NFV orchestration in edge and fog scenarios

Mención Internacional en el título de doctorLas infraestructuras de red actuales soportan una variedad diversa de servicios como video bajo demanda, video conferencias, redes sociales, sistemas de educación, o servicios de almacenamiento de fotografías. Gran parte de la población mundial ha comenzado a utilizar estos servicios, y los utilizan diariamente. Proveedores de Cloud y operadores de infraestructuras de red albergan el tráfico de red generado por estos servicios, y sus tareas de gestión no solo implican realizar el enrutamiento del tráfico, sino también el procesado del tráfico de servicios de red. Tradicionalmente, el procesado del tráfico ha sido realizado mediante aplicaciones/ programas desplegados en servidores que estaban dedicados en exclusiva a tareas concretas como la inspección de paquetes. Sin embargo, en los últimos anos los servicios de red se han virtualizado y esto ha dado lugar al paradigma de virtualización de funciones de red (Network Function Virtualization (NFV) siguiendo las siglas en ingles), en el que las funciones de red de un servicio se ejecutan en contenedores o máquinas virtuales desacopladas de la infraestructura hardware. Como resultado, el procesado de tráfico se ha ido haciendo más flexible gracias al laxo acople del software y hardware, y a la posibilidad de compartir funciones de red típicas, como firewalls, entre los distintos servicios de red. NFV facilita la automatización de operaciones de red, ya que tareas como el escalado, o la migración son típicamente llevadas a cabo mediante un conjunto de comandos previamente definidos por la tecnología de virtualización pertinente, bien mediante contenedores o máquinas virtuales. De todos modos, sigue siendo necesario decidir el en rutamiento y procesado del tráfico de cada servicio de red. En otras palabras, que servidores tienen que encargarse del procesado del tráfico, y que enlaces de la red tienen que utilizarse para que las peticiones de los usuarios lleguen a los servidores finales, es decir, el conocido como embedding problem. Bajo el paraguas del paradigma NFV, a este problema se le conoce en inglés como Virtual Network Embedding (VNE), y esta tesis utiliza el termino “NFV orchestration algorithm” para referirse a los algoritmos que resuelven este problema. El problema del VNE es NP-hard, lo cual significa que que es imposible encontrar una solución optima en un tiempo polinómico, independientemente del tamaño de la red. Como consecuencia, la comunidad investigadora y de telecomunicaciones utilizan heurísticos que encuentran soluciones de manera más rápida que productos para la resolución de problemas de optimización. Tradicionalmente, los “NFV orchestration algorithms” han intentado minimizar los costes de despliegue derivados de las soluciones asociadas. Por ejemplo, estos algoritmos intentan no consumir el ancho de banda de la red, y usar rutas cortas para no utilizar tantos recursos. Además, una tendencia reciente ha llevado a la comunidad investigadora a utilizar algoritmos que minimizan el consumo energético de los servicios desplegados, bien mediante la elección de dispositivos con un consumo energético más eficiente, o mediante el apagado de dispositivos de red en desuso. Típicamente, las restricciones de los problemas de VNE se han resumido en un conjunto de restricciones asociadas al uso de recursos y consumo energético, y las soluciones se diferenciaban por la función objetivo utilizada. Pero eso era antes de la 5a generación de redes móviles (5G) se considerase en el problema de VNE. Con la aparición del 5G, nuevos servicios de red y casos de uso entraron en escena. Los estándares hablaban de comunicaciones ultra rápidas y fiables (Ultra-Reliable and Low Latency Communications (URLLC) usando las siglas en inglés) con latencias por debajo de unos pocos milisegundos y fiabilidades del 99.999%, una banda ancha mejorada (enhanced Mobile Broadband (eMBB) usando las siglas en inglés) con notorios incrementos en el flujo de datos, e incluso la consideración de comunicaciones masivas entre maquinas (Massive Machine-Type Communications (mMTC) usando las siglas en inglés) entre dispositivos IoT. Es más, paradigmas como edge y fog computing se incorporaron a la tecnología 5G, e introducían la idea de tener dispositivos de computo más cercanos al usuario final. Como resultado, el problema del VNE tenía que incorporar los nuevos requisitos como restricciones a tener en cuenta, y toda solución debía satisfacer bajas latencias, alta fiabilidad, y mayores tasas de transmisión. Esta tesis estudia el problema des VNE, y propone algunos heurísticos que lidian con las restricciones asociadas a servicios 5G en escenarios edge y fog, es decir, las soluciones propuestas se encargan de asignar funciones virtuales de red a servidores, y deciden el enrutamiento del trafico en las infraestructuras 5G con dispositivos edge y fog. Para evaluar el rendimiento de las soluciones propuestas, esta tesis estudia en primer lugar la generación de grafos que representan redes 5G. Los mecanismos propuestos para la generación de grafos sirven para representar distintos escenarios 5G. En particular, escenarios de federación en los que varios dominios comparten recursos entre ellos. Los grafos generados también representan servidores en el edge, así como dispositivos fog con una batería limitada. Además, estos grafos tienen en cuenta los requisitos de estándares, y la demanda que se espera en las redes 5G. La generación de grafos propuesta sirve para representar escenarios federación en los que varios dominios comparten recursos entre ellos, y redes 5G con servidores edge, así como dispositivos fog estáticos o móviles con una batería limitada. Los grafos generados para infraestructuras 5G tienen en cuenta los requisitos de estándares, y la demanda de red que se espera en las redes 5G. Además, los grafos son diferentes en función de la densidad de población, y el área de estudio, es decir, si es una zona industrial, una autopista, o una zona urbana. Tras detallar la generación de grafos que representan redes 5G, esta tesis propone algoritmos de orquestación NFV para resolver con el problema del VNE. Primero, se centra en escenarios federados en los que los servicios de red se tienen que asignar no solo a la infraestructura de un dominio, sino a los recursos compartidos en la federación de dominios. Dos problemas diferentes han sido estudiados, uno es el problema del VNE propiamente dicho sobre una infraestructura federada, y el otro es la delegación de servicios de red. Es decir, si un servicio de red se debe desplegar localmente en un dominio, o en los recursos compartidos por la federación de dominios; a sabiendas de que el último caso supone el pago de cuotas por parte del dominio local a cambio del despliegue del servicio de red. En segundo lugar, esta tesis propone OKpi, un algoritmo de orquestación NFV para conseguir la calidad de servicio de las distintas slices de las redes 5G. Conceptualmente, el slicing consiste en partir la red de modo que cada servicio de red sea tratado de modo diferente dependiendo del trozo al que pertenezca. Por ejemplo, una slice de eHealth reservara los recursos de red necesarios para conseguir bajas latencias en servicios como operaciones quirúrgicas realizadas de manera remota. Cada trozo (slice) está destinado a unos servicios específicos con unos requisitos muy concretos, como alta fiabilidad, restricciones de localización, o latencias de un milisegundo. OKpi es un algoritmo de orquestación NFV que consigue satisfacer los requisitos de servicios de red en los distintos trozos, o slices de la red. Tras presentar OKpi, la tesis resuelve el problema del VNE en redes 5G con dispositivos fog estáticos y móviles. El algoritmo de orquestación NFV presentado tiene en cuenta las limitaciones de recursos de computo de los dispositivos fog, además de los problemas de falta de cobertura derivados de la movilidad de los dispositivos. Para concluir, esta tesis estudia el escalado de servicios vehiculares Vehicle-to-Network (V2N), que requieren de bajas latencias para servicios como la prevención de choques, avisos de posibles riesgos, y conducción remota. Para estos servicios, los atascos y congestiones en la carretera pueden causar el incumplimiento de los requisitos de latencia. Por tanto, es necesario anticiparse a esas circunstancias usando técnicas de series temporales que permiten saber el tráfico inminente en los siguientes minutos u horas, para así poder escalar el servicio V2N adecuadamente.Current network infrastructures handle a diverse range of network services such as video on demand services, video-conferences, social networks, educational systems, or photo storage services. These services have been embraced by a significant amount of the world population, and are used on a daily basis. Cloud providers and Network operators’ infrastructures accommodate the traffic rates that the aforementioned services generate, and their management tasks do not only involve the traffic steering, but also the processing of the network services’ traffic. Traditionally, the traffic processing has been assessed via applications/programs deployed on servers that were exclusively dedicated to a specific task as packet inspection. However, in recent years network services have stated to be virtualized and this has led to the Network Function Virtualization (Network Function Virtualization (NFV)) paradigm, in which the network functions of a service run on containers or virtual machines that are decoupled from the hardware infrastructure. As a result, the traffic processing has become more flexible because of the loose coupling between software and hardware, and the possibility of sharing common network functions, as firewalls, across multiple network services. NFV eases the automation of network operations, since scaling and migrations tasks are typically performed by a set of commands predefined by the virtualization technology, either containers or virtual machines. However, it is still necessary to decide the traffic steering and processing of every network service. In other words, which servers will hold the traffic processing, and which are the network links to be traversed so the users’ requests reach the final servers, i.e., the network embedding problem. Under the umbrella of NFV, this problem is known as Virtual Network Embedding (VNE), and this thesis refers as “NFV orchestration algorithms” to those algorithms solving such a problem. The VNE problem is a NP-hard, meaning that it is impossible to find optimal solutions in polynomial time, no matter the network size. As a consequence, the research and telecommunications community rely on heuristics that find solutions quicker than a commodity optimization solver. Traditionally, NFV orchestration algorithms have tried to minimize the deployment costs derived from their solutions. For example, they try to not exhaust the network bandwidth, and use short paths to use less network resources. Additionally, a recent tendency led the research community towards algorithms that minimize the energy consumption of the deployed services, either by selecting more energy efficient devices or by turning off those network devices that remained unused. VNE problem constraints were typically summarized in a set of resources/energy constraints, and the solutions differed on which objectives functions were aimed for. But that was before 5th generation of mobile networks (5G) were considered in the VNE problem. With the appearance of 5G, new network services and use cases started to emerge. The standards talked about Ultra Reliable Low Latency Communication (Ultra-Reliable and Low Latency Communications (URLLC)) with latencies below few milliseconds and 99.999% reliability, an enhanced mobile broadband (enhanced Mobile Broadband (eMBB)) with significant data rate increases, and even the consideration of massive machine-type communications (Massive Machine-Type Communications (mMTC)) among Internet of Things (IoT) devices. Moreover, paradigms such as edge and fog computing blended with the 5G technology to introduce the idea of having computing devices closer to the end users. As a result, the VNE problem had to incorporate the new requirements as constraints to be taken into account, and every solution should either satisfy low latencies, high reliability, or larger data rates. This thesis studies the VNE problem, and proposes some heuristics tackling the constraints related to 5G services in Edge and fog scenarios, that is, the proposed solutions assess the assignment of Virtual Network Functions to resources, and the traffic steering across 5G infrastructures that have Edge and Fog devices. To evaluate the performance of the proposed solutions, the thesis studies first the generation of graphs that represent 5G networks. The proposed mechanisms to generate graphs serve to represent diverse 5G scenarios. In particular federation scenarios in which several domains share resources among themselves. The generated graphs also represent edge servers, so as fog devices with limited battery capacity. Additionally, these graphs take into account the standard requirements, and the expected demand for 5G networks. Moreover, the graphs differ depending on the density of population, and the area of study, i.e., whether it is an industrial area, a highway, or an urban area. After detailing the generation of graphs representing the 5G networks, this thesis proposes several NFV orchestration algorithms to tackle the VNE problem. First, it focuses on federation scenarios in which network services should be assigned not only to a single domain infrastructure, but also to the shared resources of the federation of domains. Two different problems are studied, one being the VNE itself over a federated infrastructure, and the other the delegation of network services. That is, whether a network service should be deployed in a local domain, or in the pool of resources of the federation domain; knowing that the latter charges the local domain for hosting the network service. Second, the thesis proposes OKpi, a NFV orchestration algorithm to meet 5G network slices quality of service. Conceptually, network slicing consists in splitting the network so network services are treated differently based on the slice they belong to. For example, an eHealth network slice will allocate the network resources necessary to meet low latencies for network services such as remote surgery. Each network slice is devoted to specific services with very concrete requirements, as high reliability, location constraints, or 1ms latencies. OKpi is a NFV orchestration algorithm that meets the network service requirements among different slices. It is based on a multi-constrained shortest path heuristic, and its solutions satisfy latency, reliability, and location constraints. After presenting OKpi, the thesis tackles the VNE problem in 5G networks with static/moving fog devices. The presented NFV orchestration algorithm takes into account the limited computing resources of fog devices, as well as the out-of-coverage problems derived from the devices’ mobility. To conclude, this thesis studies the scaling of Vehicle-to-Network (V2N) services, which require low latencies for network services as collision avoidance, hazard warning, and remote driving. For these services, the presence of traffic jams, or high vehicular traffic congestion lead to the violation of latency requirements. Hence, it is necessary to anticipate to such circumstances by using time-series techniques that allow to derive the incoming vehicular traffic flow in the next minutes or hours, so as to scale the V2N service accordingly.The 5G Exchange (5GEx) project (2015-2018) was an EU-funded project (H2020-ICT-2014-2 grant agreement 671636). The 5G-TRANSFORMER project (2017-2019) is an EU-funded project (H2020-ICT-2016-2 grant agreement 761536). The 5G-CORAL project (2017-2019) is an EU-Taiwan project (H2020-ICT-2016-2 grant agreement 761586).Programa de Doctorado en Ingeniería Telemática por la Universidad Carlos III de MadridPresidente: Ioannis Stavrakakis.- Secretario: Pablo Serrano Yáñez-Mingot.- Vocal: Paul Horatiu Patra

Overbooking Network Slices through Yield-driven End-to-End Orchestration

Proceeding of: 14th International Conference on emerging Networking EXperiments and Technologies (CoNEXT '18)Network slicing allows mobile operators to offer, via proper abstractions, mobile infrastructure (radio, networking, computing) to vertical sectors traditionally alien to the telco industry (e.g., automotive, health, construction). Owning to similar business nature, in this paper we adopt yield management models successful in other sectors (e.g. airlines, hotels, etc.) and so we explore the concept of slice overbooking to maximize the revenue of mobile operators. The main contribution of this paper is threefold. First, we design a hierarchical control plane to manage the orchestration of slices end-to-end, including radio access, transport network, and distributed computing infrastructure. Second, we cast the orchestration problem as a stochastic yield management problem and propose two algorithms to solve it: an optimal Benders decomposition method and a suboptimal heuristic that expedites solutions. Third, we implement an experimental proof-of-concept and assess our approach both experimentally and via simulations with topologies from three real operators and a wide set of realistic scenarios. Our performance evaluation shows that slice overbooking can provide up to 3x revenue gains in realistic scenarios with minimal footprint on service-level agreements (SLAs).This work was supported in part by the H2020 5G-Transformer Project under Grant 761536 and in part by H2020-MSCA-ITN-2015 5G-Aura Project under Grant 675806

Cost-Efficient NFV-Enabled Mobile Edge-Cloud for Low Latency Mobile Applications

Mobile edge-cloud (MEC) aims to support low la- tency mobile services by bringing remote cloud services nearer to mobile users. However, in order to deal with dynamic workloads, MEC is deployed in a large number of fixed-location micro- clouds, leading to resource wastage during stable/low work- load periods. Limiting the number of micro-clouds improves resource utilization and saves operational costs, but faces service performance degradations due to insufficient physical capacity during peak time from nearby micro-clouds. To efficiently support services with low latency requirement under varying workload conditions, we adopt the emerging Network Function Virtualization (NFV)-enabled MEC, which offers new flexibility in hosting MEC services in any virtualized network node, e.g., access points, routers, etc. This flexibility overcomes the limitations imposed by fixed-location solutions, providing new freedom in terms of MEC service-hosting locations. In this paper, we address the questions on where and when to allocate resources as well as how many resources to be allocated among NFV- enabled MECs, such that both the low latency requirements of mobile services and MEC cost efficiency are achieved. We propose a dynamic resource allocation framework that consists of a fast heuristic-based incremental allocation mechanism that dynamically performs resource allocation and a reoptimization algorithm that periodically adjusts allocation to maintain a near- optimal MEC operational cost over time. We show through ex- tensive simulations that our flexible framework always manages to allocate sufficient resources in time to guarantee continuous satisfaction of applications’ low latency requirements. At the same time, our proposal saves up to 33% of cost in comparison to existing fixed-location MEC solutions

Mobile Crowd Sensing in Edge Computing Environment

abstract: The mobile crowdsensing (MCS) applications leverage the user data to derive useful information by data-driven evaluation of innovative user contexts and gathering of information at a high data rate. Such access to context-rich data can potentially enable computationally intensive crowd-sourcing applications such as tracking a missing person or capturing a highlight video of an event. Using snippets and pictures captured from multiple mobile phone cameras with specific contexts can improve the data acquired in such applications. These MCS applications require efficient processing and analysis to generate results in real time. A human user, mobile device and their interactions cause a change in context on the mobile device affecting the quality contextual data that is gathered. Usage of MCS data in real-time mobile applications is challenging due to the complex inter-relationship between: a) availability of context, context is available with the mobile phones and not with the cloud, b) cost of data transfer to remote cloud servers, both in terms of communication time and energy, and c) availability of local computational resources on the mobile phone, computation may lead to rapid battery drain or increased response time. The resource-constrained mobile devices need to offload some of their computation. This thesis proposes ContextAiDe an end-end architecture for data-driven distributed applications aware of human mobile interactions using Edge computing. Edge processing supports real-time applications by reducing communication costs. The goal is to optimize the quality and the cost of acquiring the data using a) modeling and prediction of mobile user contexts, b) efficient strategies of scheduling application tasks on heterogeneous devices including multi-core devices such as GPU c) power-aware scheduling of virtual machine (VM) applications in cloud infrastructure e.g. elastic VMs. ContextAiDe middleware is integrated into the mobile application via Android API. The evaluation consists of overheads and costs analysis in the scenario of ``perpetrator tracking" application on the cloud, fog servers, and mobile devices. LifeMap data sets containing actual sensor data traces from mobile devices are used to simulate the application run for large scale evaluation.Dissertation/ThesisDoctoral Dissertation Electrical Engineering 201

Microservices-based IoT Applications Scheduling in Edge and Fog Computing: A Taxonomy and Future Directions

Edge and Fog computing paradigms utilise distributed, heterogeneous and resource-constrained devices at the edge of the network for efficient deployment of latency-critical and bandwidth-hungry IoT application services. Moreover, MicroService Architecture (MSA) is increasingly adopted to keep up with the rapid development and deployment needs of the fast-evolving IoT applications. Due to the fine-grained modularity of the microservices along with their independently deployable and scalable nature, MSA exhibits great potential in harnessing both Fog and Cloud resources to meet diverse QoS requirements of the IoT application services, thus giving rise to novel paradigms like Osmotic computing. However, efficient and scalable scheduling algorithms are required to utilise the said characteristics of the MSA while overcoming novel challenges introduced by the architecture. To this end, we present a comprehensive taxonomy of recent literature on microservices-based IoT applications scheduling in Edge and Fog computing environments. Furthermore, we organise multiple taxonomies to capture the main aspects of the scheduling problem, analyse and classify related works, identify research gaps within each category, and discuss future research directions.Comment: 35 pages, 10 figures, submitted to ACM Computing Survey

Construction of Smart Grid Load Forecast Model by Edge Computing

This research aims to minimize the unnecessary resource consumption by intelligent Power Grid Systems (PGSs). Edge Computing (EC) technology is used to forecast PGS load and optimize the PGS load forecasting model. Following a literature review of EC and Internet of Things (IoT)-native edge devices, an intelligent PGS-oriented Resource Management Scheme (RMS) and PGS load forecasting model are proposed based on task offloading. Simultaneously, an online delay-aware power Resource Allocation Algorithm (RAA) is developed for EC architecture. Finally, comparing three algorithms corroborate that the system overhead decreases significantly with the model iteration. From the 40th iteration, the system overhead stabilizes. Moreover, given no more than 50 users, the average user delay of the proposed delay-aware power RAA is less than 13 s. The average delay of the proposed algorithm is better than that of the other two algorithms. This research contributes to optimizing intelligent PGS in smart cities and improving power transmission efficiency