Harmonic Sum-based Method for Heart Rate Estimation using PPG Signals Affected with Motion Artifacts

Wearable photoplethysmography has recently become a common technology in heart rate (HR) monitoring. General observation is that the motion artifacts change the statistics of the acquired PPG signal. Consequently, estimation of HR from such a corrupted PPG signal is challenging. However, if an accelerometer is also used to acquire the acceleration signal simultaneously, it can provide helpful information that can be used to reduce the motion artifacts in the PPG signal. By dint of repetitive movements of the subjects hands while running, the accelerometer signal is found to be quasi-periodic. Over short-time intervals, it can be modeled by a finite harmonic sum (HSUM). Using the HSUM model, we obtain an estimate of the instantaneous fundamental frequency of the accelerometer signal. Since the PPG signal is a composite of the heart rate information (that is also quasi-periodic) and the motion artifact, we fit a joint HSUM model to the PPG signal. One of the harmonic sums corresponds to the heart-beat component in PPG and the other models the motion artifact. However, the fundamental frequency of the motion artifact has already been determined from the accelerometer signal. Subsequently, the HR is estimated from the joint HSUM model. The mean absolute error in HR estimates was 0.7359 beats per minute (BPM) with a standard deviation of 0.8328 BPM for 2015 IEEE Signal Processing cup data. The ground-truth HR was obtained from the simultaneously acquired ECG for validating the accuracy of the proposed method. The proposed method is compared with four methods that were recently developed and evaluated on the same dataset

Accurate wearable heart rate monitoring during physical exercises using PPG

Objective: The challenging task of heart rate (HR) estimation from the photoplethysmographic (PPG) signal, during intensive physical exercises is tackled in this paper. Methods: The study presents a detailed analysis of a novel algorithm (WFPV) that exploits a Wiener filter to attenuate the motion artifacts, a phase vocoder to refine the HR estimate and user-adaptive postprocessing to track the subject physiology. Additionally, an offline version of the HR estimation algorithm that uses Viterbi decoding is designed for scenarios that do not require online HR monitoring (WFPV+VD). The performance of the HR estimation systems is rigorously compared with existing algorithms on the publically available database of 23 PPG recordings. Results: On the whole dataset of 23 PPG recordings, the algorithms result in average absolute errors of 1.97 and 1.37 BPM in the online and offline modes, respectively. On the test dataset of 10 PPG recordings which were most corrupted with motion artifacts, WFPV has an error of 2.95 BPM on its own and 2.32 BPM in an ensemble with 2 existing algorithms. Conclusion: The error rate is significantly reduced when compared with the state-of-the art PPG-based HR estimation methods. Significance: The proposed system is shown to be accurate in the presence of strong motion artifacts and in contrast to existing alternatives has very few free parameters to tune. The algorithm has a low computational cost and can be used for fitness tracking and health monitoring in wearable devices. The Matlab implementation of the algorithm is provided online

On the Feasibility of Real-Time HRV Estimation Using Overly Noisy PPG Signals

Funding Information: This work was funded by the Fundação para a Ciência e Tecnologia (FCT, Portugal) and NMT, S.A in the scope of the PhD grant PD/BDE/150312/2019 and by FCT within the scope of the CTS Research Unit—Center of Technology and Systems—UNINOVA, under the project UIDB/00066/2020 (FCT). Publisher Copyright: © 2022 by the authors.Heart Rate Variability (HRV) is a biomarker that can be obtained non-invasively from the electrocardiogram (ECG) or the photoplethysmogram (PPG) fiducial points. However, the accuracy of HRV can be compromised by the presence of artifacts. In the herein presented work, a Simulink® model with a deep learning component was studied for overly noisy PPG signals. A subset with these noisy signals was selected for this study, with the purpose of testing a real-time machine learning based HRV estimation system in substandard artifact-ridden signals. Home-based and wearable HRV systems are prone to dealing with higher contaminated signals, given the less controlled environment where the acquisitions take place, namely daily activity movements. This was the motivation behind this work. The results for overly noisy signals show that the real-time PPG-based HRV estimation system produced RMSE and Pearson correlation coefficient mean and standard deviation of 0.178 ± 0.138 s and 0.401 ± 0.255, respectively. This RMSE value is roughly one order of magnitude above the closest comparative results for which the real-time system was also used.publishersversionpublishe

Heart rate estimation from photoplethysmogram and accleration smartphone data based on convolutional neuralnetwork and long short time memory network

The wearable reflective photocapacitance plethysmograph (PPG) sensor can be integrated into the watch or strap to provide instantaneous heart rate (HRs), causing minimal inconvenience to users. However, the existence of motion artifacts (MAs) leads to inaccurate heart rate estimation. In order to solve this problem, I propose a new deep learning neural network to ensure accurate estimation of HR in high-intensity exercise.The average absolute error of the algorithm for all training data sets and test data sets is less than 1.5 bpm, including 1.09 bpm for training data sets and 1.46 bpm for test data sets

A novel artifact reconstruction method applied to blood pressure signals

Peer ReviewedPostprint (published version

Characterizing the Noise Associated with Sensor Placement and Motion Artifacts and Overcoming its Effects for Body-worn Physiological Sensors

Wearable sensors for continuous physiological monitoring have the potential to change the paradigm for healthcare by providing information in scenarios not covered by the existing clinical model. One key challenge for wearable physiological sensors is that their signal-to-noise ratios are low compared to those of their medical grade counterparts in hospitals. Two primary sources of noise are the sensor-skin contact interface and motion artifacts due to the user’s daily activities. These are challenging problems because the initial sensor placement by the user may not be ideal, the skin conditions can change over time, and the nature of motion artifacts is not predictable. The objective of this research is twofold. The first is to design sensors with reconfigurable contact to mitigate the effects of misplaced sensors or changing skin conditions. The second is to leverage signal processing techniques for accurate physiological parameter estimation despite the presence of motion artifacts. In this research, the sensor contact problem was specifically addressed for dry-contact electroencephalography (EEG). The proposed novel extension to a popular existing EEG electrode design enabled reconfigurable contact to adjust to variations in sensor placement and skin conditions over time. Experimental results on human subjects showed that reconfiguration of contact can reduce the noise in collected EEG signals without the need for manual intervention. To address the motion artifact problem, a particle filter based approach was employed to track the heart rate in cardiac signals affected by the movements of the user. The algorithm was tested on cardiac signals from human subjects running on a treadmill and showed good performance in accurately tracking heart rate. Moreover, the proposed algorithm enables fusion of multiple modalities and is also computationally more efficient compared to other contemporary approaches

Heart Rate Estimation During Physical Exercise Using Wrist-Type Ppg Sensors

Accurate heart rate monitoring during intense physical exercise is a challenging problem due to the high levels of motion artifacts (MA) in photoplethysmography (PPG) sensors. PPG is a non-invasive optical sensor that is being used in wearable devices to measure blood flow changes using the property of light reflection and absorption, allowing the extraction of vital signals such as the heart rate (HR). However, the sensor is susceptible to MA which increases during physical activity. This occurs since the frequency range of movement and HR overlaps, difficulting correct HR estimation. For this reason, MA removal has remained an active topic under research. Several approaches have been developed in the recent past and among these, a Kalman filter (KF) based approach showed promising results for an accurate estimation and tracking using PPG sensors. However, this previous tracker was demonstrated for a particular dataset, with manually tuned parameters. Moreover, such trackers do not account for the correct method for fusing data. Such a custom approach might not perform accurately in practical scenarios, where the amount of MA and the heart rate variability (HRV) depend on numerous, unpredictable factors. Thus, an approach to automatically tune the KF based on the Expectation-Maximization (EM) algorithm, with a measurement fusion approach is developed. The applicability of such a method is demonstrated using an open-source PPG database, as well as a developed synthetic generation tool that models PPG and accelerometer (ACC) signals during predetermined physical activities

Acoustic sensing as a novel approach for cardiovascular monitoring at the wrist

Cardiovascular diseases are the number one cause of deaths globally. An increased cardiovascular risk can be detected by a regular monitoring of the vital signs including the heart rate, the heart rate variability (HRV) and the blood pressure. For a user to undergo continuous vital sign monitoring, wearable systems prove to be very useful as the device can be integrated into the user's lifestyle without affecting the daily activities. However, the main challenge associated with the monitoring of these cardiovascular parameters is the requirement of different sensing mechanisms at different measurement sites. There is not a single wearable device that can provide sufficient physiological information to track the vital signs from a single site on the body. This thesis proposes a novel concept of using acoustic sensing over the radial artery to extract cardiac parameters for vital sign monitoring. A wearable system consisting of a microphone is designed to allow the detection of the heart sounds together with the pulse wave, an attribute not possible with existing wrist-based sensing methods. Methods: The acoustic signals recorded from the radial artery are a continuous reflection of the instantaneous cardiac activity. These signals are studied and characterised using different algorithms to extract cardiovascular parameters. The validity of the proposed principle is firstly demonstrated using a novel algorithm to extract the heart rate from these signals. The algorithm utilises the power spectral analysis of the acoustic pulse signal to detect the S1 sounds and additionally, the K-means method to remove motion artifacts for an accurate heartbeat detection. The HRV in the short-term acoustic recordings is found by extracting the S1 events using the relative information between the short- and long-term energies of the signal. The S1 events are localised using three different characteristic points and the best representation is found by comparing the instantaneous heart rate profiles. The possibility of measuring the blood pressure using the wearable device is shown by recording the acoustic signal under the influence of external pressure applied on the arterial branch. The temporal and spectral characteristics of the acoustic signal are utilised to extract the feature signals and obtain a relationship with the systolic blood pressure (SBP) and diastolic blood pressure (DBP) respectively. Results: This thesis proposes three different algorithms to find the heart rate, the HRV and the SBP/ DBP readings from the acoustic signals recorded at the wrist. The results obtained by each algorithm are as follows: 1. The heart rate algorithm is validated on a dataset consisting of 12 subjects with a data length of 6 hours. The results demonstrate an accuracy of 98.78%, mean absolute error of 0.28 bpm, limits of agreement between -1.68 and 1.69 bpm, and a correlation coefficient of 0.998 with reference to a state-of-the-art PPG-based commercial device. A high statistical agreement between the heart rate obtained from the acoustic signal and the photoplethysmography (PPG) signal is observed. 2. The HRV algorithm is validated on the short-term acoustic signals of 5-minutes duration recorded from each of the 12 subjects. A comparison is established with the simultaneously recorded electrocardiography (ECG) and PPG signals respectively. The instantaneous heart rate for all the subjects combined together achieves an accuracy of 98.50% and 98.96% with respect to the ECG and PPG signals respectively. The results for the time-domain and frequency-domain HRV parameters also demonstrate high statistical agreement with the ECG and PPG signals respectively. 3. The algorithm proposed for the SBP/ DBP determination is validated on 104 acoustic signals recorded from 40 adult subjects. The experimental outputs when compared with the reference arm- and wrist-based monitors produce a mean error of less than 2 mmHg and a standard deviation of error around 6 mmHg. Based on these results, this thesis shows the potential of this new sensing modality to be used as an alternative, or to complement existing methods, for the continuous monitoring of heart rate and HRV, and spot measurement of the blood pressure at the wrist.Open Acces

Photoplethysmography-Based Biomedical Signal Processing

In this dissertation, photoplethysmography-based biomedical signal processing methods are developed and analyzed. The developed methods solve problems concerning the estimation of the heart rate during physical activity and the monitoring of cardiovascular health. For the estimation of heart rate during physical activity, two methods are presented that are very accurate in estimating the instantaneous heart rate at the wrist and, at the same time, are computationally efficient so that they can easily be integrated into wearables. In the context of cardiovascular health monitoring, a method for the detection of atrial fibrillation using the video camera of a smartphone is proposed that achieves a high detection rate of atrial fibrillation (AF) on a clinical pre-study data set. Further monitoring of cardiovascular parameters includes the estimation of blood pressure (BP), pulse wave velocity (PWV), and vascular age index (VAI), for which an approach is presented that requires only a single photoplethysmographic (PPG) signal. Heart rate estimation during physical activity using PPG signals constitutes an important research focus of this thesis. In this work, two computationally efficient algorithms are presented that estimate the heart rate from two PPG signals using a three axis accelerometer. In the first approach, adaptive filters are applied to estimate motion artifacts that severely deteriorate the signal quality. The non-stationary relationship between the measured acceleration signals and the artifacts is modeled as a linear system. The outputs of the adaptive filters are combined to further enhance the signal quality and a constrained heart rate tracker follows the most probable high energy continuous line in the spectral domain. The second approach is modest in computational complexity and very fast in execution compared to existing approaches. It combines correlation-based fundamental frequency indicating functions and spectral combination to enhance the correlated useful signal and suppress uncorrelated noise. Additional harmonic noise damping further reduces the impact of strong motion artifacts and a spectral tracking procedure uses a linear least squares prediction. Both approaches are modest in computational complexity and especially the second approach is very fast in execution, as it is shown on a widely used benchmark data set and compared to state-of-the-art methods. The second research focus and a further major contribution of this thesis lies in the monitoring of the cardiovascular health with a single PPG signal. Two methods are presented, one for detection of AF and one for the estimation of BP, PWV, and VAI. The first method is able to detect AF based on a smartphone filming the finger placed on the video camera. The algorithm transforms the video into a PPG signal and extracts features which are then used to discriminate between AF and normal sinus rhythm (NSR). Perfect detection of AF is already achieved on a data set of 326 measurements (including 20 with AF) that were taken at a clinical pre-study using an appropriate pair of features whereby a decision is formed through a simple linear decision equation. The second method aims at estimating cardiovascular parameters from a single PPG signal without the conventional use of an additional electrocardiogram (ECG). The proposed method extracts a large number of features from the PPG signal and its first and second order difference series, and reconstructs missing features by the use of matrix completion. The estimation of cardiovascular parameters is based on a nonlinear support vector regression (SVR) estimator and compared to single channel PPG based estimators using a linear regression model and a pulse arrival time (PAT) based method. If the training data set contains the person for whom the cardiovascular parameters are to be determined, the proposed method can provide an accurate estimate without further calibration. All proposed algorithms are applied to real data that we have either recorded ourselves in our biomedical laboratory, that have been recorded by a clinical research partner, or that are freely available as benchmark data sets