousness can be made. Adapting the structure of a hardware block to the environment can bring massive savings in energy, and simple workarounds prove to perform almost as good as the inherently limited designs, but with the limitation being successfully bypassed. As a general observation, it can be concluded that hardware consciousness pays off

Solutions pour l'auto-adaptation des systèmes sans fil

The current demand on ubiquitous connectivity imposes stringent requirements on the fabrication of Radio-Frequency (RF) circuits. Designs are consequently transferred to the most advanced CMOS technologies that were initially introduced to improve digital performance. In addition, as technology scales down, RF circuits are more and more susceptible to a lot of variations during their lifetime, as manufacturing process variability, temperature, environmental conditions, aging… As a result, the usual worst-case circuit design is leading to sub-optimal conditions, in terms of power and/or performance most of the time for the circuit. In order to counteract these variations, increasing the performances and also reduce power consumption, adaptation strategies must be put in place.More importantly, the fabrication process introduces more and more performance variability, which can have a dramatic impact on the fabrication yield. That is why RF designs are not easily fabricated in the most advanced CMOS technologies, as 32nm or 22nm nodes for instance. In this context, the performances of RF circuits need to be calibrated after fabrication so as to take these variations into account and recover yield loss.This thesis work is presenting on a post-fabrication calibration technique for RF circuits. This technique is performed during production testing with minimum extra cost, which is critical since the cost of test can be comparable to the cost of fabrication concerning RF circuits and cannot be further raised. Calibration is enabled by equipping the circuit with tuning knobs and sensors. Optimal tuning knob identification is achieved in one-shot based on a single test step that involves measuring the sensor outputs once. For this purpose, we rely on variation-aware sensors which provide measurements that remain invariant under tuning knob changes. As an auxiliary benefit, the variation-aware sensors are non-intrusive and totally transparent to the circuit.Our proposed methodology has first been demonstrated with simulation data with an RF power amplifier as a case study. Afterwards, a silicon demonstrator has then been fabricated in a 65nm technology in order to fully demonstrate the methodology. The fabricated dataset of circuits is extracted from typical and corner wafers. This feature is very important since corner circuits are the worst design cases and therefore the most difficult to calibrate. In our case, corner circuits represent more than the two third of the overall dataset and the calibration can still be proven. In details, fabrication yield based on 3 sigma performance specifications is increased from 21% to 93%. This is a major performance of the technique, knowing that worst case circuits are very rare in industrial fabrication.La demande courante de connectivité instantanée impose un cahier des charges très strict sur la fabrication des circuits Radio-Fréquences (RF). Les circuits doivent donc être transférées vers les technologies les plus avancées, initialement introduites pour augmenter les performances des circuits purement numériques. De plus, les circuits RF sont soumis à de plus en plus de variations et cette sensibilité s’accroît avec l’avancées des technologies. Ces variations sont par exemple les variations du procédé de fabrication, la température, l’environnement, le vieillissement… Par conséquent, la méthode classique de conception de circuits “pire-cas” conduit à une utilisation non-optimale du circuit dans la vaste majorité des conditions, en termes de performances et/ou de consommation. Ces variations doivent donc être compensées, en utilisant des techniques d’adaptation.De manière plus importante encore, le procédé de fabrication des circuits introduit de plus en plus de variabilité dans les performances des circuits, ce qui a un impact important sur le rendement de fabrication des circuits. Pour cette raison, les circuits RF sont difficilement fabriqués dans les technologies CMOS les plus avancées comme les nœuds 32nm ou 22nm. Dans ce contexte, les performances des circuits RF doivent êtres calibrées après fabrication pour prendre en compte ces variations et retrouver un haut rendement de fabrication.Ce travail de these présente une méthode de calibration post-fabrication pour les circuits RF. Cette méthodologie est appliquée pendant le test de production en ajoutant un minimum de coût, ce qui est un point essentiel car le coût du test est aujourd’hui déjà comparable au coût de fabrication d’un circuit RF et ne peut être augmenté d’avantage. Par ailleurs, la puissance consommée est aussi prise en compte pour que l’impact de la calibration sur la consommation soit minimisé. La calibration est rendue possible en équipant le circuit avec des nœuds de réglages et des capteurs. L’identification de la valeur de réglage optimale du circuit est obtenue en un seul coup, en testant les performances RF une seule et unique fois. Cela est possible grâce à l’utilisation de capteurs de variations du procédé de fabrication qui sont invariants par rapport aux changements des nœuds de réglage. Un autre benefice de l’utilisation de ces capteurs de variation sont non-intrusifs et donc totalement transparents pour le circuit sous test. La technique de calibration a été démontrée sur un amplificateur de puissance RF utilisé comme cas d’étude. Une première preuve de concept est développée en utilisant des résultats de simulation.Un démonstrateur en silicium a ensuite été fabriqué en technologie 65nm pour entièrement démontrer le concept de calibration. L’ensemble des puces fabriquées a été extrait de trois types de wafer différents, avec des transistors aux performances lentes, typiques et rapides. Cette caractéristique est très importante car elle nous permet de considérer des cas de procédé de fabrication extrêmes qui sont les plus difficiles à calibrer. Dans notre cas, ces circuits représentent plus des deux tiers des puces à disposition et nous pouvons quand même prouver notre concept de calibration. Dans le détails, le rendement de fabrication passe de 21% avant calibration à plus de 93% après avoir appliqué notre méthodologie. Cela constitue une performance majeure de notre méthodologie car les circuits extrêmes sont très rares dans une fabrication industrielle

Architectures and Circuit Techniques for High-Performance Field-Programmable CMOS Software Defined Radios

Next-generation wireless communication systems put more stringent performance requirements on the wireless RF receiver circuits. Sensitivity, linearity, bandwidth and power consumption are some of the most important specifications that often face tightly coupled tradeoffs between them. To increase the data throughput, a large number of fragmented spectrums are being introduced to the wireless communication standards. Carrier aggregation technology needs concurrent communication across several non-contiguous frequency bands, which results in a rapidly growing number of band combinations. Supporting all the frequency bands and their aggregation combinations increases the complexity of the RF receivers. Highly flexible software defined radio (SDR) is a promising technology to address these applications scenarios with lower complexity by relaxing the specifications of the RF filters or eliminating them. However, there are still many technology challenges with both the receiver architecture and the circuit implementations. The performance requirements of the receivers can also vary across different application scenario and RF environments. Field-programmable dynamic performance tradeoff can potentially reduce the power consumption of the receiver. In this dissertation, we address the performance enhancement challenges in the wideband SDRs by innovations at both the circuit building block level and the receiver architecture level. A series of research projects are conducted to push the state-of-the-art performance envelope and add features such as field-programmable performance tradeoff and concurrent reception. The projects originate from the concept of thermal noise canceling techniques and further enhance the RF performance and add features for more capable SDR receivers. Four generations of prototype LNA or receiver chips are designed, and each of them pushes at least one aspect of the RF performance such as bandwidth, linearity, and NF. A noise-canceling distributed LNA breaks the tradeoff between NF and RF bandwidth by introducing microwave circuit techniques from the distributed amplifiers. The LNA architecture uniquely provides ultra high bandwidth and low NF at low frequencies. A family of field-programmable LNA realized field-programmable performance tradeoff with current-reuse programmable transconductance cells. Interferer-reflecting loops can be applied around the LNAs to improve their input linearity by rejecting the out-of-band interferers with a wideband low in- put impedance. A low noise transconductance amplifier (LNTA) that operates in class-AB-C is invented to can handle rail-to-rail out-of-band blocker without saturation. Class-AB and class-C transconductors form a composite amplifier to increase the linear range of the input voltage. A new antenna interface named frequency-translational quadrature-hybrid (FTQH) breaks the input impedance matching requirement of the LNAs by introducing quadrature hybrid couplers to the CMOS RFIC design. The FTQH receiver achieves wideband sub-1dB NF and supports scalable massive frequency-agile concurrent reception

Enabling low cost test and tuning of difficult-to-measure device specifications: application to DC-DC converters and high speed devices

Low-cost test and tuning methods for difficult-to-measure specifications are presented in this research from the following perspectives: 1)"Safe" test and self-tuning for power converters: To avoid the risk of device under test (DUT) damage during conventional load/line regulation measurement on power converter, a "safe" alternate test structure is developed where the power converter (boost/buck converter) is placed in a different mode of operation during alternative test (light switching load) as opposed to standard test (heavy switching load) to prevent damage to the DUT during manufacturing test. Based on the alternative test structure, self-tuning methods for both boost and buck converters are also developed in this thesis. In addition, to make these test structures suitable for on-chip built-in self-test (BIST) application, a special sensing circuit has been designed and implemented. Stability analysis filters and appropriate models are also implemented to predict the DUT’s electrical stability condition during test and to further predict the values of tuning knobs needed for the tuning process. 2) High bandwidth RF signal generation: Up-convertion has been widely used in high frequency RF signal generation but mixer nonlinearity results in signal distortion that is difficult to eliminate with such methods. To address this problem, a framework for low-cost high-fidelity wideband RF signal generation is developed in this thesis. Depending on the band-limited target waveform, the input data for two interleaved DACs (digital-to-analog converters) system is optimized by a matrix-model-based algorithm in such a way that it minimizes the distortion between one of its image replicas in the frequency domain and the target RF waveform within a specified signal bandwidth. The approach is used to demonstrate how interferers with specified frequency characteristics can be synthesized at low cost for interference testing of RF communications systems. The frameworks presented in this thesis have a significant impact in enabling low-cost test and tuning of difficult-to-measure device specifications for power converter and high-speed devices.Ph.D