Filter Bubbles in Recommender Systems: Fact or Fallacy -- A Systematic Review

A filter bubble refers to the phenomenon where Internet customization effectively isolates individuals from diverse opinions or materials, resulting in their exposure to only a select set of content. This can lead to the reinforcement of existing attitudes, beliefs, or conditions. In this study, our primary focus is to investigate the impact of filter bubbles in recommender systems. This pioneering research aims to uncover the reasons behind this problem, explore potential solutions, and propose an integrated tool to help users avoid filter bubbles in recommender systems. To achieve this objective, we conduct a systematic literature review on the topic of filter bubbles in recommender systems. The reviewed articles are carefully analyzed and classified, providing valuable insights that inform the development of an integrated approach. Notably, our review reveals evidence of filter bubbles in recommendation systems, highlighting several biases that contribute to their existence. Moreover, we propose mechanisms to mitigate the impact of filter bubbles and demonstrate that incorporating diversity into recommendations can potentially help alleviate this issue. The findings of this timely review will serve as a benchmark for researchers working in interdisciplinary fields such as privacy, artificial intelligence ethics, and recommendation systems. Furthermore, it will open new avenues for future research in related domains, prompting further exploration and advancement in this critical area.Comment: 21 pages, 10 figures and 5 table

Learning domain-specific sentiment lexicons with applications to recommender systems

Search is now going beyond looking for factual information, and people wish to search for the opinions of others to help them in their own decision-making. Sentiment expressions or opinion expressions are used by users to express their opinion and embody important pieces of information, particularly in online commerce. The main problem that the present dissertation addresses is how to model text to find meaningful words that express a sentiment. In this context, I investigate the viability of automatically generating a sentiment lexicon for opinion retrieval and sentiment classification applications. For this research objective we propose to capture sentiment words that are derived from online users’ reviews. In this approach, we tackle a major challenge in sentiment analysis which is the detection of words that express subjective preference and domain-specific sentiment words such as jargon. To this aim we present a fully generative method that automatically learns a domain-specific lexicon and is fully independent of external sources. Sentiment lexicons can be applied in a broad set of applications, however popular recommendation algorithms have somehow been disconnected from sentiment analysis. Therefore, we present a study that explores the viability of applying sentiment analysis techniques to infer ratings in a recommendation algorithm. Furthermore, entities’ reputation is intrinsically associated with sentiment words that have a positive or negative relation with those entities. Hence, is provided a study that observes the viability of using a domain-specific lexicon to compute entities reputation. Finally, a recommendation system algorithm is improved with the use of sentiment-based ratings and entities reputation

Effectiveness of Data Enrichment on Categorization: Two Case Studies on Short Texts and User Movements

The widespread diffusion of mobile devices, e.g., smartphones and tablets, has made possible a huge increment in data generation by users. Nowadays, about a billion users daily interact on online social media, where they share information and discuss about a wide variety of topics, sometimes including the places they visit. Furthermore, the use of mobile devices makes available a large amount of data tracked by integrated sensors, which monitor several users’ activities, again including their position. The content produced by users are composed of few elements, such as only some words in a social post, or a simple GPS position, therefore a poor source of information to analyze. On this basis, a data enrichment process may provide additional knowledge by exploiting other related sources to extract additional data. The aim of this dissertation is to analyze the effectiveness of data enrichment for categorization, in particular on two domains, short texts and user movements. We de- scribe the concept behind our experimental design where users’ content are represented as abstract objects in a geometric space, with distances representing relatedness and similarity values, and contexts representing regions close to the each object where it is possibile to find other related objects, and therefore suitable as data enrichment source. Regarding short texts our research involves a novel approach on short text enrichment and categorization, and an extensive study on the properties of data used as enrich- ment. We analyze the temporal context and a set of properties which characterize data from an external source in order to properly select and extract additional knowledge related to textual content that users produce. We use Twitter as short texts source to build datasets for all experiments. Regarding user movements we address the problem of places categorization recognizing important locations that users visit frequently and intensively. We propose a novel approach on places categorization based on a feature space which models the users’ movement habits. We analyze both temporal and spa- tial context to find additional information to use as data enrichment and improve the importance recognition process. We use an in-house built dataset of GPS logs and the GeoLife public dataset for our experiments. Experimental evaluations on both our stud- ies highlight how the enrichment phase has a considerable impact on each process, and the results demonstrate its effectiveness. In particular, the short texts analysis shows how news articles are documents particularly suitable to be used as enrichment source, and their freshness is an important property to consider. User Movements analysis demonstrates how the context with additional data helps, even with user trajectories difficult to analyze. Finally, we provide an early stage study on user modeling. We exploit the data extracted with enrichment on the short texts to build a richer user profile. The enrichment phase, combined with a network-based approach, improves the profiling process providing higher scores in similarity computation where expectedCo-supervisore: Ivan ScagnettoopenDottorato di ricerca in Informaticaope

Preferences in Case-Based Reasoning

Case-based reasoning (CBR) is a well-established problem solving paradigm that has been used in a wide range of real-world applications. Despite its great practical success, work on the theoretical foundations of CBR is still under way, and a coherent and universally applicable methodological framework is yet missing. The absence of such a framework inspired the motivation for the work developed in this thesis. Drawing on recent research on preference handling in Artificial Intelligence and related fields, the goal of this work is to develop a well theoretically-founded framework on the basis of formal concepts and methods for knowledge representation and reasoning with preferences

Preference Modeling in Data-Driven Product Design: Application in Visual Aesthetics

Creating a form that is attractive to the intended market audience is one of the greatest challenges in product development given the subjective nature of preference and heterogeneous market segments with potentially different product preferences. Accordingly, product designers use a variety of qualitative and quantitative research tools to assess product preferences across market segments, such as design theme clinics, focus groups, customer surveys, and design reviews; however, these tools are still limited due to their dependence on subjective judgment, and being time and resource intensive. In this dissertation, we focus on a key research question: how can we understand and predict more reliably the preference for a future product in heterogeneous markets, so that this understanding can inform designers' decision-making? We present a number of data-driven approaches to model product preference. Instead of depending on any subjective judgment from human, the proposed preference models investigate the mathematical patterns behind users’ choice and behavior. This allows a more objective translation of customers' perception and preference into analytical relations that can inform design decision-making. Moreover, these models are scalable in that they have the capacity to analyze large-scale data and model customer heterogeneity accurately across market segments. In particular, we use feature representation as an intermediate step in our preference model, so that we can not only increase the predictive accuracy of the model but also capture in-depth insight into customers' preference. We tested our data-driven approaches with applications in visual aesthetics preference. Our results show that the proposed approaches can obtain an objective measurement of aesthetic perception and preference for a given market segment. This measurement enables designers to reliably evaluate and predict the aesthetic appeal of their designs. We also quantify the relative importance of aesthetic attributes when both aesthetic attributes and functional attributes are considered by customers. This quantification has great utility in helping product designers and executives in design reviews and selection of designs. Moreover, we visualize the possible factors affecting customers' perception of product aesthetics and how these factors differ across different market segments. Those visualizations are incredibly important to designers as they relate physical design details to psychological customer reactions. The main contribution of this dissertation is to present purely data-driven approaches that enable designers to quantify and interpret more reliably the product preference. Methodological contributions include using modern probabilistic approaches and feature learning algorithms to quantitatively model the design process involving product aesthetics. These novel approaches can not only increase the predictive accuracy but also capture insights to inform design decision-making.PHDDesign ScienceUniversity of Michigan, Horace H. Rackham School of Graduate Studieshttps://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/145987/1/yanxinp_1.pd